A Report to Congress - Government Accountability Office

Highlights

Highlights of GAO-18-111SP

View GAO-18-111SP. For more information, contact Charles A Jeszeck at (202) 512-7215 or jeszeckc@.

Section 1: Landscape of U.S. Retirement System Has Shifted

A Report to Congress

October 2017

The Nation's Retirement System

A Comprehensive Re-evaluation Is Needed to Better Promote Future Retirement Security

The U.S. retirement system, and the workers and retirees it was designed to help, face major challenges. Traditional pensions have become much less common, and individuals are increasingly responsible for planning and managing their own retirement savings accounts, such as 401(k) plans. Yet research shows that many households are ill-equipped for this task and have little or no retirement savings. In this special report, GAO examines these challenges, drawing from prior work and others' research, as well as insights from a panel of retirement experts on how to better ensure a secure and adequate retirement, with dignity, for all.

Fundamental changes have occurred over the past 40 years to the nation's current retirement system, made up of three main pillars: Social Security, employer-sponsored pensions or retirement savings plans, and individual savings. These changes have made it increasingly difficult for individuals to plan for and effectively manage retirement. In particular, there has been a marked shift away from employers offering traditional defined benefit (DB) pension plans to defined contribution (DC) plans, such as 401(k)s, as the primary type of retirement plan. This shift to DC plans has increased the risks and responsibilities for individuals in planning and managing their retirement. In addition, economic and societal trends--such as increases in debt and health care costs--can impede individuals' ability to save for retirement.

Trends in Private Sector Retirement Plans since 1975

Section 2: Individuals Face Three Key Challenges in Planning and Managing Their Retirement

GAO's prior work has found that many individuals face the following challenges in their efforts to provide for a financially secure retirement at a time when increases in longevity further raise the risk of outliving their savings:

n Access: Accessing retirement plans through their employers.

n Saving: Accumulating sufficient retirement savings.

n Retirement: Ensuring accrued savings and benefits last through retirement.

Section 3: U.S. Retirement System Is Threatened by Fiscal Risks and Benefit Adequacy Concerns

The three pillars of the current retirement system in the United States are anticipated to be unable to ensure adequate benefits for a growing number of Americans due, in part, to the financial risks associated with certain federal programs.

n Social Security's retirement program (Old-Age and Survivors Insurance): Beginning in 2035, this program is projected to be unable to pay full benefits. Long-term fiscal projections show that, absent fiscal policy changes, the federal government is on an unsustainable path, largely due to spending increases driven by the growing gap between federal revenues and health care programs, demographic changes, and net interest on the public debt.

n Private employer-sponsored plans:

DB plans: On the decline; also, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) which insures most DB plans, is at risk due to substantial liabilities, especially in its multiemployer program.

DC plans: On the rise, but with more risk and responsibility for individuals; many individuals are not saving enough in these plans to provide an adequate retirement.

n Individual savings: Outside of employer-sponsored plans, individuals' retirement savings are often low or nonexistent, which may increase their reliance on various federal and state safety net programs.

Timeline of Projected Fiscal Risks for Certain Federal Programs

Section 4: The Need to Re-evaluate the Nation's Approach to Financing Retirement

Matter for Congressional Consideration

Over the past 40 years, the nation has sought to address the issues facing the U.S. retirement system in a piecemeal fashion. This approach may not be able to effectively address the interrelated nature of the challenges facing the system today. Fundamental economic changes have occurred, as well as the shift from DB to DC plans, with important consequences for the system. Further, it has been nearly 40 years since a federal commission has conducted a comprehensive evaluation of the nation's approach to financing retirement. A panel of retirement experts convened by GAO in November 2016 agreed that there is a need for a new comprehensive evaluation. The experiences of other countries can also provide useful insights for ways to improve the system.

Congress should consider establishing an independent commission to comprehensively examine the U.S. retirement system and make recommendations to clarify key policy goals for the system and improve how the nation promotes retirement security.

Contents

Preface

1

Section 1: Landscape of U.S. Retirement System Has Shifted

6

Shift in Types of Retirement Plans Offered by Private Sector

Employers

9

Section 2: Individuals Face Three Key Challenges in Planning and Managing Their Retirement

22

Challenge 1: Accessing Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plans

23

Challenge 2: Accumulating Sufficient Retirement Savings

31

Challenge 3: Ensuring Financial Resources throughout Retirement 55

Section 3: U.S. Retirement System Is Threatened by Fiscal Risks and Benefit Adequacy Concerns

72

Social Security Retirement Program

73

Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plans

77

Individuals' Savings and Reliance on Safety Net Programs

87

Section 4: The Need to Re-evaluate the Nation's Approach to Financing Retirement

94

In Recent Decades, Retirement Issues Have Been Addressed

with a Piecemeal Approach

94

Experts Agree on the Need for a More Comprehensive Approach

97

International Comparisons Can Provide Insights for Re-evaluating

the U.S. Retirement System

101

Potential Areas in Need of Comprehensive Reform for the U.S.

Retirement System

110

Conclusions and Matter for Congressional Consideration

111

Appendix I

Selected Federal Legislation and Other Milestones Shaping

Retirement in the United States

113

Appendix II

Overview of Methods

126

Appendix III

GAO's Expert Panel on the State of Retirement

128

Page i

GAO-18-111SP State of Retirement in America

Appendix IV Appendix V Appendix VI Appendix VII Glossary of Terms Related GAO Products Tables

GAO Recommendations from Prior Reports

143

Two Past Federal Commissions on Retirement Issues

149

Retirement Systems in Selected Countries

153

GAO Contacts and Staff Acknowledgments

155

156

160

Table 1.1: Key Characteristics of Private Sector Defined

Contribution and Defined Benefit Plans

12

Table 2.1: External Risk Factors Affecting Individuals' Financial

Security in Retirement

61

Table 4.1: Federal Commissions Addressing Retirement-Related

Issues since 1974

96

Table 4.2: International Rankings of Retirement Systems on

Adequacy of Income in Retirement

103

Table 4.3: International Rankings of Retirement Systems on

Sustainability

107

Table 4.4: Policy Goals for Evaluating Potential Options for

Reforming the U.S. Retirement System

110

Table II.I: Federal Agencies, Organizations, and Institutions

Providing Data Cited in This Report

126

Table IV.1: Selected GAO Recommendations and Matters for

Congress to Promote Greater Access to Retirement

Savings Plans

143

Table IV.2: Selected GAO Recommendations and Matters for

Congress to Improve Various Aspects of Defined

Contribution Plans

144

Table IV.3: Selected GAO Recommendations and Matters for

Congress to Improve Financial Literacy

146

Page ii

GAO-18-111SP State of Retirement in America

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download