PDF Why We Still Need Public Schools - ERIC - Education Resources ...

[Pages:24]Why We Still Need Public Schools

Public Education for the Common Good

Center on Education Policy 1001 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 522 Washington, D.C. 20036 tel: 202.822.8065 fax: 202.822.6008 e: cep-dc@cep- w: cep-

cep-

Why We Still Need Public Schools

Why We Still Need Public Schools

Public Education for the Common Good

Table of Contents

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 The Origins of Public Education . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 The Public Missions of Public Education--and Why They Still Apply . . . . . . . . . 7 Maintaining Public Education While Improving Its Quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Center on Education Policy

Why We Still Need Public Schools

Introduction

The whole people must take upon themselves the education of the whole people and be willing to bear the expenses of it. There should not be a district of one mile square, without a school in it, not founded by a charitable individual, but maintained at the public expense of the people themselves.

-- John Adams, U.S. president, letter to John Jebb,1785

From the early days of the nation, public education has played a vital role in American democratic society. In addition to preparing young people for productive work and fulfilling lives, public education has also been expected to accomplish certain collective missions aimed at promoting the common good. These include, among others, preparing youth to become responsible citizens, forging a common culture from a nation of immigrants, and reducing inequalities in American society.

1 In recent years, however, some of these public-spirited missions of education have been neglected and are in danger of being abandoned. Most current efforts to reform public education have focused on increasing students' academic achievement--without a doubt, a central purpose of schooling. But the reasons given for why it's important to improve achievement often stress individual or private economic benefits (such as preparing youth for good jobs in a global economy), rather than public benefits (such as preparing youth for active citizenship in a democratic society). An emphasis on the individual goals of education is especially obvious in proposals to give families vouchers toward private school tuition--proposals that treat education as a private consumer good.

This publication from the Center on Education Policy revisits the "public" missions of American public education. It is an update of the Center's 1996 brochure, Do We Still Need Public Schools? The first section of this updated version briefly reviews how and why the U.S. system of public education came into being. The second section lists six public missions that public schools have been expected to fulfill, beyond what is expected of private schools, and looks at why these missions remain relevant today. The last section discusses why the nation must hold onto these missions while pursuing reforms to help all public schools live up to these ideals. Throughout the publication, quotations from the nation's founders and other historical figures illustrate how early advocates of public education linked public schools to the common good.

As used here, the term "public education" means education that is publicly financed, tuitionfree, accountable to public authorities, and accessible to all students. It covers various types of public schools, including traditional schools, charter and magnet schools, vocational schools, and alternative schools.

2

Center on Education Policy

Why We Still Need Public Schools

The Origins of Public Education

Before Public Education

It is therefore ordred yt evry towneship in this jurisdiction, aftr ye Lord hath increased ym to ye number of 50 householdrs, shall then forthwth appoint one wthin their towne to teach all such children as shall resort to him to write & reade, whose wages whall be paid eithr by ye parents or mastrs of such children, or by ye inhabitants in genrall . . . & it is furthr ordered, yt where any towne shall increase to ye numbr of 100 families or househouldrs, they shall set up a gramer schoole . . . .

--Massachusetts Bay Colony, General School Act of 1647

3

Before a system of public schools took hold in the mid-19th century, American children were educated through a hodgepodge of mostly private institutions and arrangements. These included church-supported schools; local schools organized by towns or groups of parents; tuition schools set up by traveling schoolmasters; charity schools for poor children run by churches or benevolent societies; boarding schools for children of the wellto-do; "dame schools" run by women in their homes; and private tutoring. These early schools were financed from various sources, including parents' tuition payments, charitable contributions, property taxes, fuel contributions, and, in some cases, state support.

This disjointed approach to schooling resulted in many inequities. Often schools served only boys whose families could afford the tuition. Large groups of children--including African Americans, Native Americans, many girls, and some poor white children who did not belong to a church--were excluded from school by law or custom. In some places, it was a crime to teach a slave to read.

With limited options for formal education, boys sometimes entered apprenticeships instead of going to school, on the promise that their masters would teach them to read and write. Other children learned at home, church, or work. Still others received no formal education at all.

Access to education was limited by geography, too. Massachusetts had taken a step toward public schooling in 1647 with a law requiring towns of sufficient size to hire a teacher or establish a grammar school, to be paid for by the town's parents, apprentice masters, or all of its residents. By the time of the American Revolution, public schools could be found throughout New England, but in many other colonies, private schools remained the norm. Some rural areas had no schools at all. Those schools that did exist outside the cities were often hard to get to, skimpily equipped, and overcrowded. Teachers were poorly paid, transient, and inexperienced. Sometimes they were undereducated themselves.

The curricula, school years, and grade levels of these early schools varied widely, depending on such factors as the values of the religious groups sponsoring them and the resources of the organizations supporting them. Few young people had opportunities to pursue education beyond the elementary level. Income and social class usually fixed a child's options. Children from well-off families often had access to a "classical" education that included instruction in Latin and Greek, grammar, philosophy, and other liberal arts. In striking contrast, children of farmers and day workers or students in charity schools were lucky to receive even the most rudimentary education.

The Beginning of Public Education

The good education of youth has been esteemed by wise men in all ages, as

the surest foundation of the happiness of both private families and of

commonwealths. Almost all governments have therefore made it a principal

object of their attention, to establish and endow with proper revenues, such

seminaries of learning, as might supply the succeeding age with men qualified

4

to serve the publick with honour to themselves, and to their country.

--Benjamin Franklin, U.S. statesman, inventor, and diplomat, Proposals Related to the Education of Youth in Pennsylvania, 1749

Center on Education Policy

Soon after the American Revolution, some of the nation's founders recognized that this haphazard approach to schooling was inadequate to educate the people of the developing nation and that a more formal system was needed. Believing that the survival of the new republic depended on citizens with sufficient education to govern themselves, Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, among others, supported the creation of publicly funded schools. Jefferson submitted a proposal to the Virginia legislature in 1779 to create free elementary schools across the state for all white boys and girls, regardless of family income, and to educate the brightest boys from each school through adolescence at public expense. But the conservative legislature did not want to assume the burden of educating the poor, and the bill was defeated.

Still, Jefferson's ideas about the connection between education and democracy proved influential. In 1785, the U.S. Continental Congress adopted the Land Ordinance, based on an earlier draft by Thomas Jefferson. This federal law reserved a portion of revenues from land sales to fund public schools in the states that would be carved out of the Northwest Territory. During the 1780s, Vermont, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire enacted general laws to fund tax-supported schools. It would take another 50 years, however, before a broad system of tax-supported public schools became a reality.

Little by little, public schools took hold in communities, often because the local people, rather than the politicians, demanded them. In the 1830s, the push for public education gained momentum when reformers like Horace Mann, secretary of the Massachusetts board of education, promoted the notion of the "common school." These schools would be publicly funded and locally governed and would offer a common curriculum to all students. Inspiringly optimistic about the power of education, the common-school reformers saw

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download