Www.bostondebate.org



TitleAP Synthesis Essay: Implications of the Locavore MovementSkillResponding to CounterargumentsEBA ActivityRound Robin DebatesClaims and/or WarrantsYou may use the following claims:The locavore movement in the Boston community will improve the freshness, taste, ripeness, and nutrition of the food people eat.The locavore movement in the Boston community will improve residents’ relationship to nature and anizing a locavore movement in the Boston community is anizing a locavore movement in the Boston community will improve the ecological anizing a locavore movement in the Boston community will only be beneficial if community members are well-informed about the methods of agriculture and transportation used in producing and delivering locally grown foods. ProcedureStandard Round Robin Debates Timing/PacingThis lesson comes towards the end of this unit. Students are able to draw upon their exploration and knowledge of human relationships to nature to build and defend their arguments on this topic. Students should read and annotate the 2011 AP Lang synthesis essay prompt and sources before beginning this activity. This activity is approximately 10-30 minutes. This activity comes after the Do Now. (The Do Now may ask students to choose one of the claims below and provide warrants to support it.)NotesThe rationale for this activity is to engage students in thinking about the locavore movement and its implications for a community and to build their skills at addressing counter-arguments to make their own arguments stronger. This activity would be a good pre-writing activity for the 2011 AP Lang synthesis essay prompt. Follow-up ActivitiesTo include a written activity, follow up with a mini paragraph writing activity .TextPrompt for Question 1 from the 2011 AP English Language & Composition exam. (Exam questions are available online at the AP Central website.) Name:_____________________________________ Class: ___________ Date:__________Round-Robin DebatesBackground InformationClaim AClaim BRound 1The locavore movement in the Boston community will improve the freshness, taste, ripeness, and nutrition of the food people eat.The locavore movement in the Boston community will improve residents’ relationship to nature and agriculture.Round 2Organizing a locavore movement in the Boston community is anizing a locavore movement in the Boston community will only be beneficial if community members are well-informed about the methods of agriculture and transportation used in producing and delivering locally grown foods. Round 3Organizing a locavore movement in the Boston community will improve the ecological anizing a locavore movement in the Boston community will not improve the ecological environment.Round Robin Debate 1Student 1: Claim AStudent 2: Claim BStudent 3: Judge Round 1 Round 2WarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesWarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesClaim A:Claim B:Judge Tally1 Point for Evidence-Based Warrants2 Points for Responding to Arguments Using EvidenceCommentsStudent AStudent BTotal PointsRound Robin Debate 2Student 1: JudgeStudent 2: Claim AStudent 3: Claim B Round 1 Round 2WarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesWarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesClaim A:Claim B:Judge Tally1 Point for Evidence-Based Warrants2 Points for Responding to Arguments Using EvidenceCommentsStudent AStudent BTotal PointsRound Robin Debate 3Student 1: Claim BStudent 2: JudgeStudent 3: Claim A Round 1 Round 2WarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesWarrantsCounterarguments and/or ResponsesClaim A:Claim B:Judge Tally1 Point for Evidence-Based Warrants2 Points for Responding to Arguments Using EvidenceCommentsStudent AStudent BTotal Points ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download