University of Texas at Austin



Minor v. Happersett

Facts: Minor attempted to register to vote for a presidential and local election in Mo. in 1872. She was denied by one registrar of voters, Mr. Happersett, on the grounds that her registration would violate the Mo. Constitution that stipulated only male citizens of the U.S. were entitled to vote.

Procedural History: Ms Minor brought suit in one of the inferior courts of Mo on the grounds that the right to vote was part of the p & i of national citizenship and overrides Mo. Constitution. Mr. Happersett demurred and the Court upheld Mo. Constitution. Ms Minor appealed to U.S. Sup. Ct for Writ of Error.

Issues

1. Are women to be citizens of the U.S.?

2. Does P & I cl grant right of suffrage as part of U.S. citizenship?

3. Does the Mo Cons violate the p & i clause of the 14th?

Holding

1. Yes women are citizens of the U.S.

2. No, p and i does not confer suffrage as part of citizenship in 14th

3. No, even though women are ctzns of the U.S., they do not have a federally protected right to vote as a ctzn of the U.S. guaranteed by the 14th and Mo. may restrict its suffrage to male ctzns only

Judgment: Affirmed

(Text, structure and relationship, originalism)

Legal Reasoning(Ch.J. Waite)

1. "There is not doubt that women are citizens .. and id not need an amendment to give them this distinction. They already had it."

A. Additions may be made to citizenship by birth or naturalization. Under c/l no doubt that children born to citizens were citizens regardless of sex

B. In 1790 Congress declared a citizen could be a "free white person" in shaping naturalization statutes. These statutes made no mention of excluding women

C. Courts have j/d with ctzn and many courts cases have women as parties

D. Women are equal subject to the control of the law as men are and are therefore citizens

2. Suffrage is not a p and I of US ctznshp mentioned in 14th

A. "US has no voters in states of its own creation"

1. Senators are chosen by leg of states and reps are chosen by citizens eligible to vote for state lower houses

2. States can pick the time, place and manner of elections

B. At adoption, all states had constitutions of their own that may or may not have excluded women that didi not change post adoption. Under Art 4 Sec 2, the original p and i clause, all ctzns would have the vote it if was included.

C. Framers would have left something as important as suffrage up to interpretation

D. After 14th adopted, "it was deemed necessary to adopt the 15th." This amendment would been redundant if the right of suffrage was part of the 14th. The 15th expressly refers to males.

3. "If the law is wrong, it is not within our power to change." Mo. Cons is constitutional

Source of Law

Articles of Confederation

US Codes Regarding Alien Naturalization

Art 4 Sec 2

15th and P and I Cl of 14th

Common Law

Votes and Other Opinions

None

Contextual Explanations

This case takes place during reconstruction. Many women had worked as abolitionists and had hoped to be included in the 15th. Their omission was a great disappointment., but Republicans felt their inclusion would break a fragile and newly formed coalition that form the party. Women had begun to mobilize separately from abolitionism. This case follows Bradwell v. Ill.

Relationship to other cases

Slaughterhouse

Bradwell v. II

Values

Federalism v. state's rights

traditional social roles v. progressivism

interpretivism vs textualism

Impact of Decision

Although often overlooked in importance, Minor created by elimination the direction of the women's suffragist movement.

The movement was divided, Not all active women felt that the 14th granted the right to vote for women. After the decision in Minor, it became fairly clear that nothing less than a constitutional amend would grant women' suffrage This decision was the initial rallying call that helped greatly expand the movement.

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download