DOTD Consultant Rating Tier I Rankings 44-17438 Firm Name ...

DOTD Consultant Rating Tier I Rankings 44-17438

Firm Name AECOM Technical Services, Inc. Atlas Technical Consultants, L.L.C. Michael Baker International, Inc. Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. Volkert, Inc.

Rating * * *

63.33 62.58

Rank * * * 4 5

* The top three (3) rated firms are listed in alphabetical order. The ratings for these firms range from 74.71 to 65.23.

DOTD Consultant Rating Calculations for Tier I for Contract Number(s):

Project Magnitude:

Mega

Work Type(s):

44-17438 EV,TM,BDS,RX,CM

Firm Name

***AECOM Technical Services, Inc. Arcadis U.S., Inc. Ardaman & Associates, Inc. CDM Smith, Inc. Gulf South Research Corporation Locus, L.L.C. Marmillion Gray Media, Inc. SJB Group, L.L.C.

Prime or Sub

Prime sub sub sub sub sub sub sub

Firm Size Designation

Percent of Work

Remaining Work $1,000

Past Performance

7

Firm

Staff Firm

Experience Experience Size

4

5

1

Work Load

2

Total Rating (Including Subs)

***Atlas Technical Consultants, L.L.C. Providence Engineering & Design, L.L.C. Neel-Schaffer, Inc. CDM Smith, Inc. Figg Bridge Engineers, Inc. Shread-Kuyrkendall & Associates, Inc. GOTECH, Inc. GIS Engineering, L.L.C. Quality Engineering & Surveying, L.L.C. Franklin Associates, L.L.C. Armeni Consulting Services, L.L.C.

Prime sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub

***Michael Baker International, Inc. CSRS, Inc. COWI North America, Inc. Moffatt & Nichol, Inc. CDM Smith, Inc. Vectura Consulting Services, L.L.C. Gulf South Research Corporation GeoEngineers, Inc. Civil Design & Construction, Inc. Anastasia Brenan Communications Group, L.L.C.

Prime sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub

Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. HNTB Corporation CH Fenstermaker & Associates, L.L.C. Vectura Consulting Services, L.L.C. Rannah (Marmillion) Gray Communications Coastal Environments, Inc. ELOS Environmental, L.L.C. Ardaman & Associates, Inc. Emergent Method, L.L.C. Forte & Tablada, Inc. The Seamen's Church Institute James A. Richardson

Prime sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub

Large Large Large Micro Micro Small Small Medium Micro Medium Micro Micro

40.0

3,667

3.65

3.14

31.4

6,913

3.53 * 3.22

5.1

561

4.00

3.14

4.0

63

**

* 3.32

4.0

0

**

* 3.18

3.0

173

**

3.60

3.0

67

**

2.90

2.5

1,016

**

3.46

2.5

0

**

* 2.94

2.0

2,631

**

3.52

1.5

0

**

* 3.86

1.0

0

**

* 3.04

team scores by criteria 3.62

3.20

3.26

3 2.96

3.32

3 1.00

3.04

3 4.85

3.52

3 4.89

3.18

3 5.00

3.58

3 4.90

2.98

3 5.00

3.70

3 4.18

3.04

3 5.00

3.54

3 2.53

3.84

3 5.00

3.34

3 5.00

3.30

3 2.84

Volkert, Inc. Alliance Transportation Group, Inc. T.Y. Lin International GIS Engineering, L.L.C. R. Christopher Goodwin & Associates, Inc. Eustis Engineering, L.L.C. Arup USA, Inc. T. Baker Smith, L.L.C. Manchac Consulting Group, Inc.

Prime sub sub sub sub sub sub sub sub

Mega Mega Large Small Small Medium Mega Medium Medium

54.2

8,314

3.26 * 3.46

22.5

1,069

3.00 * 2.88

15.0

57

1.80

3.70

3.5

92

**

* 2.16

2.1

0

**

* 2.94

1.0

62

**

* 3.48

0.7

0

**

* 3.08

0.5

640

**

3.86

0.5

0

**

* 2.52

team scores by criteria 2.96

3.30

3.20

5 2.40

3.30

5 4.82

3.86

5 5.00

2.66

5 5.00

3.18

5 5.00

3.50

5 5.00

3.42

5 5.00

3.68

5 4.56

3.14

5 5.00

3.31

5 3.55

* indicates the average past performance was assigned for at least one Work Category.

** sub-consultant past performance was neutralized since doing 5% or less of the work.

Note: sub-consultants receive the same Firm Size score as the prime consultant for the same proposal.

Note: the scores which are shown to two decimal places in this table have not been rounded. The numbers are shown to two decimal places for convenience so the table can be printed on 8 1/2" x 11" paper. The actual values may vary by as much as +/- 0.005.

*** Proceeding to the Tier II Evaluation

63.33 62.58

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download