FACULTY / STAFF CENTRAL - FAO UNC Eshelman School of …



Journal Club RubricStudent Name:________________________________ Article Title:____________________________________________________5Accomplished4Developing3Acceptable, but Needs Development2Needs Significant Development1UnacceptableRequires no promptingDetailed discussion and in-depth understandingHighest level of achievementOrganized, proficient deliveryClarification needed with minor promptAbove average detail and understandingMostly organized & clear deliveryClarification needed on several promptsAverage detail and understandingAverage deliveryRequires directed questioning to prompt informationDetail with some understandingDelivery below averageExtensive clarification neededLimited detail and minimal understandingInstructor has to intervene for accuracy of informationDelivery entirely inappropriateOutcomePoints Factor xTotalCommentDescription of Relevance:Appropriately lists article citationProvides sufficient background informationIdentifies trial purpose/importanceIdentifies study question/objective(s)1 2 3 4 51.5Complete Overview & Explanation of Methods:Appropriately explains:Study designExclusion/inclusion criteriaEndpointsStudy groups (if applicable)Baseline characteristicsAdditional information as needed1 2 3 4 52Complete Explanation of Discussion & Analysis:Appropriately explains:Data and Statistical AnalysisResultsDiscussionConclusions1 2 3 4 52Clinical Trial Evaluation & Practice ApplicationCritique of:Strengths & LimitationsStatisticsAddressed author’s conclusion, but formulates own conclusion as wellExplains impact and/ or application to current clinical practiceIdentifies further studies needed1 2 3 4 52Ability to Answer QuestionsAnswers logically and accuratelyAbility to think under pressureMay attempt to answer if unsure, but clearly specifies uncertainty if necessary1 2 3 4 51Overall Presentation Delivery and Handout:Organization and PreparednessHandout: accurate, concise, organized, grammatically correctInformation delivered logicallyCommunication and PresentationPronunciationConfidenceEye contact & Rate of speechTransitions1 2 3 4 51.5Total: Multiply the points earned (1-5) in each section by the factor to calculate the total points per outcome. Add the total for each outcome to determine the total points. Total Points: _______/50Evaluator:__________________________________________ Date:___________________________This rubric was formatted after the “Journal Club Evaluation Form” from Ohio Northern University, Raabe College of Pharmacy ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download