Off the Map



Off the Map | |

|Mark Anstice, Saturday December 23, 2006, Guardian |

|[pic] |

|Imagine going on an expedition deep into the jungle to find one of the last hidden tribes left on the planet and make "first contact" with them. A holiday to |

|quicken the pulse - and not just among extreme sports desperados? What's on offer is a chance to go back a hundred years to the time when the world's powers |

|were racing to fill in the blanks on the maps. For just a month and £3,000 you could don the khakis and discover a tribe that has never before set eyes on an |

|outsider. You might even be shot at by bushmen with bows and arrows. |

|This is the experience offered by Kelly Woolford, a 43-year-old former tennis coach from Wisconsin who runs an adventure travel outfit based in Bali. He |

|specialises in trekking trips to West Papua, the most eastern province of Indonesia, a rugged land of swamp, jungle and mountain. Access to the interior must |

|be made either by boat, up one of the many rivers snaking north and south from the mountainous spine of the island, or via chartered light aircraft and a short|

|landing strip hacked from the jungle. |

|There has been tourism in West Papua for many years but few have ventured beyond a few well-trodden destinations. Much of the province has only been |

|air-surveyed and with good reason - away from the navigable rivers, travel can be slow and arduous, the way forward barred by torrents and treacherously steep,|

|overgrown terrain. |

|Woolford runs all the usual tours but his "first contact" expeditions are the real draw. He promises encounters with "truly 'stone-age' tribes ... people who |

|have never experienced anything from our modern world". It seems incredible. On a planet populated by six billion, where traditional tribes are being pushed to|

|the brink of extinction, can there really still be undiscovered peoples? Yet it's not such a fantastic claim. Survival International, a UK-based charity |

|working to protect the rights of indigenous peoples, reckons New Guinea "has the largest number of un-contacted peoples outside Brazil". |

|Most anthropologists are sceptical, citing the improbability of an entire tribe somehow escaping the scrutiny of the thousands of explorers, soldiers, |

|missionaries and prospectors who have crisscrossed the island for the past 150 years. Queasy at Woolford's human safaris, they point to the arrogance inherent |

|in the very concept of "first contact". And what constitutes a genuine "first contact" anyway? Does it have to be their first view of white skin, or would a |

|man from the neighbouring Moluccas Islands count? Or a Papuan from another part of the island? |

|Woolford, however, is adamant there are still "lost" tribes in West Papua and dismisses as professional protectionism claims to the contrary. Anthropologists |

|are simply too afraid, he says, to go into the areas he visits. |

|It did not take long for his expeditions to attract a clientele - or controversy. When Outside Magazine, a respected US adventure journal, sent one of its |

|reporters on a first contact expedition in 2004, the ensuing article effectively claimed the whole trip had been a hoax and that Woolford had somehow staged a |

|show of tribal aggression deep in the forest. Anthropologists shown photographs of the "ambush" agreed, pointing to the fact that the tribesmen were wearing |

|ceremonial dress: what amounted to their Sunday best. In response, Woolford invited the BBC on the first expedition scheduled for 2006. |

|My initial reaction to being asked to accompany this film crew was emphatically negative. Previously unaware of first contact tourism, I was angry at the very |

|idea. But there was an element of hypocrisy to my outrage for, seven years ago, I had what I believe to have been a first contact, and it was not just by |

|chance. |

|In January 2000, fellow explorer Bruce Parry and I were on our way to attempt the unclimbed south face of an obscure mountain in West Papua, making a film of |

|our trip. Having paddled a dugout canoe some 230 miles upriver from the coast we were nearing the point at which we would be forced to continue on foot, |

|extremely curious about what lay ahead. Everybody we met insisted we should avoid cutting a trail straight to the mountains and instead continue following the |

|river. |

|"You'll be eaten," one village chief told us. "They use the trees and make strange sounds, like birds. They will encircle you." He made a pincer movement with |

|his arms. "Then ..." he drew back an imaginary bowstring and released the arrow, "you'll be chopped up, baked and everyone will eat a bit of you. Then there |

|will be dancing. Nobody can go there." |

|We were surprised, but I don't remember having a single doubt that we must go there. I wasn't thinking of first contact, just of encountering an entirely |

|traditional people, still naked and, even better, still eating human flesh. With childhood heroes such as explorer Wilfred Thesiger, I had thought myself born |

|too late for such adventures. |

|For the next fortnight, accompanied by an Indonesian called Supratman, we travelled through Korowai territory. Abandoned by our porters, we almost drowned |

|struggling to cross vast rivers before finally meeting some hunters on the fringes of their clan territory. They barred our path but the encounter only |

|inflamed our curiosity. At last, with swamp-rotted feet and weak with hunger, we saw a ladder leading to a treehouse 20ft above. What followed has occupied my |

|thoughts more than almost any other event in my life. |

|A man rushed out of the doorway and started down the ladder but, at the sight of us, froze. "Owhh! Owhh!" Cries of fear from the others in the treehouse |

|shattered the forest calm. Clinging to the ladder the man shrank into a ball, his eyes wide with fear. A second, older man stepped out and peered down at us. A|

|third, crouching submissively, alternately held his head and pointed to the sky, repeating the same cry, "Owhh, Owhh!" |

|Our offered gifts were ignored but as they realised we meant no harm, fear turned to aggression. A bow was drawn and we ran. At our first halt the tribesmen |

|caught up with us. They kept their distance and appeared to be unarmed but the gestures were unchanged: open palms thrust towards the sky - and us - then |

|withdrawn to pat the head. This time they seemed to be pointing in a specific direction. Bruce made an obvious display of having understood and we set off down|

|the path indicated. Behind us the men fell silent, and when I snatched a glance over my shoulder they were gone. |

|Later, I had the film we shot that day translated and discovered that, as we suspected, the men had been arguing over whether or not to kill us. The man with |

|the bow had that intention but the others held him back. As we were leaving they said this: "We know that's tobacco [about our gifts]. We know what that is. We|

|would like to take that but we do not know what you are and the spirits might be angry and turn our world upside down." |

|Bruce and I escaped to continue our journey with contradictory feelings of wonderment and shame. The fear of having caused lasting damage was short-lived: the |

|global search for aloeswood - found in local trees and used in Middle Eastern perfume - had reached West Papua. Indonesian traders were penetrating ever deeper|

|into the forest, persuading tribesmen to supply them with it in exchange for goods. Bruce and I reckoned we were only 10 miles in front of a sweeping tide of |

|pots and pans, steel axes and T-shirts. But however much I turn that event around in my head, I still carry a little shame for the belligerent determination of|

|our invasion. |

|I am certain those tribesmen had never before seen the likes of Supratman's Indonesian face, let alone ours, and that they possessed minimal awareness of what |

|lay outside their forest home. The explorer in me would like to think that they had never even heard of white-skinned men, but that's unlikely. In May this |

|year I returned to West Papua to live for three months with the Kombai, a neighbouring tribe. There I learned how to build and live in an 80-foot treehouse and|

|how to fish using poison from a local leaf. I also learned how astonishingly efficient the jungle grapevine is. |

|If peoples do exist in West Papua who are unknown beyond, say, their neighbours' tribal territories, I believe it must be because they wish to escape detection|

|- which means they must know far more about the outside world than we give them credit for. Why would they now reveal themselves to a bunch of sweating white |

|men? The more convinced of a hoax I became, the more I began to relax about Woolford's operation, and the prospect of joining one of his trips. The two locals |

|who were to act as our guide had, he told us, been prospecting for gold up in the hills when they had been taken prisoner by a tribe who ate raw meat. Relieved|

|of their clothes and machetes, they had eventually been released, and were now willing to lead us back to the same place. No tribe I had come across ate raw |

|meat: what about worms? With our film crew along, I thought Woolford would pull out all the stops: we would probably be taken prisoner, too, forced to eat raw |

|rat, then miraculously released. |

|I signed up and three months later was motoring upriver beneath a cloud of giant fruit bats. The film crew and I were in two minds about whether we were being |

|hoaxed. We dissected everything that was going on; Woolford disappearing for a day in the boat; the hopeless disorganisation that allowed the boatmen to steal |

|half our food. Often Woolford seemed barely in control of our small army of porters, let alone of some larger scam. |

|On the other hand, a hoax wouldn't be hard to arrange. All you'd need is to have met the tribesmen before and to have a trusty man slip ahead to make sure the |

|group was met in style. Many Papuan tribes traditionally meet strangers on their territory with angry posturing and arrows brandished or even fired overhead - |

|it's protocol. In this case, they'd just have to slow it down for photos and then make sure they got everyone running for their lives as a finale. |

|But as the days passed and our caravan snaked towards the dark hills ahead, we still could not work out what was going on. I liked Woolford. I wanted him to be|

|hoaxing us and for the tribe to be making something out of it, but I just couldn't be sure. One day we passed the remains of an enormous logging operation that|

|had been going for 30 years. Surely the tribesmen and loggers must have made contact? But the next day we were into terrain where no bulldozer could ever go. |

|As we climbed through ever steeper gorges, my fear that Woolford was indeed leading us toward a genuine first contact increased. I did not want that shame and |

|guilt again. Furthermore, several of our porters had colds. In West Papua first contact does not seem to have had the same catastrophic consequences that it |

|had in the Amazon where, typically, around 50% of a tribe would die within a year from imported diseases, including the common cold. But who wanted to take |

|that risk? Part of me wanted to turn back but I was also feeling that powerful drive of excitement and curiosity again. |

|Two days later, one of the path-cutting team came crashing back through the undergrowth and breathlessly told us that one of the prospectors had met some of |

|the tribe. There was no fear on his face, so we marched ahead. The prospector was standing by the river with two men and two boys. All four were naked but for |

|penis gourds, and the men held bows and arrows; it was immediately apparent this was a friendly meeting. Vigorous hand-shaking was still in progress as |

|Woolford and I joined them. We smiled and, squatting in the mud, smoked each other's tobacco and tried to communicate. I felt relief at their obvious ease - |

|and the fact that they wore plastic bead necklaces. Woolford could not hide his disappointment. He perked up, however, when they promised to take us to their |

|village the next day. |

|In the morning the hunting party was gone. We never did get to the village and I still do not know for sure whether or not there are genuine first contacts to |

|be made in West Papua. Watching one of our porters splashing about in a river one day, however, it struck me that if a naked hunter-gatherer were to emerge |

|from the forest and dress himself in shorts and a T-shirt, he would look exactly like one of our porters; would he still be a traditional hunter-gatherer? And |

|would he be less interesting purely because he was carrying an old steel machete rather than a bow and arrow? |

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download