THE CASE AGAINST IMMIGRATION - NumbersUSA

[Pages:362]THE

CASE AGAINST IMMIGRATION

The moral, economic, social, and environmental reasons for reducing U.S. immigration back to

traditional levels _____________________________________________

ROY BECK

CLICK "BOOKMARKS" ON LEFT SIDE OF PAGE TO VIEW BOOK BY CHAPTERS

Copyright ? 1996 by Roy Beck All rights reserved

Printed in the United States of America First Edition

For information about permission to reproduce selections from this book, write to Permissions, W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 500 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10110.

The text of this book is composed in Galliard with the display set in Helvetica Condensed and Tea Chest Composition and manufacturing by the Haddon Craftsmen, Inc.

Book design by Jacques Chazaud

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Beck, Roy Howard.

The case against immigration / Roy Beck. p. cm.

Includes index. ISBN 0-393-03915-3 1. United States-Emigration and immigration-Economic aspects. 2. United States-Emigration and immigration-Social aspects. 3. Alien labor-United States. 4. Afro-Americans-Employment.

I. Title. JV6471.B43 1996 330.973-dc20 95-51128 W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., 500 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10110 W. W. Norton & Company Ltd., 10 Coptic Street, London WC1A 1PU

2

To Warren the milkman, Freda the homemaker and secretary,

and an era of respect for the American worker

3

______________________________________________________________________

CLICK "BOOKMARKS" ON

LEFT SIDE OF PAGE TO VIEW BOOK BY CHAPTERS

Contents

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

PREFACE 6

1. A Nation of (Too Many) Immigrants?

11

2. Learning from the Great Wave

46

3. How Many Refugees?

69

4. Engineering a Disaster

91

5. Shooting the Middle Class

103

6. Jobs Americans Will Do

141

7. Foreign Skills We Don't Need

192

8. On the Backs of Black Americans: The Past

222

9. On the Backs of Black Americans: The Present

248

10. The High Cost of Cheap Labor

286

Conclusion: Picking the Right Number

341

4

CONTENTS Acknowledgments 362 Charts follow page 19

5

Preface

During annual summer treks leading high school students in building houses for the poor, I gradually came to see what became some of the central themes of this book.

In the part of the country where we work, most of the people who qualify for the houses are black Americans with full-time jobs. A steady income is necessary because housing recipients must make monthly payments to Habitat for Humanity for the cost of materials used in building their small, simple houses. But without the free labor provided by volunteers and the interest-free loans provided by Habitat, these American workers' wages are inadequate to secure a 900square-foot home that meets modern codes. The Habitat efforts are able to help but a tiny percentage of those in need; many of the masses who continue to live in substandard housing do not even have indoor bathrooms. That Americans who seem to play by the rules and work hard would have to live in such conditions, or rely on our charitable assistance to have decent housing, strikes many of the teenage volunteers as unjust.

Questioning the reason for the inadequate wages is a part of the religious tradition of the youths' sponsoring church. The tradition holds that charity is an insufficient response to need if the cause of the need is an unjust system that could reasonably be corrected. I looked further for causes of the low wages. I found that nearly every job these Americans have is in an industry into which Washington brings thousands of additional foreign workers each year through its immigration policies. There are many factors in the poor housing and job conditions of the area where we work, but the federal government inexplicably makes matters worse by running an immigration program that intensifies the job competition for these low-income

6

Americans. Not surprisingly their already low real wages have been flat or declining during the last two decades of radically increased national immigration.

Additional research revealed that a person could step into local communities and neighborhoods all across America and find similar circumstances, not just for the poor and unemployed but even for middle-class professionals thrown into decline by immigration competition. The evidence leads to a disconcerting conclusion: The federal government's current immigration program primarily benefits a small minority of wealthy and powerful Americans at the expense of significant segments of the middle class and the poor. Attempts to protect the current level of immigration by wrapping it in the language of tradition or humanitarianism generally distort both history and the practical realities of our own era while diverting attention from immigration's role as a tool against the interests of the broad public.

This book primarily addresses that theme. It is not about future immigrants' personal attributes, their intelligence, character, race, and nationality; the focus instead is on the effects of quadrupling the annual number of immigrants over traditional levels. The book is not about illegal immigration, despite the importance of reducing it; the focus is on legal immigration, because it produces more than three quarters of the numbers and is the simplest to change legislatively.

The battle to greatly reduce illegal immigration will be a long and complex one. One of the major tools in cutting illegal migration, however, is to reduce legal immigration. The relatives and fellow villagers from the home country who come as legal immigrants are essential for many illegal aliens in providing shelter from detection and in helping them to enter the labor market. It is also those legal immigrants who send back letters and gifts that entice more people to leave their Third World villages and urban neighborhoods to enter the United States, often illegally. The number of illegal aliens has proliferated over the last three

7

decades as the United States has allowed larger and larger numbers of people to enter legally. A drastic reduction in legal immigration over time will significantly reduce the opportunities for both illegal U.S. entry and for illegally overstaying temporary tourist, student, and work visas.

While the number of immigrants-not their attributes-is the main factor of immigration that causes many U.S. problems, it is the only factor of real significance in terms of environmental concerns. I originally turned my journalistic attention to the immigration issue and moved into full-time study, research, and writing about it in 1991 because of my interest in America's environmental resources. Beginning as a newspaper reporter in the 1960s, I had written on the emergence of the modern environmental era and the giant strides toward restoring environmental health during the 1970s. But by the 1980s, progress had substantially stalled. For every several steps forward in overall environmental quality because of reductions in each American's negative impact, the addition of millions more residents drove environmental results several steps backward. I discovered that immigration, a topic to which I'd given little thought, had become a central environmental issue that I could no longer avoid.

Unfortunately, to write about problems of immigration is to risk seeming to attack immigrants themselves. Even worse is the risk of inadvertently encouraging somebody else to show hostility toward the foreign-born.

I encounter too many immigrants and children of immigrants in daily affairs where I live in northern Virginia to take those risks lightly. From five continents, members of immigrant families pass through my home, especially in the persons of friends of my two teenage sons. They are among the physical therapy patients of my wife; they are participants in youth activities which I lead; they are friends at my church, which has received national recognition

8

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download