CDW Paragraph Graphic Organizer



CDW Paragraph Graphic Organizer

ISSUE:____________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________.

[pic]

CLAIM:____________________________________________________________________________.

DATA #1

WARRANT 1A

WARRANT 1B

DATA #2

WARRANT 2A

WARRANT 2B

 

Claim - Data - Warrant: The Model for Analyzing Arguments

Rubric

 

|Claim |

|Element |Possible Points |

| | |

|The claim states your position on the issue you have chosen to write about. |6 |

|The claim is not obvious: Why bother proving a point nobody could disagree with? |6 |

|The claim is engaging. |8 |

|Consider your audience's attention span. | |

|Make claims which point out new ideas or a new way to think about something. | |

|Teach the reader something new. | |

|The claim is not too vague: The best claims are very specific. |6 |

|The claim includes the author and title of the work you are analyzing. |6 |

|The claim is debatable: Claims that are purely factual or only opinion fail this requirement. |8 |

|Data (at least 1 of the following for each piece of data) |Warrant | |

| |Data #1 |Data #2 | | |

|The evidence you cite to |Possible Points |Possible Points |Interprets the data and shows how it supports your claim.  |Possible Points |

|support your claim. | | | | |

|Quotes or examples from the text. |100 |100 |Explains how the example, statistic, quote or reference |100 |

|Facts or statistics | | |supports the claim | |

|Expert opinion | | | | |

|Personal anecdotes | | |Explains the significance of the data | |

| | | | | |

| | | |Usually three to five sentences long | |

Score Chart

| |Paragraph 1 |Paragraph 2 |Paragraph 3 |Paragraph 4 |Paragraph 5 |

|Claim | | | | | |

|Data | | | | | |

|Warrant | | | | | |

-----------------------

WARRANT 2B

WARRANT 2A

WARRANT 1B

WARRANT 1A

DATA #2

DATA #1

CLAIM

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download