Review form



5380813060Review formTitle of the reviewed manuscriptClick to insert a titleOverall opinion (please mark a chosen answer by clicking on the left box below):?innovative and erudite, a valuable contribution to the field?distinguishing but not innovative?average?below average?unacceptable for publicationQuality of the manuscript?excellent?acceptable after minor corrections?acceptable after major corrections?acceptable, but has to be rewritten?unacceptable in its current form?unacceptableRequired revisions?formal (adjustment to the guidelines and journal’s scope)?linguistic (grammar, spelling, punctuation)?stylistic ?logical?methodological?meritorical?bibliographicalConclusion?I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication?I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication providing all the suggested revisions are considered?I recommend the reviewed manuscript for publication providing all the suggested revisions are considered and accepted by the reviewer?I advise against publication of the reviewed manuscript?I strongly advise dismissing the manuscriptText of the reviewClick to write a textReview dateClick and expand to select a dateReviewer’s signatureNotes ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download