Equivalent Technical Proposal DESIGN ...

Cycle 17

CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT EVALUATION SYSTEM CUMULATIVE REPORT

DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

ENVIRONMENTAL

STRUCTURAL EVALUATION

PLANNING

July '05~March '06; April~Sept '06 October '06~March '07; April~Sept '07

Equivalent Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points RATING FACTOR ALL DISCIPLINES Design Construction Inspection Environmental Structural Evaluation Planning

A. D. Marble & Company

NR

0

NR

0

4.32 0.98 121

NR

0

NR

0

0.98

Abbington Associates

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

5.00 1.10 140

NR

0

1.10

Advanced Infrastructure Design

4.36 0.97 122

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.97

Advantage Engineering

4.75 1.06 133

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.06

AmerCom Corporation

NR

0

4.34 0.98 122

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.98

Ammann & Whitney

Ammann & Whitney/ Maitra Joint Venture

Amy S. Greene Environmental

NR

0

3.89 0.88 109

NR

0

NR

0

4.22 0.96 118

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.35 0.99 122

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.88

NR

0

0.96

NR

0

0.99

Arora & Associates

4.44 0.99 124

NR

0

NR

0

4.81 1.06 135 3.93 0.92 110

0.99

ATC Associates, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

5.00 1.13 140

NR

0

NR

0

1.13

B & H Engineering, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.55 1.00 127

NR

0

1.00

BAE Systems

5.00 1.12 140

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.12

BEM Systems, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

4.60 1.04 129

NR

0

NR

0

1.04

BET Consultants

2.50 0.56

70

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.56

BioEngineering

NR

0

NR

0

4.20 0.95 118

NR

0

NR

0

0.95

Effective 2/19/2008 for TP 702 through TP ___ last revised 6/2/08 for name changes

Page 1 of 6

123

121

0

124

118

138

136

133

0

132

0

120

118

123

117

0

131

129

135

127

123

0

119

124

118

110

0

107

112

106

120

0

116

122

115

124

122

0

126

119

0

122

120

0

0

140

139

0

140

136

125

123

121

0

120

0

138

136

140

135

130

128

0

132

125

0

69

68

71

67

119

117

0

121

114

CES 17 rating report as of 9-24-08, Summary Prepared by Professional Services

Cycle 17

CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT EVALUATION SYSTEM CUMULATIVE REPORT

DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

ENVIRONMENTAL

STRUCTURAL EVALUATION

PLANNING

July '05~March '06; April~Sept '06 October '06~March '07; April~Sept '07

Equivalent Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points RATING FACTOR ALL DISCIPLINES Design Construction Inspection Environmental Structural Evaluation Planning

Booz-Allen & Hamilton

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.35 1.01 122

1.01

Buchart-Horn, Inc.

4.42 0.99 124

NR

0

4.50 1.02 126 4.90 1.08 137 4.18 0.97 117

1.02

Chas. H. Sells

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.75 1.05 133

NR

0

1.05

Cherry Weber & Associates

4.27 0.95 120 4.83 1.10 135

NR

0

4.93 1.09 138 4.71 1.10 132

1.06

Chilton Engineering

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

5.00 1.10 140

NR

0

1.10

Churchill Consulting

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.58 1.01 128

NR

0

1.01

CMX (Schoor DePalma)

4.62 1.03 129 4.29 0.97 120

NR

0

5.00 1.10 140

NR

0

1.04

Collins Engineers

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.80 1.06 134

NR

0

1.06

CV Associates

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

3.15 0.69

88

NR

0

0.69

Dewberry & Goodkind, Inc.

4.56 1.02 128 4.43 1.00 124 3.88 0.88 109

NR

0

4.44 1.03 124

0.98

DMJM Harris, Inc.

4.87 1.09 136 4.56 1.03 128

NR

0

NR

0

4.28 1.00 120

1.04

Dresdner Robin Environmental

NR

0

NR

0

4.47 1.01 125

NR

0

NR

0

1.01

Earth Tech, Inc.

4.49 1.00 126

NR

0

3.50 0.79

98

5.00 1.10 140

NR

0

0.97

Fay Spoffard & Thorndike

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

3.80 0.84 106

NR

0

0.84

Figg Bridge Engineers

NR

0

4.73 1.07 132

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.07

French & Parrello, Inc.

4.74 1.06 133

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.06

Effective 2/19/2008 for TP 702 through TP ___ last revised 6/2/08 for name changes

Page 2 of 6

127

125

123

128

0

0

126

0

0

0

132

130

127

0

126

0

0

129

0

0

138

136

133

0

132

127

125

123

0

121

0

0

126

0

125

133

131

129

0

127

87

85

84

0

83

0

0

0

124

0

0

0

126

132

0

127

125

0

128

121

0

120

0

0

117

105

104

102

0

101

134

0

130

136

129

0

131

129

135

127

CES 17 rating report as of 9-24-08, Summary Prepared by Professional Services

Cycle 17

CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT EVALUATION SYSTEM CUMULATIVE REPORT

DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

ENVIRONMENTAL

STRUCTURAL EVALUATION

PLANNING

July '05~March '06; April~Sept '06 October '06~March '07; April~Sept '07

Equivalent Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points RATING FACTOR ALL DISCIPLINES Design Construction Inspection Environmental Structural Evaluation Planning

Gannett Fleming, Inc.

4.80 1.07 134 4.23 0.96 118

NR

0

3.70 0.82 104 4.53 1.06 127

0.98

GEOD Corporation

3.39 0.76

95

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.76

Gibson Associates

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.70 1.04 132

NR

0

1.04

Greenman-Pedersen, Inc.

4.73 1.06 132 4.40 1.00 123

NR

0

4.64 1.02 130 4.56 1.06 128

1.03

HAKS Engineers

NR

0

3.83 0.87 107

NR

0

4.80 1.06 134

NR

0

0.96

Hardesty & Hanover

4.75 1.06 133

NR

0

NR

0

4.13 0.91 116

NR

0

0.99

Harold Pellow & Associates, Inc.

4.09 0.91 115

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.91

Hatch Mott McDonald, Inc.

4.73 1.06 132

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.06

HNTB Corporation

4.45 0.99 125 4.07 0.92 114

NR

0

4.95 1.09 139 4.00 0.93 112

0.98

Hunter Research, Inc.

4.93 1.10 138

NR

0

4.45 1.01 125

NR

0

NR

0

1.05

IH Engineers

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.81 1.06 135

NR

0

1.06

Jacobs Engineering Group, Inc.

4.67 1.04 131 4.84 1.10 136

NR

0

NR

0

4.26 0.99 119

1.04

Jenny Engineering

3.90 0.87 109

NR

0

NR

0

4.70 1.04 132

NR

0

0.95

Kise Straw & Kolodner

NR

0

NR

0

4.58 1.04 128

NR

0

NR

0

1.04

KMA Consulting

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

3.80 0.84 106

NR

0

0.84

KS Engineers

NR

0

4.57 1.04 128

NR

0

4.68 1.03 131

NR

0

1.03

Effective 2/19/2008 for TP 702 through TP ___ last revised 6/2/08 for name changes

Page 3 of 6

0

0

119

0

0

0

94

92

97

91

130

128

126

0

125

0

0

125

0

0

120

0

116

0

115

0

122

120

0

119

0

112

110

116

109

0

131

129

135

127

0

0

119

0

0

0

130

0

133

126

133

131

129

0

127

0

0

126

132

0

0

117

115

0

114

130

128

0

132

125

105

104

102

0

101

129

0

125

0

124

CES 17 rating report as of 9-24-08, Summary Prepared by Professional Services

Cycle 17

CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT EVALUATION SYSTEM CUMULATIVE REPORT

DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

ENVIRONMENTAL

STRUCTURAL EVALUATION

PLANNING

July '05~March '06; April~Sept '06 October '06~March '07; April~Sept '07

Equivalent Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points RATING FACTOR ALL DISCIPLINES Design Construction Inspection Environmental Structural Evaluation Planning

Kupper Associates

NR

0

4.41 1.00 123

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.00

L. Robert Kimball Associates, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

4.66 1.06 130

NR

0

NR

0

1.06

Lord Worrell & Richert

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

3.20 0.71

90

NR

0

0.71

Louis Berger Group, Inc.

4.67 1.04 131

NR

0

4.41 1.00 123 5.00 1.10 140 4.32 1.01 121

1.04

Maguire Group

4.14 0.92 116

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.92

Maitra

NR

0

4.45 1.01 125

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.01

McCormick Taylor, Inc.

4.56 1.02 128

NR

0

NR

0

4.75 1.05 133 4.41 1.03 123

1.03

Medina Consultants

4.60 1.03 129

NR

0

NR

0

4.50 0.99 126

NR

0

1.01

Michael Baker Jr., Inc.

4.68 1.04 131

NR

0

3.52 0.80

99

4.60 1.01 129 4.56 1.06 128

0.98

Modjeski & Masters, Inc.

4.79 1.07 134

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.07

Orth Rodgers & Associates, Inc.

4.01 0.89 112

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.56 1.06 128

0.98

Parsons Transportation Group

4.64 1.04 130

NR

0

NR

0

4.28 0.94 120 3.87 0.90 108

0.96

Paul Carpenter & Associates

NR

0

NR

0

4.74 1.08 133

NR

0

NR

0

1.08

PB Americas, Inc.

4.63 1.03 130

NR

0

NR

0

4.88 1.08 137 4.05 0.94 113

1.02

Pickering Corts & Summerson, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.84 1.07 136

NR

0

1.07

Polytran Engineering Associates

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.27 0.94 120

NR

0

0.94

Effective 2/19/2008 for TP 702 through TP ___ last revised 6/2/08 for name changes

Page 4 of 6

125

0

121

127

120

133

131

0

135

127

89

88

86

0

85

0

128

0

0

0

0

114

112

117

111

127

0

123

128

121

0

127

125

0

0

0

125

123

0

121

0

121

0

0

0

0

132

130

136

129

0

121

119

124

0

0

118

116

0

0

136

133

0

137

130

0

126

124

0

0

134

132

130

0

129

118

116

114

0

113

CES 17 rating report as of 9-24-08, Summary Prepared by Professional Services

Cycle 17

CONSULTANT

CONSULTANT EVALUATION SYSTEM CUMULATIVE REPORT

DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION

ENVIRONMENTAL

STRUCTURAL EVALUATION

PLANNING

July '05~March '06; April~Sept '06 October '06~March '07; April~Sept '07

Equivalent Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points

Discipline Rating Average

Discipline Rating Factor

Technical Proposal Rating Points RATING FACTOR ALL DISCIPLINES Design Construction Inspection Environmental Structural Evaluation Planning

QBS International, Inc.

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.56 1.01 128

NR

0

1.01

127

125

123

0

121

RBA Group

4.44 0.99 124

NR

0

4.23 0.96 118

NR

0

4.54 1.06 127

1.00

0

123

0

127

0

S & R Engineers, PC

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.98 1.10 139

NR

0

1.10

138

136

133

0

132

So-Deep, Inc.

4.55 1.02 127

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.02

0

126

124

130

123

Stantec Consulting, Inc.

4.73 1.06 132

NR

0

NR

0

4.77 1.05 134 4.07 0.95 114

1.02

0

126

124

0

0

STV, Inc.

4.50 1.00 126 4.73 1.07 132

NR

0

4.70 1.04 132

NR

0

1.04

0

0

126

0

125

T & M Associates

4.60 1.03 129

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.03

0

127

125

131

124

Taylor Wiseman & Taylor

4.51 1.01 126

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

1.01

0

125

123

128

121

TranSystem (Lichtenstein)

4.45 0.99 125

NR

0

NR

0

4.85 1.07 136

NR

0

1.03

0

127

125

0

124

TRC Engineers, Inc. (Site-Blauvelt)

4.33 0.97 121 4.24 0.96 119

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

0.96

0

0

116

122

115

Urban Engineers, Inc.

4.65 1.04 130 4.70 1.07 132

NR

0

3.50 0.77

98

4.38 1.02 123

0.97

0

0

118

0

0

Urbitran Associates, Inc.

4.27 0.95 120

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.25 0.99 119

0.97

0

120

118

123

0

URS Corporation

5.00 1.12 140

NR

0

4.25 0.96 119

NR

0

3.90 0.91 109

1.00

0

123

0

127

0

Wilbur Smith & Associates

NR

0

NR

0

NR

0

4.00 0.88 112

NR

0

0.88

110

109

107

0

106

firms per discipline 42

19

17

39

21

Effective 2/19/2008 for TP 702 through TP ___ last revised 6/2/08 for name changes

Page 5 of 6

CES 17 rating report as of 9-24-08, Summary Prepared by Professional Services

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download