Naturopathic Physicians Medical Board



State Of Arizona

Naturopathic Physicians Medical Board

“Protecting the Public’s Health”

1400 West Washington • Suite 230 • Phoenix, AZ 85007 • Telephone 602-542-8242 • FAX 602-542-3093

Website

TTY for Americans with Disability 800-367-8939 • Disability Voice Relay 800-842-4681

Janice K. Brewer – Governor

Dr. Bruce Sadilek, ND – Chair • Ms. Amanda Reeve – Vice Chair • Dr. Marianne Marchese, ND – Secretary / Treasurer,

Dr. John Eldridge, NMD– Physician Member - Dr. Amy Terlisner, ND- Physician Member

MINUTES

BOARD MEETING

Thursday July 10, 2014 • 1:00 p.m. • Basement Conference Room B-1

1400 West Washington • Phoenix, AZ 85007

1. Call to Order by Presiding Officer

A. Roll call of Board members and establishment of a quorum to conduct meeting.

The meeting was called to order at 1:05 pm.

Roll Call: Dr. Terlisner; Present, Dr. Marchese; Present, Ms. Reeve; Present, Dr. Eldridge; Present, Dr. Sadilek' Present. 5 Present 2 Vacant

B. Acknowledgement of presence of Board staff and legal counsel.

Present were Ms. Elizabeth Campbell, Assistant Attorney General, Ms. Gail Anthony, Executive Director

2. Civility Statement

In accordance with the Open Meeting Law, the Board has a civility policy that prohibits any type of

disorderly conduct that disrupts the Board from carrying out its business. Those violating this policy will

be asked to modify their behavior and act civilly. If the disorderly conduct continues, the person may be

removed from the meeting room. (Adopted 11/8/2012)

3. Executive Director Report

Status of Administrative Operation

Procedural Matters

◦ Rules Package

◦ Sunset Review

Summary of Agency Reports

Budget

Current Licensee Numbers

Current Case Numbers

No Action Required

4. Call to the Public

This item was moved to the end of the agenda.

5. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by Board of Consent Agenda

C. Declaration of any Conflict of Interest on any Item on the Consent Agenda.

Dr. Terlisner and Dr. Marchese declared conflicts of interest.

D. Request for Removal of any Consent Agenda Item for independent discussion and possible action by the Board.

Dr. Kristy Anderson, Dr. Jennifer Dye and Dr. Kayla Eckart were removed from item 5 (C) of the

consent agenda.

E. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action and by Board of Regular and Executive Session Minutes of May 8, 2014.

Dr. Marchese made a motion to accept the minutes of the May 8th, 2014 Board Meeting. Seconded by Dr. Turlisner. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant. Ms. Reeve made a motion to accept the Executive Minutes from the May 8th, 2014 Board Meeting. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

F. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Medical License(s) / Examination Application

Collinge, Hayley

The Board approved the application for licensure by examination.

G. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Medical License(s) / Endorsement.

Helms, Lawrence - UT. Reinstatement. (temporary license issued in accordance with A.R.S. 32- 1522.01)

Hill, Taylor- NH, (temporary license issued in accordance with A.R.S. 32- 1522.01)

Rosario, Sue Ellen - VT. (temporary license issued in accordance with A.R.S. 32- 1522.01)

The Board approved the application(s) for licensure by endorsement.

H. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application(s) for Certificate to Dispense (initial)

Adelson, Harry

Collinge, Hayley

Davenport, Emily

Eastman, Carol

Moroso, Heather

Nowak-Stears, Julie

Sickinger, Karleen

Song, Crystal

Sumegi, Lorraine

The Board approved the application(s) for initial certificate to dispense.

I. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application(s) for Renewal of Certificate to Dispense.

Aidun, Sima

Alschuler, Lisa

Alejandro, Angelina

Alexandros, Karsten

Anderson-McLaughlin, Jessica

Ardolf, Deborah

Armanti, Christian

Aton Robins, Nancy

Bachelier, Aimee

Bakty, Esti

Barnes, Lori

Barnett, Kevin

Bantel, Dawn

Barth, Inge

Beardsley, Lauren

Beck, Patricia

Belt, Amber

Beltran, Chriselda

Bird, Robb

Birdsall, Shauna

Birdsall, Timothy

Black, Wayne

Blackman, Kenneth

Blasi, Jennifer

Borsa, Robin

Botham, Jennifer

Boyer, Veronica

Breiten, Valeria

Brooks, Barbara

Brown, Kimberly

Buratovich, Nick

Burns, Jennifer

Buxbaum, Dane

Cain, Brianna

Cain, Nicole

Callejas, Yezid

Cameron, Brent

Carpenter, Rebecca

Carrell, Carol

Ceballos-Logan

Cerre, Eric

Chambers, Keith

Christianson, Alan

Chung, Ashley

Clark, Kerri Lynne

Clough, Kelly

Coats, Melissa

Correia, Kirstin

Crider, Heather

Cronin, Courtney

Cronin, Kyle

Cronin, Michael

Curtis, Judith

Dallman, Terra

D'Aprile, Delores

Darley, April

Darragh, Angela

Deal, Sheldon

Derion, Cheryl

de Soler, Alexander

Devile, Lauren

Dietzgen, Mark

DiFillippo, Mary

Dubasik Valentina

Dunn, Melenie

Eastman, Stephanie

Eaton, Lois

Eischens, Shawna

Ellsworth, Robert

Engard, Kimberly

Epstein, Danya

Etcheverry, Chase

Ewald, Jaime

Ezrre. Barbara

Farner, Hope

Fosdick Turner, Leila

Flagler, Lila

Flagler, Samuel

Flynn, Julie

Ford, Rebecca

Franco, Gioacchino

Freeze, Karen

Gaines, Patricia

Gajus, Stephanie

Galaburri, Mario

Gallagher, Jeanette

Gerard, Nicole

Gianni, Judy

Girard, Christine

Grady, Elizabeth

Graham, Stephanie

Grey, Laurence

Grimes Saber, DeeAnn

Haller, Danite

Ham, Natalie

Hampton, Eric

Hassberger, Kelly

Hayman, Jessica

Hazel, Sara

Heffner, Karlee

Hernandez Guzman, Margarita

Hicks, Anna

Hinojosa, Cynthia Renee

Hinojosa-Sinks, Judith

Hoffman, Jordan

Hooker, Laree

Hoppe, Michelle

Huber, Colleen

Hyun, Yu-Ree

Ian, Hannah

Inouye, Vance

Jacques, F. Debbie

Jamison, Carol Ann

Jensen, Jason

Johnson, Eric

Jones, Judith

Kasdorf, Cheryl

Katz, Steven

Keaton, Dana

Keiffer, Julie

Keilty, Jeni

Kellum, Nicole

Kennedy, Laura

Kerievsky, Adam

Kerievsky, Ross H.

Khalsa, Sarv Varta

Khoshaba, Linda

King, Denette

Knytych, Jeffrey

Kohler, Gemie

Kollin, Cheryl

Koomia, Jessica

Koudelka, Barbara

Kovalik, Christina

Krieger-Fiedler, Allyn

Krukowski, Jody Lynn

Kruzel, Thomas

Lambert-Rampe, Laura

Lambert, Linda

Lan, Cara

Larke, Dan

Lee, Thomas

Leon, Gilberto

Leone, Jacquie

Linton, LoRal

Logan, Darla

Lopez. Eric

Lopez, Jorge

Loschert, Amy-Jane

Lovick, Ann

Lussier, Spice

Lutrin, Sandy

Maltais, Shannon

Manrique, Javier

Marcantel, Mary

Martell, Casey

Martell, Laura

Maturo, Lisa

McCallister, Heath

McCarthy, Brendan

McCarthy, Heather

McConnell, Bryan

McGarey, Peggy

McJunckin, Clinton

Mehrabani, Ardeschir

Messer, Stephen

Middlemiss, Erica

Miles, George Michael

Milisen, Robert

Miller, Michael

Miller-Sickels, Laura

Mitchell, Jessica

Mitchell, Kenneth

Mitchell, Tiffany

Monterrey, Dayna

Moody, Lauri

Morehouse, Delaney

Morrissey, Robert

Morstein, Mona

Muhammad, Kim

Mullis, Nancy Ellen

Mundt, Jennifer

Murray, M. Ann

Myers, Robert

Navarro, Alma

Nevels, Jennifer

Norris, Kristi

Nguyen, Krystine

O'Brien, Kareen

O'Brien, Mary Ellen

Oertle, John

Ortiz, Jose

Orlowski, Andria

Orona, Shahrzad

Oskin, Jamie

Ozalan, Glenn

Palzer, Anne Marie

Patrice, Analiah

Paulson, Heather

Peachy, Miriam

Pearson, Lindsey

Peruch, Tracy

Peyman, Tara

Pierce, Brandie

Pingel, Patricia

Poindexter, Beth

Popiel, Brian

Potts, Jeffrey

Poulos, Jacqueline

Predmore, Leslie

Pritchard, Allison

Purcell, Andrea

Quintanar, Noemie

Ramsey, Theresa

Reker, Mary

Revak, Carol

Rezaie, Saman

Rhodes, Rachel

Riabikina, Irina

Richardson, Lisa

Rittling, Carrie

Roberson, Amanda

Rodgers, Sara

Romero-Bosch, Cristina

Rubin, Daniel

Ruinard, Leytocha

Runbeck, Craig

Sage, Kathryn

Sager, Jeffrey

Santora, Marie

Schwartz, Boris

Schwehr, Maureen

Schuck, Herbert

Seipt, Ann

Selvey, Don

Sherman, Leah

Shiffler, Nichole

Skelton, Janice

Smialek, Kiera

Smith, Garrett

Smith, Jennifer

Smolinski, Deb i

Spat, Tam

Spooner, Carol

Stage, Katrina

Stallone, Paul

Stark, Stephanie

Seitz, Stephanie

Steinberger, Katrina

Steinke, Rhonda

Stewart, Adrienne

Stone, Carolyn

Stouk, Olya

Strand, Roxie

Strong, Christine

Sundermeyer, Zahara

Swanick, Summer

Tabares. Amber

Takaki, Nanao

Tecaya, Kam

Terranella, Robin

Terrell, Shana

Thacker, Meghna

Thanki, Meghana

Thatcher, Michelle

Thomas, Suzanne

Thompson, Corrie

Toghyani, Jeannette

Triplett-Foss, Paula

Turner, Mary Jo

Tveit-Pettersen, Sonja

Udell, Eric

Upchurch, Robert

Vaghela, Monica

Vassighi, Nazanin

Ventura, Jose

Vesco, Teresa

Victor, Erin

Virdee, Kulveen

Volk, Kimberly

Wagner, Amy

Waldman, Renee

Walker, Catherine

Walker, Samuel

Walters, Sam

Wazny, Philip

Wdowin, Garrett

Weeshoff, Laura

Weiner, Andrea

Weyrich, Orville

Whelchel, Rebecca

Whitley, Marnie

Whitsell, Melinda

Wiggins, Natalie

Williamson, Susan

Wilkinson, Charles

Wilson, Adrienne

Winton, Jeffrey

Woeller, DeAnna

Wojtowicz, Angela Loise

Wolf, Jacob

Worden, Donese

Yongren, Christina

Yosef, Isaac

Yurgel, Betty

Zeller, Barrie

The Board approved the application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense.

J. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application(s) for Initial and Renewal of Medical Assistant Certificate.

Cook, Brittany

DiMatteo, Nancy (initial)

Hermosa, Karina (initial)

Hofmeister, Susan Ann

Lockly-Johnson, Denise

Shelton, Susan

Sherwood, Jessica Ann

Walters, Dustin

White, Sara

The Board approved the application(s) for initial and renewal medical assistant certificates.

K. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application(s) for Certificate to Engage in a Clinical Training Program, Initial and Renewal.

Abed, Wafa

Adams, Konstantina

Agard, Janelle

Ahmad, Arsallan

Alvarez, Wilbert-John

Annello, Alyssa

Avakian, Ara

Bailey, Stephanie

Balduzzi, Anthony

Banker, Rosanna

Barraza, Michelle

Becker, Kelsey

Bendokaitis, Beth

Bennett, Brittany

Bejarano, Alfredo

Bloom, Laura

Briante, Carla

Britton, Mallory

Buseman, Sarah

Butner, Lana Olvia

Chavez, Jessyca

Cummins, Emy

Davis, Lynette

de Graaf, Tara

Despotides, Bianca

Dickerson, Wendy

Doyle, Kimberly

Dragg, Darlyn

Dugan, Angela

Dutton, Jordan

Ellington, Amber Jade

Ellis, Erin

Endahl, Ann-Charlotte

Erath, Laurel

Farshad, Yasamine

Fuller, Ashley

Gariboldi, Matthew

Gaston, Clark

Goff, Vince

Golay, Kira

Griffith, Brandi

Gustavson, Rebecca

Harding, Lindsey

Higgs, Nathanael

Hines, Najakielladiji

Homkovics, Shannon

Hulet, Katherine

Huston, Stephanie

Jackson, Donna

James, Cara

James, Charmainge

Janjua, Kiran

Jeong, Dian

Jollie, Jane

Jonas, Mary

Keddie, Kalli

Kiger, Garrett

Krick, Kira

Krueger, Dylan

Kuang, LeeAnn

Kuchenbecker, Christina

Lad, Pranav

Lisiechi, Michele

Liu, Liy

Mackay-Timmermans, Drew

Major, Michael

Markham, Jennifer

Markison, Laura

Maycher, Megan

Maxwell, Erin

McCalla, Bethany

McClory, Christopher

McCormack, Kristen

Meraz, Samantha

Mitchell, Sasha

Mittman, Arie

Morse, Michael

Molina, Jose

Morin, Tanya

Mowery, Travis

Mulligan, Sarah

Nagallo, Krisel

Nelson, Erik

Nickel, Beck

Nguyen, Kensive

Pagano, Taylor

Pannu, Neelamjeet

Parent, Diana

Pendleton, Ashley

Pollock, Tara

Poteet, Zachary

Price, Gabrielle

Ramanan, Karthik

Reveron, Jorge

Richards, Calvin

Robins, Jade

Rodriguez-Berrios, Maria

Rodriquez, Carolina

Romero, Kelly

Ruiz, Guillermo

Sabetisoofyani, Arash

Salisbury, Laurne

Salzwedel, Kristen

Savage, Annie

Schaefer, Cosima

Shulman, Kathryn

Singh, Sahib

Smithers, Jillian

Sobczyk, Jean-Marc

Soto, Christy

Sowards, Dustin

Sparks, Linda

St. Rose, John

Sumberg, Kayla

Taddiken, Elizabeth Anne

Tapia, Paola

Thomas, Christopher Michae

Thompson, Rebekah

To, Lina

Touw, Henderson

Valero, Bernardo

Wright, Ellie

Yacabi, Eva

Zamora, Jamie

Zenhausen, Alissa

The Board approved the application(s) for initial and renewal certificates to engage in clinical training.

L. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application(s) for Specialty Training Certification.

Dr. Laura Martell - Oncology, Approved by the AANP/ OncANP

The Board approved the application for specialty certificate.

CONSENT AGENDA VOTE

Ms. Reeve made a motion to accept items 5 F - L of the consent agenda. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

6. Regulatory Matters

M. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Investigations and Complaints. (The Board may go into executive session on any of the following items under A.R.S. §38-431.03(A)(2) for discussion of any information made confidential by law.)

(1) Dr. Kathy Kamin, Case No. 13-016 - Consent Agreement for Surrender of License.

Dr. Kamin was not present. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Dr. Sadilek made a motion to accept the consent agreement for surrender of license. Seconded by Dr. Marchese.

Roll Call: Dr. Terlisner; Aye, Dr. Marchese; Aye, Ms. Reeve; Aye, Dr. Eldridge; Aye, Dr. Sadilek; Aye. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(2) Dr. Lewis Underwood, Case No. 10-037 - Consent Agreement for Surrender of License.

Dr. Underwood was not present. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Dr. Marchese made a motion to accept the consent agreement for surrender of license. Seconded by Ms. Reeve. Roll Call: Dr. Terlisner; Aye, Dr. Marchese; Aye, Ms. Reeve; Aye, Dr. Eldridge; Aye, Dr. Sadilek; Aye. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(3) Dr. Susan Godman, Case No 13-025 - Investigative Interview

(4) Dr. Susan Godman, Case No. 13-035 - Investigative Interview

Items (3) and (4) were reviewed and considered as one item by the Board.

Dr. Godman was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Dr. Sadilek made a motion to issue a non-disciplinary order for CE to include 3 hours in record keeping, 3 hours in physical assessment and diagnosis in addition to the 30 hours required each year for licensure renewal. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Dr. Terlisner; Aye, Dr. Marchese; Aye, Ms. Reeve; Aye, Dr. Eldridge; Nay, Dr. Sadilek; Aye. Motion Carried 4 Ayes, 1 Nay, 2 Vacant.

(5) Dr. Krystal Tellier, Case No. 13-020 - Investigative Interview

Dr. Tellier was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Dr. Terlisner made a motion to dismiss the case. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(6) Dr. Eugene Eihausen, Case No. 14-004 - Investigative Interview

Dr. Eihuasen was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to dismiss. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(7) Dr. Cheryl Kubacz, Case No. 14-007 - Investigative Interview

Dr. Kubacz was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to dismiss. Seconded by Dr. Sadilek. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(8) Dr. Ramon Esquerdo, Case No. 13-011 - Consent Agreement

Dr. Esquerdo was present with Mr. Williams; Council for Respondent. Both made statements and answered questions. Ms. Campbell presented a revised consent agreement to the Board regarding this case. The revisions made were based on Board request at the meeting of May 8th, 2014. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to accept the revised consent agreement. Seconded by Dr. Sadilek. Roll Call: Dr. Terlisner; Aye, Dr. Marchese: Aye, Ms. Reeve; Aye, Dr. Eldridge; Aye, Dr. Sadilek; Aye. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

N. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Renewal Applications.

(1) Dr. Krystal Tellier, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense- Open Investigation.

(2) Dr. Eugene Eihausen, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense- Open Investigation

(3) Dr. Ramon Esquerdo, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense - Open Investigation

(4) Dr. Kenneth Proefrock, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense-Open Investigation- Without prejudice to any ongoing investigation.

Ms. Reeve made a motion to approve the application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

(5) Dr. Bruce Sadilek, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense-Board Member

(6) Dr. Katherine Rose, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense

Dr. Sdilek recused himself. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms Reeve made a

motion to approve the application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense. Seconded by Dr.

Marchese. Motion Carried 4 Ayes, 1 Recused, 2 Vacant.

(7) Dr. Marianne Marchese, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense - Board Member

Dr. Kristy Anderson; application for renewal of certificate to dispense was removed from the

consent agenda and taken into consideration along with item (7). Dr. Marchese recused herself. After

discussion and consideration by the Board, Dr. Terlisner made a motion to approve the

application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense. Seconded by Ms. Reeve. Motion Carried 4

Ayes, 1 Recused, 2 Vacant.

(8) Dr. Amy Terlisner, Renewal of Certificate to Dispense-Board Member

Dr Jennifer Dye and Dr. Kayla Eckart; application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense, were removed from the consent agenda and taken into consideration along with item (8). Dr. Terlisner requested herself. After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to accept the application(s) for renewal of certificate to dispense. Seconded by Dr. Marchase. Motion Carried 4 Ayes, 1 Recused, 2 Vacant.

The Board took a break at 2:20pm and resumed regular session at 2:30 pm.

7. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application for Clinical Training

Certificate. Pursuant to A.R.S. §38-431.03 (A) (3), the Board may vote to hold an executive session

for legal advice.

Jill Zdan

Ms. Zdan was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and

consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to approved the application. Seconded by Dr.

Eldridge. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

Michelle Pettitt

Ms. Pettitt was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and

consideration by the Board, Dr. Marchese made a motion to approve the application. Seconded by

Dr. Eldridge. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

Odessa, Rodriquez

Ms. Rodriquez was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and

consideration by the Board, Dr. Sadilek made a motion to approve the application. Seconded by Ms.

Reeve. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

8. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board of Application for Licensure.

Pursuant to A.R.S. §38-431.03 (A) (3), the Board may vote to hold an executive session for legal

advice.

Kathleen Muratore

Ms. Reeve made a motion to go into Executive Session for legal advice. Seconded by Dr. Terlisner. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

The Board resumed regular session at 3:00 pm.

Ms. Muratore was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and

consideration, Dr. Marchese made a motion to find the application administratively complete based

on A.R.S. §32-1552. Seconded by Dr. Terlisner. Motion carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

After discussion and consideration by the Board, Ms. Reeve made a motion to offer reissuance of license pursuant to a consent agreement with specific terms and conditions, including probation, practice supervision, additional CME, and prescribing limitations. The proposed consent will be brought back at the next meeting for Board approval. Seconded by Dr. Marchese. Motion Carried 5 Ayes, 2 Vacant.

9. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board Regarding Petition for

Reconsideration of Nutrients Listed Under R4-18-904 (2),(a,b,c,d)

After discussion and consideration of the item, the Board requested Staff to investigative the matter further and bring the results back to the next meeting.

10. Discussion, Consideration, Possible Action by the Board Regarding Draft Opioid Prescribing

Guidelines for Treatment of Acute Pain provided by the Arizona Department of Health

Services.

No action required

Adjournment

The meeting adjourned at 4:00 pm.

__________________________________________________________________ _________________

sTATE OF ARIZONA NATUROPATHIC PHYSICIANS MEDICAL BOARD DATE

Approved at the September 11, 2014 Board Meeting

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download