Digitalportfolioronf.weebly.com



Final Project – Managing Part of a CollectionFor my final project, I have decided to work with one of the non fiction collections at the Cora J Belden Public Library located at 33 Church Street, Rocky Hill, CT 06067. The collection subject is Horticulture/Gardening/Landscaping. I worked with 50 of the texts, although there is significantly more than this in the collection. In determining whether or not I would weed a particular text, I noted what certain reviews said regarding the content as well as the physical condition of the texts. I was also was allowed to view the circulation (etc.) records, known as the Dusty Book Report, to see how often since acquisition the texts have been checked out and other information about them. The only problem with considering circulation usage is it does not factor in how many people use the text at the library without checking it out. I also incorporated in my own opinion in conjunction with the reviews and circulation records as I have worked in the horticultural industry for a number of years. This library uses the CREW method when they perform their own weeding projects. 50 Texts and their Final Verdict1. Bremness, Lesley. (1994). “Herbs.” New York: Dorling Kindersley Publishing Inc. Physically this text is in very good shape. There are no major tears, stains, or other signs of damage to the cover or the pages. Publisher’s Weekly () does not paint the text in a positive light. They write “Bremness here produces a work of some interest, but little use … this is not a dependable field guide for plant identification … the book isn't useful enough … “ (Publisher’s Weekly, 2000). There is more to the review but those are some of the highlights. The book was acquired in 2000, and only checked out 32 times since then. It was last used in May of 2012. Final Verdict: Given the overall negative response I would flag this text as being in need of weeding from the collection. 2. Stark, Tim. (2008). “Heirloom – Notes From an Accidental Tomato Farmer.” New York: Broadway Books. Physically this text is in good shape. No evidence of major damage from insects, water, or any other extreme issues or imperfections. Kendra Nordin, a staff editor of the the Christian Science Monitor’s, review () was overall positive. Kendra writes “love, and organic tomatoes, do not ripen without patient labor and battles with anxiety. Farmer and writer Tim Stark?illustrates the latter with chaotic flair … (Nordin, 2008). Nordin also writes “wandering amid the weedy, erratic rows, it’s hard not to be endeared to Stark and his stories. There is plenty of delicious fruit where the writer shines through the farmer …” (Nordin, 2008). From this review readers get the impression that this is a charming text worth reading. The Publisher’s Weekly review for this text was drastically different than that of the “Herbs” text by Leslie Bremness. They highlight some of Stark’s major troubles from the book. Publisher’s Weekly () writes “His recounting of fly-by-night agricultural tactics, stomach-turning worries and relief-inducing bumper crops paints a poignant picture of a dwindling form of American life …” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2008). They also write “he illustrates the unlikely bond between the tomato-laden farm and the urban table” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2008). The text was acquired by the library in 2008. It has been charged 17 times since then. For me, there is one aspect that I would consider in more detail before determining the text’s fate in the collection. I would consider the content in more detail. It is a book about horticulture and gardening, but my question is whether or not this text would be better suited for a different collection. It does not appear to be about how to grow tomatoes directly so much as Stark’s personal story of his life in which tomato farming became a major part of. Note: The “Book a Week” blog also has more entries about this text: Final Verdict: I would flag this text as being in need of further evaluation to consider it for possible weeding from the collection on the basis of content. If others agree that despite it being more of an autobiography than a scientific growing guide it should stay then I would be fine with the decision. This also depends on the needs of the patron base. 3. Warren, Susan. (2007) “Backyard Giants” New York: Bloomsbury USA.Physically this text is in good shape. No major tears or other forms of damage. Publisher’s Weekly () paints this text positively in their review when they statements such as “Warren peaks the anticipation with the big fall weigh-ins, lending a humorous, poignant touch to this hearty gardener’s tale” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2007). Readers get the sense this is a charming personal tale, not so unlike Stark’s organic Tomato farming Tale from “Heirloom” in the previous review. Kylee Baumle also paints this text in a positive light in his review located here: ). He writes “what might have been a boring textbook of botany is deftly crafted into a suspenseful story of the personal quests of some of the best pumpkin growers in the world …” (Baumle, 2010). He also writes “Of course, I’m a gardener and how things are grown is of great interest to me, but I think even the casual reader will find “Backyard Giants” a fun and easy read” (Baumle, 2010). This is important as it means this text could be open to enjoyment by a larger span of people which should theoretically increase its value to the patron community that accesses the collection. The text has been checked out a total of only 5 times and was last used in August of 2011. It was acquired in 2007. Final Verdict: Noticeably low circulation amount as compared to other texts in this collection, even though many others do not have immense circulation amounts. I would submit this text for evaluation on the same basis as Stark’s text “Heirloom.” 4. Franks, Eric & Richardson, Jasmine. (2009) ‘Microgreens – a guide to growing nutrient packed greens.” Layton: Gibbs Smith. This text is physically in good shape. Growing for Market () writes “This book … provides detailed advice on producing microgreens for market or personal use … Written for both eaters and commercial growers, this book is the first to offer specific techniques and problem-solving advice (Growing for Market, 2011). Book Depository () writes “with simple instructions, Microgreens: A Guide to Growing Nutrient-Packed Greens by Eric Franks and Jasmine Richardson, shows readers how to grow their own little greens of …” (Book Depository, 2013). ?There are also a handful of unofficial user reviews that can be found at Better World Books ().The Dusty Book Report for this title indicates that it has been charged a total of 16 times. It was acquired in 2009 and last used in September of 2012. Because the reviews explain that the text is geared towards a wide audience of readers (experienced and inexperienced alike) I would recommend that it not be weeded from the collection. 5. Lima, Patrick. (2012) “Herbs, The Complete Gardner’s Guide.” (2) Buffalo: Firefly Books (US) Inc.This text is in good physical condition. Publisher’s Weekly () writes “all things herbal are showcased in this expansive study … Lima and Forsyth focus on the plants' physical characteristics rather than on cultivation: how they look, smell, feel and taste, what makes them thrive, which parts make the best food or medicine (Publisher’s Weekly, 2001). This lets the reader know that those who are seeking for comprehensive herb cooking guides should consider a different text for that purpose. This is important for the lay person just coming into the hobby of herb cultivation and cooking who would benefit from a guide that can be used to identify what different herbs are and what makes each one unique. Powell’s Books () writes “This volume, as beautiful as it is useful, combines the wisdom of two longtime gardeners to make Herbs, The Complete Gardener's Guide, a delightful and essential addition to any gardener's library” (Powell’s Books, 2013). This text was acquired in April of 2012. It was last used in January of 2013 and the total charges are 12. Final Verdict: Given the nature of this text’s content, as well as the currency of this second edition, I would not weed it from the collection. 6. De la tour, Shatoiya & Rihard. (2001). “The Herbalist’s Garden. Canada: Transcontinental Printing.This book is in poor physical condition. There is immense water damage throughout the pages. They are stiff, wrinkled, and discolored. It looks like it could have been stuck in the middle of a rainstorm or dropped into a bathtub full of water. The pages barely turn due to how stiff and brittle they have become. The reviews for this text are overall positive. Books Enthusiast () writes “Such eccentrics make?The Herbalist's Garden?an entertaining read, yet it's also informative, with wide-ranging advice on the medicinal and mystical uses of herbs” (Books Enthusiast, 2004). () writes “The de la Tours have managed to bring together all these facets in a lively and handsome volume” (Hortmag, 2013). Canadian Gardening () writes “The Herbalist's Garden?ought to be approached on its own terms. It's not a practical book of gardening advice, but a words-and-pictures tour of 10 herb-filled gardens-primarily in California and New England, with B.C.'s Raven Hill Farm representing Canada-and profiles of the people who made them” (Canadian Gardening, 2013). This information is particularly useful for those who wish to forgo the aesthetic aspect of gardening and delve right into the cultivation aspect. The total number of charges for this text is 26. It was acquired in 2001 and last charged in May of 2013. Final Verdict: Due to the extremely poor physical condition of this text I would definitely weed this copy from the collection. I also feel that the library should acquire a new copy of this text. Not all materials in the collection have to be “scientific” in nature, and gardeners/horticultural enthusiasts/etc. would likely take pleasure in all types of horticulture related materials. 7. Sombke, Laurence. (1997). ‘Beautiful Easy Herbs.” Emmaus: Rodale Press Inc.The physical condition of this text is good. No major imperfections that would be detrimental. Paperback Swap () writes “Find all your favorite herbs, delicious recipes--even herbal crafts--in this elegant volume that shows gardeners of all levels how to successfully grow herbs indoors and out” (Paperback Swap, 2013). A review below this listing writes “This book is a great guide for someone just starting out in gardening” (Paperback Swap, 2013). Even though the review at the bottom of the Paperback Swap write up is “unofficial” in nature people nevertheless will use it to help determine if they will chance reading it or not. The Google Books listing () also depicts overall positive customer reviews of the text, and the AbeBooks () description helps further inform the reader of what the book contains. This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 51 times and was last charged in January of 2013. Final Verdict: I would keep this text in the collection. Neither the physical condition nor the analysis of its contents leads me to suspect that it is an immense piece of dead weight on the shelf. 8. Buchanan, Rita. (2000). “Taylor’s Master Guide to Landscaping” Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.The physical condition of this text is good. There is evidence of use but nothing too detrimental to the book’s health. Publisher’s Weekly () states “Comprehensive and easy to follow, Buchanan's companion volume to Taylor's Master Guide to Gardening covers just about all the features that can be included in home landscapes” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2000). They also write “Buchanan's clearly written, abundantly illustrated guide should go a long way toward helping amateurs have the courage to tackle what often seems a daunting task” (2000). This is an informative text. A review on Canadian Gardening () states “the book is well-written, I found a long essay on aggregate path paving made compulsive reading. This is one landscaping book you can't do without” (Canadian Gardening, 2013). ?This text was added to the collection in 2001. It was last charged in 2012, and the total number of charges is 71. Final Verdict: I would keep this text in the collection. Not only is it in decent physical condition but the contents are useful for people. 9. Clarke, Ethne. (1996). “Gardening with Foliage Plants; Leaf Bark and Berry.” New York: Abbeville Press.Physically this book is in good shape. Publisher’s Weekly () praises the book, and concludes its review by informing us “While Clarke concentrates on gardening in the English climate, readers will have little trouble adapting her comments to their own zones” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1997). Through Barnes and Noble, the Library Journal () review posted by Daniel Kalk for this text is also accessible. Part of this review states “A basic book providing solid information; highly recommended for all gardening collections” (Kalk, 2013). This book was acquired in 2009. It was last charged in February of 2010. The total number of charges since purchase is 1. Only one time has this text been checked out. For me that would be a major red flag. I can understand texts with low circulation rates, but only one check out since acquisition is merits investigation. Why do the patrons not see this book as fit as others on the same subject to check out? Maybe it’s because the writer focuses on English gardening, as we are told by the Publisher’s Weekly review. It is a possibility that people may not think the text applies to US gardening because of this. Or it could be something else. Final Verdict: The reviews speak highly of the text, but the extremely low circulation rate merits investigation. Because of this, I would flag this item as in need of review by library staff, and to be weeded if it is determined that it does not meet patron needs as well as initially planned. 10. Clausen, Ruth Rogers. (2002). “Dreamscaping” New York: Hearst Books.Physically, this book is in good shape. Through Barnes and Noble () I was able to read part of the Bookpage review. It explains “Each layout includes planting instructions, site specifications, comprehensive plant information, and beautiful color photos. "This is the sort of book that makes the best kind of armchair gardening, full of ideas for new plant combinations. It's a lifesaver” (Bookpage, 2013). Powell’s Books () also lists the Bookpage review. This text was acquired in 2002. It was last checked out in July or 2013 and it has been charged a total of 42 times. Final Verdict: I see no major reasons to flag this text for weeding at this time. 11. Clifton, Joan. (2003). “Climbing Gardens: adding height and structure to your garden.” Buffalo: Firefly Books (US) Inc. Physically this book is in adequate shape. Better World Books (), in describing the book, writes that it “explores all the varieties and uses of climbing plants to create unique garden spaces” (Better World Books, 2013). It also explains how the text is “Illustrated with more than 150 inspiring photographs of gardens” (2013). Yet when the reader scrolls to the bottom of the page and glances the Goodreads reviews the first one (as of the writing of this paper) listed there writes that they wanted more images. While Goodreads reviews are not “official” people will inevitably factor them in and because of this I would have to have the text examined more thoroughly to determine if the images it contains are both adequate and helpful for readers. () writes that the book “Explores creative ways to maximize space in a small garden” (Bookish, 2013). As a gardener myself I understand the importance of this as many people do not have massive expanses of land in which to plant unhindered. When I worked at a gardening/landscaping store as a teenager I cannot count how many customers would come in seeking advice on what and how to plant in an area with limited space. This book was acquired in 2003. It has been checked out 28 times and was last charged in July of 2013. Final Verdict: Given the importance of the content (gardening in small spaces, among other factors) I would keep this title in the collection. 12. Dillon, Helen. (1995). “The Flower Garden.” New York: Sterling Publishing Company. Physically this text is not in the best of shape. The inside pages are reasonably acceptable, however the outer covers have unusual brown “crud like” stains. Similarly, the inside front cover also has this unusual unsightly crud smeared onto it. If there is any way to clean this off of the covers it must certainly be done as no one will want to hold it. It was surprisingly hard to find much in the form of reviews on this text. Even the Barnes and Noble () and () listings, which very often have reviews from Booklist and other sources incorporated into the product details, were lacking for this text (excepting one positive unofficial review on the Amazon page). The Indigo () listing for this text provides a summary of what is contained in the pages. The book was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 34 times and was last used in July of 2013. Final Verdict: As useful as the contents may be, I find it hard to believe that a large portion of patrons would be able to get past the physical issues (brown crud on the covers). If it cannot be cleaned off then I would flag it for weeding. 13. Dillon, Helen. (1995). Garden Artistry. New York: Simon & Schuster Macmillan Company.Physically this book is in good condition. Joy Weese Moll, a “librarian writing about books” (2013) as she describes herself in the side bar of her “Joys Book Blog” page (), discusses her review of this text. At one point she writes “this is a lovely book for gardeners or even those who just wish they were. Although there are certainly some practical tips, it feels most like taking a walk in a beautiful garden with the accomplished gardener–a pleasure in any country” (Moll, 2013). This gives the text the impression of it being more of an admiration of the author’s garden(s) as opposed to solely focused on how to cultivate plants. This type of text, however, is certainly worth keeping, as fellow gardeners and garden enthusiasts will likely enjoy the photographical “tour” of the author’s garden(s). This text was acquired in 2000. It has been checked out 46 times and was last used in July of 2013. Final Verdict: Given the contents and physical condition of this text I would keep it in the collection. 14. Donaldson, Stephanie & Berry, Susan. (1998). “Plants for small spaces” Collins & Brown Limited. Physically this book is in good condition. Through Amazon’s listing of the Booklist review () we are informed that “Donaldson and Berry give basic information on tools, containers, fertilizing, watering, propagating, staking, pruning, repairing and painting pots” (Booklist, 2013). As with the other texts that deal with planting in smaller areas this is important to maintain in the collection as long as possible. The book was acquired in 2000. It has been checked out 34 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict: The useful information combined with the good physical condition leads me to keep this title in the collection. 15. Fornari, C. L. (2007). “A Garden Lover’s Cape Cod.” Beverly: Memoirs Unlimited Inc. Physically this book is in good condition. (), in describing this text, writes “With high winds, sandy soil, and a spring season that seems to stay cold forever, Cape Cod provides unique challenges to the creative gardener. Then why do so many glorious gardens flourish here?” (Bookish, 2013). These are definitely some major factors that will severely affect the cultivation of plants. While the Cape Cod region is listed as being the primary focus of this text, these same types of environmental conditions can be found in other regions too (though other regions may not have so many of these factors in combination). Seeing how gardeners in this area deal with such extreme conditions can be an inspiration for others who may have gardening difficulties in their own regions. The customer reviews on the bottom of the “Through his Blood” Christian Bookstore () listing for this book are positive. The book was acquired in 2008. It has been checked out 14 times and it was last used in August of 2012). Final Verdict: Given the usefulness of learning about how gardeners cope with such extreme environmental conditions, this text should remain in the collection. 16. Beckett, Ken, Bradley, Steve, Kingsbury, Noel & Newbury, Tim. (1999). ‘Gardening Basics” New York: Sterling Publishing Company, Inc. There are no major issues with this book’s physical condition. From the Booklist review of this text, accessible via its listing (), we are told that it is “truly a comprehensive introduction to gardening, with basic information on designing and creating family gardens, patio gardens, large gardens....Care and maintenance focuses on using basic tools....1,200 splendid color photographs complement the text” (AbeBooks, 2013). It is important to note that words such as “introduction” and “basic” are used multiple times in addition to the word “basic” being in the title itself. I feel this is important because it helps direct any would be readers. If someone is already an “advanced” gardener they will likely not find “basic” information very useful. On the other hand, someone who is just entering the world of horticulture may find this text to be a wealth of knowledge and a way to get their foot “firmly in the door” so to speak. I know I tend to shy away from someone I perceive as too “technical” if it involves a subject I am not familiar with in order to avoid confusion. Strangely, the date of acquisition was not present in the record for this text. It has been charged 37 times and was last used in August of 2012. Final Verdict: This text is a definite keeper. All types of patrons must be factored in when considering the makeup of the collection. In this instance newcomers and less advanced gardeners are likely to most appreciate what this book has to offer. 17. Gustafson, Herb. (1999). ‘The Art of Japanese Gardens.” New York: Sterling Publishing Co. Inc. This book is in acceptable physical condition. Part of the review located on the Tower Books listing for this text () indicates “Often gardeners become so enslaved to the work of maintenance and transformation that they neglect the meditative potential of their green space. Worrying over the details, the whole picture is sometimes lost. This is an attitude Herb Gustafson hopes to check …” (Tower Books, 2012). I admit this has happened to me as well and this aspect of the book will hopefully connect with readers. Further into the review it states “to truly carry out many of Gustafson''s projects, the reader needs to be extremely handy, or planning on hiring a professional” (Tower Books, 2012). That is very important as some may not wish to spend time reviewing the book only to determine in the end they are unable to practice its ideas in reality and develop the feeling that they “wasted their time” with it. The book was acquired in 2000. It has been checked out 31 times and was last used in October of 2011. Final Verdict: I would flag this text as in need of review for possible weeding. Because one has to be “extremely handy, or planning on hiring a professional” in order to really utilize the information in the book it may not be an item that a large percentage of the patron base can use. 18. Heger, Mike & Whitman, John. (1998). ‘Growing Perennials in Cold Climates.” Chicago: Contemporary Publishing Group Inc.No major physical issues with this text. There is a new revised edition of this text that should be acquired. The Library Journal entry for the revised edition accessible through Barnes and Noble () states “This new expanded edition of a gardening standard is just what gardeners need when choosing plants for a region that dips below -20°F in winter … This edition is expanded to include over 2000 varieties” (Library Journal, 2013).The Renegade Gardener () review for this text states “This new revised edition … is a complete update of nearly 70 of the best perennial genera for northern gardens. A lot has changed in eleven years, with the introduction of myriad new varieties” (Renegade Gardener, 2011). This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 38 times and it was last checked out in 2012. Final Verdict: This text must be weeded and the new edition should be acquired to replace it. Perennials are a very popular group of plants for gardeners and a large percentage of the country endures cold winters. As stated above, there are new varieties and genera of perennials that have been introduced since the earlier edition of the text. Patrons will not want to use this text when they realize that a newer edition exists; the collection has to stay current. 19. Halpin, Anne & Mackey, Betty. (1993). “Cutting Gardens.” Roundtable Press Inc. No physical issues with this text. The Chegg listing () for this book states “there's a special satisfaction in creating a lovely arrangement with flowers that you've grown yourself. Now comes a complete guide to growing flowers and creating spectacular arrangements, for every season and every region. Features more than 250 full-color photographs” (Chegg, 2013). The subject of this book is different than the others I examined. Most of them focus on growing plants and landscaping but this one focuses on the art of cut flower arrangement. There are a number of unofficial reviews on the listing (), and all but one are positive (as of my writing this paper). The acquisition date of this text is unavailable. It has been charged 52 times and was last used in May of 2013. Final Verdict: Due to the unique nature of this text it should remain in the collection. 20. Harkness, Philip. (2004). “Reliable Roses.” Buffalo: Firefly Books (US) Inc.No physical issues with this book. The Chicago Botanic Garden () states “This book is organized with the rose beginner in mind, although those more experienced with roses will also find much of interest here. Easy-to-read sections on rosebeds, plant selection, growing needs, insect and disease control, and pruning make this work informative for all sorts of roses fanciers” (Chicago Botanic Garden, 2013). There is more praise for this book and the write up concludes with “Harkness succeeds in presenting an exceptional rose book that will encourage gardeners of all skill levels to experiment with roses” (Chicago Botanic Garden, 2013). This text was acquired in 2004. It has been charged 25 times and was last used in August of 2013. Final Verdict: This text should be kept in the collection. 21. Hayward, Goron. (2003). “Your House, Your Garden.” New York: W.W. Norton & Company.Physically this text is in good condition. The Publisher’s Weekly review for this text () states that the book “gives the reader a solid foundation in home garden design. In six chapters devoted to the main locations for the garden … readers learn how to create inviting outdoor spaces, solve common problems and establish a unifying flow” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2003). The text was acquired in 2003. It has been charged 42 times and was last used in October of 2012. Final Verdict: This text is worth keeping in the library collection. 22. Hessayon, D.G. (1994). “The Flowering Shrub Expert.” Transworld Publishers Ltd.No major physical anomalies to report with this item. Powell’s Books () states that this item is “A guide to all the classic flowering shrubs, as well as to the multitude of new varieties that have appeared in the garden centers. It includes a shrub selector to help gardeners choose the right plants for year-round blooms, as well as advice on planting, pruning, mulching and plant care” (Powell’s Books, 2013). Such information is certainly useful for anyone looking for help with this particular group of plants. This item was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 33 times and was last used in March of 2011). Final Verdict: This item should remain in the collection. As many facets of horticulture must be acquired as possible, and in this instance the flowering shrubs have been addressed. 23. Hynes, Erin. (1998). “Rodale’s Weekend Gardner.” Rodale Press Inc.This item is in good physical shape. The Publisher’s Weekly () write up for this text states “Can home owners create an interesting, satisfying landscape without the support of an army of gardening help and while maintaining a life outside their garden? The answer from Hynes … who admits to spending most of her days ""earning a living, raising a child, doing volunteer work,"" is an unequivocal yes” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1998). On a similar note, the Library Journal write up for this book, accessible through the Barnes and Noble listing (), writes “… gives us a straightforward book geared especially for homeowners long on gardening enthusiasm but short on time and resources … Recommended for all public and horticultural libraries” (Library Journal, 1998). This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 37 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict: Not everyone has seemingly endless time to dedicate to creating a nice garden. This book takes time management into account as evidenced by the reviews. This item should remain in the collection. 24. Levine, Ketzel. (2000). ‘Plant This!” Seattle: Sasquatch Books.Physical condition of this book is good. The AbeBooks review () states “What other wise, pragmatic, reliable garden reference books include such enjoyable reading? Levine's?Plant This! is an exceptional find, a gardening book that's at home on your coffee table as well as in the dirt and mulch of your garden” (AbeBooks, 2013). Also, a warm hearted review of this book can be found here: item was acquired in 2001). It has been charged 14 times and was last used in January of 2013. Final Verdict: The item should stay in the collection. It has received positive notoriety and is both entertaining and useful from what I have read about it. 25. Lloyd, Christopher & Bird, Richard. (1999). “The Cottage Garden.” New York: DK Publishing Inc.This text is in good physical condition. The author of the Soil Sister Blog () writes” The Cottage Garden … was recommended to me some years ago as the best book available on cottage gardening … the book is an informative guide, written in a friendly manner, for creating a true cottage garden” (Soil Sister Blog, 2012). This item was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 45 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict: This item should remain in the collection. The “Cottage Garden” look is not one I have seen often in other texts and in general, so this resource is valuable. 26. Martin, Tovah. (1994). “Tasha Tudor’s Garden.” New York: Houghton Mifflin Company.This text is in good physical condition. The Publisher’s Weekly review for this text () states “the book's roundly picturesque and dappled with full-color photos of herself minding the peonies and strolling barefoot (by preference) past the daffodils. The text by Martin is friendly and informative” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1994). The book has the reputation of a heart warming journey through Tasha’s gardening lifestyle. The feeling of friendliness is a positive aspect for a text like this as compared to a less emotion filled encyclopedia style piece. This item was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 50 times and was last used in June of 2011. Final Verdict: This text has the feeling of being friendly, humorous, and also informative based on what I have read about it. Certainly those interested in Tasha’s daily gardening tasks will be interested. It also has a circulation amount on the higher end of the scale as compared to a lot of the other texts in this collection. I would keep it on the shelf. 27. Mcdonald, Elvin. (2012). ‘A Garden Makes a House a Home.” New York: The Monacelli Press, LLC.This text is in good physical condition. One review by “Flower” magazine, accessed through this book’s listing on Fishpond () writes that the text is “A beautiful book . . . brimes with personal ideas from plant material and color combinations to stone walls, pergolas, fountains, walkway choices, and more. . . . A treasure and would make a lovely gift for anyone who is smitten with gardens” (Flower Magazine, 2013). From the same Fishpond listing, we also see another review that writes “"McDonald, a distinguished garden writer, presents 25 varied and gorgeous gardens from around the country, all reflecting the needs of their sites and the personalities of their owners” (Traditional Home, 2013). The Random House listing for this book () writes that it is“a collection of exquisite landscapes, created both by avid amateurs and well-known designers including Suzy Bales, Rosalind Creasy, Douglas Hoerr, Raymond Jungles, Karen Strohbeen and Bill Luchsinger, and Phillip Watson, that will inspire all who recognize the allure greenery can add to a home” (Random House, 2013). This text was acquired in January of 2013. It has 12 times and was last used in September of 2013. Final Verdict: I would keep this in the collection. From what I have read in the reviews not only is the text a good source for horticulturalists but it could also provide ideas for other home owners who are looking to improve their houses. 28. Primeau, Liz. (2003. “Front Yard Gardens.” Buffalo: Firefly Books (US) Inc. This book is in good physical condition. There is a new edition available. Colleen Vanderlinden on the Organic Gardening section of provides one of the reviews I examined for this text. In part of her review she writes “I very highly recommend … to any gardener who looks at that swath of green in the front yard and envisions a more colorful, lively landscape. The photos, tips, and stories of real gardeners who have put together their own front yard gardens make this an indispensable resource” (Vanderlinden, 2013). Publisher’s Weekly () states “The book is handsome, informative and amusingly written, and it should serve as an inspiration to those who are tired of old-fashioned lawns. 240 color photographs” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2003). This book was acquired in 2003. It has been charged 43 times and was last used in May of 2013. Final Verdict: A newer edition (which can be seen here: ) of this text exists and should be explored and acquired to replace this one if enough has been added or changed. 29. Rice, Graham. (1999). “Discovering Annuals.” Portland: Timber Press Inc.This text also has some of the same unusual brown crud that was present on the Helen Dillon text “The Flower Garden”, although not as much of it. This should be addressed as it is unsightly and will likely be a turn off for people. Through the Barnes and Noble listing for this text () we are able to view the Booknews review. This review explains how “Vibrant photographs demonstrate some creative and thoughtful combinations of unusual annuals and old favorites. Rice includes planting instructions and other practical information” (Booknews, 2013). The same page also displays a review from Fine Gardening. In discussing the book this review states at one point that there is “enough solid information on annual gardening techniques and seed starting to help anyone get these plants ready for their day in the sun” (Fine Gardening, 2013). This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 23 times and was last used in April of 2011. Final Verdict: The reviews certainly speak highly of this text. But the unsightly brown stains on the cover are a problem. I would submit this item to be cleaned and reviewed by the appropriate library staff. If there is a chance that its condition can be improved I see no other reason to not leave it in the collection. 30. Ruggiero, Michael A & Christopher, Tom. (2000). “Annuals with Style.” Newtown: The Taunton Press Inc.This book is in good physical condition. The Publisher’s Weekly review for this text () writes “The reader-friendly layout includes helpful sidebars and glorious photos. This book is ideal for beginners, yet seasoned gardeners should enjoy the fresh spin on an often overlooked subject” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2000). It makes it easier to reach a decision about the item when we are told outright that it is suitable for all levels of gardeners. Carol Cubberley’s review on Library Journal is viewable on the Barnes and Noble listing for this text (). The review briefly outlines what is contained in the book. “… This book traces the history of annuals and offers design ideas and instruction on the various methods of propagation. It also covers planting and care, weed prevention, and garden layout. The last third of the book is an encyclopedia of 75 essential annuals” (Cubberley, 2000). The status report did not indicate when the item was acquired by the library. It has been charged 20 times and was last used in April of 2011). Final Verdict: Annuals (plants that only survive for one season) are one of many important aspects of gardening. The positive reviews and good physical condition of this item leads me to keep it in the collection. 31. Schneller, Lee. (2009). “The Ever Blooming Flower Garden.” North Adams: Storey Publishing.This item is in acceptable physical condition. From the Barnes and Noble listing, we are able to read the “Midwest Book” review (). Part of this review states “Roughly half of The Ever-Blooming Flower Garden is devoted to a quick reference flower catalog, with color photos of each specimen and a simple line representing which months a given species is most likely to bloom. An excellent resource for flower-loving gardeners” (Midwest, 2013). I particularly like the “quick reference flower catalog” design as it allows for easy access to a lot of information. This item was acquired in 2011. It has been charged 13 times and was last used in August of 2013. Final Verdict: Given the design of the text, the fact that it focuses on yet another aspect of gardening (plants that bloom more so than other groups), and the positive review feedback I would keep this text in the collection. 32. Scanniello, Stephen. (1997). “A Year of Roses.” New York: Henry Holt and Company, Inc.This item is in good physical condition. Publisher’s Weekly () writes “each of the dozen chapters … outlines a particular month's chores and sends out shoots to embrace such broader subjects as rose history, pruning, planting and training techniques, as well as environmentally friendly methods of tackling the wide variety of pests and diseases to which roses are susceptible” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1997). In a book review by Debbie Blystone for Master Gardener’s Mecklenburg, she writes “A Year of Roses is not a coffee table book. There are no photos, just simple line drawings to illustrate the fine points of pruning, trellising and the like. Whether you’re thinking about buying your first rose or planning to dig up all your beds to revitalize 600 existing plants, I think you’d find something worth knowing in this book” (Blystone, 2006). This book was acquired in 2013. It has been charged 1 time and was last used in April of 2013. From Debbie Blystone’s review, as well as from the Barnes and Noble listing () I realized that there is an edition that was published in 2006). Whether or not there has been any updates to the text in this newer edition I would have to examine in closer detail.Final Verdict: If there are no significant changes to the newer publication of the text compared to the version on the library shelf then I see no reason to weed the item. I realize it has only circulated once, but that may be due to the library only having had it a short time (it was acquired in 2013). It is another more personal feeling text that also provides helpful information about rose gardening. 33. Smith, Linda Joan. (1998). “Garden Ornament.” New York: Workman Publishing.This text is in good physical condition. The Library Journal review accessed on the Barnes and Noble listing for this text states “The right ornament, placed in the right spot, can transform a garden into a place of mystery, repose, or enchantment … complete with instructions on the selection, siting, and care of ornaments … this profusely illustrated book, complete with source guide, will delight all gardeners” (Harris, 1998). The item was acquired in 2005. It has been charged 13 times and was last used in April of 2013. Final Verdict: Garden ornaments and their placement is not a topic that as large of a customer base ever brought up when I worked at the garden center. But those that did bring it up placed incredible importance on it. This book caters to those individuals who are looking for more details on these non plant additions to gardens. Because of this and the positive review status I would keep this text in the collection. 34. Sombke, Laurence. (1995). “Beautiful Easy Flower Gardens.” Emmaus: Rodale Press.This item is in good physical condition. The Publisher’s Weekly review for this book () states “The title is not misleading … Sombke writes in engagingly conversational style and offers practical design suggestions that should prompt even the most garden-wary to try their hands at growing flowers” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1995). Towards the end of the review it continues this when it states “although there are certainly ideas here for the experienced gardener, the book is an excellent choice for the beginner” (Publisher’s Weekly, 1995). Being geared for beginning gardeners is an important factor for this text. This book can be called upon to help those who want to become more involved with flower gardening but who are a bit unsure where to begin. It is not listed when this book was acquired. It has been charged 63 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict: Due to the good physical condition, positive review status, and suitability for individuals who would come to the library seeking help in getting started with gardening I would definitely keep this text in the collection. 35. Toogood, Alan. (2003). “Flowers – What to Grow and How to Grow it.” New York: Harper Collins Publishers, Inc.This book is in good physical condition. Through the listing, we are able to view the Booklist review for this text written by Carol Haggas. In part of the review she writes “Cleverly designed, carefully developed, and concisely detailed, this new gardening book is an indispensable, easy-to-use resource for horticultural information” (Haggas, 2013). The item was acquired in 2005. It has been charged 18 times and was last used in May of 2013. Final Verdict: The review material for this text is certainly positive. The good physical condition is also a plus. However, with this item I am wondering if it is necessary to keep it in the collection given that there are other similar texts present (including the Sombke text “Beautiful Easy Flower Gardens” that I reviewed just before this). I would flag this book as in need of review as compared to the other similar books in the collection. Perhaps this item being from 2003 might be more favorable than, for example, the Sombke text which is from 1995, on the basis of being more “current.” A closer examination of the actual contents should be done as well. 36. Wingate, Marty. (2011). “Landscaping for Privacy.” Timber Press Inc.The physical condition of this book is questionable. There is major folding on a lot of the corners of the pages. The cover is faded and has the appearance of being an “older” item despite it having only been in the library since December of 2011. Not sure if this should be attributed to sun damage, customer neglect, etc. The Danger Garden blog review paints this book in a positive light. At one point it states “there is a plant list at the back of the book, and this section is invaluable. After devouring the terrific ideas in the preceding chapters you are then given the information you need to make good plant choices. The list is divided into groupings … Some of these groups are further broken down by regions and their unique growing climates” (Danger Garden Blog, 2012). Additionally, when the review states “A tall, thin, “wall” of hedge plants can disguise a chain-link fence, but if those plants grow to 25 ft. tall and wide, you need to make the commitment to keep the hedge in check” (Danger Garden Blog, 2012) it really struck home for me. This is advice that I have given countless individuals over time for designing the landscaping of their yards. I always feel accomplished when I steer a person away from a particular plant that they were not aware could grow large enough to overtake the area. This item was acquired in 2011. It has been charged 14 times and was last used in May of 2013. Final Verdict: Given the importance of meeting the needs of people who are landscaping for privacy, as well as ensuring the proper plants are installed, I would definitely keep this text in the collection. The positive review status is also a plus. It is a fairly recent book and the timeliness will help its reputation among patrons. 37. Petrides, George A. (1972). “A Field Guide to Trees and Shrubs.” (2). Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.The physical condition of this book is poor. There is significant water damage, stains on many of the pages, and the paper is noticeably yellowing. Write ups I have seen for this title do not seem to match my personal assessment of this text. For example, Powell’s Books writes “All the wild trees, shrubs, and woody vines in the area north to Newfoundland, south to North Carolina and Tennessee, and west to the Dakotas and Kansas are described in detail … clear, accurate drawings illustrate leaves, flowers, buds, tree silhouettes, and other characteristics” (Powell’s Books, 2013). What this write up failed to include is that there is an insufficient amount of images in the book. Descriptions in words are somewhat helpful, but for the large percentage of people with only a normal degree of knowledge about plants the lack of imagery to help identify them would likely be an issue. The text was acquired in 2002. It has been charged only 5 times and was last used in September of 2009. The horticultural section of this library’s collection is likely not the most often circulated, as the average amount of charges for the texts I’ve reviewed seem to indicate, but this text is even on the low end of that. Final Verdict: I would weed this item. The copyright date is one issue, as people will likely assume it is dated in comparison to other texts in this section. The lack of imagery is another problem. The physical problems of yellowing pages, water damage, stains, etc. are additional strikes against the book. Even though write ups, such as the Powell’s Books one I quoted above paint the book in a positive light, I am still not convinced that it can outweigh the negatives from these other factors. 38. Powell, Eileen. (2004). “The Gardener’s A-Z Guide to Growing Flowers from Seed to Bloom.” North Adams: Storey Publishing.This item is in good physical condition. The BookReview review ($spindb.query.listreview2.booknew.13218) for this item states “For each individual plant, the author lets you know when to plant the seeds and where, then how often to water and feed, how to maintain the flowers, when to transplant-everything there is to know … A definitive, must-read book” (, 2013). It does not list when this item was acquired by the library. It has been charged 2 times and was last used in May of 2013. I would have to look into when this book was acquired. Either way, the extremely low circulation amount is a red flag for me.Final Verdict: The book seems like a good item to have based on reviews, but the low circulation amount is what grabs my attention here. If it was acquired very recently the low circulation amount could be justified. But if it was acquired around 2004 and has only circulated twice in the last 9.5 years then it should be reviewed for possible weeding.39. Kourik, Robert. (2000). “The Tree & Shrub Finder.” Newtown: The Taunton Press.This book is in good physical condition. Through the listing we are able to read George Cohen’s Booklist review of this text (). He writes “Part 1 covers many of the functions that trees and shrubs can offer the gardener … such elements as privacy, sun and shade, lawns, colorful foliage and bark, … in Part 2, Kourik explains how to care for the trees and shrubs; buying options, planting, fertilizing, staking, watering, mulching, and pruning are discussed, and data on pest and disease control are presented” (Booklist, 2013). The Rabbits and Radishes blog entry for this text () also paints the book in a positive light. Part of this review states “This book offers great suggestions for specific tree varieties to fit the specifications of almost any situation.? As a bonus there are also clear instructions and diagrams for planting, watering and pruning a tree” (Rabbits and Radishes Blog, 2013). This item was acquired in 2000. It was charged 51 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict: based on the reviews, circulation amount, and my own thoughts as I glanced through the book I would keep this item in the collection. 40. Tukey, Paul. (2007) “The Organic Lawn Care Manual.” North Adams: Storey Publishing.This book is in good physical condition. One section of the Publisher’s Weekly review for this text (), in discussing the author himself, states “When, after years on the job, he began to experience nosebleeds and shortness of breath, his doctor ordered him to stop using lawn chemicals, and that was the beginning of his commitment to organic lawn care” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2007). I personally agree with keeping chemicals off of my property, so I have actually marked this text and I will check it out when I have some free time to read it! In this text readers will find information “on soil structure and how to improve it; grass varieties; "starting a lawn from scratch"; natural lawn foods; "watering dews and don'ts"; and how to deal with moles, voles, grubs and bugs” (Publisher’s Weekly, 2007). Anyone interested in a healthier lawn without chemicals would be interested in this book based on this review. Based on the review written by Kelly Burke (), this book will help the reader create a “natural, low maintenance system for a beautiful, safe lawn, learn how to eliminate weeds and beat pests naturally, step by step instructions on how to start a new lawn or improve an existing one, learn how to pick and maintain grass varieties for your region” (Burke, 2013). This item was acquired in 2007. It has been charged 18 times and was last used in January of 2012. Final Verdict: Based on the positive reviews and the good physical condition of the item I see no reason to remove it from the collection. The circulation amount is a bit on the low side but I would give this item more time before considering weeding it. 41. Lesniewicz, Paul. (1996). “Bonsai in Your Home.” New York: Sterling Publishing Co. Inc.This item is in good physical condition. Part of the Columbus Bonsai Society’s review () of this text states “one of the attractive features of this book is its numerous full-page color plates, many of trees in flower … as with several other books, Bonsai in Your Home is organized into a history-horticultural section, and then a section devoted to the care of individual species” (Columbus Bonsai Society, 2013). On the Amazon listing for this book () part of George Cohen’s (of Booklist) review of this text can be seen. He writes that the book “offers instructions on care, including light, humidity, temperature, watering, and feeding requirements. He includes step-by-step directions on shaping and creating four classic bonsai forms … the bulk of the book is a listing of 42 bonsai plants arranged alphabetically with detailed instructions on their care” (Cohen, 2013). The book was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 24 times and was last used in April of 2012. Final Verdict: Bonsai is yet another facet of horticulture and should be included in the collection. Because of this, and the positive reviews, I would not weed this item. 42. Chiusoli, Alessandro & Boriani, Maria Luisa. (1986). “Simon & Schuster’s Guide to House Plants.” New York: Simon & Schuster.This text is in extremely poor physical condition. The spine is almost completely torn away from the book. There is evidence of rotting. Severe water damage as if the book was dropped into a swimming pool. I cannot be 100% sure without closer inspection but I also believe there is some insect damage to the book. Even before I looked up reviews for this book I already decided to weed this item on the basis of its physical condition. The Through Life Blog () writes “this compact, pocket-sized handbook is perfect for taking along when you are shopping for houseplants. This is a very informative and practical guide that is fun to flip through and easy to reference.Check to see if your local library has a copy of this good book. If they do, check it out” (Through Life Blog, 2009). Though they are unofficial I did briefly glance at the customer reviews on Amazon for this book and several reviewers noted that it is a “good book but nothing special” (). The write up for this book on the I Grow Hydro () listing is positive. The book was acquired in 2008. It has been charged only 3 times and was last used in March of 2010. Final Verdict: This text should be weeded from the collection given its incredibly poor physical condition. 43. Hadden, Evelyn J. (2012). “Beautiful No Mow Yards.” Portland, Timber Press Inc.This book is in good physical condition. Susan Morrison of Lawn Reform Coalition reviews this text here: . Toward the end of her review, she lists her “Likes” and “Quibbles” about this book. Some positives she says about the text include “I appreciate the level of detail provided about the gardens featured in the design section … The book is very comprehensive” (Morrison, 2013). Among the criticisms she has of the book include “While the book is filled with excellent photographs, the majority are close-ups that don’t easily convey the effect of a lawn alternative vs. traditional turf grass” and “many of the same plants are referenced repeatedly … this book probably won’t introduce you to many plants you aren’t already familiar with (Morrison, 2013). The Common Weeder Blog entry review for this book () provides an additional positive perspective. This book was acquired in 2012. It has been charged 14 times and was last used in April of 2013. Final Verdict: I would keep this item in the collection. However, I would make a note to examine the collection at a future time in order to determine if other books that would help make up for this one’s shortcomings are present. If not, it may be worth acquiring one or two if demand calls for it and budgets will allow it. 44. Swindells, Philip. (1995). “Garden Pools, Waterfalls, & Fountains.” New York: Sterling Publishing Co. Inc. This text is in good physical condition. Garden Guides () states that the book “provides all the information needed to build everything from small-scale fountains to inviting ponds and flowing waterfalls … step-by-step photos show how to create your own water feature (Garden Guides, 2013). The Amazon listing () explains that with the book you can “Learn the best place to site a water feature, what type best complements gardens of every size and style, and much more” (, 2013). The text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 20 times and was last used in May of 2012. Final Verdict: Given the subject matter and informative nature of the text I would keep it in the collection. 45. Hayward, Gordon. (2001). “Stone in the Garden.” New York: W.W. Norton & Company.Physical condition of this text is good. The Booknews review accessible through the Barnes and Noble listing for this book () states “a garden designer describes the creative and practical aspects of garden rock work … covers practicalities such as choosing a stone mason and calculating amounts of stone. Especially useful is a visual index of 53 widely-available varieties of stone” (Booknews, 2013). Through the Amazon listing (), Carol Haggas’ Booklist review of the text states “Whether it's benches or boulders, walls or walkways, stone is hard, but Hayward makes it look easy” (Haggas, 2013). The book was acquired in 2003. It has been charged 42 times and was last used in October of 2012. Final Verdict: Stonescaping is an important aspect of gardening/landscaping/etc. The reviews also point to the usefulness of this text. However, it has been charged less than half the amount of the Barbara Pleasant text “Garden Stone” on the same subject (see next item below). I would have to delve deeper into both texts contents in order to determine if the lower circulation amount is an indicator to weed this item. 46. Pleasant, Barbara. (2002). “Garden Stone.” North Adams: Storey Publishing. This text is in good physical condition. Through the reviews on the Barnes and Noble listing () we are told ““Pleasant's excellent book covers everything that's necessary to add stone to your garden...” (Buffalo News, 2013) as well as how the text is “a must-read for anyone wanting to add stone to the garden, whether it’s a do-it-yourself project or work-for-hire job” (Detroit News and Free Press, 2013). The Booklist review by Carol Haggas that can be found on the Amazon listing for the text () states “no stone has been left unturned in this encyclopedic discourse on the many ways it can enhance a landscape, from captivating pathways to romantic garden walls” (Haggas, 2013). The item was acquired in 2002. It has been charged 44 times and was last used in January of 2013. Final Verdict: This text has been charged a little more than double the amount of the Gordon Hayward text on the same subject. I would have to compare both in more detail to determine why this is the case and what the final verdict for the Hayward text will be. 47. Swindells, Philiip. (1997). “The Master Book of the Water Garden.” Blacksburg: Tetra Press. The physical condition of this text is average. It could be better but I have seen items in much worse shape as well. The Barnes and Noble listing () states “With a wealth of practical ideas and tips on water gardening, this indispensable book helps minimize the problems faced in building and maintaining a water garden, and maximizes the pleasure a well-designed water garden can give” (Barnes and Noble, 2013). This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 36 times and was last used in June of 2013. Final Verdict From what I have seen I would keep it in the collection as it handles a different aspect of water gardening than the other Swindell text. This book deals with more varied aspects of water gardening while “Garden Pools, Waterfalls, and Fountains” deals more specifically with the fountains aspect. 48. Thompson, Peter. (1993). “The Propagator’s Handbook.” Newton Abbot: David & Charles. This text is in good physical condition. Better World Books () states “this practical guide explains how to divide plants, sow seeds, and take cuttings using simple, foolproof techniques … Propagation methods are included for annuals, perennials, shrubs, ferns, alpines, climbers, conservatory plants, bulbs, and trees” (Better World Books, 2013). This is important as it covers various plant types that people will be interested in learning about. This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 15 times and was last used in September of 2013. Final Verdict: Because starting plants from seed is an important aspect of horticulture, and the write up and condition of the text are good, I would keep this item in the collection. 49. Bryant, Geoff. (2003). “Plant Propagation A to Z.” Buffalo: Firefly Books (US) Inc.This text is in good physical condition. Through the Barnes and Noble listing () a number of reviews are viewable. Carol Haggas of Booklist states “Comprehensive ... Bryant's guide provides an essential and encyclopedic resource for the fiscally minded, or just creatively curious, gardener” (2013). Science news writes “Clearly outlines all aspects of plant propagation, from selecting the right tools to identifying which plants reproduce by seed, division, and cutting” (2013). Rachael Green in American Reference Books Annual, Volume 35 writes “A handy guide to all propagation techniques... written in an accessible style…” (2013). This text was acquired in 2003. It has been charged 13 times and was last used in May of 2011. Final Verdict: Given the positive reviews, nature of the text, and good physical condition of the item I would keep it in the collection. Seeding plants is a major aspect of horticulture. I remember growing literally hundreds of thousands of plants from seed to maturity in order to be sold at the garden center I worked at. 50. Kelly, John. (1996). “Growing Plants from Seed.” London: Ward Lock. This text is in good physical condition. Through the Amazon listing (), which displays the Booklist write up by George Cohen, the book “The author offers step-by-step instructions on growing trees, shrubs, perennials, annuals, alpines, bulbs, and vegetables, all from seeds. He gives brief instructions on growing more difficult trees, shrubs, perennials, and bulbs--also from seeds. This helpful paperback, with 50 black-and-white illustrations, is a Garden Book Club selection” (Cohen, 2013).This text was acquired in 2000. It has been charged 19 times and was last used in January of 2013. Final Verdict: Due to the amount of texts on the topic of propagation present I would have to compare them all before making a final decision, but if it is deemed unique enough to remain I would keep the item in the collection. The positive Booklist write up is also a plus for the item. Regarding circulation, it is average with the previous two texts I discussed here on propagation. At this time I feel that the library’s horticulture/gardening/etc. collection is reasonably complete. In examining the texts I have found ones that cover a wide array of sub sections that were not addressed in the 50 titles I used for this exercise. However, one area that I feel would benefit from at least one more text on the subject is hydroponics/hydroponic gardening. While I would not recommend having too many seemingly duplicate texts on one subject, having at least two gives patrons some form of variety. As of writing this paper, the only book on Hydroponics that the library has is:Bridwell, Raymond. (1972). “Hydroponic Gardening: the “magic” of modern hydroponics for the home gardener.” Loma Linda: Woodbridge Press Publishing Co. The only issue I have with this text from what I have seen is the publication date. People might have a sense that the information is “out dated” being that it was published in 1972. One text that I would recommend adding to the collection is: Patten, George F Van. (2008). “Gardening Indoors with Soil and Hydroponics.” (5) SI: Van Patten Pub. () displays some reviews for this text. Tom Alexander of Growing Edge Magazine, in discussing the book, states “It is literally a one stop gardening encyclopedia of information for both the beginner to the very experienced gardener. If I was to buy only one book on indoor gardening, this would be the one" (Alexander, 2013). On a similar note, Jim Jesson of Maximum Yield Publications states “Everything you need to know about hydroponics and then some! … The book is written in layman's terms and is complete with illustrations and photos” (Jesson, 2013). There are other items that could be examined on Hydroponics on this page but given that this text is the 5th edition and is “A Best Seller since 1986, now expanded and completely rewritten with all new information!” (Botanical, 2013), I feel this is a good book to start with. Concluding ThoughtsThis exercise has taught me much about the entire process of examining a collection, assessing an item’s relevancy through means such as reviews, and ultimately reaching a verdict on whether or not an item is still relevant enough to remain in the collection. The library I used for this exercise also allowed me to examine their own printed book that explains the CREW method of weeding that the staff there uses. It was a major asset to be able to examine the process in a real environment. The only disappointment (in a light hearted joking way) for the staff was that I did not use the particular collection on the shelves that is currently (as of 12/1/13) undergoing weeding and management! The staff is very friendly and was interested in my approach to this exercise. Works Cited1. 2000, February 28. “Herbs.” Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . Nordin, Kendra. 2008, August 6. “Heriloom, Notes from an Accidental Tomato Farmer.” The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . 2008, May 5. “Heirloom, Notes from an Accidental Tomato Farmer. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from: . 4. 2007, July 9. “Backyard Giants: The Passionate, Heartbreaking, and Glorious Quest to Grow the Biggest Pumpkin Ever” Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . Baumle, Kylee. 2010, November 2. “Backyard Giants: The Passionate, Heartbreaking, and Glorious Quest to Grow the Biggest Pumpkin Ever.” Gardening by the Book. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . 2011. “Finally, the first book on growing high-dollar gourmet greens for sale or your own table.” Growing for Market. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . 2013. “Microgreens (Paperback)” Book Depository. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . 2013. “Microgreens, A Guide to Growing Nutrient-Packed Greens.” Better World Books. Retrieved 12 November, 2013 from . 9. 2001. “Herbs, the Complete Gardener’s Guide” Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 14 November, 2013 from . 2013. Herbs The Complete Gardener’s Guide. Powell’s Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2004. The Herbalist's Garden: A Guided Tour of 10 Exceptional Herb Gardens: The People Who Grow Them and the Plants That Inspire Them” Book Enthusiast. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2007, May 1. “Gardening Book Reviews: The Personal Odyssey of a Great Plantsman and Gardener.” Horticulture. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. “Book Review: The Herbalists Garden” “Canadian Gardening” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Beautiful Easy Herbs How to Get the Most from Herbs - In Your Garden and in Your Home. “Paperback Swap” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. “Beautiful Easy Herbs: How to Get the Most from Herbs - In Your Garden and in Your Home.” “AbeBooks.co.uk.” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Beautiful Easy Herbs:?How to Get the Most from Herbs-In Your Garden and in Your Home. Google Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2000, May 1. Taylor's Master Guide to Landscaping: Everything a Homeowner Needs to Know about Designing, Maintaining, and Renovating a Home Landscape. “Publisher’s Weekly.” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . Adam, Judith. Book Review: Taylor’s Master Guide to Landscaping. “Canadian Gardening” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 1997, February 2. Gardening with Foliage Plants: Leaf, Bark, Berry. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Gardening with Foliage Plants. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Country Living Gardener Dreamscaping: 25 Easy Designs for Home Gardens. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Climbing Gardens: Adding Height and Structure to Your Garden. Better World Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Climbing Gardens: Adding Height and Structure to Your Garden. Bookish. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Flower Garden: A Practical Guide to Planning and Planting the Wayside Gardens Collection. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Flower Garden: a Practical Guide to Planning and Planting (The Wayside Collection). Amazon. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Flower Garden: a Practical Guide to Planning and Planting (The Wayside Collection). Indigo. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . Moll, Joy Weese. 2012, June 1. “Book Review: Garden Artistry by Helen Dillon. Joy’s Book Blog. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Plants for Small Spaces. Amazon. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. A Garden Lover’s Cape Cod. Bookish. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. A Garden Lover’s Cape Cod. Through His Blood Christian Store. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013 Country Living Gardener Gardening Basics: How to Design, Plant & Maintain Your Garden (Our Garden Variety) “AbeBooks. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Art of Japanese Gardens: Designing & Making Your Own Peaceful Space (Paperback). Tower Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Growing Perennials in Cold Climates: Revised and Updated Edition. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2011. Timely Revision and Update of a Great Perennial Plant Book:Growing Perennials in Cold Climates. “Renegade Gardener.” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Cutting Gardens The Complete Guide to Growing Flowers and Creating Spectacular Arrangements from. “Chegg” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Cutting Gardens: The Complete Guide to Growing Flowers and Creating Spectacular Arrangements from?[Hardcover]. Amazon UK. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Reliable Roses. Chicago Botanic Garden. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2003, May 5. YOUR HOUSE, YOUR GARDEN: A Foolproof Approach to Garden Design. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. “The Flowering Shrub Expert. Expert Series.” Powells Books” Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 1998, February 2. Rodale's Weekend Gardener: Create a Low-Maintenance Landscape to Enjoy Year-Round. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Plant This!: Best Bets for Year-Round Gorgeous Gardens. AbeBooks. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2012, June 20. The Cottage Garden: June Book Review. Soil Sister. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 1994, October 10. Tasha Tudor's Garden. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. A Garden Makes a House a Home. Fish Pond. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. A Garden Makes a House a Home. Random House. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2003, February 17. Front Yard Gardens: Growing more than Grass. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Discovering Annuals. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2000, February 28. Annuals with Style. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Annuals with Style. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Ever Blooming Flower Garden. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 1997, February 2. A Year of Roses. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December 2013 from . 2013. A Year of Roses. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December 2013 from . 2013. Garden Ornament. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 1995, October 30. Beautiful Easy Flower Gardens. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Flowers, What to Grow and How to Grow It. Amazon. Retrieved 1 December 2013 from . 2012, January 5. Lanscaping For Privacy. Danger Garden Blog. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. A Field Guide to Trees and Shrubs. Powell’s Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. The Gardener’s A to Z Guide to Growing Flowers. Book Review. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from $spindb.query.listreview2.booknew.1321859. Mahler, Evee. 2013, May 1. Book Review: Tree and Shrub Finder. Rabbits and Radishes Blog. Retrieved 1 December 2013 from . 2007, January 8. The Organic Lawn Care Manual. Publisher’s Weekly. Retrieved 1 December 2013 from . Burke, Kelly. Organic Lawn Care Manual. About. Retrieved 1 December, 013 from . 2013. Review: Bonsai In Your Home, Lesniewicz. The Columbus Bonsai Society. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2009, June 1. Another Good Houseplants Book. Plowing Through Life. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . Morrison, Susan. Beautiful No Mow Lawns Book Review. Lawn Reform Coalition. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2010. Garden Pools. Garden Guide. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Stone In The Garden. B&N. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Garden Stone. Amazon. Retrieved 1 Dec, 2013 from . 2013. Master Book of the Water Garden. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 Dec, 2013 from . 2013. The Propagator’s Handbook. Better World Books. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . 2013. Plant Propagation from A to Z. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 Dec 2013 from . 2013. Growing Plants from Seed. Barnes and Noble. Retrieved 1 Dec 2013 from . 2013. Hydroponic Books. Botanical. Retrieved 1 December, 2013 from . ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download