International Journal of - iRE-Asia



International Journal of

Engineering Innovation and Management

Review Report (No. )

|Author(s): |

|Title of Paper: |

|Decision (check the appropriate box): |

| |Accept as is |

| |Accept with minor revisions |

| |Accept with major revisions (re-review) |

| |Reject but encourage re-submission after the work is more developed |

| |Reject |

| |

|Criteria (check the appropriate box): |Yes |No |

|1. Is the subject matter suitable for this journal? | | |

|2. Is the paper original and up-to-date? | | |

|3. Is the paper described accurately? | | |

|4. Is it clearly presented? | | |

|5. Are there sufficient references to related work? | | |

|6. Can the paper be shortened? | | |

|7. Are the figures & tables adequate? | | |

|8. Are the results interpreted correctly? | | |

|9. Is the abstract a good summary of the paper? | | |

|10. Are the conclusions justified? | | |

Reviewer’s Comments and Suggestions to Author(s):

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download