Questions to ask when evaluating a scientific paper
Some questions to ask when evaluating a scientific paper
Introduction
Does the manuscript clearly explain the question under consideration?
Do you agree that this is an important/interesting question?
Would there have been a better question to ask?
Data
Did they measure the right variables to answer their question?
How good are the data? (quality, precision)
How extensive are the data? (more is usually better)
Is there any evidence that “inconvenient” data were ignored?
If there are weaknesses in the data, how easy would it have been to do better?
Would the collection of more or better data be likely to change the answer?
Analysis
Were there any flaws in the data analysis?
How strong were the results of the analyses?
Were alternative hypotheses evaluated?
Presentation
Were the figures and tables easy to understand?
Were the figures and tables “honest” or were they misleading?
Discussion
Did the discussion go beyond what the data support?
Were alternative explanations considered?
Can you think of alternative explanations that were not addressed?
Do you agree with the logic of the discussion?
Do you agree with the conclusions of the paper?
Do the authors evaluate potential weaknesses of the paper?
Can you think of potential weaknesses that were not addressed?
Does the paper advance our understanding of the field?
................
................
In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.
To fulfill the demand for quickly locating and searching documents.
It is intelligent file search solution for home and business.
Related download
- questions to ask when evaluating a scientific paper
- critique example journal article
- the scientific paper airplane method
- the nature of a scientific paper
- template for academic papers
- course proposal scientific writing
- preparation of papers in two column format
- scientific writing exercise
- dissecting a scientific paper in evolutionary biology
Related searches
- things to ask when buying a house
- questions to ask when buying a home
- questions to ask when hiring a realtor
- questions to ask when looking at houses
- questions to ask when analyzing
- questions to ask when interviewing someone
- questions to ask when selling a home
- questions to ask when viewing a home
- questions to ask before buying a house
- questions to ask customers as a banker
- questions to ask when conducting an interview
- questions to ask when looking at colleges