Philsci-archive.pitt.edu
Thought Experiments and Experimental Philosophy PREPRINTin the?Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments, edited by Mike Stuart and James Brown (2016).Kirk LudwigPhilosophy DepartmentIndiana University1. IntroductionMuch of the recent movement organized under the heading “Experimental Philosophy” has been concerned with the empirical study of responses to thought experiments drawn from the literature on philosophical analysis. I consider what bearing these studies have on the traditional projects in which thought experiments have been used in philosophy. This will help to answer the question what the relation is between Experimental Philosophy and philosophy, whether it is an “exciting new style of [philosophical] research”, “a new interdisciplinary field that uses methods normally associated with psychology to investigate questions normally associated with philosophy” ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Knobe</Author><Year>2012</Year><RecNum>6342</RecNum><DisplayText>(Knobe et al. 2012)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6342</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1386709177">6342</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Knobe, Joshua</author><author>Buckwalter, Wesley</author><author>Robbins, Philip</author><author>Sarkissian, Hagop</author><author>Sommers, Tamler</author><author>Nichols, Shaun</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Experimental Philosophy</title><secondary-title>Annual Review of Psychology</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Annual Review of Psychology</full-title></periodical><pages>72-73</pages><volume>63</volume><number>50</number><dates><year>2012</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Knobe et al. 2012), or whether its relation to philosophy consists, as some have suggested, in no more than the word ‘philosophy’ appearing in its title, or whether the truth lies somewhere in between these two views.Section 2 distinguishes different strands in Experimental Philosophy. Section 3 reviews some ways in which Experimental Philosophy has been criticized. Section 4 considers what would have to be true for Experimental Philosophy to have one or another sort of relevance to philosophy, whether the assumptions required are true, how we could know it, and the ideal limits of the usefulness Experimental Philosophy to philosophy. Section 5 is a brief conclusion.2. Varieties of Experimental PhilosophyBroadly construed, Experimental Philosophy is philosophy informed by empirical work. Experimental Philosophy in this sense stretches back to antiquity. Here we will be concerned with a narrower conception of Experimental Philosophy characterized by the adoption of the survey as a central methodological tool, with a yes-or-no question, or a graduated range of answers from “strongly disagree” to “strongly agree” or the like, typically about a scenario in a philosophical thought experiment. Given this, Experimental Philosophy, in the sense we are interested in it, might more aptly be called “Survey Philosophy.” The most important division among experimental philosophers is between those who conceive of its project negatively and those who conceive of it positively. The negative (x-phi?) and the positive projects (x-phi+) both share the assumption that a central philosophical activity involves eliciting (what are often called) intuitions about actual and hypothetical cases, the latter involving conducting what we call thought experiments, with the aim of conceptual articulation or analysis. The traditional attempts to provide a satisfactory analysis of the concept of knowledge surrounding the literature on the Gettier cases ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Gettier</Author><Year>1963</Year><RecNum>6220</RecNum><DisplayText>(Gettier 1963)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6220</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1341322630">6220</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Edmund Gettier</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?</title><secondary-title>Analysis</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Analysis</full-title></periodical><pages>121-3</pages><volume>23</volume><dates><year>1963</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Gettier 1963) is a paradigm of the sort of activity they have in mind. In this case, the judgment (or intuition) that a subject with a justified true belief that p that is based on a justified false belief does not thereby know that p is taken to show that justified true belief is not sufficient for knowledge.The negative project seeks to show that the results of surveys of undergraduates or others without much philosophical sophistication cast doubt on the probative value of intuitions and the use of thought experiments by philosophers. The negative project argues that the standard use of thought experiments makes certain empirical assumptions which can easily be tested by the survey method, and that (surprisingly) the assumptions (never tested) turn out to be false PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwMzwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwMzwvWWVhcj48
UmVjTnVtPjQzMDY8L1JlY051bT48RGlzcGxheVRleHQ+KE5pY2hvbHMsIFN0aWNoLCBhbmQgV2Vp
bmJlcmcgMjAwMzsgQWxleGFuZGVyIGFuZCBXZWluYmVyZyAyMDA3OyBTdGFjeSBTd2FpbiAyMDA4
OyBXZWluYmVyZywgTmljaG9scywgYW5kIFN0aWNoIDIwMDE7IE1hY2hlcnkgZXQgYWwuIDIwMDQ7
IExpYW8gZXQgYWwuIDIwMTIpPC9EaXNwbGF5VGV4dD48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjQzMDY8
L3JlYy1udW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlzMnVw
MHh2NGVleDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMCI+NDMwNjwva2V5PjwvZm9y
ZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJCb29rIFNlY3Rpb24iPjU8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250
cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzLCBTaGF1bjwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+
U3RpY2gsIFN0ZXBoZW48L2F1dGhvcj48YXV0aG9yPldlaW5iZXJnLCBKb25hdGhhbiBNLjwvYXV0
aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9ycz48c2Vjb25kYXJ5LWF1dGhvcnM+PGF1dGhvcj5TdGV2ZW4gTHVwZXI8L2F1
dGhvcj48L3NlY29uZGFyeS1hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPk1l
dGEtU2tlcHRpY2lzbTogTWVkaXRhdGlvbnMgaW4gRXRobm8tRXBpc3RlbW9sb2d5PC90aXRsZT48
c2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPlRoZSBTa2VwdGljczogQ29udGVtcG9yYXJ5IEVzc2F5czwvc2Vjb25k
YXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxrZXl3b3Jkcz48a2V5d29yZD5FcGlzdGVtb2xvZ3k8L2tleXdv
cmQ+PGtleXdvcmQ+RXRobm9ncmFwaHk8L2tleXdvcmQ+PGtleXdvcmQ+U2NlcHRpY2lzbTwva2V5
d29yZD48L2tleXdvcmRzPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDAzPC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHB1Yi1sb2Nh
dGlvbj5BbGRlcnNob3Q8L3B1Yi1sb2NhdGlvbj48cHVibGlzaGVyPkFzaGdhdGUgUHVibGlzaGlu
ZzwvcHVibGlzaGVyPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5B
bGV4YW5kZXI8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDA3PC9ZZWFyPjxSZWNOdW0+NjI2OTwvUmVjTnVtPjxy
ZWNvcmQ+PHJlYy1udW1iZXI+NjI2OTwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBw
PSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0
YW1wPSIxMzQxNTkzNTA5Ij42MjY5PC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9
IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1
dGhvcj5BbGV4YW5kZXIsIEpvc2h1YTwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+V2VpbmJlcmcsIEpvbmF0aGFu
PC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPkFuYWx5dGlj
IEVwaXN0ZW1vbG9neSBhbmQgRXhwZXJpbWVudGFsIFBoaWxvc29waHk8L3RpdGxlPjxzZWNvbmRh
cnktdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoeSBDb21wYXNzPC9zZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+PC90aXRsZXM+PHBl
cmlvZGljYWw+PGZ1bGwtdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoeSBDb21wYXNzPC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVy
aW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NTYtODA8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+Mjwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+MTwv
bnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDA3PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVj
b3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48Q2l0ZT48QXV0aG9yPlN0YWN5IFN3YWluPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwODwv
WWVhcj48UmVjTnVtPjYyNzE8L1JlY051bT48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjYyNzE8L3JlYy1u
dW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlzMnVwMHh2NGVl
eDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMTM0MTU5NDA2MyI+NjI3MTwva2V5Pjwv
Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlw
ZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+U3RhY3kgU3dhaW4sIEpvc2h1YSBBbGV4
YW5kZXIsIEpvbmF0aGFuIFdlaW5iZXJnPC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3Jz
Pjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPlRoZSBJbnN0YWJpbGl0eSBvZiBQaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIEludHV0aW9u
czogUnVubmluZyBIb3QgYWRuIENvbGQgb24gVHJ1ZXRlbXA8L3RpdGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0
bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoeSBhbmQgUGhlbm9tZW5vbG9naWNhbCBSZXNlYXJjaDwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRp
dGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPlBoaWxvc29waHkgYW5kIFBoZW5v
bWVub2xvZ2ljYWwgUmVzZWFyY2g8L2Z1bGwtdGl0bGU+PC9wZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxwYWdlcz4xMzgt
MTU1PC9wYWdlcz48dm9sdW1lPjc2PC92b2x1bWU+PG51bWJlcj4xPC9udW1iZXI+PGRhdGVzPjx5
ZWFyPjIwMDg8L3llYXI+PC9kYXRlcz48dXJscz48L3VybHM+PC9yZWNvcmQ+PC9DaXRlPjxDaXRl
PjxBdXRob3I+V2VpbmJlcmc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDAxPC9ZZWFyPjxSZWNOdW0+NTY2MDwv
UmVjTnVtPjxyZWNvcmQ+PHJlYy1udW1iZXI+NTY2MDwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlz
PjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2
ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIwIj41NjYwPC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9
IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1
dGhvcj5Kb25hdGhhbiBXZWluYmVyZzwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+U2hhdW4gTmljaG9sczwvYXV0
aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+U3RlcGhlbiBTdGljaDwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9ycz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9y
cz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5Ob3JtYXRpdml0eSBhbmQgRXBpc3RlbWljIEludHVpdGlvbnM8L3Rp
dGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBUb3BpY3M8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRs
ZT48L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIFRvcGljczwv
ZnVsbC10aXRsZT48L3BlcmlvZGljYWw+PHBhZ2VzPjQyOS00NjA8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+Mjk8
L3ZvbHVtZT48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAwMTwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3Jl
Y29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5NYWNoZXJ5PC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNDwvWWVh
cj48UmVjTnVtPjQzMDc8L1JlY051bT48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjQzMDc8L3JlYy1udW1i
ZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlzMnVwMHh2NGVleDlv
cHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMCI+NDMwNzwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1rZXlz
PjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJpYnV0
b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+TWFjaGVyeSwgRS48L2F1dGhvcj48YXV0aG9yPk1hbGxvbiwg
Ui48L2F1dGhvcj48YXV0aG9yPk5pY2hvbHMsIFMuPC9hdXRob3I+PGF1dGhvcj5TdGljaCwgUy48
L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PC9jb250cmlidXRvcnM+PHRpdGxlcz48dGl0bGU+U2VtYW50aWNz
LCBDcm9zcy1DdWx0dXJhbCBTdHlsZTwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5Db2duaXRpb248
L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5Db2duaXRp
b248L2Z1bGwtdGl0bGU+PC9wZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxwYWdlcz5CMS1CMTI8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+
OTI8L3ZvbHVtZT48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAwNDwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48
L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5MaWFvPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMjwvWWVh
cj48UmVjTnVtPjEzOTI5PC9SZWNOdW0+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJlcj4xMzkyOTwvcmVjLW51
bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4
OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIxNDEyNzk2NjA2Ij4xMzkyOTwva2V5Pjwv
Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlw
ZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+TGlhbywgUy4gTWF0dGhldzwvYXV0aG9y
PjxhdXRob3I+V2llZ21hbm4sIEFsZXg8L2F1dGhvcj48YXV0aG9yPkFsZXhhbmRlciwgSm9zaHVh
PC9hdXRob3I+PGF1dGhvcj5Wb25nLCBHZXJhcmQ8L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PC9jb250cmli
dXRvcnM+PHRpdGxlcz48dGl0bGU+UHV0dGluZyB0aGUgdHJvbGxleSBpbiBvcmRlcjogRXhwZXJp
bWVudGFsIHBoaWxvc29waHkgYW5kIHRoZSBsb29wIGNhc2U8L3RpdGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0
bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBQc3ljaG9sb2d5PC9zZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+PC90aXRsZXM+PHBl
cmlvZGljYWw+PGZ1bGwtdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBQc3ljaG9sb2d5PC9mdWxsLXRpdGxl
PjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NjYxLTY3MTwvcGFnZXM+PHZvbHVtZT4yNTwvdm9sdW1lPjxu
dW1iZXI+NTwvbnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDEyPC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91
cmxzPjwvcmVjb3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48L0VuZE5vdGU+AG==
ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003; Alexander and Weinberg 2007; Stacy Swain 2008; Weinberg, Nichols, and Stich 2001; Machery et al. 2004; Liao et al. 2012). Among these alleged assumptions are that philosophers’ intuitions are shared by everyone, that they are not biased, based on irrelevant factors, or theory driven, and that they are not relative to cultural or socioeconomic background, and the like. There are two main ways of taking the positive project. The first is the Continuity Account, and the second the Psychological Account.The Continuity Accounts. X-phi is an enterprise with the same goals that philosophers have when they use thought experiments (the investigation of the application conditions of words or concepts, or of entailment relations between propositions, or implications of sentences), except that we crowd source the answers PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OYWhtaWFzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNjwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OYWhtaWFzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNjwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Nahmias et al. 2006; Knobe 2003a, 2003b, 2004, 2006; Malle and Knobe 2001; Pettit and Knobe 2009; Buckwalter and Schaffer 2013; Genone and Lombrozo 2012). There are two further subcategories.Replacement Accounts: We add that survey philosophy should replace traditional “armchair” methods. ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Alexander</Author><Year>2007</Year><RecNum>6269</RecNum><DisplayText>(Alexander and Weinberg 2007)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6269</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1341593509">6269</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Alexander, Joshua</author><author>Weinberg, Jonathan</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Analytic Epistemology and Experimental Philosophy</title><secondary-title>Philosophy Compass</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Philosophy Compass</full-title></periodical><pages>56-80</pages><volume>2</volume><number>1</number><dates><year>2007</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Alexander and Weinberg 2007)Supplement Accounts: We urge only that survey philosophy can provide a useful supplement to traditional methods. ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Papineau</Author><Year>2011</Year><RecNum>13887</RecNum><DisplayText>(Papineau 2011; Talbot 2013)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13887</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1412613231">13887</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>David Papineau</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>What is x-phi good for?</title><secondary-title>The Philosophers' Magazine</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>The Philosophers' Magazine</full-title></periodical><pages>83-88</pages><volume>52</volume><dates><year>2011</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite><Cite><Author>Talbot</Author><Year>2013</Year><RecNum>13966</RecNum><record><rec-number>13966</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1413387121">13966</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Talbot, Brian</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Reforming intuition pumps: when are the old ways the best?</title><secondary-title>Philosophical Studies</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Philosophical Studies</full-title></periodical><pages>315-334</pages><volume>165</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>2013</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Papineau 2011; Talbot 2013)Psychological Accounts. X-phi is not the pursuit of traditional philosophical goals (or at least analysis) by appeal to surveys of the philosophically unsophisticated but instead a psychological inquiry, as opposed to a philosophical inquiry, into concepts that philosophers have been interested in PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMTwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMTwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Nichols 2011; Sarkissian et al. 2010; Knobe and Burra 2006), or, into psychological mechanisms generating responses, whatever they might reveal, that people have (in various groupings) about philosophical thought experiments PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Zb3VuZzwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMDY8L1llYXI+PFJl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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Zb3VuZzwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMDY8L1llYXI+PFJl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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Young et al. 2006; Nichols and Knobe 2007; Sarkissian et al. 2011; Knobe 2007, sec. 2). I will consider each of these programs within x-phi, but focus most attention on the Continuity Account as the most promising case of the positive relevance of x-phi to the traditional projects of philosophy.3. Criticisms of Experimental PhilosophyExperimental Philosophy has been criticized on a number of different grounds (not all these will be completely independent of, or consistent with, one another).Negative x-phi has been directed against positive x-phi, on the assumption that it is pursuing what philosophers have traditionally been trying to do ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Alexander</Author><Year>2010</Year><RecNum>6336</RecNum><DisplayText>(Alexander, Mallon, and Weinberg 2010)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6336</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1385752884">6336</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Alexander, Joshua</author><author>Mallon, Ronald</author><author>Weinberg, Jonathan M.</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Accentuate the Negative</title><secondary-title>Review of Philosophy and Psychology</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Review of Philosophy and Psychology</full-title></periodical><pages>297-314</pages><volume>1</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>2010</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Alexander, Mallon, and Weinberg 2010). If intuitions are not probative, then they are not probative period, whether you are gathering them in the armchair or in Central Park.Critics have argued that x-phi has been taken in by an illusion widespread among philosophers themselves, namely, that contemporary analytic philosophers rely on intuitions as a source of evidence for philosophical theories. Herman Cappelen in his ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite ExcludeAuth="1"><Author>Cappelen</Author><Year>2012</Year><RecNum>6258</RecNum><DisplayText>(2012)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6258</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1341500690">6258</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book">6</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Herman Cappelen</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Philosophy without Intuitions</title></titles><dates><year>2012</year></dates><pub-location>Oxford</pub-location><publisher>Oxford University Press</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(2012) book Philosophy without Intuitions argues that this is simply an illusion, and experimental philosophers have been taken in by it. While philosophy goes the way it always has, experimental philosophers are engaged both in their critical and in their constructive projects in pursuing a will o’ wisp. X-phi? is tilting at windmills while x-phi+ is simulating in surveys a practice that philosophers have never actually been engaged in. (See also ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Cappelen</Author><Year>2014</Year><RecNum>13939</RecNum><DisplayText>(Cappelen 2014)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13939</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1412886349">13939</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Herman Cappelen</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Anthony Robert Booth</author><author>Darell P. Rowbottom</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>X-Phi without Intuitions?</title><secondary-title>Intuitions</secondary-title></titles><pages>271-285</pages><dates><year>2014</year></dates><pub-location>Oxford</pub-location><publisher>Oxford University Press</publisher><urls></urls><electronic-resource-num>10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199609192.001.0001</electronic-resource-num></record></Cite></EndNote>(Cappelen 2014); and see Cohnitz and H?ggqvist in this volume for discussion, section III.)An allied criticism of x-phi+ is that concepts philosophers are interested in are not amenable to conceptual analysis because they are of natural kinds and, hence, their real essence is to be discovered by empirical investigation of the world, not in empirical investigation of speakers’ dispositions to classify things under the concept. (Cf. Hilary Kornblith’s view that knowledge is a natural kind and therefore not amenable to investigation by conceptual analysis ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite ExcludeAuth="1"><Author>Kornblith</Author><Year>2002</Year><RecNum>6165</RecNum><DisplayText>(2002)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6165</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1338400691">6165</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book">6</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Kornblith, Hilary</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Knowledge and Its Place in Nature</title></titles><dates><year>2002</year></dates><pub-location>Oxford</pub-location><publisher>Clarendon Press</publisher><isbn>0199246319</isbn><work-type>Monograph</work-type><urls><related-urls><url>;(2002).)Another criticism of the continuity version of x-phi+ is that there are no (at least interesting) conceptual truths, since there are no (at least interesting) analytic truths, and, hence, the x-phi+ conceived of as pursuing conceptual analysis is aiming for a non-existent or uninteresting target ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Quine</Author><Year>1953</Year><RecNum>1276</RecNum><DisplayText>(Quine 1953; Putnam 1965)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>1276</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="0">1276</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Quine, Willard Van Orman</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Two Dogmas of Empiricism</title><secondary-title>From a Logical Point of View</secondary-title></titles><edition>2nd</edition><keywords><keyword>ANALYTICITY</keyword><keyword>DAVIDSON</keyword><keyword>MEANING</keyword></keywords><dates><year>1953</year></dates><pub-location>Cambridge</pub-location><publisher>Harvard University Press</publisher><label>1090</label><urls></urls></record></Cite><Cite><Author>Putnam</Author><Year>1965</Year><RecNum>13216</RecNum><record><rec-number>13216</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13216</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Hilary Putnam</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>It Ain't Necessarily So</title><secondary-title>Journal of PHilosophy</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Journal of Philosophy</full-title></periodical><pages>658-671</pages><volume>LIX</volume><dates><year>1965</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Quine 1953; Putnam 1965), and, in any case, in fact philosophy has all along been aiming at general synthetic a posteriori truths ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Papineau</Author><Year>2013</Year><RecNum>13215</RecNum><DisplayText>(Papineau 2013)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13215</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13215</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Papineau, David</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Matthew Haug</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>The Poverty of Conceptual Analysis</title><secondary-title>The Armchair or the Laboratory</secondary-title></titles><pages>166-194</pages><section>11</section><dates><year>2013</year></dates><pub-location>New York</pub-location><publisher>Routledge</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Papineau 2013).Yet another criticism that focuses on the relation of x-phi to philosophy is that it assumes both in its negative and its positive versions an overly simplified and narrow role for thought experiments in philosophical theorizing, focusing on an overly simplified conception of the “case method,” whereas in fact thought experiments are used for illustration, to draw analogies, to raise puzzles (as in Thomson’s contrasting the switch and fat man trolley cases ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Thomson</Author><Year>1976</Year><RecNum>14317</RecNum><DisplayText>(Thomson 1976)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>14317</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1443895400">14317</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Thomson, Judith Jarvis</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Killing, Letting Die, and the Trolley Problem</title><secondary-title>The Monist</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>The Monist</full-title></periodical><pages>204-217</pages><volume>59</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>1976</year></dates><publisher>Oxford University Press</publisher><isbn>00269662</isbn><urls><related-urls><url>;(Thomson 1976)), to draw attention to the range of cases that a theory must deal with, to draw out the consequences of theories, to illustrate arguments and bring out the limitations of our use of language (e.g. thought experiments involving sorites series), and to draw out how we think about certain matters, assumptions we make or principles we reply on, without the suggestion that we are drawing attention to conceptual truths ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Sosa</Author><Year>2007</Year><RecNum>13233</RecNum><Pages>pp. 101-102</Pages><DisplayText>(Sosa 2007a, pp. 101-102)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13233</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13233</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Sosa, Ernest</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Experimental philosophy and philosophical intuition</title><secondary-title>Philosophical Studies</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Philosophical Studies</full-title></periodical><pages>99-107</pages><volume>132</volume><number>1</number><dates><year>2007</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Sosa 2007a, pp. 101-102). (See also Cohnitz and H?ggqvist, this volume, section II, in this connection).Even in the so-called case method, x-phi operates with a caricature of philosophical method. Philosophers aim to arrive at a reflective judgment about a case and then to review it in the light of other judgments (their own and others) and more general theoretical considerations. They do not simply record their spontaneous judgments and take the third person stance toward them as neutral observations to be explained. They do not present themselves with scenarios out of the blue and like a medium at a séance wait for the spirit to move them to say something. It is an intellectual exercise like figuring out how to construct a proof of something in logic, or figuring out a mathematical problem, turning something on all sides to get the right view of it, reviewing a range of cases, testing for things that might be misleading by “turning the knobs” as Douglas Hofstader puts it, and looking out for familiar pitfalls. We often enough (though not always) have a sense of not being clear, and we withhold judgment until it becomes clearer (it is not a forced choice). Where it seems relevant, many of us think it is important to be familiar with contiguous domains of scientific investigation, which, while not immune from conceptual confusion, often present us with important puzzle cases and problems and insights. And we do not do this like hermits in the woods: we try out ideas and thought experiments on others, give and publish papers, take criticism, make revisions, try out new ideas generated in this process, and so on. See PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5MdWR3aWc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDA3PC9ZZWFyPjxS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 EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5MdWR3aWc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDA3PC9ZZWFyPjxS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 EN.CITE.DATA (Ludwig 2007; Jackson 2011, sec. 5; Bealer 1998).Experimental philosophy has been criticized more narrowly on methodological grounds (these are all intertwined—see PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5MdWR3aWc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDEwPC9ZZWFyPjxS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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5MdWR3aWc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDEwPC9ZZWFyPjxS
ZWNOdW0+NjIwOTwvUmVjTnVtPjxEaXNwbGF5VGV4dD4oTHVkd2lnIDIwMTAsIDIwMDc7IERldXRz
Y2ggMjAwOTsgS2F1cHBpbmVuIDIwMTQsIHBwLiA1LTY7IFdpbGxpYW1zb24gMjAxMTsgU29tbWVy
cyAyMDEwKTwvRGlzcGxheVRleHQ+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJlcj42MjA5PC9yZWMtbnVtYmVy
Pjxmb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PGtleSBhcHA9IkVOIiBkYi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3Bw
ZHcxYXd4OXgyYTJ3ZnZyIiB0aW1lc3RhbXA9IjEzNDA4ODA3ODkiPjYyMDk8L2tleT48L2ZvcmVp
Z24ta2V5cz48cmVmLXR5cGUgbmFtZT0iSm91cm5hbCBBcnRpY2xlIj4xNzwvcmVmLXR5cGU+PGNv
bnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48YXV0aG9ycz48YXV0aG9yPkx1ZHdpZywgS2lyazwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9y
cz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5JbnR1aXRpb25zIGFuZCBSZWxhdGl2aXR5
PC90aXRsZT48c2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPlBoaWxvc29waGljYWwgUHN5Y2hvbG9neTwvc2Vjb25k
YXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPlBoaWxvc29waGljYWwg
UHN5Y2hvbG9neTwvZnVsbC10aXRsZT48L3BlcmlvZGljYWw+PHBhZ2VzPjQyNy00NDU8L3BhZ2Vz
Pjx2b2x1bWU+MjM8L3ZvbHVtZT48bnVtYmVyPjQ8L251bWJlcj48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAxMDwv
eWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5M
dWR3aWc8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDA3PC9ZZWFyPjxSZWNOdW0+MzcyMDwvUmVjTnVtPjxyZWNv
cmQ+PHJlYy1udW1iZXI+MzcyMDwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBwPSJF
TiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0YW1w
PSIwIj4zNzIwPC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0
aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1dGhvcj5MdWR3aWcs
IEtpcms8L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PC9jb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGgtYWRkcmVzcz5MdWR3
aWcsIEsmI3hEO1VuaXYgRmxvcmlkYSwgRGVwdCBQaGlsb3NvcGh5LCBHYWluZXN2aWxsZSwgRkwg
MzI2MTEgVVNBJiN4RDtVbml2IEZsb3JpZGEsIERlcHQgUGhpbG9zb3BoeSwgR2FpbmVzdmlsbGUs
IEZMIDMyNjExIFVTQTwvYXV0aC1hZGRyZXNzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPlRoZSBFcGlzdGVtb2xv
Z3kgb2YgVGhvdWdodCBFeHBlcmltZW50czogRmlyc3QgUGVyc29uIHZlcnN1cyBUaGlyZCBQZXJz
b24gQXBwcm9hY2hlczwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5NaWR3ZXN0IFN0dWRpZXMgaW4g
UGhpbG9zb3BoeTogUGhpbG9zb3BoeSBhbmQgdGhlIEVtcGlyaWNhbDwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxl
PjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPk1pZHdlc3QgU3R1ZGllcyBpbiBQaGls
b3NvcGh5OiBQaGlsb3NvcGh5IGFuZCB0aGUgRW1waXJpY2FsPC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9k
aWNhbD48cGFnZXM+MTI4LTE1OTwvcGFnZXM+PHZvbHVtZT4zMTwvdm9sdW1lPjxrZXl3b3Jkcz48
a2V5d29yZD5pbnRlbnRpb25hbCBhY3Rpb248L2tleXdvcmQ+PGtleXdvcmQ+Zm9sayBwc3ljaG9s
b2d5PC9rZXl3b3JkPjxrZXl3b3JkPmZyZWUgd2lsbDwva2V5d29yZD48a2V5d29yZD5tb3JhbCBj
b25zaWRlcmF0aW9uczwva2V5d29yZD48a2V5d29yZD5vcmRpbmFyeSBsYW5ndWFnZTwva2V5d29y
ZD48L2tleXdvcmRzPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDA3PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PGlzYm4+MDM2My02
NTUwPC9pc2JuPjxhY2Nlc3Npb24tbnVtPklTSTowMDAyNTAyMDIwMDAwMDc8L2FjY2Vzc2lvbi1u
dW0+PHVybHM+PHJlbGF0ZWQtdXJscz48dXJsPiZsdDtHbyB0byBJU0kmZ3Q7Oi8vMDAwMjUwMjAy
MDAwMDA3PC91cmw+PC9yZWxhdGVkLXVybHM+PC91cmxzPjxsYW5ndWFnZT5FbmdsaXNoPC9sYW5n
dWFnZT48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5EZXV0c2NoPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+
MjAwOTwvWWVhcj48UmVjTnVtPjEzMjU0PC9SZWNOdW0+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJlcj4xMzI1
NDwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMy
dXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIxMzk0OTMxMjE1Ij4xMzI1
NDwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3
PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+RGV1dHNjaCwgTWF4PC9h
dXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPkV4cGVyaW1lbnRh
bCBwaGlsb3NvcGh5IGFuZCB0aGUgdGhlb3J5IG9mIHJlZmVyZW5jZTwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFy
eS10aXRsZT5NaW5kIGFuZCBMYW5ndWFnZTwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJp
b2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPk1pbmQgYW5kIExhbmd1YWdlPC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9k
aWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NDQ1LTQ2NjwvcGFnZXM+PHZvbHVtZT4yNDwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+NDwv
bnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDA5PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVj
b3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48Q2l0ZT48QXV0aG9yPkthdXBwaW5lbjwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTQ8L1ll
YXI+PFJlY051bT4xMzkyNDwvUmVjTnVtPjxQYWdlcz5wcC4gNS02PC9QYWdlcz48cmVjb3JkPjxy
ZWMtbnVtYmVyPjEzOTI0PC9yZWMtbnVtYmVyPjxmb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PGtleSBhcHA9IkVOIiBk
Yi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3BwZHcxYXd4OXgyYTJ3ZnZyIiB0aW1lc3RhbXA9IjE0
MTI3ODc3MjUiPjEzOTI0PC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9IkJvb2sg
U2VjdGlvbiI+NTwvcmVmLXR5cGU+PGNvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48YXV0aG9ycz48YXV0aG9yPkthdXBw
aW5lbiwgQW50dGk8L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PHNlY29uZGFyeS1hdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+
Sm9zaHVhIEtub2JlPC9hdXRob3I+PGF1dGhvcj5TaHVhbiBOaWNob2xzPC9hdXRob3I+PC9zZWNv
bmRhcnktYXV0aG9ycz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5UaGUgcmlzZSBhbmQg
ZmFsbCBvZiBleHBlcmltZW50YWwgcGhpbG9zb3BoeTwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5F
eHBlcmltZW50YWwgUGhpbG9zb3BoeTwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwYWdlcz4z
LTMwPC9wYWdlcz48dm9sdW1lPjI8L3ZvbHVtZT48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAxNDwveWVhcj48L2Rh
dGVzPjxwdWItbG9jYXRpb24+T3hmb3JkPC9wdWItbG9jYXRpb24+PHB1Ymxpc2hlcj5PeGZvcmQg
VW5pdmVyc2l0eSBQcmVzczwvcHVibGlzaGVyPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+
PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5XaWxsaWFtc29uPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMTwvWWVhcj48UmVjTnVt
PjYyNzQ8L1JlY051bT48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjYyNzQ8L3JlYy1udW1iZXI+PGZvcmVp
Z24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlzMnVwMHh2NGVleDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5
eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMTM0MTU5OTI2MyI+NjI3NDwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1rZXlz
PjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJpYnV0
b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+V2lsbGlhbXNvbiwgVGltb3RoeTwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9y
cz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIEV4cGVydGlzZSBh
bmQgdGhlIEJ1cmRlbiBvZiBQcm9vZjwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5NZXRhcGhpbG9z
b3BoeTwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPk1l
dGFwaGlsb3NvcGh5PC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+MjE1LTIyOTwvcGFn
ZXM+PHZvbHVtZT40Mjwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+MzwvbnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDEx
PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVjb3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48Q2l0ZT48QXV0aG9y
PlNvbW1lcnM8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDEwPC9ZZWFyPjxSZWNOdW0+MTMyNTA8L1JlY051bT48
cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjEzMjUwPC9yZWMtbnVtYmVyPjxmb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PGtleSBh
cHA9IkVOIiBkYi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3BwZHcxYXd4OXgyYTJ3ZnZyIiB0aW1l
c3RhbXA9IjEzOTQ5MzEyMTUiPjEzMjUwPC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5h
bWU9IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+
PGF1dGhvcj5Tb21tZXJzLCBUYW1sZXI8L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PC9jb250cmlidXRvcnM+
PHRpdGxlcz48dGl0bGU+RXhwZXJpbWVudGFsIHBoaWxvc29waHkgYW5kIGZyZWUgd2lsbDwvdGl0
bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGh5IENvbXBhc3M8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48
L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGh5IENvbXBhc3M8L2Z1bGwt
dGl0bGU+PC9wZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxwYWdlcz4xOTktMjEyPC9wYWdlcz48dm9sdW1lPjU8L3ZvbHVt
ZT48bnVtYmVyPjI8L251bWJlcj48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAxMDwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjx1cmxz
PjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PC9FbmROb3RlPgB=
ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Ludwig 2010, 2007; Deutsch 2009; Kauppinen 2014, pp. 5-6; Williamson 2011; Sommers 2010) for general discussion; see ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Cullen</Author><Year>2010</Year><RecNum>6273</RecNum><DisplayText>(Cullen 2010)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6273</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1341598508">6273</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Cullen, Simon</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Survey-Driven Romanticism</title><secondary-title>Review of Philosophy and Psychology</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Review of Philosophy and Psychology</full-title></periodical><pages>275-296</pages><volume>1</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>2010</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Cullen 2010) for empirical refutations of assumptions behind some celebrated survey results).Poor Design. In some surveys which have gotten wide attention, the scenarios or questions have been unclear, misleading, or ambiguous, and insufficiently informed by the relevant knowledge of the issues, so that the interpretation of the results depends upon further untested assumptions about how respondents understood the scenarios and questions.Misunderstanding Intuitions. Experimental philosophers (many) have simply misunderstood the sort of intuition (or judgment) sought in philosophical thought experiments. They are not “spontaneous judgments … for which the person making the judgment may be able to offer no plausible justification” ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Nichols</Author><Year>2003</Year><RecNum>4306</RecNum><Pages>p. 19</Pages><DisplayText>(Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003, p. 19)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>4306</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="0">4306</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Nichols, Shaun</author><author>Stich, Stephen</author><author>Weinberg, Jonathan M.</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Steven Luper</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>Meta-Skepticism: Meditations in Ethno-Epistemology</title><secondary-title>The Skeptics: Contemporary Essays</secondary-title></titles><keywords><keyword>Epistemology</keyword><keyword>Ethnography</keyword><keyword>Scepticism</keyword></keywords><dates><year>2003</year></dates><pub-location>Aldershot</pub-location><publisher>Ashgate Publishing</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003, p. 19), nor are they expressions of what we would say or how things seems to us. They are rather, for example, judgments that draw solely on the concepts contained in the question in relation to the description of the scenario (there are a variety of views about the form and basis of the judgment, but they all reject the spontaneous judgment account). (See PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Cb290aDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTQ8L1llYXI+PFJl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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Cb290aDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTQ8L1llYXI+PFJl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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Booth 2014; Ludwig 2010; Goldman 2010, 2007; Sosa 2007b, 2007a, 2008) for further discussion.)Confusion about what data surveys supply. Surveys do not ipso facto elicit intuitions (6b encourages the conflation). Not every response to a question on a survey about a scenario expresses an intuition. The survey data then is not straightforwardly data about intuitions. To use survey’s for traditional philosophical purposes, we to filter responses that are not intuitions, or show the noise level isn’t so high it makes the data unusable. Controlling for Factors Relevant to Eliciting Relevant Responses. Surveys typically do not control for a variety of factors that are relevant to getting useful results, such asproper understanding of the point of the survey, namely, that it is to elicit responses that on the basis of the content of the scenario itself and the content of the concepts involved in the question about it;the motivation of respondents in responding; their level of effort;the general intellectual capacities of respondents, including their capacity to make and keep track of relevant distinctions;responses to pragmatic implicatures; extraneous factors in experimental design that introduce confounds like implicit biases and emotional responses that skew judgments.Impracticality. Doing philosophy by the survey method is unwieldy, even if it can be done. Philosophers can run through a large number of scenarios relevant to assessing various aspects of an account in a short time. Doing the same thing using the survey method would take a lot more time, with nothing more to show for it in the end. Doing philosophy by surveys, while it would generate more journal articles, would slow progress to a glacial pace.Failure to take into account the relevance of competence. Taking the responses of unsophisticated people to thought experiments to be on a par with those of philosophers rests on the false assumption that professional philosophers are no better than their undergraduates in sorting out subtle conceptual issues. Taking the responses of unsophisticated undergraduates and laypeople as being on a par with the responses of philosophers (even controlling for other factors) is to fail to recognize that people differ in how good they are at it and that one can develop a competence in conceptual analysis (inter alia, making distinctions, getting clear on the issues, understanding the point, framing questions and scenarios in the right way, being sensitive to things that might mislead, being ready with alternative cases to check for confusions, etc.) in the same way that one can develop a competence in mathematics or color matching and so on, and that training in philosophy develops such a competence. Over quick generalization from studies. Some of the most celebrated and provocative early studies of the x-phi movement PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwMzwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OaWNob2xzPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwMzwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003; Stacy Swain 2008; Weinberg, Nichols, and Stich 2001; Machery et al. 2004), as well as more recent studies ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Buckwalter</Author><Year>2014</Year><RecNum>13226</RecNum><DisplayText>(Buckwalter and Stich 2014)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13226</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13226</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Buckwalter, Wesley</author><author>Stich, Stephen</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Knobe, Joshua</author><author>Nichols, Shaun</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>Gender and Philosophical Intuition</title><secondary-title>Experimental Philosophy, Vol.2</secondary-title></titles><dates><year>2014</year></dates><publisher>Oxford University Press</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Buckwalter and Stich 2014) alleging a divergence between “intuitions” of women and men, have failed replication tests: on epistemic intuitions see PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OYWdlbDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTM8L1llYXI+PFJl
Y051bT4xMzk1NzwvUmVjTnVtPjxEaXNwbGF5VGV4dD4oTmFnZWwsIFNhbiBKdWFuLCBhbmQgTWFy
IDIwMTM7IEFkbGViZXJnLCBUaG9tcHNvbiwgYW5kIE5haG1pYXM7IEtpbSBhbmQgWXVhbjsgU2V5
ZWRzYXlhbWRvc3QgMjAxNTsgTmFnZWwgMjAxMik8L0Rpc3BsYXlUZXh0PjxyZWNvcmQ+PHJlYy1u
dW1iZXI+MTM5NTc8L3JlYy1udW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlk
PSIyZHdzYTlzMnVwMHh2NGVleDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMTQxMzE0
MDIyNyI+MTM5NTc8L2tleT48L2ZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48cmVmLXR5cGUgbmFtZT0iSm91cm5hbCBB
cnRpY2xlIj4xNzwvcmVmLXR5cGU+PGNvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48YXV0aG9ycz48YXV0aG9yPk5hZ2Vs
LCBKZW5uaWZlcjwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+U2FuIEp1YW4sIFZhbGVyaWU8L2F1dGhvcj48YXV0
aG9yPk1hciwgUmF5bW9uZCBBLjwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9ycz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48dGl0
bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5MYXkgRGVuaWFsIG9mIEtub3dsZWRnZSBmb3IgSnVzdGlmaWVkIFRydWUgQmVs
aWVmczwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5Db2duaXRpb248L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48
L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5Db2duaXRpb248L2Z1bGwtdGl0bGU+PC9w
ZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxwYWdlcz42NTItNjYxPC9wYWdlcz48dm9sdW1lPjEyOTwvdm9sdW1lPjxkYXRl
cz48eWVhcj4yMDEzPC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVjb3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48
Q2l0ZSBFeGNsdWRlWWVhcj0iMSI+PEF1dGhvcj5BZGxlYmVyZzwvQXV0aG9yPjxSZWNOdW0+MTM5
NTg8L1JlY051bT48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjEzOTU4PC9yZWMtbnVtYmVyPjxmb3JlaWdu
LWtleXM+PGtleSBhcHA9IkVOIiBkYi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3BwZHcxYXd4OXgy
YTJ3ZnZyIiB0aW1lc3RhbXA9IjE0MTMzMjIxODkiPjEzOTU4PC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+
PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRv
cnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1dGhvcj5BZGxlYmVyZywgVG9uaTwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+VGhvbXBz
b24sIE1vcmdhbjwvYXV0aG9yPjxhdXRob3I+TmFobWlhcywgRWRkeTwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9y
cz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5EbyBNZW4gYW5kIFdvbWVuIEhhdmUgRGlm
ZmVyZW50IFBoaWxvc29waGljYWwgSW50dWl0aW9ucz8gRnVydGhlciBEYXRhPC90aXRsZT48c2Vj
b25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPlBoaWxvc29waGljYWwgUHN5Y2hvbG9neTwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwv
dGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRpdGxlPlBoaWxvc29waGljYWwgUHN5Y2hvbG9neTwv
ZnVsbC10aXRsZT48L3BlcmlvZGljYWw+PHBhZ2VzPjYxNS02NDE8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+Mjg8
L3ZvbHVtZT48bnVtYmVyPjU8L251bWJlcj48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAxNDwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVz
Pjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29yZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGUgRXhjbHVkZVllYXI9IjEiPjxBdXRo
b3I+S2ltPC9BdXRob3I+PFJlY051bT4xMzk1OTwvUmVjTnVtPjxyZWNvcmQ+PHJlYy1udW1iZXI+
MTM5NTk8L3JlYy1udW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdz
YTlzMnVwMHh2NGVleDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMTQxMzMyMjMxOCI+
MTM5NTk8L2tleT48L2ZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48cmVmLXR5cGUgbmFtZT0iSm91cm5hbCBBcnRpY2xl
Ij4xNzwvcmVmLXR5cGU+PGNvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48YXV0aG9ycz48YXV0aG9yPktpbSwgTWluc3Vu
PC9hdXRob3I+PGF1dGhvcj5ZdWFuLCBZdWFuPC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0
b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPk5vIENyb3NzLUN1bHR1cmFsIERpZmZlcmVuY2VzIGluIEdldHRp
ZXIgQ2FyIENhc2UgSW50dWl0aW9uOiBBIFJlcGxpY2F0aW9uIFN0dWR5IG9mIFdlaW5iZXJnIGV0
IGFsLiAyMDAxPC90aXRsZT48L3RpdGxlcz48ZGF0ZXM+PC9kYXRlcz48dXJscz48L3VybHM+PC9y
ZWNvcmQ+PC9DaXRlPjxDaXRlIEV4Y2x1ZGVZZWFyPSIxIj48QXV0aG9yPkFkbGViZXJnPC9BdXRo
b3I+PFJlY051bT4xMzk1ODwvUmVjTnVtPjxyZWNvcmQ+PHJlYy1udW1iZXI+MTM5NTg8L3JlYy1u
dW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlzMnVwMHh2NGVl
eDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMTQxMzMyMjE4OSI+MTM5NTg8L2tleT48
L2ZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48cmVmLXR5cGUgbmFtZT0iSm91cm5hbCBBcnRpY2xlIj4xNzwvcmVmLXR5
cGU+PGNvbnRyaWJ1dG9ycz48YXV0aG9ycz48YXV0aG9yPkFkbGViZXJnLCBUb25pPC9hdXRob3I+
PGF1dGhvcj5UaG9tcHNvbiwgTW9yZ2FuPC9hdXRob3I+PGF1dGhvcj5OYWhtaWFzLCBFZGR5PC9h
dXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPkRvIE1lbiBhbmQg
V29tZW4gSGF2ZSBEaWZmZXJlbnQgUGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBJbnR1aXRpb25zPyBGdXJ0aGVyIERh
dGE8L3RpdGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBQc3ljaG9sb2d5PC9zZWNv
bmRhcnktdGl0bGU+PC90aXRsZXM+PHBlcmlvZGljYWw+PGZ1bGwtdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNh
bCBQc3ljaG9sb2d5PC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NjE1LTY0MTwvcGFn
ZXM+PHZvbHVtZT4yODwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+NTwvbnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDE0
PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVjb3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48Q2l0ZT48QXV0aG9y
PlNleWVkc2F5YW1kb3N0PC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxNTwvWWVhcj48UmVjTnVtPjE0MzQzPC9S
ZWNOdW0+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJlcj4xNDM0MzwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlz
PjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2
ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIxNDQ1MzU1MTgwIj4xNDM0Mzwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYt
dHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxh
dXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+U2V5ZWRzYXlhbWRvc3QsIEhhbWlkPC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwv
Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPk9uIE5vcm1hdGl2aXR5IGFuZCBFcGlzdGVtaWMg
SW50dWl0aW9uczogRmFpbHVyZSBvZiBSZXBsaWNhdGlvbjwvdGl0bGU+PHNlY29uZGFyeS10aXRs
ZT5FcGlzdGVtZTwvc2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPjwvdGl0bGVzPjxwZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxmdWxsLXRp
dGxlPkVwaXN0ZW1lPC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+OTUtMTE2PC9wYWdl
cz48dm9sdW1lPjEyPC92b2x1bWU+PG51bWJlcj4xPC9udW1iZXI+PGRhdGVzPjx5ZWFyPjIwMTU8
L3llYXI+PC9kYXRlcz48dXJscz48L3VybHM+PC9yZWNvcmQ+PC9DaXRlPjxDaXRlPjxBdXRob3I+
TmFnZWw8L0F1dGhvcj48WWVhcj4yMDEyPC9ZZWFyPjxSZWNOdW0+MTQzNDg8L1JlY051bT48cmVj
b3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjE0MzQ4PC9yZWMtbnVtYmVyPjxmb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PGtleSBhcHA9
IkVOIiBkYi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3BwZHcxYXd4OXgyYTJ3ZnZyIiB0aW1lc3Rh
bXA9IjE0NDUzNjI4MTMiPjE0MzQ4PC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10eXBlIG5hbWU9
IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1dGhvcnM+PGF1
dGhvcj5OYWdlbCwgSmVubmlmZXI8L2F1dGhvcj48L2F1dGhvcnM+PC9jb250cmlidXRvcnM+PHRp
dGxlcz48dGl0bGU+SW50dWl0aW9ucyBhbmQgRXhwZXJpbWVudHM6IEEgRGVmZW5zZSBvZiB0aGUg
Q2FzZSBNZXRob2QgaW4gRXBpc3RlbW9sb2d5PC90aXRsZT48c2Vjb25kYXJ5LXRpdGxlPlBoaWxv
c29waHkgYW5kIFBoZW5vbWVub2xvZ2ljYWwgUmVzZWFyY2g8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48L3Rp
dGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGh5IGFuZCBQaGVub21lbm9sb2dp
Y2FsIFJlc2VhcmNoPC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NDk1LTUyNzwvcGFn
ZXM+PHZvbHVtZT44NTwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+MzwvbnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDEy
PC95ZWFyPjwvZGF0ZXM+PGlzYm4+MTkzMy0xNTkyPC9pc2JuPjx1cmxzPjxyZWxhdGVkLXVybHM+
PHVybD5odHRwOi8vZHguZG9pLm9yZy8xMC4xMTExL2ouMTkzMy0xNTkyLjIwMTIuMDA2MzQueDwv
dXJsPjwvcmVsYXRlZC11cmxzPjwvdXJscz48ZWxlY3Ryb25pYy1yZXNvdXJjZS1udW0+MTAuMTEx
MS9qLjE5MzMtMTU5Mi4yMDEyLjAwNjM0Lng8L2VsZWN0cm9uaWMtcmVzb3VyY2UtbnVtPjwvcmVj
b3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48L0VuZE5vdGU+AG==
ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5OYWdlbDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTM8L1llYXI+PFJl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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Nagel, San Juan, and Mar 2013; Adleberg, Thompson, and Nahmias; Kim and Yuan; Seyedsayamdost 2015; Nagel 2012); on theories of reference for names see ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Lam</Author><Year>2010</Year><RecNum>13964</RecNum><DisplayText>(Lam 2010)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13964</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1413376159">13964</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Lam, Barry</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Are cantonese speakers really descriptivists? Revisiting cross-cultural semantics</title><secondary-title>Cognition</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Cognition</full-title></periodical><pages>320–32</pages><volume>115</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>2010</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Lam 2010); on gender differences see PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5TZXllZHNheWFtZG9zdDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTQ8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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5TZXllZHNheWFtZG9zdDwvQXV0aG9yPjxZZWFyPjIwMTQ8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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Seyedsayamdost 2014a; Wright 2010; Adleberg, Thompson, and Nahmias). See ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Seyedsayamdost</Author><Year>2014</Year><RecNum>14344</RecNum><DisplayText>(Seyedsayamdost 2014b)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>14344</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1445355381">14344</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Thesis">32</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Seyedsayamdost, Hamid</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Reproducibility of empirical findings: experiments in philosophy and beyond</title><secondary-title>Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method</secondary-title></titles><volume>PhD</volume><dates><year>2014</year></dates><pub-location>London</pub-location><publisher>London School of Economics</publisher><urls><related-urls><url>;(Seyedsayamdost 2014b) for a more wide ranging critique. In this, x-phi shares in the larger replication crisis of psychology (see Social Psychology, 45(3), May 2014 and ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Collaboration</Author><Year>2015</Year><RecNum>14319</RecNum><DisplayText>(Collaboration 2015)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>14319</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1443896458">14319</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Open Science Collaboration</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science</title><secondary-title>Science</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Science</full-title></periodical><volume>349</volume><number>6251</number><dates><year>2015</year><pub-dates><date>August 28, 2015</date></pub-dates></dates><urls><related-urls><url>;(Collaboration 2015)). Failure to yield the right kind of knowledge of results ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Ludwig</Author><Year>2013</Year><RecNum>13220</RecNum><DisplayText>(Ludwig 2013)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13220</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13220</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Ludwig, Kirk</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Matthew Haug</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>Methods in Analytic Philosophy</title><secondary-title>Philosophical Methodology: The Armchair or the Laboratory</secondary-title></titles><dates><year>2013</year></dates><pub-location>New York</pub-location><publisher>Routledge</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Ludwig 2013). In philosophy, like mathematics, we are interested in understanding whether something is so from the first person standpoint. It is one thing to be told that the Pythagorean theorem is true. It is another to see that (and why) it is true. If you survey high school math teachers, you will find that most think that the Pythagorean theorem is true. You may be justified in accepting that if they all say that it is true, then it is. But you don’t thereby see that (and why) it is true. And if you are interested in mathematics, it is not enough to know that it is true, you want to see that it is true. You want to know on the basis of the exercise of your own reasoning abilities that it is true. And that is the same kind of knowledge that we seek in philosophy. The results of surveys cannot supply it. I will come back to the last of these below in assessing the question of the relevance of x-phi surveys involving thought experiments and their use in philosophy.4. What Are the Ways Experimental Philosophy Might be Relevant to PhilosophyWhat, put abstractly, are the ways in which x-phi might be relevant to philosophy? It might give us reason to think that there is something deeply problematic about the use of thought experiments in philosophy (for some purposes at least).It might give us reason to think that some response to a thought experiment is the correct one.It might give us insight into ways in which people can fall into error when responding to thought experiments.We take these up in turn.4.1 Can Experimental Philosophy show that there is something deeply problematic about the use of thought experiments in philosophy?The negative project in x-phi aims to show that intuitions are not probative. This can take either a moderate or aggressive form. The moderate form merely says that in some cases the results of x-phi show that we should be more cautious about the consensus philosophers have reached about some thought experiments (e.g., whether in Gettier cases subjects lack knowledge), and should be less sanguine perhaps generally than they (allegedly) have been. The aggressive form says that the results of surveys show that reactions to thought experiments never yield any knowledge.It is difficult to take the aggressive form seriously. Thought experiments rely on our ability to tell when one proposition entails another. We describe scenarios as if about particular individuals, but in fact their content is general. In a Gettier case, we are asked whether if there is someone with a justified true belief that p in a circumstance in which he infers it from a justified false belief, he knows that p or doesn't know that p. We are supposed to answer on the basis of whether instances of the antecedent entail corresponding instances of the consequent. A general skepticism about our ability to respond correctly to questions about thought experiments calls into question our ability to tell when one proposition entails another or does not. If we can’t tell that with a reasonable degree of reliability in appropriate conditions and with adequate training, then all inquiry collapses. There is nothing special about the abilities that we call upon in philosophy. We call upon them in everyday life and in all areas of inquiry. The moderate form cannot be dismissed out of hand, but even there it is difficult to establish a conclusion of the form: in such and such an area or on such and such a question, we are simply not in a position to come to know whether a test proposition is true given the description of the scenario. We might be provided, however, with evidence for the presence of confounding factors, which can alert us to the need to guard against them. We return to this below.The mere fact (if it is a fact) of diversity of response to thought experiments, within or across cultural, ethnic, or socio-economic groups PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5NYWNoZXJ5PC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNDwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5NYWNoZXJ5PC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNDwvWWVhcj48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ADDIN EN.CITE.DATA (Machery et al. 2004; Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003; Weinberg, Nichols, and Stich 2001), does not show that the application conditions of concepts like the concept of knowledge are relative to different cultures or social milieus. As many people have observed, if the participants are deploying the same concepts (and otherwise they just understand the words differently—and this may explain some diversity of responses ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Sosa</Author><Year>2007</Year><RecNum>13233</RecNum><Pages>p. 104</Pages><DisplayText>(Sosa 2007a, p. 104)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13233</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13233</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Sosa, Ernest</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Experimental philosophy and philosophical intuition</title><secondary-title>Philosophical Studies</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Philosophical Studies</full-title></periodical><pages>99-107</pages><volume>132</volume><number>1</number><dates><year>2007</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Sosa 2007a, p. 104)), all that could be shown by these results is that that not everyone is getting it right, and that there can be factors that correlate with different cultural, ethnic, or socio-economic backgrounds that can contribute to errors PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Tb3NhPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMTwvWWVhcj48UmVj
TnVtPjEzODg4PC9SZWNOdW0+PFBhZ2VzPnAuIDQ2NjwvUGFnZXM+PERpc3BsYXlUZXh0PihTb3Nh
IDIwMTEsIHAuIDQ2NjsgMjAwN2EsIHAuIDEwNzsgTHVkd2lnIDIwMDcsIDIwMTApPC9EaXNwbGF5
VGV4dD48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjEzODg4PC9yZWMtbnVtYmVyPjxmb3JlaWduLWtleXM+
PGtleSBhcHA9IkVOIiBkYi1pZD0iMmR3c2E5czJ1cDB4djRlZXg5b3BwZHcxYXd4OXgyYTJ3ZnZy
IiB0aW1lc3RhbXA9IjE0MTI2MjQzMjAiPjEzODg4PC9rZXk+PC9mb3JlaWduLWtleXM+PHJlZi10
eXBlIG5hbWU9IkpvdXJuYWwgQXJ0aWNsZSI+MTc8L3JlZi10eXBlPjxjb250cmlidXRvcnM+PGF1
dGhvcnM+PGF1dGhvcj5Fcm5lc3QgU29zYTwvYXV0aG9yPjwvYXV0aG9ycz48L2NvbnRyaWJ1dG9y
cz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5DYW4gVGhlcmUgQmUgYSBEaXNjaXBsaW5lIG9mIFBoaWxvc29waHk/
ICBBbmQgQ2FuIEl0IEJlIEZvdW5kZWQgb24gSW50dWl0aW9ucz88L3RpdGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnkt
dGl0bGU+TWluZCBhbmQgTGFuZ3VhZ2U8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9k
aWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5NaW5kIGFuZCBMYW5ndWFnZTwvZnVsbC10aXRsZT48L3BlcmlvZGlj
YWw+PHBhZ2VzPjQ1My00Njc8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+MjY8L3ZvbHVtZT48bnVtYmVyPjQ8L251
bWJlcj48ZGF0ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAxMTwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjx1cmxzPjwvdXJscz48L3JlY29y
ZD48L0NpdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Tb3NhPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAwNzwvWWVhcj48UmVj
TnVtPjEzMjMzPC9SZWNOdW0+PFBhZ2VzPnAuIDEwNzwvUGFnZXM+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJl
cj4xMzIzMzwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJk
d3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIxMzk0OTMxMjE1
Ij4xMzIzMzwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGlj
bGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+U29zYSwgRXJu
ZXN0PC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPkV4cGVy
aW1lbnRhbCBwaGlsb3NvcGh5IGFuZCBwaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIGludHVpdGlvbjwvdGl0bGU+PHNl
Y29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIFN0dWRpZXM8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48L3Rp
dGxlcz48cGVyaW9kaWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5QaGlsb3NvcGhpY2FsIFN0dWRpZXM8L2Z1bGwt
dGl0bGU+PC9wZXJpb2RpY2FsPjxwYWdlcz45OS0xMDc8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+MTMyPC92b2x1
bWU+PG51bWJlcj4xPC9udW1iZXI+PGRhdGVzPjx5ZWFyPjIwMDc8L3llYXI+PC9kYXRlcz48dXJs
cz48L3VybHM+PC9yZWNvcmQ+PC9DaXRlPjxDaXRlPjxBdXRob3I+THVkd2lnPC9BdXRob3I+PFll
YXI+MjAwNzwvWWVhcj48UmVjTnVtPjM3MjA8L1JlY051bT48cmVjb3JkPjxyZWMtbnVtYmVyPjM3
MjA8L3JlYy1udW1iZXI+PGZvcmVpZ24ta2V5cz48a2V5IGFwcD0iRU4iIGRiLWlkPSIyZHdzYTlz
MnVwMHh2NGVleDlvcHBkdzFhd3g5eDJhMndmdnIiIHRpbWVzdGFtcD0iMCI+MzcyMDwva2V5Pjwv
Zm9yZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlw
ZT48Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+THVkd2lnLCBLaXJrPC9hdXRob3I+PC9h
dXRob3JzPjwvY29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjxhdXRoLWFkZHJlc3M+THVkd2lnLCBLJiN4RDtVbml2IEZs
b3JpZGEsIERlcHQgUGhpbG9zb3BoeSwgR2FpbmVzdmlsbGUsIEZMIDMyNjExIFVTQSYjeEQ7VW5p
diBGbG9yaWRhLCBEZXB0IFBoaWxvc29waHksIEdhaW5lc3ZpbGxlLCBGTCAzMjYxMSBVU0E8L2F1
dGgtYWRkcmVzcz48dGl0bGVzPjx0aXRsZT5UaGUgRXBpc3RlbW9sb2d5IG9mIFRob3VnaHQgRXhw
ZXJpbWVudHM6IEZpcnN0IFBlcnNvbiB2ZXJzdXMgVGhpcmQgUGVyc29uIEFwcHJvYWNoZXM8L3Rp
dGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+TWlkd2VzdCBTdHVkaWVzIGluIFBoaWxvc29waHk6IFBoaWxv
c29waHkgYW5kIHRoZSBFbXBpcmljYWw8L3NlY29uZGFyeS10aXRsZT48L3RpdGxlcz48cGVyaW9k
aWNhbD48ZnVsbC10aXRsZT5NaWR3ZXN0IFN0dWRpZXMgaW4gUGhpbG9zb3BoeTogUGhpbG9zb3Bo
eSBhbmQgdGhlIEVtcGlyaWNhbDwvZnVsbC10aXRsZT48L3BlcmlvZGljYWw+PHBhZ2VzPjEyOC0x
NTk8L3BhZ2VzPjx2b2x1bWU+MzE8L3ZvbHVtZT48a2V5d29yZHM+PGtleXdvcmQ+aW50ZW50aW9u
YWwgYWN0aW9uPC9rZXl3b3JkPjxrZXl3b3JkPmZvbGsgcHN5Y2hvbG9neTwva2V5d29yZD48a2V5
d29yZD5mcmVlIHdpbGw8L2tleXdvcmQ+PGtleXdvcmQ+bW9yYWwgY29uc2lkZXJhdGlvbnM8L2tl
eXdvcmQ+PGtleXdvcmQ+b3JkaW5hcnkgbGFuZ3VhZ2U8L2tleXdvcmQ+PC9rZXl3b3Jkcz48ZGF0
ZXM+PHllYXI+MjAwNzwveWVhcj48L2RhdGVzPjxpc2JuPjAzNjMtNjU1MDwvaXNibj48YWNjZXNz
aW9uLW51bT5JU0k6MDAwMjUwMjAyMDAwMDA3PC9hY2Nlc3Npb24tbnVtPjx1cmxzPjxyZWxhdGVk
LXVybHM+PHVybD4mbHQ7R28gdG8gSVNJJmd0OzovLzAwMDI1MDIwMjAwMDAwNzwvdXJsPjwvcmVs
YXRlZC11cmxzPjwvdXJscz48bGFuZ3VhZ2U+RW5nbGlzaDwvbGFuZ3VhZ2U+PC9yZWNvcmQ+PC9D
aXRlPjxDaXRlPjxBdXRob3I+THVkd2lnPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMDwvWWVhcj48UmVjTnVt
PjEyNTQ4PC9SZWNOdW0+PHJlY29yZD48cmVjLW51bWJlcj4xMjU0ODwvcmVjLW51bWJlcj48Zm9y
ZWlnbi1rZXlzPjxrZXkgYXBwPSJFTiIgZGItaWQ9IjJkd3NhOXMydXAweHY0ZWV4OW9wcGR3MWF3
eDl4MmEyd2Z2ciIgdGltZXN0YW1wPSIxMzk0OTMxMjE1Ij4xMjU0ODwva2V5PjwvZm9yZWlnbi1r
ZXlzPjxyZWYtdHlwZSBuYW1lPSJKb3VybmFsIEFydGljbGUiPjE3PC9yZWYtdHlwZT48Y29udHJp
YnV0b3JzPjxhdXRob3JzPjxhdXRob3I+THVkd2lnLCBLaXJrPC9hdXRob3I+PC9hdXRob3JzPjwv
Y29udHJpYnV0b3JzPjx0aXRsZXM+PHRpdGxlPkludHVpdGlvbnMgYW5kIFJlbGF0aXZpdHk8L3Rp
dGxlPjxzZWNvbmRhcnktdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBQc3ljaG9sb2d5PC9zZWNvbmRhcnkt
dGl0bGU+PC90aXRsZXM+PHBlcmlvZGljYWw+PGZ1bGwtdGl0bGU+UGhpbG9zb3BoaWNhbCBQc3lj
aG9sb2d5PC9mdWxsLXRpdGxlPjwvcGVyaW9kaWNhbD48cGFnZXM+NDI3LTQ0NTwvcGFnZXM+PHZv
bHVtZT4yMzwvdm9sdW1lPjxudW1iZXI+NDwvbnVtYmVyPjxkYXRlcz48eWVhcj4yMDEwPC95ZWFy
PjwvZGF0ZXM+PHVybHM+PC91cmxzPjwvcmVjb3JkPjwvQ2l0ZT48L0VuZE5vdGU+
ADDIN EN.CITE PEVuZE5vdGU+PENpdGU+PEF1dGhvcj5Tb3NhPC9BdXRob3I+PFllYXI+MjAxMTwvWWVhcj48UmVj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 EN.CITE.DATA (Sosa 2011, p. 466; 2007a, p. 107; Ludwig 2007, 2010). It doesn’t show that if there is a consensus among philosophers about what the right answers are, they are wrong, or that they don’t know that they are right. Similarly, that you might get variations in responses to simple mathematics questions across different cultural, ethnic, and socio-economic groups does not entail that the consensus among mathematicians about the right answers are wrong or that they don’t know that they are right.4.2 The Positive Program of Contributing to Conceptual AnalysisWhat has to be true for x-phi (in the survey mode) to have a positive contribution to make to philosophy?Responses to surveys are never uniform. Consider a yes-no survey on whether a concept applies in a scenario (for example, whether someone with a Gettierized belief has knowledge or not). There are three possible outcomes: a majority say ‘yes’, a majority say ‘no’, or the respondents are split evenly between ‘yes’ and ‘no’. The positive program (on the Continuity Account) aims to use the results to say something about the application conditions of the concept of knowledge. If answers are split evenly, we can draw no conclusions. If a majority favors one answer, it is natural to suggest the majority is right (parallel considerations to those brought up below would apply if we held that the minority is right).What has to be true for this to be so? An assumption that would justify it is that the respondents have a positive bias toward a correct response. Given this, and that their responses are independent, we can show that the larger the group surveyed, the higher the probability that the majority is right. In fact, as long as none is invariably right, we can show that after a certain number of voters (as we can call them) the majority always outperforms anyone in the group. More precisely, according to the Condorcet Jury Theorem, where agents’ choices are independent of one another, they all have the same bias p (1 < p < 0), the decision rule is simple majority, and there are two alternatives one of which is correct, where PN is the probability for N agents’ of the majority being right, and prior odds as to which of the two alternatives is correct are even ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Grofman</Author><Year>1983</Year><RecNum>13312</RecNum><Pages>p. 264</Pages><DisplayText>(Grofman, Owen, and Feld 1983, p. 264)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13312</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13312</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Bernard Grofman </author><author>Guillermo Owen</author><author>Scott L. Feld</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Thirteen theorems in search of the truth</title><secondary-title>Theory & Decision </secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Theory & Decision</full-title></periodical><pages>261-78</pages><volume>15</volume><dates><year>1983</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Grofman, Owen, and Feld 1983, p. 264):If 1 > p > ?, then PN is monotonically increasing in N and limnPN 1; if 0 < p < ?, then PN is monotonically decreasing in N and limnPN 0; while if p – ? then PN = ? for all N.Even more impressively, the rate of convergence can be quite rapid. If p = .8 then P13 > 0.99. The following figure shows, in the top graph, the rise in the probability that the majority is right with the probability each individual is right for a group with 95 members. The bottom graph shows the increasing probability that the majority is right, given that the probability that each individual is right of .6, with increasing numbers of members. Both of these show only data points for odd numbered groups—ties for even numbered groups reduce the reliability of the majority though it still tends to 1 in the long run.Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1Even more striking are related theorems that relax some of these rather idealized assumptions, and, in particular, the assumption of uniform competence. Thus, with pa representing the average competence of members of the group, if the distribution of pi is symmetric, then (op. cit. p. 268)If 1 > pa > ?, then PN is monotonically increasing in N and limnPN 1; if 0 < pa < ?, then PN is monotonically decreasing in N and limnPN 0; while if pa = ? then PN = ? for all N.Furthermore (op. cit. p. 269), For heterogeneous groups, if pi > 0.5 for all i, then the greater the size of the majority in favor of an alternative, the more likely is that alternative to be the correct choice.Finally, there is a Generalized Condorcet Jury Theorem:If pa > 0.5 then limNPN 1; if pa < 0.5 then limNPN 0; while if pa = 0.5, 1 – e? < limNPN < e?, i.e., 0.39 < PN < 0.61.What this means is that, so far as the positive program goes, all we need to know is that the participants have a positive bias toward truth and are independent, and to have enough participants, in order to get results that are probative. Ladha ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite ExcludeAuth="1"><Author>Ladha</Author><Year>1992</Year><RecNum>13969</RecNum><DisplayText>(1992)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13969</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1413396160">13969</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Ladha, Krishna K.</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>The Condorcet Jury Theorem, Free Speech, and Correlated Votes</title><secondary-title>American Journal of Political Science</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>American Journal of Political Science</full-title></periodical><pages>617-634</pages><volume>36</volume><number>3</number><dates><year>1992</year></dates><publisher>Midwest Political Science Association</publisher><isbn>00925853</isbn><urls><related-urls><url>;(1992) has extended this to show that even when there are correlations among judgments, in a wide range of conditions for large groups the majority outperforms any individual. Abstracting a bit from details, let us call the assumption that enough members of groups surveyed on thought experiments have a sufficiently positive bias and make judgments sufficiently independently of one another for the majority results to have a significant probability of being right the Positive Bias Assumption. It is an empirical question whether for any given group, e.g., of philosophically unsophisticated undergraduates, or random people enjoying a Saturday in Central Park, the Positive Bias Assumption is correct, in the sampling context. In connection with this, I want to raise three questions.Is it presupposed by the standard view of the method of thought experiments?Do we have reason to believe it? What would it take to establish the needed assumption?I raise the first question because if it is a presupposition of the method of thought experiments in philosophy that for any random group of individuals (or for most random groups of individuals) most will have a positive bias toward the truth (let this stand in for the constellation of conditions required), then survey philosophers don’t need to argue against their traditionalist opponents that the assumption is correct. Their opponents will be committed to it already, and so they would have to regard the results as probative, and as the numbers surveyed get larger and larger, other things being equal, the results would have to be given more and more weight.However, while the traditional philosopher is committed to it being possible to make advances in analysis by careful consideration of thought experiments, she is certainly not committed to thinking that most of those in groups being surveyed in the conditions of survey philosophy have a positive bias toward providing a correct response. Competence based accounts are committed to concept possession putting us in a position to articulate the application conditions of concepts. But they do not entail that it is easy, or that individuals might not for various reasons, in various circumstances, particularly for subtle questions, in an unfamiliar practice, be more likely than not to answer a question about a scenario incorrectly. This makes the next two questions salient. Do we have reason to think that the Positive Bias Assumption is correct? There is no question that it is always correct. For example, the gambler’s fallacy is quite common (similarly the hot hand fallacy, the assumption that one’s probability of guessing correctly an outcome goes up after having guessed correctly a number of times in a row). Someone subject to the gambler’s fallacy will think it more likely that the flip of a fair coin will yield a tails if it comes after a series of flips that turned up heads. The prevalence of the gambler’s fallacy has been demonstrated both in laboratory and in real world settings ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Croson</Author><Year>2005</Year><RecNum>6341</RecNum><DisplayText>(Croson and Sundali 2005)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6341</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1385837100">6341</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Croson, Rachel</author><author>Sundali, James</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>The Gambler's Fallacy and the Hot Hand: Empirical Data from Casinos</title><secondary-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</full-title></periodical><pages>195-209</pages><volume>30</volume><number>3</number><dates><year>2005</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Croson and Sundali 2005). Proportion of gambler’s fallacy outside bets after a streak of at least length N from data gathered at a large casino in Reno, Nevada, from 18 hours of security videotape of the roulette table. ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Croson</Author><Year>2005</Year><RecNum>6341</RecNum><Pages>203</Pages><DisplayText>(Croson and Sundali 2005, 203)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>6341</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1385837100">6341</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Croson, Rachel</author><author>Sundali, James</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>The Gambler's Fallacy and the Hot Hand: Empirical Data from Casinos</title><secondary-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</full-title></periodical><pages>195-209</pages><volume>30</volume><number>3</number><dates><year>2005</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite><Cite><Author>Croson</Author><Year>2005</Year><RecNum>6341</RecNum><record><rec-number>6341</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1385837100">6341</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Croson, Rachel</author><author>Sundali, James</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>The Gambler's Fallacy and the Hot Hand: Empirical Data from Casinos</title><secondary-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty</full-title></periodical><pages>195-209</pages><volume>30</volume><number>3</number><dates><year>2005</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Croson and Sundali 2005, 203)The standard explanation is that the gambler’s fallacy is the result of a representativeness bias. People expect short sequences to reflect the underlying probabilities, and so think a string of heads should be balanced by a tail. Similarly, data from surveys also show that we can’t in general assume that the majority in a group is correct. This is shown by the fact that can be variations in the majority judgments between groups which differ with respect to culture and socio-economic background, at least on some occasions ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Nichols</Author><Year>2003</Year><RecNum>4306</RecNum><DisplayText>(Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003; Machery et al. 2004)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>4306</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="0">4306</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Nichols, Shaun</author><author>Stich, Stephen</author><author>Weinberg, Jonathan M.</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Steven Luper</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>Meta-Skepticism: Meditations in Ethno-Epistemology</title><secondary-title>The Skeptics: Contemporary Essays</secondary-title></titles><keywords><keyword>Epistemology</keyword><keyword>Ethnography</keyword><keyword>Scepticism</keyword></keywords><dates><year>2003</year></dates><pub-location>Aldershot</pub-location><publisher>Ashgate Publishing</publisher><urls></urls></record></Cite><Cite><Author>Machery</Author><Year>2004</Year><RecNum>4307</RecNum><record><rec-number>4307</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="0">4307</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Machery, E.</author><author>Mallon, R.</author><author>Nichols, S.</author><author>Stich, S.</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Semantics, Cross-Cultural Style</title><secondary-title>Cognition</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Cognition</full-title></periodical><pages>B1-B12</pages><volume>92</volume><dates><year>2004</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Nichols, Stich, and Weinberg 2003; Machery et al. 2004), as well as relative amount of training in the philosophy and so on. Since different runs with different groups yield different results, we cannot say that whatever the majority says is correct. Moreover, the fact that ordering effects make a difference to the distribution of responses in some cases shows that judgments can be affected by factors that are not truth related ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Liao</Author><Year>2012</Year><RecNum>13929</RecNum><DisplayText>(Liao et al. 2012)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13929</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1412796606">13929</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Liao, S. Matthew</author><author>Wiegmann, Alex</author><author>Alexander, Joshua</author><author>Vong, Gerard</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Putting the trolley in order: Experimental philosophy and the loop case</title><secondary-title>Philosophical Psychology</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Philosophical Psychology</full-title></periodical><pages>661-671</pages><volume>25</volume><number>5</number><dates><year>2012</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Liao et al. 2012). We can seek larger groups, but it seems unlikely, as the case of the gambler’s fallacy shows, that simply increasing the size itself guarantees that most members of the group will have a positive bias toward truth in the relevant conditions. There are other sorts of errors we would expect to be systematic as well, such as responding to standardized conversational implicatures, rather than to what is literally expressed in a scenario.Thus, in some cases, we know that the majority result is not correct and this cannot be corrected simply by increasing the size of the group. Can we assume nonetheless that in most cases the majority result will be correct? Well, in most cases of what? We might say: in most cases in which the judgment is very simple, and there are no distorting or distracting features of the case or the conditions, and subjects understand what they are doing and are motivated to try to respond in the right way in response just to what the scenario says. Maybe so. But, first, how are we to test for whether or not there are distorting or distracting features of the case? We might find something that obviously is irrelevant to truth correlated with responses—like the choice of names of characters in a scenario or ordering effects or cultural background or personality type—but if there is nothing obvious, can we assume there are no distracting features of the case? Second, aren’t many of the cases we are interested in not simple cases? Third, in the end, don’t we want to know in particular cases whether or not the majority result is likely to be true? This brings us to the last of the three questions I want to take up: what would it take to establish the Positive Bias Assumption? We have a method that purports to help us discern the truth about the domain of conceptual truths. The method is indirect in the sense that it appeals to data about the judgments of agents relative to the assumption that they have a positive bias toward the correct judgment. We third person observers of the majority response in a group of subjects to questions about the scenario in a thought experiment want to know whether this is a correct expression of their conceptual competence. If our only access to the domain is through their judgments, however, we have no independent method of checking on whether they are getting it right or not. It looks as if, in order to support the Positive Bias Assumption, we need to sample the domain independently of the response of the majority. Can we do this?Yes, why not? Isn’t that how we determine that the gambler’s fallacy is a fallacy? It is a fallacy, we can see, because each flip of a fair coin is independent of the others, and, hence, for each flip, the probability that a heads or a tails comes up remains constant. On the assumption that the coin is fair, the probability that it comes up heads or tails is .5 each time it is flipped. That follows from the assumptions. We have independent access to the domain in question. We can see ourselves what the correct thing to say is. And seeing that, we can see that what most people may say or think about the probability of tails after a sequence heads is a mistake, and explain to them why it is a mistake, and why they made it.So it is in the case of surveys of the philosophically unsophisticated. If we want to know whether the majority opinion is correct or probative, and so whether something like the Positive Bias Assumption is correct, we can check to see whether most of our subjects get it right. If they do, then that is evidence that the Positive Bias Assumption is correct. Then, having provided evidence for the Positive Bias Assumption, we can use the survey data to advance one or another particular thesis about a concept’s application conditions on that basis.But wait a minute! If to confirm the Positive Bias Assumption, in a particular case, we have to independently decide the truth of the matter about what we were interested in testing, then … we don’t need it. Once we are in a position to use the Survey Data to contribute to a philosophical problem, we have settled the matter. Furthermore, it could give us no more justification than we already had, since any confidence we have in the majority being right, or even in the probability that the majority is right, rests on our confidence that the Positive Bias Assumption is right, and that rests on our confidence that we have independently made the right judgment. To try to raise our confidence by this means would appear to be a kind of illegitimate bootstrapping of our epistemic position.Perhaps it was evident from the start that the solution offered was a poison pill. While it seems the most straightforward way for one to try to establish that for a given population the Positive Bias Assumption is correct, it would undermine the point of survey philosophy (on the continuity approach). It is obvious also, though, that one cannot simply assume that it is true. It needs defense, and it needs defense on a case by case basis. Is there an indirect method of arguing in particular cases that we should give some credence to the Positive Bias Assumption, especially when the results might seem to have the most potential for overturning philosophical orthodoxy, that is, when most philosophers don’t agree with the majority in survey results? We could try to test for general competency and then try out thought experiments with subjects who have been confirmed to be good at making the right judgment. Perhaps that is what we do informally in philosophy already. But this seems unlikely to be much help in cases in which there is controversy.4.3 Does x-phi deliver what we want?Suppose that we can solve the confirmation problem for x-phi, so that we can provide reasons to think that in particular cases the Positive Bias Assumption is true without independently establishing the right result, so that it could actually contribute to advancing a thesis about the application conditions of a concept. Would this deliver what we wanted?Why not? After all didn’t we want to know what the application conditions for a certain concept were? Suppose that the concept were the concept of justice, for example, and suppose that we had someone construct a theory of justice using the results of surveys in an especially clever and sophisticated way. There we would have it, finally, we would know what justice is! Suppose that a young Greek philosopher in antiquity is interested in the question what justice is, and she has learned of the Oracle at Delphi. She decides then to travel to Delphi to ask the Oracle. Suppose that the Oracle does not speak in riddles, and that it tells her that justice in the state is when individuals receive benefits according to their merits. Suppose that she justifiably believes that the Oracle has a high positive bias toward the truth. She writes down what the Oracle has told her, and she is justified in believing that it is true. Should she be satisfied? Now suppose an undergraduate student is interested in the nature of justice. She decides to survey faculty who teach courses related to justice in political science, philosophy, cognitive science, sociology and so on. A majority of those she surveys agree that justice is that state of society represented by arrangements which people would choose were they to have been constrained to choose it behind a veil of ignorance, not knowing their natural abilities or position in society or their sex or race, culture, or individual tastes, but knowing that in any society there would be a distribution of abilities, differences in sex, race, culture, individual tastes, and so on. Suppose that she justifiably believes that the faculty she has surveyed have a positive bias toward the truth. She accepts what they say and is justified in believing it to be true on the basis of their authority. Should she be satisfied? She should not be satisfied. Why not? The problem is not that what she believes is not true. Let us grant, in one or the other case, it is true, and in fact, we can grant, let us say, that our undergraduate student knows what justice is on the basis of authority. She knows what justice is in the sense that she can give a correct statement of it and she is justified (in a non-deviant way) in her belief. But what she doesn’t have is any understanding of why that is what justice is. Or if she does, it does not come from the mere fact that she has ascertained that most of the people in positions of authority that she has asked about it agree on a characterization, and that the majority is likely to be right. The situation would be the same for the undergraduate who learns that the Pythagorean Theory is true (or the Condorcet Jury Theorem) from reading it in a textbook but not from being given a proof of it. She would know the Pythagorean theorem, but she would not know why it was true. She would not have any understanding why the area of the square on the hypotenuse of a right triangle is the sum of the areas of the squares constructed on its sides. The textbook for her is an oracle, a known reliable source, but not a reliable source that conveys an understanding of the ground for the truth. (Imagine that you told a freshman who is not too sophisticated mathematically but also not completely ignorant that 1 = .99999999…. She might accept it on authority but find it puzzling. Everything changes when you point out that 1 = 3 x 1/3 = 3 x .333333 … = .9999999….)What is missing from the x-phi conception of philosophical method is only the most important thing about philosophy. What we want in philosophy is not to know things on the basis of their being the pronouncements of someone who is competence to say, but to know them out of our own competence, to see why they are true. Even if we could trust surveys, they would never give us the kind of knowledge we seek in philosophy. You might as well ask an oracle.4.4 Can Experimental Philosophy help Philosophy? Suppose you grant that x-phi is not a replacement or supplement for philosophy, even in the relatively narrow domain of philosophical activity that it concerns itself with. Is that the end of the line for x-phi? Is all the elaborate surveying of the unsophisticated to be relegated to some niche branch of psychology, for whoever might be interested in it? Or is there still some role for it to play as a kind of aid to core philosophical activities?Experimental philosophy conceived of as a psychological enterprise can still be of some help. Psychology is not irrelevant to philosophical methodology. Our cognitive abilities are impressive, but we are not perfectly rational, we don’t always get things right, and there are sometimes interesting explanations of this that only come to light with empirical investigation. The systematic study of the conditions under which we are liable to make mistakes helps us to guard against them. It can help us in teaching students as well, in choosing examples, and giving appropriate context.That there are order effects in the judgments that people make about cases is an important insight for example ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Schwitzgebel</Author><Year>2012</Year><RecNum>13877</RecNum><DisplayText>(Schwitzgebel and Cushman 2012)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13877</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1411901973">13877</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Schwitzgebel, Eric</author><author>Cushman, Fiery</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Expertise in Moral Reasoning? Order Effects on Moral Judgment in Professional Philosophers and Non-Philosophers</title><secondary-title>Mind and Language</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Mind and Language</full-title></periodical><pages>135-153</pages><volume>27</volume><number>2</number><dates><year>2012</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Schwitzgebel and Cushman 2012). That people respond differently depending on the variance of factors that we are convinced are irrelevant to the correctness of a judgment provides a caution about our own judgments. This can help us to think about good thought experiment design, especially in the context of testing ideas with others. This doesn’t show that we can never figure out what the right thing to say is, but it does show that figuring it out can be a complicated matter, and that we need to think systematically about the subject matter and to take into account all of the possible factors that may incline us to error, and to try to correct for them so far as possible. All of this is familiar, of course, but details help. How much does the identification of misleading factors in particular cases show about how far we can or cannot trust our judgments? In this volume, Stich and Tobias suggest that what it shows is that we can’t get started using thought experiments in inquiry without first undertaking the experimental study of intuitions. This is an overreaction. They make this claim in responding to the point (made in an earlier paper of mine ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Ludwig</Author><Year>2007</Year><RecNum>10062</RecNum><DisplayText>(Ludwig 2007)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>10062</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931212">10062</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Ludwig, K.</author></authors></contributors><auth-address>Ludwig, K
Univ Florida, Dept Philosophy, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA
Univ Florida, Dept Philosophy, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA</auth-address><titles><title>The Epistemology of Thought Experiments: First Person versus Third Person Approaches</title><secondary-title>Midwest Studies in Philosophy: Philosophy and the Empirical</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Midwest Studies in Philosophy: Philosophy and the Empirical</full-title></periodical><pages>128-159</pages><volume>31</volume><keywords><keyword>intentional action</keyword><keyword>folk psychology</keyword><keyword>free will</keyword><keyword>moral considerations</keyword><keyword>ordinary language</keyword></keywords><dates><year>2007</year></dates><isbn>0363-6550</isbn><accession-num>ISI:000250202000007</accession-num><urls><related-urls><url><Go to ISI>://000250202000007</url></related-urls></urls><language>English</language></record></Cite></EndNote>(Ludwig 2007)) that responses to surveys are not ipso facto philosophical intuitions. For Ludwig, a judgment or belief that is influenced by factors other than conceptual competence will not count as an intuition. … A judgment that is influenced by order of presentation, or font size or fart spray is not solely the expression of conceptual competence. Thus when intuitions are characterized in this way, the studies pose no challenge to the use of intuitions as evidence in philosophy. But we are inclined to think that in making this move, Ludwig is hoist on his own petard. For the effects discussed in §3 are almost always covert; people have no conscious awareness that their beliefs or judgments are being affected. So [i] on Ludwig’s restricted account, the only way to determine whether one’s beliefs or judgments are intuitions is to do well designed and carefully controlled experiments. Rather than [ii] showing that the experimental studies are irrelevant to philosophical practice, [iii] Ludwig’s restricted account of intuition leads directly to the conclusion that the sorts of studies that experimental philosophers have undertaken are required before we can begin to use intuitions as evidence, since without such studies we have no way of knowing which of our beliefs or judgments are intuitions. (p. nn; lower case roman numerals added)There are a number of points to be made in response. The first is a point of interpretation. In the article that Stich and Tobias cite, I argued that extravagant claims made on the basis of surveys pose no threat to traditional philosophical methods, but I did not argue that surveys were irrelevant to philosophical practice, as here implied [ii]. Instead, I suggested, as I have above, that they can help us think about good thought experiment design and to identify pitfalls. In fact, except for the absence of the triumphalist tone, and my rejection of the (false and ungrounded) assumption that survey philosophy is essential to success in philosophy, my conclusion is not that different in its details from Stich and Tobias. Why all the fuss?The second is about the claim (in [i] and [iii]) that (a) the fact that in some cases there are factors that distort responses to thought experiments shows that (b) “we [generally] have no way of knowing which or our beliefs or judgments are intuitions” without first undertaking surveys about scenarios in thought experiments. In fact, the inference from (a) to (b) is a non sequitur. It doesn’t follow from the fact that there are sometimes distorting influences at work in thought experiments that there always are. And it doesn’t follow that because there are sometimes distorting influences at work in responses to thought experiments that we can never know that our responses are intuitions—just as it doesn’t follow from the fact that we sometime make mistakes in calculations that we never know that we have made a correct calculation! In response to the charge that there is no way we can ever tell whether we are in the good condition or the bad condition, and that if we can’t, then we can never trust our intuitions, there are several things to say. The first is that it has not been demonstrated that we can never tell when we are in the good condition, and that it doesn’t follow from the fact that if we are in the bad condition we can’t tell (which has also not been demonstrated), that if we are in the good condition we cannot tell (cf. Bernard Williams’s discussion of the cases of dreaming and anoxia ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Williams</Author><Year>1978</Year><RecNum>14326</RecNum><Pages>appendix 3</Pages><DisplayText>(Williams 1978, appendix 3)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>14326</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1444148985">14326</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book">6</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Williams, Bernard</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Descartes: The Project of Pure Enquiry</title></titles><pages>320 p.</pages><keywords><keyword>Descartes, Rene?, 1596-1650.</keyword></keywords><dates><year>1978</year></dates><pub-location>London</pub-location><publisher>Pelican</publisher><isbn>0855279613</isbn><accession-num>4161408</accession-num><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Williams 1978, appendix 3)). The second is that, waiving the last point, on the assumption that mistakes are not the norm, we can apply the method of reflective equilibrium to sort out what to say. The third is that there is empirical work that supports the common sense thesis that we are often implicitly aware of cases in which intuition instability (e.g., due to order effects) is a threat and that there are reliable methods for tracking it (introspective confidence and belief strength) ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Wright</Author><Year>2010</Year><RecNum>13962</RecNum><DisplayText>(Wright 2010)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13962</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1413323523">13962</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Wright, Jennifer</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>On intuitional stability: The clear, the strong, and the paradigmatic</title><secondary-title>Cognition</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Cognition</full-title></periodical><pages>491-503</pages><volume>115</volume><number>3</number><dates><year>2010</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Wright 2010).The third is that the general claim Stich and Tobias make is self-defeating. Intuitions, on the view in question, are conceptually grounded judgments about entailments. Therefore, as a completely general thesis about judgments about entailments, it is clearly self-defeating to claim that we must first engage in surveys before we can ever tell whether our judgments about entailments are correct, since in evaluating what the surveys show us we must make judgments about entailments. For example, the judgment that order effects show that there is something problematic about responses to a thought experiment rests on the claim that order of presentation is irrelevant to the correct judgment. That order is completely irrelevant to the correct judgment and that judgments are influenced by order entails that the judgments are being distorted by truth-irrelevant features of the experimental set-up. I trust that readers feel confident that they know, in this case, that the one proposition entails the other. It a point of mild irony that the use of survey results to argue against the use of thought experiments in philosophy relies on an epistemology which could only be supported by the sources which it aims to undermine.The fourth is that it does not follow from the fact that, in some cases, there are factors that distort responses to scenarios, that to discover and correct this we need to do surveys. In actual philosophical practice, as noted earlier, sec. 3 #6, we aim to survey a range of cases, vary the cases studied, test them on others, compare results with previously established results, bring to bear general theoretical considerations, and when we notice a problem, try to get a clearer view of what is going on, in much the same way that we sort through a problem in geometry or mathematics. The journal literature in philosophy, among other things, carries out this task over time, just as the journal literature in the sciences carries out the task of self-correction and revision that is an on-going part of the advancement of science. The fifth is that to arrive at the right view, survey methods alone will not suffice, for in cases in which we suspect that there are distorting factors, the question of whether the positive bias assumption is correct for a group surveyed becomes urgent. Intuitions are ultimately methodologically basic in this domain.Finally, perhaps another way that x-phi is relevant to philosophy is that it can (potentially) throw up challenges to philosophical theories (though one might wonder whether it will raise challenges that wouldn’t be raised anyway). For example, those who want to maintain the Simple View in the philosophy of action, that if someone intentionally Fs, then she intended to F, must confront the fact that there are circumstances in which many people say that someone intentionally F-ed but did not intend to F. Philosophers of course noticed this first, and indeed this was the impetus for the surveys ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Harman</Author><Year>1976</Year><RecNum>9839</RecNum><DisplayText>(Harman 1976)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>9839</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931212">9839</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Harman, Gilbert</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Practical Reasoning</title><secondary-title>Review of Metaphysics</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Review of Metaphysics</full-title></periodical><pages>431-63</pages><volume>79</volume><dates><year>1976</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Harman 1976). Proponents of the Simple View need to offer an explanation for why people get it wrong. These explanations are of course empirical claims about distorting factors. It is not clear the extent to which these can actually be resolved using the survey method (or whether it is the best method ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Levin</Author><Year>2009</Year><RecNum>13256</RecNum><DisplayText>(Levin 2009)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13256</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1394931215">13256</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Journal Article">17</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Levin, Janet</author></authors></contributors><titles><title>Experimental philosophy</title><secondary-title>Analysis</secondary-title></titles><periodical><full-title>Analysis</full-title></periodical><pages>761-769</pages><volume>69</volume><number>4</number><dates><year>2009</year></dates><urls></urls></record></Cite></EndNote>(Levin 2009)), but it seems plausible enough that some testing of these theories could be conducted by the survey method, and that this can have some value.5. ConclusionWhat is the relation of x-phi to philosophy? A pessimist might say: The connection is that people who do x-phi are largely housed in philosophy departments, just as people who do religious studies are sometimes housed in philosophy departments. There is a social and an administrative connection. In addition, there is the appearance of the word ‘philosophy’ in ‘Experimental Philosophy’, and the fact that scenarios from philosophical thought experiments are featured in its surveys. They also sometimes publish in philosophy journals. In short: “experimental philosophy is a cuckoo-bird in the nest of philosophy” ADDIN EN.CITE <EndNote><Cite><Author>Sorensen</Author><Year>2014</Year><RecNum>13936</RecNum><DisplayText>(Sorensen 2014)</DisplayText><record><rec-number>13936</rec-number><foreign-keys><key app="EN" db-id="2dwsa9s2up0xv4eex9oppdw1awx9x2a2wfvr" timestamp="1412880003">13936</key></foreign-keys><ref-type name="Book Section">5</ref-type><contributors><authors><author>Roy Sorensen</author></authors><secondary-authors><author>Robert Booth</author><author>Darrell P. Rowbottom</author></secondary-authors></contributors><titles><title>Novice Thought Experiments</title><secondary-title>Intuitions</secondary-title></titles><dates><year>2014</year></dates><pub-location>Oxford</pub-location><publisher>Oxford University Press</publisher><urls></urls><electronic-resource-num>DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199609192.001.0001</electronic-resource-num></record></Cite></EndNote>(Sorensen 2014).Not so fast! X-phi is not promising as a positive program for contributing to the articulation of application conditions of concepts or conceptual connections. First, we have to have independent access to the domain to validate the assumptions that would enable us to use the data, which renders it otiose for our primary purpose, and, second, the kind of knowledge we want in philosophy is not supplied by asking an oracle. But even philosophers dismissive of x-phi? and skeptical of the continuity account should be interested in the results of surveys, for it provides a map of the reactions of the unsophisticated (and in some cases of the sophisticated) and evidence bearing on influences on responses and mechanisms involved that are not related to truth. We can learn something from this, and it can help to make us more sophisticated about the construction and use thought experiments. In addition, some testing of empirical claims about errors that are made in response to thought experiments can be pursued fruitfully in this way. What then is the relation of x-phi to philosophy? X-phi is philosophy from the sociological point of view. From the standpoint of the tradition in philosophy, in so far as it is to be of aid to philosophy, it is more properly thought of as a non-philosophical activity or an adjunct to philosophical activity that has relevance to philosophy in the way in which the investigation of the foibles and frailties of human reasoning has relevance to the practice of human reasoning. We should use all the tools we can assemble to advance our understanding.References ADDIN EN.REFLIST Adleberg, Toni, Morgan Thompson, and Eddy Nahmias. 2014. Do Men and Women Have Different Philosophical Intuitions? Further Data. Philosophical Psychology 28 (5):615-641.Alexander, Joshua, Ronald Mallon, and Jonathan M. Weinberg. 2010. Accentuate the Negative. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 1 (2):297-314.Alexander, Joshua, and Jonathan Weinberg. 2007. Analytic Epistemology and Experimental Philosophy. Philosophy Compass 2 (1):56-80.Bealer, George. 1998. Intuition and the Autonomy of Philosophy. In Rethinking Intuition: The Psychology of Intuition and Its Role in Philosophical Inquiry, edited by M. DePaul and W. Ramsey. New York: Rowman & Littlefield.Booth, Anthony. 2014. Intuitions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Buckwalter, Wesley. 2014. Intuition Fail: Philosophical Activity and the Limits of Expertise. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 89 (2).Buckwalter, Wesley, and Jonathan Schaffer. 2013. Knowledge, Stakes, and Mistakes. No?s 47 (1).Buckwalter, Wesley, and Stephen Stich. 2014. Gender and Philosophical Intuition. In Experimental Philosophy, Vol.2, edited by J. Knobe and S. Nichols: Oxford University Press.Cappelen, Herman. 2012. Philosophy without Intuitions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.———. 2014. X-Phi without Intuitions? In Intuitions, edited by A. R. Booth and D. P. Rowbottom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Collaboration, Open Science. 2015. Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Science 349 (6251).Croson, Rachel, and James Sundali. 2005. The Gambler's Fallacy and the Hot Hand: Empirical Data from Casinos. The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 30 (3):195-209.Cruz, Helen De. 2014. Where Philosophical Intuitions Come From. Australasian Journal of Philosophy.Cullen, Simon. 2010. Survey-Driven Romanticism. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 1 (2):275-296.DePaul, Michael, and William Ramsey, eds. 1998. Rethinking Intuition: The Psychology of Intuition and Its Role in Philosophical Inquiry. New York: Rowman & Littlefield.Deutsch, Max. 2009. Experimental philosophy and the theory of reference. Mind and Language 24 (4):445-466.Doris, John. 2002. Lack of Character: Personality and Moral Behavior. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Doris, John M. 1998. Persons, Situations, and Virtue Ethics. No??s 32 (4):504-530.Genone, James, and Tania Lombrozo. 2012. Concept Possession, Experimental Semantics, and Hybrid Theories of Reference. Philosophical Psychology 25 (5):1-26.Gettier, Edmund. 1963. Is Justified True Belief Knowledge? Analysis 23:121-3.Goldman, Alan. 2007. Philosophical Intuitions. Grazer Philosophische Studien 74:1-26.———. 2010. Philosophical Naturalism and Intuitional Methodology. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Association 84 (2):115-150.Grofman, Bernard, Guillermo Owen, and Scott L. Feld. 1983. Thirteen theorems in search of the truth. Theory & Decision 15:261-78.Grundmann, Thomas. 2010. Some Hope for Intuitions: A Reply to Weinberg. Philosophical Psychology 23 (4):481-509.Hales, Steven D. 2012. The faculty of intuition. Analytic Philosophy 53 (2):180-207.Harman, Gilbert. 1976. Practical Reasoning. Review of Metaphysics 79:431-63.———. 1999. Moral Philosophy Meets Social Psychology: Virtue Ethics and the Fundamental Attribution Error. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series 119:316-331.———. 2000. The Nonexistence of Character Traits. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 100:223-226.Hitchcock, Christopher. 2012. Thought experiments, real experiments, and the expertise objection. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 2 (2):205-218.Jackson, Frank. 2011. On Gettier Holdouts. Mind and Language 26 (4):468-481.Kamtekar, Rachana. 2004. Situationism and Virtue Ethics on the Content of Character. Ethics 114 (3):458-491.Kauppinen, Antti. 2014. The rise and fall of experimental philosophy. In Experimental Philosophy, edited by J. Knobe and S. Nichols. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Kim, Minsun, and Yuan Yuan. No Cross-Cultural Differences in Gettier Car Case Intuition: A Replication Study of Weinberg et al. 2001.Knobe, Joshua. 2003a. Intentional Action and Side Effects in Ordinary Language. Analysis 63 (3):190-194.———. 2003b. Intentional Action in Folk Psychology: An Experimental Investigation. Philosophical Psychology 16 (2):309-324.———. 2004. Intention, Intentional Action and Moral Considerations. Analysis 64 (2):181-187.———. 2006. The Concept of Intentional Action: A Case Study in the Uses of Folk Psychology. Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition 130 (2):203-231.———. 2007. Experimental philosophy. Philosophy Compass 2 (1):81–92.Knobe, Joshua, Wesley Buckwalter, Philip Robbins, Hagop Sarkissian, Tamler Sommers, and Shaun Nichols. 2012. Experimental Philosophy. Annual Review of Psychology 63 (50):72-73.Knobe, Joshua, and Aruda Burra. 2006. Experimental Philosophy and Folk Concepts: Methodological Considerations. Journal of Cognition and Culture 6 (1-2):331-342.Knobe, Joshua Michael, and Shaun Nichols. 2008. Experimental philosophy. Oxford ; New York: Oxford University Press.———. 2014. Experimental philosophy. Vol. 2. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Kornblith, Hilary. 2002. Knowledge and Its Place in Nature. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Ladha, Krishna K. 1992. The Condorcet Jury Theorem, Free Speech, and Correlated Votes. American Journal of Political Science 36 (3):617-634.Lam, Barry. 2010. Are cantonese speakers really descriptivists? Revisiting cross-cultural semantics. Cognition 115 (2):320–32.Levin, Janet. 2009. Experimental philosophy. Analysis 69 (4):761-769.Liao, S. Matthew, Alex Wiegmann, Joshua Alexander, and Gerard Vong. 2012. Putting the trolley in order: Experimental philosophy and the loop case. Philosophical Psychology 25 (5):661-671.Ludwig, Kirk. 2007. The Epistemology of Thought Experiments: First Person versus Third Person Approaches. Midwest Studies in Philosophy: Philosophy and the Empirical 31:128-159.———. 2010. Intuitions and Relativity. Philosophical Psychology 23 (4):427-445.———. 2013. Methods in Analytic Philosophy. In Philosophical Methodology: The Armchair or the Laboratory, edited by M. Haug. New York: Routledge.Machery, E., R. Mallon, S. Nichols, and S. Stich. 2004. Semantics, Cross-Cultural Style. Cognition 92:B1-B12.Malle, Bertram F., and Joshua Knobe. 2001. The Distinction between Desire and Intention: A Folk-Conceptual Analysis. In Intentions and Intentionality: Foundations of Social Cognition, edited by B. F. Malle, L. J. Moses and D. A. Baldwin. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.Naess, Arne. 1953. Interpretation and Preciseness: a contribution to the theory of communication. Oslo: I Kommisjon Hos J. Dybwad.Nagel, Jennifer. 2012. Intuitions and Experiments: A Defense of the Case Method in Epistemology. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 85 (3):495-527.Nagel, Jennifer, Valerie San Juan, and Raymond A. Mar. 2013. Lay Denial of Knowledge for Justified True Beliefs. Cognition 129:652-661.Nahmias, Eddy, Stephen G. Morris, Thomas Nadelhoffer, and Jason Turner. 2006. Is Incompatibilism Intuitive? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 73 (1):28 - 53.Nichols, Shaun. 2011. Experimental Philosophy and the Problem of Free Will. Science 331 (6023):1401-1403.Nichols, Shaun, and Joshua Knobe. 2007. Moral responsibility and determinism: The cognitive science of folk intuitions. No?s 41 (4):663–685.Nichols, Shaun, Stephen Stich, and Jonathan M. Weinberg. 2003. Meta-Skepticism: Meditations in Ethno-Epistemology. In The Skeptics: Contemporary Essays, edited by S. Luper. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing.Papineau, David. 2011. What is x-phi good for? The Philosophers' Magazine 52:83-88.———. 2013. The Poverty of Conceptual Analysis. In The Armchair or the Laboratory, edited by M. Haug. New York: Routledge.Pettit, Dean, and Joshua Knobe. 2009. The Pervasive Impact of Moral Judgment. Mind and Language 24 (5):586-604.Pritchard, Duncan. 2014. Sceptical Intuitions. In Intuitions, edited by A. R. Booth and D. P. Rowbottom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Putnam, Hilary. 1965. It Ain't Necessarily So. Journal of PHilosophy LIX:658-671.Quine, Willard Van Orman. 1953. Two Dogmas of Empiricism. In From a Logical Point of View. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Rini, Regina A. 2013. Analogies, Moral Intuitions, and the Expertise Defence. Review of Philosophy and Psychology (2):1-13.Rose, David, and David Danks. 2013. In Defense of a Broad Conception of Experimental Philosophy. Metaphilosophy 44 (4):512-532.Sarkissian, Hagop, Amita Chatterjee, Felipe De Brigard, Joshua Knobe, Shaun Nichols, and Smita Sirker. 2010. Is Belief in Free Will a Cultural Universal? Mind and Language 25 (3):346-358.Sarkissian, Hagop, John Park, David Tien, Jennifer Wright, and Joshua Knobe. 2011. Folk Moral Relativism. Mind and Language 26 (4):482-505.Schwitzgebel, Eric, and Fiery Cushman. 2012. Expertise in Moral Reasoning? Order Effects on Moral Judgment in Professional Philosophers and Non-Philosophers. Mind and Language 27 (2):135-153.Seyedsayamdost, Hamid. 2014a. On gender and philosophical intuition: Failure of replication and other negative results. Philosophical Psychology:1-32.———. 2014b. Reproducibility of empirical findings: experiments in philosophy and beyond, Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method, London School of Economics, London.———. 2015. On Normativity and Epistemic Intuitions: Failure of Replication. Episteme 12 (1):95-116.Snow, Nancy. 2010. Virtue as Social Intelligence: An Empirically Grounded Theory. New York: Routledge.Sommers, Tamler. 2010. Experimental philosophy and free will. Philosophy Compass 5 (2):199-212.Sorensen, Roy. 2014. Novice Thought Experiments. In Intuitions, edited by R. Booth and D. P. Rowbottom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Sosa, Ernest. 2007a. Experimental philosophy and philosophical intuition. Philosophical Studies 132 (1):99-107.———. 2007b. Intuitions: Their Nature and Epistemic Efficacy. Grazer Philosophische Studien.———. 2008. A Defense of the Use of Intuitions in Philosophy. In Stich and His Critics, edited by M. Bishop and D. Murphy. Oxford: Blackwell.———. 2011. Can There Be a Discipline of Philosophy? And Can It Be Founded on Intuitions? Mind and Language 26 (4):453-467.Stacy Swain, Joshua Alexander, Jonathan Weinberg. 2008. The Instability of Philosophical Intutions: Running Hot adn Cold on Truetemp. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 76 (1):138-155.Talbot, Brian. 2013. Reforming intuition pumps: when are the old ways the best? Philosophical Studies 165 (2):315-334.———. 2014. Why so negative? Evidence aggregation and armchair philosophy. Synthese 191 (16):3865-3896.Thomson, Judith Jarvis. 1976. Killing, Letting Die, and the Trolley Problem. The Monist 59 (2):204-217.Weinberg, Jonathan. 2007. How to Challenge Intuitions Empirically without Risking Skepticism. Midwest Studies in Philosophy 31 (1):318-343.Weinberg, Jonathan, Chad Gonnerman, Cameron Buckner, and Joshua Alexander. 2010. Are Philosophers Expert Intuiters? Philosophical Psychology 23 (3):331-355.Weinberg, Jonathan, Shaun Nichols, and Stephen Stich. 2001. Normativity and Epistemic Intuitions. Philosophical Topics 29:429-460.Williams, Bernard. 1978. Descartes: The Project of Pure Enquiry. London: Pelican.Williamson, Timothy. 2011. Philosophical Expertise and the Burden of Proof. Metaphilosophy 42 (3):215-229.Wright, Jennifer. 2010. On intuitional stability: The clear, the strong, and the paradigmatic. Cognition 115 (3):491-503.Young, Liane, Fiery Cushman, Ralph Adolphs, Daniel Tranel, and Marc Hauser. 2006. Does emotion mediate the effect of an action's moral status on its intentional status? Neuropsychological evidence. Journal of Cognition and Culture 6:291-304. ................
................
In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.
To fulfill the demand for quickly locating and searching documents.
It is intelligent file search solution for home and business.
Related searches
- pitt admissions staff
- titanic research archive wow
- art archive software
- ultimate guitar archive chords
- armour archive sca
- archive lottery ny game past
- archive math
- newspapers archive maine
- new brunswick newspaper archive library
- national archive and records administration
- archive training courses
- windows 10 mail archive folder