TWO SOCIOLOGICAL STUDIES OF RAPE



TWO SOCIOLOGICAL STUDIES OF RAPE

I. Sanday, The Socio-Cultural Context of Rape: A Cross-Cultural Study (1981)

• a cross-cultural sample of 156 tribal societies

• conclusions:

1. Rape is linked with an overall pattern of violence (interpersonal, intergroup, and war);

and violence against women is part of a larger pattern of violence.

2. Rape is linked with an ideology that encourages men to be tough and aggressive. Thus

rape is the playing out of a cultural script in which the expression of personhood for males is directed by--among other things--interpersonal violence and an ideology of toughness. Male sexuality is expressed in physical aggression, as are other expressions of self.

3. Rape is an expression of an ideology of male dominance. Female power and authority are

lower in rape-prone societies. In addition, there is also greater sexual separation in rape-prone societies.

II. Baron and Straus, Four Theories of Rape in American Society (1989)

Rape Rates by Region, 1970 and 1980 (in descending order):

West---South---North Central---Northeast

1. Gender Inequality

A major theme of feminist theories of rape is that rape functions as a mechanism of social control in patriarchal societies--e.g., rape and the fear of rape enable men to assert power over women and maintain the existing system of gender stratification. A related theme is that traditional gender-role attitudes encourage rape.

-Gender Equality Index (GEX) operationalized the status of women with three dimensions: economic equality (labor force participation, employment, income, SBA loans, above poverty households), political equality (% Congress, state senates and houses, governors, judges, mayors, governing boards), legal equality (fair employment acts, equal pay laws, sex discrimination laws, family violence laws, etc.)

-Gender Equality Index Scores by Region (in descending order):

West---Northeast---North Central---South

-GEX (Gender Equality Index) correlation with rape rates = .23 (NOT statistically

significant)

2. Pornography

Feminist argument: "Pornography is the theory; rape is the practice."

-Sex Magazine Circulation Index (SMCX) = # copies sold / 100 males aged 15+ of 8 magazines (Playboy, Hustler, Penthouse, Chic, Club, Gallery, Genesis, Oui)

-Sex Magazine Circulation Index by Region (in descending order):

West---North Central---Northeast---South

-SMCX (Sex Magazine Circulation Index) correlation with rape rates = .64 (the 2nd highest

correlation Baron and Straus found)

-BUT, Baron and Straus found that when appropriate statistical controls were introduced, the

correlation between sex-magazine readership and rape rates no longer held. "A more

likely possibility, in our opinion, is that the correlation between the circulation of

sexually explicit magazines and the rape rate is due to the presence of a hypermasculine

or macho culture pattern."

3. Social Disorganization

Social disorganization refers to those conditions that undermine the ability of traditional institutions (e.g., family, church, neighborhood) to govern social behaviors.

-Social Disorganization Index (SDX) included 6 measures: geographical mobility, divorce, lack of religious affiliation, men who live alone, female-headed households with children, ratio of tourists to residents

-Social Disorganization Index by Region ( in descending order):

West---South---North Central---Northeast

-SDX (Social Disorganization Index) correlation with rape rates = .68 (the HIGHEST

correlation of any factor Baron and Straus tested)

4. Legitimate Violence

The "cultural spillover theory" holds that the more a society tends to endorse the use of physical force to attain socially approved ends (e.g., order in schools, crime control, military dominance), the greater the likelihood that this legitimation of force will be generalized to other spheres of life where violence is less socially approved (e.g., family, relations between the sexes).

-Legitimate Violence Index (LVX) constructed to measure cultural support for violence, with 3 major groups of indicators: mass media preferences (violent TV viewership, violent magazine circulation), government use of violence (corporal punishment in schools, death sentences, executions), participation in legal or socially approved violent activities (hunting licenses, college football players, National Guard enrollment and expenditures, lynchings)

-Legitimate Violence Index by Region (in descending order):

West---South---North Central---Northeast

-LVX (Legitimate Violence Index) correlation with rape rates = .22 (NOT significant)

A second measure was also constructed: a Violence Approval Index (VAX), based directly on attitudes regarding circumstances justifying use of violence (social norms)--militarism, executions, and guns (% supporting greater military spending, death penalty, opposing gun control), % approval of punching an adult male stranger under a variety of circumstances, and % approval of police striking an adult male citizen under a variety of circumstances.

-Violence Approval Index by Region (in descending order):

West---South---North Central---Northeast

-VAX (Violence Approval Index) correlation with rape rates = .17 (NOT significant)

direct effects on rape: social disorganization (+), sex magazine circulation (+), gender equality (-)

-other variables also related: % population in SMSAs, Gini Index, % unemployed

-indicates that combination of urbanism, economic inequality, and unemployment constitutes a

mixture of societal characteristics that increase the likelihood of rape

-combination of these 6 variables accounts for 83% of the state-to-state variation in rape rates

indirect effects on rape:

-social disorganization, ratio of males to females, & economic inequality (-) ( circulation of sex

magazines

-social disorganization, economic inequality (-), & legitimate violence (-) ( gender equality

social origins of rape:

• gender inequality: gender inequality ( social climate conducive to violence against women

-in a male-dominated society, rape both reflects a low valuation of women and contributes to and enforces their subordinate position

• hypermasculinity: the underlying third variable that likely produces a spurious correlation between pornography and rape

• social disorganization: 2 effects: (1) in a violent and sexist society, lower social control ( higher rape, and (2) erosion of traditional sexist norms and domination ( gender equality ( lower rape

• legitimate violence: no direct relationship

-but indirectly related through inverse relationship with gender equality

-i.e., status of women lower is lower in states with higher levels of legitimate violence

• urbanism, economic inequality, and unemployment: (1) urban areas provide greater opportunities for criminal violence, (2) status inequalities ( resentment, hostility (some of it directed at women); without economic avenues of asserting masculinity, men may turn to rape to do it

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download