PDF Students Under Stress

[Pages:24]CQResearcher

Published by CQ Press, a division of Congressional Quarterly Inc.

Students Under Stress

Do schools assign too much homework?

T he average homework load for first- through thirdgraders has doubled over the past two decades, even though research shows homework doesn't benefit such young children. Indeed, some schools require preschoolers to tackle academic subjects like reading and writing. In response a parents' movement has arisen -- mainly in middle- and upper-income suburbs -- protesting excessive homework and other forms of academic pressure, including so-called high-stakes testing. Parents say the added pressure robs children of needed play and family time and can cause stress, sleep deprivation, depression and family strife. Some schools have responded by limiting homework for the youngest children and downplaying stress-causing programs, such as academic honor rolls. At the same time, however, U.S. high school students spend less time in class than students in most other countries, and their homework loads remain far below the two hours per day that research shows is optimal for college-bound students.

CQ Researcher ? July 13, 2007 ? Volume 17, Number 25 ? Pages 577-600

RECIPIENT OF SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISTS AWARD FOR EXCELLENCE AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION SILVER GAVEL AWARD

Six-year-old Aisha Jones does her homework in Bolingbrook, Ill. A growing number of parents oppose

the trend toward homework for young children.

I N

THIS

REPORT

S THE ISSUES ......................579 I BACKGROUND ..................586 D CHRONOLOGY ..................587 E

AT ISSUE ..........................593

CURRENT SITUATION ..........594

OUTLOOK ........................595

BIBLIOGRAPHY ..................598

THE NEXT STEP ................599

STUDENTS UNDER STRESS

CQ Researcher

THE ISSUES

581

579 ? Are students today under more academic pressure?

? Are schools assigning

too much homework? ? Do high-stakes tests

582

cause too much pressure?

BACKGROUND

583

586 Schooling Expands

584 Education is seen as the

path to success.

588 585 Different Visions Best learning practices for students are debatable.

589 587 Cold War Fears Competition with the Soviet Union sparks homework.

590 Bulging Backpacks?

588

Homework has increased

since the Reagan era.

590

CURRENT SITUATION

594 Reevaluating Homework

Schools are questioning

591

the value of homework.

594 Testing the Tests Some say the No Child Left Behind law breeds

593

stress.

OUTLOOK

595 Learning to Teach Schools face pressure to

597

teach more.

598

SIDEBARS AND GRAPHICS

599

580

Should Students Be Pushed

Harder? Many parents think so.

599

Cover: AP Photo/Stacie Freudenberg

Students Do More Socializing Than Studying At least half spend over six hours a week with friends.

Low-Income Kids Face Most Pressure in Class A family atmosphere helps.

School Is Top Cause of Stress Many blame homework.

Parents Say Children Get Enough Free Time Less than a fifth say they don't.

Few Homework Complaints Parents and students say the right amount is assigned.

Chronology Key events since 1890.

Foreign Middle-Schoolers Do More Homework Workload is twice U.S. average.

Tailoring Teaching to Fit the Brain Neuroscience overcomes cognitive difficulties.

How Cognitive Science Helps Educators Research findings are not well understood.

At Issue Do American students get too much homework?

FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

For More Information Organizations to contact.

Bibliography Selected sources used.

The Next Step Additional articles.

Citing CQ Researcher Sample bibliography formats.

July 13, 2007 Volume 17, Number 25

MANAGING EDITOR: Thomas J. Colin tcolin@

ASSISTANT MANAGING EDITOR: Kathy Koch kkoch@

ASSOCIATE EDITOR: Kenneth Jost STAFF WRITERS: Marcia Clemmitt, Peter Katel

CONTRIBUTING WRITERS: Rachel S. Cox, Sarah Glazer, Alan Greenblatt, Barbara Mantel, Patrick Marshall, Tom Price, Jennifer Weeks

DESIGN/PRODUCTION EDITOR: Olu B. Davis ASSISTANT EDITOR: Darrell Dela Rosa EDITORIAL INTERN: Paul Elliott

A Division of Congressional Quarterly Inc.

SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT/PUBLISHER: John A. Jenkins

DIRECTOR, EDITORIAL OPERATIONS: Ann Davies

CONGRESSIONAL QUARTERLY INC. CHAIRMAN: Paul C. Tash

VICE CHAIRMAN: Andrew P. Corty PRESIDENT/EDITOR IN CHIEF: Robert W. Merry

Copyright ? 2007 CQ Press, a division of Congressional Quarterly Inc. (CQ). CQ reserves all copyright and other rights herein, unless previously specified in writing. No part of this publication may be reproduced electronically or otherwise, without prior written permission. Unauthorized reproduction or transmission of CQ copyrighted material is a violation of federal law carrying civil fines of up to $100,000.

CQ Researcher (ISSN 1056-2036) is printed on acidfree paper. Published weekly, except March 23, June 29, July 6, Aug. 10, Aug. 17, Nov. 23, Dec. 21 and Dec. 28, by CQ Press, a division of Congressional Quarterly Inc. Annual full-service subscriptions for institutions start at $667. For pricing, call 1-800-8349020, ext. 1906. To purchase a CQ Researcher report in print or electronic format (PDF), visit or call 866-427-7737. Single reports start at $15. Bulk purchase discounts and electronicrights licensing are also available. Periodicals postage paid at Washington, D.C., and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to CQ Researcher, 1255 22nd St., N.W., Suite 400, Washington, DC 20037.

578 CQ Researcher

Students Under Stress

BY MARCIA CLEMMITT

THE ISSUES

W hen Nancy Kalish's daughter was in seventh grade,

may be seeping down to students in such schools, some researchers say.

Piles of homework dim children's love of learning -- while depriving them of vital

she suddenly began saying,

free time -- without im-

"I hate school," recalls Kalish,

proving their school achieve-

a journalist in New York City.

ment, says Kalish's coauthor,

"She started saying it every

Sara Bennett, a New York City

single day."

lawyer.

Getty Images/David Young-Wolff

Kalish soon discovered

"Polls say that kids no longer

that what had been "a rea-

read for pleasure after age 8,"

sonable amount" of home-

mainly because of too much

work for Allison in grade

homework, "and I didn't like

school "had mushroomed into

the future I was seeing for

four hours a night" in middle

my children," says Bennett,

school."

who organized parents to fight

Soon, "our entire rela-

homework at her children's

tionship revolved around

schools. Many teachers argue

homework," with "the first

that homework "is reinforce-

question when she came in To reduce stress on students, a number of high schools

ment" of what's studied in

the door each afternoon, around the country are reducing homework and other

class, "but there's no evidence

`How much homework do you have?' " says Kalish. The answer determined whether Allison would see friends, at-

sources of stress that can cause depression, anxiety and family strife. Over the past two decades, high school homework loads have not increased, while first-, second- and third-graders have been getting more.

that it helps younger children," she says.

After a years-long struggle, the parents Bennett or-

tend a concert or a grandparent's birth- dren, however, even though it's U.S. ganized won a new homework poli-

day party or stay home studying.

high-schoolers who score lowest on cy that limited tests to two per week,

The resulting family tension and international achievement tests.

declared Monday test-free and banned

their daughter's newfound anger to- But high school homework loads school projects over certain vacations.

ward school turned Kalish and her haven't increased, while first-, second- A number of schools around the

husband -- once "true believers" in and third-graders have been getting country are mulling similar moves.

the value of homework -- into ac- more homework, even though data In Massachusetts, for example,

tivists who sought a school policy lim- show homework doesn't improve learn- Needham High School Principal Paul

iting homework at Allison's school. ing for young children. And with con- Richards sought to limit stress after three

With a coauthor, Kalish wrote the 2006 gressionally mandated standardized student suicides in recent years. Richards

book The Case Against Homework. testing also aimed mainly at elemen- urges teachers not to give homework

Kalish is part of a new wave of tary school students, some schools over school vacations and to be more

parents, many in middle- and upper- also are pressuring kindergarten and flexible about assignment deadlines. He

income communities, protesting what preschool teachers to teach academic also ended the tradition of publishing

they say is too much homework -- subjects to 4- and 5-year-olds, who the school's academic honor roll in the

particularly in elementary and middle often lack the physical and cognitive local newspaper, which made him the

school -- causing stress, sleep depri- skills to handle them.

butt of jokes and criticism from "Tonight"

vation, depression and family strife.

Meanwhile, under the 2002 No Child host comedian Jay Leno and conserv-

Over the last two decades, worries Left Behind law, teachers -- especially ative commentator Rush Limbaugh.

about global competition have prompt- in high-poverty schools -- fear they'll But Richards has stood firm, saying

ed U.S. business leaders and lawmakers be unable to bring their students to that critics don't understand the amount

to increase pressure on schools to mandated achievement levels, which of stress his college-bound students feel,

raise achievement. Most of that pres- could lead to firings and school even as they try to act cool. For exam-

sure has fallen on the youngest chil- takeovers. That pressure on teachers ple, "there are perceptions that Boston

Available online:

July 13, 2007

579

STUDENTS UNDER STRESS

Should Students Be Pushed Harder?

More than half of U.S. adults say parents are not pushing their children hard enough in school. Only 15 percent think students are under too much pressure.

No opinion

How much pressure are parents putting on students?

5%

Right amount

24%

Too little

56%

Too much

15%

Source: Richard Wike and Juliana Menasce Horowitz, "Parental Pressure on Students: Not Enough in America; Too Much in Asia," Pew Research Center, Aug. 24, 2006

College only takes two seniors from each high school," said Richards. "Students hear this and start ranking each other," adding more pressure to an already "product-oriented and competitive" culture that's "gone into overdrive." 1

Education researchers who study student workloads say that such highpressure situations may be more the exception than the rule, however.

"Most of what you hear" about excessive homework "is anecdotal," says Tom Loveless, director of the Brown Center on Education Policy at the Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank. "You have a group of kids who take tons of Advanced Placement (AP) classes and have lots of extracurricular activities" who experience a major school-related time crunch, he says. "But they're not numerous."

Overall, "all the data show that homework is not increasing," says Loveless. Currently 30 to 40 percent of U.S. students say that they have zero homework. Furthermore, a survey of college freshmen that's been repeated since the 1960s shows that high school

homework reported by those students "is hitting all-time lows," about five hours per week -- less than an hour per night, Loveless says.

Nevertheless, "I wouldn't want to trivialize the part of the population that's saying there's an overload," says Harris M. Cooper, director of Duke University's Program in Education. "It's unusual but not unheard of to find a teacher who's piling it on."

Especially in schools where many parents are professionals, some students voluntarily take on heavy homework burdens as they seek a competitive academic edge, says Cooper.

"There's lots of pressure to get into the best universities, and this has led some kids to take the most challenging courses they can," he says. "If you find a student with two AP courses and two honors courses, then each of those will be 45 minutes of homework a night" -- three hours overall, more than the usually suggested maximum for high school of two hours a night, says Cooper. "Non-elite courses would only assign about 30 minutes a night each," he says.

Researchers agree that, to the extent homework burdens have increased in the past 20 years, it's the school backpacks of the youngest kids that have gained the most weight.

From 1997 to 2002, for example, the proportion of 6-to-8-year-old children being assigned homework on any given day rose from 34 percent to 64 percent. 2

The increase has occurred even though reviews of research on homework by Cooper and others have turned up no evidence that homework actually improves achievement for children of that age.

"In my professional opinion, these trends suggest that the emphasis in the United States is kind of backwards," says Gerald LeTendre, a professor of education at Pennsylvania State University.

Some school critics also say that new high-stakes testing mandated by some states and by the federal government over the past decade has increased pressure on teachers, whose anxiety often spills over onto students.

"We have a lot of discouraged teachers," especially in low-income schools, from standardized tests coupled with insufficient resources, says David C. Berliner, a professor of education at Arizona State University. "Schools of education aren't perfect," he acknowledges. "But it's bad when the students come back and say, `This is not why I became a teacher.' They end up being drill sergeants."

Test pressure is increasing homework pressure in some schools, says Wendy A. Patterson, an associate professor of education at Buffalo State College, in New York. As "the curriculum becomes more loaded with requirements, such as expanded literacy classes" -- extra reading-skills classes that have been added to improve test scores -- "teachers get to the end of the day with material left, so they send it home" as homework, Patterson says. Such assignments, originally scheduled as in-class work, are usually "bad

580 CQ Researcher

homework" -- work that children should be doing with the teacher present and can't be expected to complete on their own -- she says.

As parents and teachers debate the proper role of homework, testing and competition in American schools, here are some questions that are being asked:

Are students today under more

academic pressure than in past

generations? With businesses and state and fed-

eral governments looking more to schools to produce savvier workers and entrepreneurs, some parents say today's kids face unprecedented schoolrelated stress beginning as early as kindergarten. Critics of that view, however, point to data showing that many students, especially high-schoolers, may actually spend less time on schoolwork than in the past.

While some students probably are working harder these days, "about 90 percent aren't under much pressure," says Laurence Steinberg, a professor of psychology at Philadelphia's Temple University and author of one of the most extensive nationwide surveys ever done of U.S. teens. "A very high percentage of kids in our sample say they do as little as they can without getting into trouble," he says.

"Compared to high school kids in Japan or Korea, for example, our kids are coasting through a dream," says Steinberg. The difference shows up on international achievement tests. American elementary school students score well on tests, but by middle school U.S. scores begin to fall, and on the high school tests "we've fallen off the charts. If we were really making such great demands, this wouldn't be happening."

More information exists for today's children to absorb, but that isn't translating into excess academic pressure, said Lynn Spampinato, deputy superintendent of the Pittsburgh Public Schools. "There's more for children to learn today, more exposure to all

Students Do More Socializing Than Studying

A far higher percentage of high school students spend at least six hours per week on non-homework activities, such as socializing with friends, playing sports and surfing the Internet, rather than on homework or studying.

No. of Hours High School Students Spend on Various Activities in a Typical 7-Day Week

Activity

Written homework Reading/studying for class Reading for self Participating in schoolsponsored activities Practicing a sport or musical instrument Working for pay Volunteer work Exercising Watching TV/playing video games Surfing/chatting online Talking on the phone Socializing with friends outside of school

0 7% 12% 16% 32%

30%

34% 48%

8% 6%

21% 8% 4%

Number of Hours

1 or fewer 2-5

6-10

36%

40% 12%

43%

35%

7%

40%

30%

9%

17%

21% 13%

12%

23% 16%

13% 30% 22% 24%

18% 16% 36% 39%

13% 3%

18% 18%

27% 32% 10%

30% 32% 32%

14% 15% 27%

10+ 5% 2% 5% 17%

19%

21% 2%

15% 13%

9% 13% 27%

* Percentages may not total 100 due to rounding.

Source: Ethan Yazzie-Mintz, "Voices of Students on Engagement: A Report on the 2006 High School Survey of Student Engagement," Center for Evaluation & Education Policy, Indiana University, Bloomington, 2006

kinds of information at younger ages." Nevertheless, "I'm not sure I believe we're pushing children to the edge. I'd say in many cases we're not challenging them enough." 3

Education trends, such as a heavy focus on children's learning differences and "discovery" learning in which children follow their own interests, are making many classrooms less challenging, according to some analysts.

Learning "inevitably requires very substantial commitments of student time

and effort," but contemporary trends require teachers "to produce learning in ways that are stimulating yet minimally obtrusive," with "only minimal levels of exertion" from students, said J. E. Stone, a professor of educational psychology at East Tennessee State University in Johnson City. 4

Today's education mindset puts the whole burden on teachers to entice students to learn and to avoid boring or pushing them, a far cry from creating excessive stress, Stone says.

Available online:

July 13, 2007

581

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download