MANUSCRIPT REVIEW SHEET (FORM D)
MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION SHEET
Manuscript Title(#) ___________________________________________________________
Appropriateness: If manuscript should be sent to a different journal or magazine, which one(s):
______________________________________________________
Content: Evaluate the quality and importance of the research independently of presentation:
_____ 1. Major contribution: profound, theoretically or empirically important, very well conceived and executed.
_____ 2. Warrants publication: solid, sound contribution.
_____ 3. Sufficiently sound and important to justify publication if space is plentiful.
_____ 4. May be publishable if analysis is improved or extended.
_____ 5. Insufficiently sound or important to warrant publication.
Presentation: Is it orderly, clear and interesting? Does it adhere to professional standards of scientific writing?
_____ 1. Exceptionally well written: needs only routine editing.
_____ 2. Satisfactorily written: can be improved by careful editing.
_____ 3. Unevenly written: portions require rewriting.
_____ 4. Poorly written: must be extensively rewritten before acceptance.
RECOMMENDATIONS OF REVIEWER REGARDING PUBLICATION
_____ 1. Accept for publication as submitted.
_____ 2. Accept for publication with minor revisions.
_____ 3. Accept for publication with major revisions.
_____ 4. Invite author to revise and resubmit for further review before a publication decision is made.
_____ 5. Do not accept for reasons indicated.
Make your comments on the enclosed "Review Comments" sheet and return to the associate editor.
_______________________________________
_______________________________________
_______________________________________
_______________________________________
Reviewer name and address
................
................
In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.
To fulfill the demand for quickly locating and searching documents.
It is intelligent file search solution for home and business.
Related searches
- photosynthesis review sheet answers
- customer review sheet templates
- photosynthesis and cellular respiration review sheet answers
- cellular respiration review sheet answers
- form d search
- d d 5th edition character sheet pdf
- d d 5e character sheet word doc
- character sheet template d d
- form d 1199
- sec form d search
- review sheet 17 gross anatomy
- transformation review sheet answers