Posted Updated Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River ...

Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River curse of Col. Thomas Westbrook - Portland... Page 1 of 10

Menu

News

Business

> Opinion

Sports

Subscriber

Life & SCuubltsucrreibe ObituLaorgiesin Real Estate

What are you looking for?

Submit Query

M AINE VOICES > Posted June 23 Updated June 23

INCREASE FONT SIZE

Maine Voices: Lifting the

Presumpscot River curse of

Col. Thomas Westbrook

Standish is doing its part to lift this curse, feeling that something is fishy with the current deal.

BY ROGER WHEELER SPECIAL TO THE PRESS HERALD

Share

... 6/25/2018

Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River curse of Col. Thomas Westbrook - Portland... Page 2 of 10

Menu News

Business

> Opinion

Sports

STANDISH -- Historically, there have been What atiremyeosuwlohokeinngthfoer?entire Presumpscot River was

blessed by fish passage over all the dams.

However, without fail, this passage sooner or

later is taken away by powerful special interests

in Westbrook. The Presumpscot is cursed by this

history.

Subscriber

Life & SCuubltsucrreibe ObituLaorgiesin Real Estate

Submit Query

The town of Standish is now doing its part to help lift this curse. Town councilors there recently decided to intervene in a federal Presumpscot River dam proceeding, an important action that sends a message to governing agencies and citizens that something is fishy with the current deal. Standish now becomes part of a contentious 300-year saga involving everyone from Chief Polin to the residents of towns in the Sebago Lakes region and 19th-century federal officials, all standing up for fish passage on the dams.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Roger Wheeler is a resident of Standish and president of Friends of Sebago Lake.

The Presumpscot River once was home to a great annual migration

of sea-run

salmon, shad and

alewives to inland headwaters in western Maine.

That was first disrupted in the 1730s, when Col.

Thomas Westbrook prevented the passage of

these valuable food fishes to their spawning

grounds by building an impassable dam. The

existence and benefits of continuing watershed

fish restoration were taken away for brief

periods during early Colonial times, the

... 6/25/2018

Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River curse of Col. Thomas Westbrook - Portland... Page 3 of 10

>

RevolMuteinounaryNWewas r anBdustihneeslsate 1O80pi0niso.nThisSports

What acruerysoeuolofopkrinegvefonr?ting fish passage strikes again in 2018, as powerful interests work to prevent the

great natural wonder and wealth of sea-run fish

from gaining access to their full natural inland

range.

Subscriber

Life & SCuubltsucrreibe ObituLaorgiesin Real Estate

Submit Query

During the Revolutionary War, hungry settlers living inland from the mills of Westbrook successfully petitioned for the removal of the dams blockading their food fishes, only to have the powers of Westbrook eliminate fish passage by 1800.

After the Civil War, Spencer Baird, the U.S. fish commissioner, became aware that the inability of sea-run fish to migrate to their historic freshwater spawning habitat was harming the coastal and Gulf of Maine fishery. Baird pushed for restoration. Within eight years, fish passage on all Presumpscot dams was easily completed and so successful that Sebago Lake soon became a world-class salmon fishery. The only problem was the army of poachers who speared 20- and 30-pound salmon by the thousands in the tributary rivers of Sebago and Long lakes.

RELATED

Read more Maine Voices columns

In the early 1900s, Westbrook mills with their pollution and new hydropower dams again blocked the fish. In 2003, thanks to the fish passage requirements of the Clean Water Act,

... 6/25/2018

Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River curse of Col. Thomas Westbrook - Portland... Page 4 of 10

>

the paMthentuo fulNl efwissh resBtuosrinaetsios n wOapsinoinonce agSapionrts What aproesysoiublloeo. kMingillfoorw? ner Sappi North America

fought the state of Maine and the mandates of the Clean Water Act all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court but lost in a unanimous decision in 2006. On the terms set by the high court, Sappi's 2003 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission license for the five lower river dams said that as fish migrate in sufficient numbers upriver, the company is required to successively build fish passage on each of the five dams.

Subscriber

Life & SCuubltsucrreibe ObituLaorgiesin Real Estate

Submit Query

But Sappi, with their Pierce Atwood legal team, was not deterred in their quest to prevent these valuable fish from returning to their former range. They met with the city of Westbrook, Gov. LePage's Maine Department of Marine Resources, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the U.S. Department of the Interior and two lower-river groups: Friends of the Presumpscot River and the Conservation Law Foundation.

After a series of secretive negotiations, these groups produced the Saccarappa Agreement, which amends the federal license to eliminate fish passage at the upper Gambo and Dundee dams in Gorham and Windham. Under the 2016 agreement, fish passage around the dams won't be considered until 2053; even then, Sappi won't be required to remove the dams. In return, Westbrook receives some land and recreational waterfalls at Saccarappa; Sappi wins the jackpot! Without passage requirements at Gambo and Dundee, these dams become worth millions

... 6/25/2018

Maine Voices: Lifting the Presumpscot River curse of Col. Thomas Westbrook - Portland... Page 5 of 10

>

river dMaemnus at SNaecwcsarapBpuasiFneasllss, LiOttplieniFonalls aSnpdorts

What aMreayloliusolonokFinagllfsoar?re relatively worthless for hydropower, and these dams will be removed.

Subscriber

Life & SCuubltsucrreibe ObituLaorgiesin Real Estate

Submit Query

A decade ago, the same agencies and nonprofit groups that are presently parties to the new agreement filed letters with the Maine Department of Environmental Protection and FERC fully backing and justifying fish passage on all five dams. Now they support the wording of the current agreement, which says that fish passage "is not required or appropriate" at Gambo or Dundee dams. Will the Presumpscot curse of impassable dams be lifted or not?

4 COMMENTS

Share

Send questions/comments to the editors.

Ad

New sock is helping millions of seniors turn back the clock on their aging, aching feet.



VISIT SITE

RELATED STORIES

LOCAL & STATE

Standish councilors wade into dam dispute

BUSINESS

Benton's alewife festival is

... 6/25/2018

 ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download