23 OCT 2006 Dear Lawrence,
JANUARY 31/MARCH 12/15/17/18/20/22/26 APRIL 6/8/16/26/29/JULY/DEC 2013/18 NOVEMBER 2015
MoreLove-HolySpiritInteractive
“Soul Ties” and ëthos Institute
This inquiry was undertaken at the requests of a national leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from the archdiocese of Bombay and a diocese-approved lay ministry in Goa.
A report from this ministry in the form of a letter to Fr. Faustine Lobo, Bangalore, made on request
From: prabhu To: faustinelobo@yahoo.in ; pmsindia66@ Sent: Thursday, November 08, 2012 9:30 AM
Subject: THE APPARENT MISUSE OF YOUR NAME AND THE NAME OF THE VATICAN BY LAY MINISTRIES ACTIVE IN BANGALORE
BCC: Fr. A. Sagayanathan, parish priest of St. Patrick's Church, Bangalore, sagaya1959@ and the Mumbai and Goa parties.
KIND ATTENTION:
FR. FAUSTINE LOBO,
National Director,
Pontifical Mission Societies (PMS)
10, Ulsoor Road,
BANGALORE 560 042
November 8, 2012
Dear Father Faustine Lobo,
I greatly appreciate your having kindly consented to agree to meet with me at your office on the evening of November 5 against the appointment* originally granted to my colleague Mr. Francis Lobo of Bangalore who was held up with office work. I have briefed him in a general way on our conversation. *See page 12 of this report for the correspondence
I also thank you for granting me your precious time to listen to what we desired to share with you, and much more. […]
You had requested me to give you a letter on what I brought to your attention, and I hope that the following will suffice.
It is a long and complicated matter and I will make an effort to connect all the different threads together.
A. There is a Bangalore-based ministry called "MoreLove" founded and operated by one Dr. Dominic F. Dixon who signs as a "psychologist". He is the author of "The Beautiful Christian Mind-Deliverance from Mental Illness"*, Asian Trading, 2006 and "Living for the Audience of One", More Love, 2008. *Please see the information at the end of the letter, page 8
The reason Mr. Francis Lobo approached you for an appointment is against some of his findings resulting from his inquiries after we were requested on August 16 by a very senior Church-approved person in lay ministry from another archdiocese [Bombay] to check out the "Soul Ties" program that Dr. Dixon advertised for in conjunction with a "Theology of the Body" program organized by him at St. Patrick's Church mini hall, Brigade Road, Bangalore.
The information in the form of a "Veritas TV" flyer [329 KB, attached to this email] was received by that leader in an email, From: info@morelove.in Date: Tue, 14 Aug 2012, Subject: Theology of the Body.
The referred leader forwarded the MoreLove email to us.
The referred leader wrote to us, "Trying to find out what this 'soul ties' is all about. It does not have anything in common with Theology of the Body. Can you trace this? Is it dangerous?"
On October 5, I received an email from a reputed lay Catholic ministry in yet another archdiocese [Goa], part of which read, "The session Soul Ties is happening next Sunday 7 Oct and it is being presented by Br. Vasudevan. I don't think he is a catholic, but the main resource Dominic said that he is good. So waiting to hear him next sunday. The next sunday's session is open to all, so we have been told that we can invite our friends for this session." The above quote is from a letter that they received from Bangalore from a Catholic lay person who is a participant of the course.
1.
I could find no Catholic teaching on "Soul Ties" on the Internet. Whatever I located is Protestant. See for example .
In fact, with some of them like , the “theology” is questionable, and some such as are anti-Catholic.
If you so desire, I can provide you with some more links.
B. According to the flyer published on the Internet, , and sent to us by the referred lay leader, the "School" commenced September 2nd and was to have ended October 28, "every Sunday 4 pm to 6 pm".
Mr. Francis Lobo attended the Soul Ties session on October 7, and I did so along with him for the TOB session on November 4. The latter’s talks were based on Pope John Paul II’s "Theology of the Body" [TOB] and an interactive workbook by the eminent Christopher West was used. From the Catholic perspective, we found no problem with the contents of the course or the talks. In fact, Dr. Dixon decried the many aberrations and abuses [both inculturational and liturgical] resulting from personal interpretations of some Vatican II documents, and we commend him for that because there are few lay people – if at all there are any – who have the moral courage to speak out in such a forthright manner against such errors.
From our enquiries and letters received by email, we learnt that there was [so far at least] only one session [October 7] on Soul Ties and the speaker was one Rev. K. Vasudevan, a Protestant pastor [Methodist] belonging to the Bangalore Bible Fellowship , , revkvasudevan@.
The flyer introduced pastor Vasudevan, without naming him or indicating that the speaker would be Protestant, thus: "There will be a special session on SOUL TIES by an international and renowned authority on the subject."
Again, the following is the text of an email received by me from Mr. Francis Lobo on October 9:
“I went to Soul Ties program conducted by Dominic Dixon at St. Patricks Church Bangalore on 7th October 2012. He called a protestant pastor as a guest speaker to have deep understanding on Soul Ties. The protestant pastor’s name is Rev. K Vasudevan. I do not know who gave the permission to Dominic Dixon to invite a Pastor to the Catholic Church. Since Vasudevan grew up in a Protestant background and graduated in theology from a Protestant seminary, he will promote anti-Catholic doctrine during his speech when it comes to Salvation, Confession etc. Soul Ties is familiar around the Protestant circle. I feel with influence of protestant pastors Dominic Dixon introduced Soul Ties to the Catholic Church. Also he invited protestant pastors to the Catholic Church. During his talks Rev. Vasudevan introduced 3 protestant ministries. Out of them I remember only two. 1) Jim B. Richards 2) Wellspring Ministries. Even he also distributed the pamphlets of Wellspring Ministries [457 KB, sample attached to this email]. There are many Catholics poisoned by Protestant teaching. Even Dominic Dixon’s website too promotes Protestant faith based approach to the word or positive thinking. It is very sad. Can you please look into this matter? “
Several questions arise, including:
1. What is this Protestant "Soul Ties" program doing in the middle of a Catholic TOB study? Is there any relationship between the two? Or, having obtained the permission to use a Catholic venue, was it an opportunity for Dr. Dixon to exchange favours with Protestant ministries with which he appears to be excessively familiar?
2. Why are Catholic ministries inviting Protestant pastors to give us teachings which have not been priorly submitted to the concerned Catholic authorities for approval?
3. Is Fr. A. Sagayanathan, the parish priest of St. Patrick’s Church, aware that pastor Vasudevan has been teaching at Dr. Dixon’s classes?
The answer is "No". I talked to Fr. Sagayanathan yesterday afternoon on the telephone. He informs me that he is completely unaware that pastor Vasudevan has taught at the St. Patrick’s Church mini hall.
[On an aside, I may mention that there is a report on my web site on New Age being promoted by the asst. parish priest Fr. Adrian Mascarenhas at the same place:
FR ADRIAN MASCARENHAS-YOGA AT ST PATRICK’S CHURCH BANGALORE JULY/NOVEMBER 28, 2011
]
C. For "more information", one is requested to visit as per the guidance given on the said Veritas TV flyer at .
According to the flyer at , the complete title of the TOB programme is "The HSI School of Theology of the Body". HSI stands for "Holy Spirit Interactive", a ministry founded and operated by Mr. Aneel Aranha from Dubai around 2004. He later started "Discipleship" programs which were conducted at various places in India including the archdioceses of Bangalore, Bombay and Madras-Mylapore. HSI is now banned in Bombay archdiocese.
a) In that connection, I must share an old letter written to me by the owner moderator of Konkani Catholics yahoo group, and my letter to Mr. Aneel Aranha:
From: Austine J. Crasta To: prabhu ; rohitd@axes-mach01.usa. ; Deepak Vian Ferrao
Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2007 9:51 AM Subject: Cautions Against HSI
JMJ Dear Michael,
Just want to inform you that I came across Catholic Culture’s modified review for “Holy Spirit Interactive”. The once “triple green” rating has now been changed to caution visitors against HSI on grounds of fidelity to the Magisterium. The review is posted at:
Particular weaknesses are mentioned with examples. Love, Austine.
The cautions were regarding Protestant material being hosted by Mr. Aneel Aranha on the HSI site.
From: prabhu To: aneel@ ; aneelnet@eim.ae ; aneelnet@.ae
Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2007 7:35 AM Subject: PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT
Dear Aneel, I trust that all is well with you and family.
A few days ago, Austine Crasta of KC drew my attention to the “caution” issued on HolySpiritInteractive by . From a triple-green rating, there is an amber light flashing on FIDELITY [to Church teaching]:
"There is much to recommend about this site but readers should be aware of charismatic elements which confuse sound Catholic theology with Protestant Biblical understanding.
WEAKNESSES
Example(s) Numerous articles by non-Catholic author, Marcia Montenegro (Fidelity)
Example(s) Protestant approach
Example(s) Omission of Catholic approach in youth section (Fidelity)
Protestant Christian music and “resources” under the youth/kids sections (Fidelity)
Example(s) Total condemnation of any drinking of alcohol (Fidelity)"
Love, Michael Prabhu [The "Examples" in blue are hyperlinks]
b) I was recently informed telephonically by the [Mumbai] sender of the inquiry concerning the St. Patrick’s program advertised through the Veritas TV flyer that Mr. Aneel Aranha has now been banned by the archdiocese of Bombay from conducting any further activities there.
However, he continues to be active elsewhere, especially in your archdiocese of Bangalore, and the invitations have almost always been accorded to him by the local service teams of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal [CCR].
c) In addition to being recognized by the Bangalore service team of the CCR which, from the naming of its Chairman [Mr. Simon Rodrigues] as a resource person for the Soul Ties-TOB program as on the flyer, appears to be working now in association with them, MoreLove founder Dr. Dixon has apparently been felicitated by Most Rev. Bernard Moras, the Archbishop of Bangalore who released his first book, "The Beautiful Christian Mind – Deliverance from Mental Illness".
Yesterday, I received a telephone call stating that MoreLove/HSI has an office on the first floor of the office-commercial complex in the St. Patrick’s Church campus. The St. Patrick’s Church administrative office also confirmed this to us when we contacted them.
We could not ascertain whether this office space has been let out to MoreLove/HSI by the parish itself or by the archdiocese of Bangalore. Otherwise, their published address as on the Internet is 12/1, 12th cross, Ejipura, Bangalore 560 047.
D. Since 2009, there exists a tie-up between MoreLove, which operates a number of "ministries" from Bangalore, and HSI. There is so much evidence available on the Internet that I do not need to send you any.
In case you are interested, you may check out where you can see the "ministries" of MoreLove’s Dr. Dominic Dixon and HSI’s Mr. Aneel Aranha on the same page. The page also provides one with links to Veritas TV and HSI MoreLove Radio.
The Power of Words may be viewed at .
I received an email from Bangalore from which I quote,
“This is a 24 hour Global Internet Christian Television Network controlled by Dominic Dixon and Aneel Aranha. It is not right to say it is a Catholic channel because we can see Hillsong and other [Protestant] worship singers on this site. Also Aneel Aranha is talking about words having power.
“Bro. Aneel teaches Christians how to speak out and claim the promises of God rather than grumble. Thus receiving blessings and joy.”
There is something wrong in his teaching, similar to Johnson Sequeira and Joel Osteen.”
A cursory examination of the VeritasTV pages reveals that the majority of the information made available there is sourced from Protestant ministries.
We also are informed by MoreLove/HSI that "Like Elisha asked Elijah for a double portion of anointing, we too can ask God for the same." I have been taught by Catholics that this double- and triple-anointing claimed by Protestants is theologically incorrect as we receive a single, once-and-for-all anointing of the Holy Spirit in Baptism which is only re-confirmed or made present in the Sacrament of Confirmation.
There is the possibility of other similar teachings in the HSI/MoreLove ministries, but I have not so far gone into that research.
3.
E. Pastor Vasudevan's web page advertises HSI/MoreLove [28.1 KB attachment - Radio Bible Teachings - ].
Conversely, through MoreLove/HSI, Catholics may get to know about pastor Vasudevan's Protestant ministries.
There are very few such cases, if any, where one can find a Protestant ministry giving a link to "Catholic" ministries.
One wonders if pastor Vasudevan teaches on MoreLove Radio.
F. I am recording a lot of information from the MoreLove/HSI flyer referred above in case it is pulled from the Internet in the event of an inquiry from you.
It states that the TOB program would be "presented by renowned Catholic Evangelist, author and Ambassador of Theology of the Body, Dr. Dominic Dixon and his team."
The "team", according to the same flyer, under the heading of "Teaching Faculty" consists of
i) Dr. Dominic Dixon, Director HSI More Love/TOB India, IAD Vatican**
**Please see Mr. Francis Lobo's email further below; the flyer also states that HSI is "under the IAD, Vatican".
ii) Rev. Fr. A. Sagayanathan, Parish Priest, St. Patrick's Church, Author: Blessed John Paul the Great
iii) Rev. Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, Pontifical Mission, Vatican***
iv) Bro. Simon Rodrigues, Chairman, Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal Service [sic]
*** clarifies that "Pontifical Mission Society, which is a unit of the 'Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples' of the Vatican based in Rome, is a national level organization."
Is Fr. A. Sagayanathan, the parish priest of St. Patrick's Church, aware that his name is used to state that he is on the "Teaching Faculty" of the programme?
He is not. Fr. Sagayanathan informed me that he declined the invitation given by Dr. Dixon to him to talk to the course participants.
Fr. Faustine, as far as your being on the "Teaching Faculty", you have confirmed to me that you accepted an invitation to give the course participants a talk and that you were ignorant of the fact that your name has been used on the flyer.
You would also have noted that you are described as "Director, Pontifical Mission, Vatican", whereas your true and correct designation would be "National Director, Pontifical Mission Societies, Bangalore, India".
I have tried calling Mr. Simon Rodrigues myself several times on 98803 94898 but he is not reachable, so I could not ascertain from him whether his name too, in the manner of Fr. Sagayanathan's and yours, has been misused or not.
G. An email from a Bangalore contact is reproduced below:
From: Name Withheld To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, October 06, 2012 9:20 AM
Subject: Dominic Dixon, HSI-official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical
Dominic Dixon wrote on his facebook page
"HSI School of Theology of the Body" for the first time in India and for the first time in the world as a School. TOB is based on the teaching of Blessed John Paul II. TOB is based on Pope John Paul VI Encyclical "Humanae Vitae" HSI is now the official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical. Please see attachment. To get a better view of this post, log on to ."
a) Is it true that TOB is being taught "for the first time in India" as claimed by HSI/MoreLove? I believe that Fr. Sagayanathan himself knows a Marriage Encounter [M.E.] couple from Goa who teaches "Theology of the Body". There may be others in India who do this, and certainly many others all over the world.
b) Letters from a colleague in this ministry to Dr. Dixon and his responses:
From: Francis Lobo To: dom@morelove.in ; editor@ Sent: Monday, October 08, 2012 10:44 PM
Subject: Soul Ties
Dear Dixon,
I attended the Soul Ties program conducted by you at St. Patricks. What I have noticed that your ministry is an official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical and **International Association for Deliverance under the Vatican council. I just want to know how I can be certified by Vatican and what is the course fee?
Regards, Francis Sunil Lobo
On Tue, Oct 9, 2012 at 11:53 AM, Dominic Dixon wrote:
Dear Francis,
Thank you for attending our program.
The Vatican does not certify or endorse an individual but it recognizes Ministries that have been operational for a minimum of 10 years with good standing. The process is a legal process as it deals with the Canon Law.
The Vatican conducts programs on deliverance, etc. The prerequisite is that you should have been in deliverance for several years, with documentation and certification from the Vatican officials in India.
4.
You would be pleased to know that we will be conducting programs on the Vatican documents from January as we’ve been authorized to run an Institute for the Laity.
Hope this helps.
Best Regards,
Dr. Dominic Dixon (Psychologist)
Director – ML Dept. of Social Justice
Editor-in-Chief
I ML Radio
VERITAS TELEVISION NETWORK
Mobile : +91 98805-36501
Counsel : +91 72040-12777
Legal : +91 72040-13777
Media : +91 72040-14777
Fax : +91 11-66173777
From: fsunillobo@ Subject: Re: Soul Ties To: domdix@ Date: Tuesday, October 9, 2012, 11:44 AM
Thanks Dixon. It is wonderful source of information and every people should aware of this. Till now I was thinking only local Bishop or Provincial General can certify the lay ministry. That too as a Catholic lay Ministry, not as a Vatican approved ministry. Many people don’t know how to approach Vatican on these types of matters. I never saw a ministry which is recognized by Vatican except yours. How you approached the legal (CANON LAW) process to get approval from Vatican and who is the contact person in India. Who is the Vatican official who liable to provide the certificate in India.
Regards, Francis Sunil Lobo
From: domdix@ Date: Wed, Oct 10, 2012 at 4:08 PM Subject: Re: Soul Ties To: fsunillobo@
Speak to your spiritual director about matters such as these. Thereafter it’s a long and time consuming process.
c) Since Dr. Dixon declined to clarify the apprehensions of Mr. Lobo, he wrote to Mr. Aneel Aranha who, instead of answering him, apparently unwilling and unable to, forwarded the letter to Dr. Dixon who wrote back.
From: fsunillobo@ Date: Thu, Oct 11, 2012 at 9:55 PM Subject: HSI/MoreLove Recognition by Vatican
To: aa@, aneel@
Dear Aneel,
HSI/MoreLove is giving a program at St. Patrick’s church in Bangalore on Soul Ties which I am attending. I made an enquiry from Br. Dixon about its recognition by the Vatican, and he replied, “The Vatican does not certify or endorse an individual but it recognizes Ministries that have been operational for a minimum of 10 years with good standing. The process is a legal process as it deals with the Canon Law. The Vatican conducts programs on deliverance, etc. The prerequisite is that you should have been in deliverance for several years, with documentation and certification from the Vatican officials in India. You would be pleased to know that we will be conducting programs on the Vatican documents from January as we’ve been authorized to run an Institute for the Laity”.
On my further enquiry, he did not answer my questions but asked me to speak to my spiritual director.
I would like to know more about the Institute for the Laity and the program on Vatican documents so that I could join, if permitted.
I am happy to hear that your work is recognised and certified by the Vatican. We need such institutes.
I am happy to read that from Br. Dixon on Facebook that I is now the official ambassador of the Vatican’s official encyclical, Humanae Vitae. I have never known such a thing to be granted before this.
The flyer at mentions a Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, Pontifical Mission, Vatican as one of the faculty at your TOB school. I did not see him at the program in Bangalore. Will he be speaking soon?
I could not understand Br. Dixon. If you could explain where Canon Law comes in the picture, I will be very happy.
I would like to know when you will be speaking so that I could meet you and discuss more.
Regards, Francis Sunil Lobo
From: domdix@ Date: Fri, Oct 12, 2012 at 11:17 AM Subject: Re: Soul Ties To: fsunillobo@
Dear Francis,
I invited you to come meet us at our Ministry Centre in Bangalore. I’m way too busy to keep responding to emails and Bro. Aneel is on a two month international mission and does not have the time to respond to you.
Also, we need to uphold the dignity and Magesterium [sic] of the Holy Catholic Church and cannot discuss such matter via email. We love the Mother Church and cannot discuss its matters with people whom we don’t know. I have not met you and don’t know your intentions.
For an appointment, call Bro. Horace 7204012777.
Best Regards, Dr. Dominic Dixon (Psychologist)
With that, the only alternative left was for us to write to you, Father Faustine, which we did on October 13, and against which we received your email reply followed by your invitation – when we spoke to you over the ‘phone – to meet with you in person on November 5.
5.
MY CLOSING COMMENTS
1. It is a false statement made by Dr. Dixon that he invited Mr. Lobo "to come meet us at our Ministry Centre in Bangalore". I have reproduced the email correspondence between them in its totality and there was no exchange of telephone calls between them either.
2a. The statement "HSI School of Theology of the Body" for the first time in India and for the first time in the world as a School" is subtly misleading. The key word is "School". There are Catholic lay ministries that teach TOB in other formats such as seminars. Most readers will assume that the HSI/MoreLove TOB is exclusive and original apart from being "Vatican certified/authorized" as repeatedly stated.
2b. There appears to be a lot of name-dropping and misuse of names of contacts in this HSI/MoreLove affair.
When I attended his talk on November 4, I listened to Dr. Dixon referring at regular intervals to how much approval and endorsements he receives from different archbishops.
Apart from that, there is the frequent [mis]use of the "Vatican" word. He is a self-declared "official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical [Humanae Vitae]", "an ambassador for the views of the Holy Father" and "an ecumenical ambassador" [] and "Ambassador of Theology of the Body".
One wonders how these titles were assumed and what they are meant to convey.
2c. The use of the term "veritas" in the Dr. Dixon/Mr. Aneel Aranha-owned Veritas TV appears to be unethical.
As you yourself immediately noted, the word "veritas" at once brings to one's mind a certain Vatican media ministry, and this would happen with any visitor to a blog or web site using that name. Mr. Aneel Aranha and Dr. Dixon declare themselves as Vatican ambassadors or give the impression that their ministries as Vatican-associated/approved on Facebook and then provide links to their own site "VeritasTV" where they themselves ratify their claim and endorse their own selves.
As I pointed out to you when we met, just because you favoured me with 75 minutes of your time and said a few good things about me and my ministry, it does not give me the licence to claim that you or the Vatican endorse my work just because you are the National Director of the Pontifical Mission Societies and a Vatican appointee.
All of the above appears to be duplicity of the highest order and a blatant attempt to befool Catholics.
If I am correct in the information that I furnished to you, then I believe that it would be in order for the Church to take a very serious view of the matter and impose severe sanctions on this "ministry" combine.
2d. Catholics would like to know by which ecclesial authority MoreLove/HSI has "been authorized to run an Institute for the Laity" and what exactly this Institute intends to teach.
They hint that they "have been in deliverance for several years" and so have received the requisite "documentation and certification from the Vatican officials in India".
Since your name is on their "faculty", and the "Vatican" word was used there too, wouldn't it be wrongly assumed by most people that they indeed have recognition from Rome?
"The Vatican conducts programs on deliverance": What are the details of these programs which we have never heard of?
2e. An individual may become a member of the IAD, I am given to understand, by making a nominal payment after which one receives IAD newsletters and invitations to attend IAD international seminars [at one's own cost].
Ms. Gibello and I correspond almost on a fortnightly basis. Though I have never registered as a member, I receive all their newsletters and seminar invitations. That does not give me the licence to use "IAD Vatican" on my visiting cards, printed letter heads and ministry mast heads or web pages.
Dr. Dixon "is a member of the International Association for Deliverance under the Vatican Council" []. [What "Vatican Council"?].
He is "Director HSI More Love/TOB India, IAD Vatican" according to the flyer which also states that HSI is "under the IAD, Vatican".
This again appears to be misleading. Whether any type of recognition has been given to MoreLove and HSI by the "IAD Vatican" needs to be ascertained.
Ms. Erika Gibello, Secretary-General of the IAD [International Association for Deliverance] and former Secretary for the English-speaking members of the AIE [Association of Exorcists International] can give you the correct information. [Note added on March 15: Her response to this report is on page 13]
The use of "IAD" in conjunction with "Vatican" is itself a question mark.
2f. "Dr. Dixon has represented the Church of India at parlimentary [sic] levels, as an advisor to the President and Prime Minister of India on various issues."
3. In my computer files, I have maintained records of slanderous campaigns* released in the public domain by Dr. Dixon on certain individuals and lay ministries who dared to criticise him, even on others who didn’t.
I can give you the contacts of these people for verification. There is every possibility that it will be my turn when this letter to you is made public, but that does not cause me any anxiety. That such attacks on Catholics by Dr. Dixon occur is even more amazing considering that he projects himself as a crusader of Christian morals and ethics. Keep that in mind also in view of his apparently misusing the names of priests, Church officials and Church offices. *See pages 11 and 12 for selected information and a few links
I keep repeating the word "apparently" since it remains for you to ascertain whether our findings are correct or not. I only present you information already available in the public domain.
4. In the extract further below**, we find Dr. Dixon writing and signing a testimonial to himself.
5. I might have considered marking a copy of this letter to the Archbishop of Bangalore who I believe needs to be kept in the loop, except that he has never acknowledged even one of many such letters from me while the New Age and other errors that I brought to his attention continue unabated and unchecked in the archdiocese. However, it was God's providence that we could meet and I look forward to an acknowledgement from you to this letter of mine, followed by your intimation of what steps were taken by the concerned ecclesial authorities, if any.
Actually, I completed this letter in more detail than this yesterday but due to a computer glitch I lost it and rewrote the last half of it. This letter therefore is not as clear and complete as the one that I envisaged but I trust that it is sufficient for you.
At your service in Jesus' Name,
Michael Prabhu
** EXTRACT:
Dr. Dominic F. Dixon, a Catholic Evangelist based in Bangalore, under the authority of the Catholic Church and is a member of the International Association for Deliverance under the Vatican Council. He is the Founder and Director of MORE (Ministry Of Reconciliation & Evangelization), MORELOVE.IN, VERITAS TV, MORELOVERADIO. Dom has reached out to several hundred thousand youth in over 36 Countries who have been abused, addicts, alcoholics, and the outcast including gangsters.
Dom is a faculty member at Colleges in the discipline of Ethics and Value Education, promoting PURITY. Dom is the most interviewed Christian Evangelist in India having been interviewed by CNN, NDTV, India Today, Times of India, Headlines Today, Agence France-Presse and other International News channels and projected in over 100 Provinces worldwide in regards to his work amongst the youth. Dom is a leading voice in India for Pro-Life and is an ambassador for the views of the Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI and the Catholic Church in the areas of abortion, chastity and homosexuality. He is also an ecumenical ambassador to bring the Church in total unity which granted him appreciation by international Christian leaders of all denominations.
Dr. Dixon has represented the Church of India at parlimentary [sic] levels, as an advisor to the President and Prime Minister of India on various issues.
After working as a Technology Corporate consultant in the US, Canada and India, he submitted to the CALL to serve Jesus in 2001. Since then he has travelled extensively proclaiming the good news of Salvation through Jesus Christ. Dom holds a Doctorate in Counseling Psychology. He has done his Discipleship Training and School of University Ministries with Youth With A Mission****.
Dom has authored two major books on Psychology and Sociology. "The Beautiful Christian Mind", approved by Vatican officials and released by Archbishop Bernard Moras, Bangalore Archdiocese & "I'm a Teenager, pls understand me" and has produced an Audio Album on his series "Purpose of Life's Events" and a book on Christian character titled, "Living for the Audience of One", endorsed by Archbishop Ignatius Pinto, Archbishop Emeritus of Bangalore and released by Bishop Camillo Ballin, Vicar Apostolic of Kuwait*****. Dom has produced a song "When innocence is stolen" for the nun who was gang raped in Orissa. This song was higly [sic] appreciated around the world and was endorsed by Archbishop Raphael Cheenath of Orissa.
Dom's cry: Lord Jesus, give me the YOUTH of this world or I will die!
Dr. Dominic F. Dixon
****See , "an international volunteer movement of Christians from many backgrounds" but not a single testimonial from a Catholic priest or Catholic ministry though all shades of Protestant/Pentecostal "churches" are included. See also .
*****This was probably through the intervention of HSI's Mr. Aneel Aranha whose web site notes that his ministry is approved by the Vicariate of Arabia.
Critique of psychologist Dominic Dixon’s book by another psychologist
*[From the top of this letter, point A.] Please read the extract below which is taken from my report titled
SANGAM INTEGRAL FORMATION AND SPIRITUALITY CENTRE, GOA-NEW AGE PSYCHOLOGY, ETC. JULY 2009
EXTRACT
THE BEAUTIFUL CHRISTIAN MIND BY DR. DOMINIC DIXON
The New Leader, August 16-31, 2007, Book Review: The Beautiful Christian Mind by Dominic F. Dixon, ATC Publications, Bangalore. The book is reviewed by Fr. Emmanuel Arockiam, SJ**. I now copy the review:
The title of the book, "The Beautiful Christian Mind: Deliverance From Mental Illness" is indicative of the author’s leaning toward a Christian understanding of mental illness. The author looks at various illnesses of the mind such as depression, schizophrenia, etc. through the glass of faith. Sounding like a spirited Pentecostal preacher, the author, Dominic Dixon, who is involved in the Ministry of Evangelization and Reconciliation (MORE) advocates passionately that we should acknowledge our need for God’s healing touch and deliverance from the devil. Using many snippets from his experience in his spiritual healing ministry, he asserts that mental illnesses are not caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain but by the demon’s vicious torments. Hence, claiming that mental illnesses may not be cured by medication and psychotherapy as practiced by professional psychologists and counselors, the author argues that the healing of the oppressed mind can happen only through biblical counseling.
As he believes that mental and physical illnesses can also be God’s way of disciplining and chastening his people when they go against Him, he recommends that we must be ready for the 'spiritual warfare' with the devil, who is our 'enemy'. The devil for the author is not a habit or mental state but a person equipped with knowledge, will, emotion and ability to speak.
While the book might be of interest and some help to those involved in pastoral healing ministry, the content and the tone of the book will be jarring to anyone with a professional training in psychiatry or counselling and those who do not take the words of the Bible literally or believe that demons are persons.
Though spirituality is a 'core category' in anyone’s life, and faith plays an important role in physical and mental wellbeing, we cannot easily ignore the modern medical research on neurochemical changes in the brain that can be controlled by certain medications. Though references to people who have recovered are galore in this book, the author has not explained in detail the process of helping people with mental illness. Fr. Emmanuel Arockiam
**The New Leader, May 16-31, 2009: "M. A. Emmanuel Arockiam, SJ., did his Ph. D. in Counseling Psychology in the U.S. He is currently teaching psychology-related courses and practising counseling at Loyola Institute of Business Administration, Chennai. He teaches part time at Satya Nilayam [the Jesuit philosophate, Chennai] and facilitates group therapy at the Sadhana Institute***, Lonavala.
MY COMMENTS: I do not intend to analyze here the contents of Dr. Dominic Dixon’s book though he sent me a copy for my library. Rather, I will analyze just one point of Fr. Emmanuel Arockiam’s review of the book, a point that he stresses all too often. To me, the Jesuit’s comments appear to be based on his personal belief -- one that is shared today by many priests and apparently by most priest-psychologists -- that the devil does not exist, at least not as a personal entity "equipped with knowledge, will, emotion and ability to speak", and that he [the priest] does not accept the reality of 'spiritual warfare'. [The words that the priest chose to put in inverted commas in his review, reveal his mind.] For the priest, the devil or evil is purely a habit or a mental state – to use his words -- and psychological counseling with medication is the solution.
It is difficult to understand why the priest, reviewing in a Catholic magazine a book written by a Catholic lay person and published by a Catholic publishing house, would consider the hypothetical reaction of "those who do not take the words of the Bible literally or believe that demons are persons"; unless he is one of that number.
While I might agree with the priest in that it would be irrational to blame the devil for all emotional problems and to completely reject psychiatry and medicine for just biblical counseling alone, I must also disagree with his anti-Christian secular humanistic approach. But then, that is what one must expect from modern psychoanalytical approaches to the problems that beset the human condition, even those that might be related to unrepented [or the effects of even repented] sin, unforgiveness, guilt, etc.
***The Jamshedpur Jesuits’ Newsletter, August 2002, records NLP programmes at Sadhana Institute. There is also a course titled "The Embodying Experience". Without any doubt, there will be other New Age courses.
END OF LETTER TO FR. FAUSTINE LOBO
RESPONSE FROM FR. FAUSTINE LOBO
From: Faustine Lobo To: prabhu Sent: Sunday, November 11, 2012 12:13 PM Subject: Re: THE APPARENT MISUSE OF YOUR NAME AND THE NAME OF THE VATICAN IN LAY MINISTRIES ACTIVE IN BANGALORE
Dear Mr. Michael Prabhu,
Thank you very much for the detailed note. I am going through the same and I will do the needful on my part.
With warm regards,
Fr. Faustine L. Lobo
National Director, PMS India
This was the last I heard from Fr. Faustine Lobo, despite reminders, thus necessitating this report.
[Visit this ministry’s web site for a number of reports and articles on psychology and psycho-spiritualities]
8.
MORELOVE/HSI LAUNCHES A BIBLE COLLEGE IN BANGALORE WITH THE BLESSINGS OF ARCHBISHOP BERNARD MORAS
From: prabhu To: faustinelobo@yahoo.in Sent: Tuesday, December 11, 2012 6:45 PM
Subject: DOMINIC DIXON'S BIBLE COLLEGE
Dear Fr Faustine,
A month has lapsed since I received your kind letter. Do you have anything more to share with me about the results of your inquiry and your intervention if any?
You may be aware that Mr. Dominic Dixon has launched a Bible College with the blessing of the Archbishop of Bangalore, see the picture below.
Yours in Jesus' Name,
Michael Prabhu
From: prabhu To: faustinelobo@yahoo.in ; pmsindia66@ Sent: Saturday, December 15, 2012 4:19 AM
Subject: REMINDER PLEASE: DOMINIC DIXON'S BIBLE COLLEGE / SEE THE FOLLOWING EMAIL TO YOU FROM ME
From: prabhu To: faustinelobo@yahoo.in ; pmsindia66@ Sent: Saturday, December 15, 2012 4:22 AM
Subject: Fw: FW: CATHOLIC BIBLE COLLEGE FOR THE LAITY/ DOMINIC DIXON'S BIBLE COLLEGE
,
Dear Father,
You are included as "Pontifical Missions Advisor"
Kind regards, Michael
Fr. Faustine Lobo declined to respond to the above three successive letters to him.
SOME INFORMATION RETRIEVED, ëTHOS INSTITUTE LINKS AS ON DECEMBER 15, 2012
Dedicated to and under the Patronage of His Holiness, Blessed John Paul II
CHIEF PATRON
His Grace Most Rev. Dr. Bernard Moras, Archbishop of Bangalore, DD.
Spiritual Director
Rev. Fr. A. Sagayanathan, Parish Priest - St. Patrick’s Church
Pontifical Missions Advisor
Rev. Fr. Faustine Lobo - Dir. Pontifical Missions
Office
Horace Fernandes - Registrar
Martina Charles, PCP- Office Executive
Family Council
Simon Rodrigues, CA
Ethics & Pro-Life
Dr. Gerry Abreo (Chair)
Campus Council
Dr. Rev. Sis. Genevieve Secretary, State Education
Michael Jebaraj
Women Empowerment
Andrea Alphonso, BA, MBA, D.PG -Bible
Julia Coutinho, . MBA
Ecumenical Panel for Peace & Unity
Dr. Siga Arles, Ph.D. (Missiology) (Chair)
Rev. K. Vasudevan, Pres. Bethany High
Michael Jebaraj, Director - Faith Ventures
Scholarship Research Team
Dr. Dominic Dixon, D. Psych - Chair
Faculty/ Research Team
Desmond Cotter BA(His) BA(Phil), D.PG-Theology
Varun Menezes, BE, MBA, (D.PG-Bib. Studies)
Neil Richard BBM, EDP, (D.PG-Theology)
Christian Business Ethics
Ralph Coutinho, B.E, MBA, (D. PG Canon Law) DVK Pontificial [sic] Athenaeum
Child Development Research
Sabrina Fernandes, , PCP, TOB
Family Development Research
Rev. Fr. Arul Raj (Chair)
Horace Fernandes, BA, BBM, PCP, D.PG- Counselling
Leadership Development
Colin Calmiano, Dir. Spread your wings**
Michael Jebaraj - Dir. Christian Management
The names of the two priests Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj on the ëthos team were deleted from the above web page after my letter to Fr. Faustine Lobo. What does that say?
There is no priest and no theologian on the ëthos Institute team.
At least three members of the team are Protestants.
[pic]
Email received from ëthos:
From: registrar@ Subject: CATHOLIC BIBLE COLLEGE FOR THE LAITY Date: Thu, 29 Nov 2012
[pic][pic]
**From: prabhu To: Colin Calmiano Sent: Saturday, December 15, 2012 4:26 AM
Subject: FW: CATHOLIC BIBLE COLLEGE FOR THE LAITY
Dear Colin, Can you please confirm to me whether or not you are -- as Dr Dixon advertises -- "Leadership Development
Colin Calmiano, Dir. Spread your wings" at his new BIBLE COLLEGE? Thank you, Michael
From: Colin Calmiano To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, December 15, 2012 8:14 AM
Subject: Re: FW: CATHOLIC BIBLE COLLEGE FOR THE LAITY
Yes Michael, I was requested by Dominic. God bless, Colin
[Colin Calmiano: SPREAD YOUR WINGS (Institute for Growth & Development), Bangalore, leads the People of Praise Covenant Community which is affiliated to Sword of the Spirit, an international community.]
On December 19, I wrote a cautionary letter to Colin Calmiano who declined to respond.
EXTRACT:
MoreLove is under the authority of the Archdiocese of Bangalore.
Seemingly, the Church has somehow skipped the chapter of Academics for the Laity [??], to respond to a more profound understanding of the mystery of salvation in Christ. This urgently calls for higher studies and scholarship. ETHOS Institute aims at complimenting [sic] the Church in conducting such
studies in accordance with Catholic doctrine as held by the Magisterium of the Catholic Church.
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: Dom's Friends Sent: Thursday, August 14, 2008 5:23 PM
Subject: FOUR GLORIOUS YEARS
This 15th August we celebrate FOUR glorious years in Ministry. […]
10.
We now have a three story [sic] building with our Radio station, guest house and a full fledged Missions centre.
Their site says:
HSI MoreLove Institute is located in the heart of the City, downtown central of Bangalore. Attached to the campus is St. Patrick’s Church, and an Adoration Chapel. The campus has a parking capacity for over 100 cars. It also has an elevator. The campus has a Wi-Fi internet facility.
The wordings can be misleading. HSI MoreLove occupies rented commercial space along with other business establishments on the third floor of a building among other buildings in a campus adjacent to St. Patrick’s Church, Bangalore, which has car parking space, etc. for common use as per a commercial agreement.
[pic] [pic]
"ëthos Institute, HSI MoreLove Focus Centre, #4, 3rd Floor, 'A' Block"
As mentioned on page 7 of my letter to Fr. Faustine Lobo, here are some links to just five of Dr. Dominic Dixon’s online attacks on the International Catholic Programme for Evangelization [ICPE], Bangalore, and its Director, Fritz Mascarenhas. Colin Calmiano, on the preceding page, was the next senior leader in ICPE for many years. [The information and links are samples of several more that I have in my archives.] The reader will notice that they are three years apart. For a ministry that claims Archdiocesan approval and Vatican ambassadorship and preaches ethics and morals and more, HSI MoreLove certainly does not give up on its slanderous campaigns against those it deems to be its enemies. Look out now for an assault on this ministry!
What transpired in June 2009 in Mangalorean Catholics [MC] a group known for its hundreds of anti-Catholic posts led by its owner Ancy D’Souza and Fr Claude Saldanha O.P., is interesting. (Fed up -- along with sometime MC moderator Derrick D’Costa of Bahrain who finally also quit, and a couple of other members -- of constantly defending the Church against the virulent posts of a lone Hindu member ganged up with a handful of Church-haters including the liberal priest already named, I unsubscribed a few years ago. [Though I have repeatedly cited proof of that to MC members, Mr. Paladka, to save face, falsely claims that I was banned!] However, since I continue to be subscribed under an alternative email address, I remain privy to the goings-on at MC. Before I unsubscribed,) Mr. Paladka privately passed on to me a message from Dominic Dixon in which Dominic Dixon threatened to take legal action against MC! The said threat was made not against anything concerning the Catholic faith but against a comment I wrote on a thread which simply discussed the reason why Indian immigrants in Australia were being racially targeted! See pages 23 ff.
Mr. Dixon will know that I am aware of that threat to MC only when he reads this report.
In his February 2007 MC posts, Mr. Dixon’s pretends that he is actually posting a report made by another investigator. However, MC member Joel Fernandes*, a personal friend of mine who knows Dominic Dixon and Fritz Mascarenhas, and served in BOTH their ministries, saw through Mr. Dixon’s subterfuge. He wrote:
*From: Joel G Fernandes To: prabhu Sent: Sunday, February 25, 2007 2:34 PM Subject: Re: UNCONDITIONALLY SORRY!
EXTRACT: The Report** was made by Dom himself and claims that it was prepared by some journalists and investigators. That is a humongous lie… Dom is the mastermind with his penchant for creating havoc in people's lives… Slandering, insulting, bad-mouthing are but just a few of his traits…
I believe that Joel speaks true.
**EXPOSURE: Freedom from Fascism and Fritzism!
February 19, 2007
February 21, 2007
February 22, 2007
The contents of these links can be found on pages 31-33. 11.
I have received emails from another such fake journalist, "Sunder Dass", who wrote me with an uncannily similar agenda, and vanished without a trace when I eventually requested his contact information. He was seeking my assistance in defaming the then chairman of the Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal Services, Mr. Anthony Sagayaraj. More of this can be read on pages 35 ff.
If deemed necessary, more of Dr Dominic Dixon’s slanderous attacks on Catholics in ministry, exaggerated statements and falsehoods, along with related letters to this ministry from reputable individuals, will be included in an update to this report. [SEE THE UPDATES ON PAGES 30 FF.]
Some correspondence between Francis Lobo and Fr. Faustine Lobo prior to my Nov. 5 meeting with the latter
From: Francis Lobo To: pmsindia66@ Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2012 8:59 PM
Subject: Need Clarification on VATICAN APPROVED LAY MINISTRY
Dear Father,
I am Francis Lobo, belong to St. Antony Parish in Bangalore. Recently I attended a program conducted by a lay minister in a particular parish. What he claims that he is an official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical and member of the International Association for Deliverance which works in association with the International Association for Exorcism in the Vatican. I asked the clarification to the same Lay minister and he replied "The Vatican does not certify or endorse an individual but it recognizes Ministries that have been operational for minimum of 10 years with good standing. The process is a legal process as it deals with the Canon Law. The Vatican conducts programs on deliverance, etc. The prerequisite is that you should have been in deliverance for several years, with documentation and certification from the Vatican officials in India. You would be pleased to know that we will be conducting programs on the Vatican documents as we've been authorized to run an Institute for the Laity". On my further clarification, he did not answer my questions but asked me to speak to my spiritual director. I never saw a ministry which has direct official recognition from Vatican except this one.
Dear Father, can [you] please provide the clarification for the below questions.
1) Can a Lay ministry directly get the approval from Vatican?
2) How can a lay minister approach the legal (CANON LAW) process to get approval from Vatican? What is the role of Canon law in this matter?
3) Who is the Vatican official who is liable to approve the lay ministry in India?
4) What is the dos and don’ts of a Lay ministry which has official approval from Vatican?
From: Pontifical Mission Society To: fsunillobo@
Date: Wed, Oct 17, 2012 at 11:50 AM Subject: Re: Need Clarification on VATICAN APPROVED LAY MINISTRY
Dear Mr. Francis Lobo,
I need further explanation about this particular person to tell everything precisely.
But for your general understanding, no one is given any status by Vatican unless his/her case is recommended by the Bishop of the Diocese concerned. If he says that he has obtained it directly from Rome by himself that is a false claim. In that case he has to produce a valid certificate to this effect. There is no such official position in the Church called 'Lay Ministry'. If officially someone has to be appointed as a 'Lay Minister', the Diocesan Bishop does it according to the need of the Diocese and Rome is not doing it directly without the knowledge of the bishop of the Diocese concerned.
I hope I have satisfied you to the extent the explanation that you have given me. Fr. Faustine L. Lobo, Director, PMS India
On Fri, Oct 19, 2012 at 7:57 AM, Francis Lobo wrote:
Thanks Father I am convinced with your answer. I will meet personally and share the more in detail. Please do let me know if you are free on 5th November at your convenient time. If you are not available on 5th November, I will meet you on 6th November after 2 PM. Please do let me know your convenient time. Regards Francis Sunil Lobo
On Fri, Oct 19, 2012 at 9:10 AM, Pontifical Mission Society wrote:
Dear Mr. Francis, I am available on the 5th of November. You may come anytime but before coming please give me a call.
My No.: 98455 76410. Fr. Faustine L. Lobo
From: fsunillobo@ To: Pontifical Mission Society Date: Tue, Nov 6, 2012 at 6:51 AM
Subject: Re: Need Clarification on VATICAN APPROVED LAY MINISTRY
Dear Father, Thank you very much for your meeting with Michael in my absence. I am ready to provide more information if you need any. Regards, Francis Sunil Lobo
UPDATE FEBRUARY 14, 2013
This morning, I have blacked out three lines on page 6 of this report pending a reply to an enquiry from this ministry with the alleged department of the "Vatican [that] conducts programs on deliverance" “under the Vatican Council". [The lines were later restored. Find the responses from the "department" below***.]
From: Name Withheld To: prabhu Sent: Wednesday, February 13, 2013 9:22 PM
Subject: Re: LATEST INFORMATION ADDED AT OUR WEB SITE
Thanks for the email received. I was just recently having a conversation from a member of Bangalore Service Team wherein he was sharing his concern over the Dixon ministries which he felt was highly objectionable but having full permission of bishop and priest and being conducted at St. Patrick’s church. Hence I am happy for the matter you have sent and have forwarded it. Am sure it will be helpful. There is a lot you have sent and will slowly go through the rest when time permits. God bless your efforts! Catholic Charismatic Renewal Services, Mangalore. 12.
NOTE: PAGES 11 AND 12 OF THE ORIGINAL REPORT WERE MODIFIED ON MARCH 20, 2013 BECAUSE OF AN ERRONEOUS STATEMENT MADE BY THIS MINISTRY. ON CLOSER SCRUTINY, THE ERROR WAS NOTICED AND THIS REPORT HAS BEEN CORRECTED ACCORDINGLY. THE ERROR IS REGRETTED. THE ERRONEOUS STATEMENT HAS BEEN EXPUNGED AND IT HAS BEEN SUBSTITUTED WITH DETAILED INFORMATION ON THE PAGES INDICATED -- IN BLUE COLOUR -- AT THE BOTTOM OF PAGE NO. 11 AND TOP OF PAGE NO. 12.
UPDATES MARCH 12/15, 2013
Criminal behaviour of the “official Ambassador of the Vatican's official Encyclical”, “ambassador for the views of the Holy Father” and Catholic ministry “under the authority of the Archdiocese of Bangalore”
PHONE-TAPPING, GANGSTER-HIRING AND ARREST-WARRANT THREATS
Around noon today, Mr. Francis Lobo received on his cell phone an SMS from +91 98805 36501. It was from Dominic Dixon asking Francis to contact Simon Rodrigues, Chairman of the Service Team of the Charismatic Renewal Services in Bangalore for necessary clarifications regarding the Ethos Institute, etc. Apparently Mr. Dixon has only now become aware of this report [which we have not sent to individuals on our mailing list].
Later, Francis Lobo received a 32-minute call originating from the same number. During the conversation, Mr. Dixon flaunted his media and political contacts and threatened to take Mr. Lobo to court because of his being associated with the filing of this report. Mr. Dixon informed Mr. Lobo that he had tapped Mr. Lobo’s phone and recorded his conversation with Fr. A. Sagayanathan, parish priest of St. Patrick's Church. Unless I am mistaken, the unauthorised tapping of an individual’s telephone is a criminal offence. Interestingly, Mr. Lobo has never spoken with Fr. A. Sagayanathan either on the telephone or personally even though he has attended Masses celebrated by the priest. It has never been claimed in this report that Mr. Lobo had ever contacted Fr. Sagayanathan. The wider implications of this are that Mr. Dixon has got Mr. Lobo’s telephone under surveillance ["tapped"] for a very long time now, even before Mr. Lobo first enquired about MoreLove, according to his [Mr. Dixon’s] own claim of course. Now, why would he have wanted to do such a thing? Does he routinely put randomly selected fellow-Catholics in Bangalore under surveillance in anticipation of future 'threats' to his "ministries"?
Whatever the answer to that riddle, this latest revelation does nothing to flatter the profile of a person in lay ministry and heading a Bible Institute which is recognised and supported by the local leaders of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, covenant communities like that of Colin Calmiano, and the Archbishop of Bangalore.
These church leaders might consider the possibility that their phones might be tapped by their associate Mr. Dixon and that in the event of their falling out with Mr. Dixon, his response would be to take them to commission gangsters to physically assault them, or to take them to court.
***Correspondence with the alleged "department of the 'Vatican [that] conducts programs on deliverance'"; my letters to Ms. Erika Gibello and her responses:
From: prabhu To: Erika Gibello Cc: Francis Lobo Sent: Wednesday, February 13, 2013 6:38 AM
Subject: Re: IS THIS CORRECT WHAT THESE MINISTRIES ARE DOING?
From: Michael Prabhu To: Erika Gibello Sent: Tuesday, March 12, 2013 2:44 PM Subject: DOMINIC DIXON
You forgot to give your final reply to my letter of February 13 on this man.
A couple of hours ago, he called my web master Francis Lobo who also works with me on many Catholic issues along with Croydon D’Souza who met you in London last month, and threatened that he is going to file a court case against him because I published a critical report about Dixon's ministries on my web site. Francis had done a bit of the initial investigation for me at my request and he gave permission for me to use his name in the report. Dixon spoke for half an hour threatening how he has high contacts etc. etc. I told you what he is like. He is very cheap and dangerous. He told Francis that he has tapped his phone! Sent to Ms. Gibello with MORELOVE document
From: Erika Gibello To: 'Michael Prabhu' Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 11:07 PM Subject: RE: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Dear Michael, I simply will not renew Dixon’s Membership to IAD. To add, IAD is not an official Vatican approved private association; hence Dixon’s claims are uninformed. I will inform him and tell him to close his membership. I will state that Fr Rufus has departed and hence the Indian Membership might not be possible anymore. Thank for informing me.
From: Erika Gibello To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 11:31 PM Subject: Re: DOMINIC DIXON
I have already answered what I will do with Dixon. This type of people cannot and should not be confronted head on. He might be psychotic. He is not a "good friend". All he did was contacting me and wanting to be a member of IAD, I did not realise to what purpose. He has not answered to my invitation to give a talk, and by now all the slots for talks are filled. I simply will not renew his membership. As I wrote this is not a "Vatican approved Association". It is simply a private association for the purpose of teaching and sharing in the ministry of deliverance by non-exorcist priests and lay people. 13.
As I had forecast, Mr. Dixon quickly made some modifications to one of his web sites on finding my report:
EXTRACT
Due to their hectic clergy responsibilities, Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj could not be a part of our team as initially requested and desired.
MORAL ADVISORS
Rev. Fr. Franklin D’Souza - National Director - ICYM
Rev. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel - Director - Delhi Catholic Archdiocese Communication Bureau
Alex Anthony- Mentor, Jesus Youth India
We may recall that Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj disassociated with MoreLove after reading this report.
On the basis of the first threat from 98805 36501, I wrote the following letters to the "MORAL ADVISORS"
1. Fr. Franklin D’Souza
Secretary CBCI Office for Youth
National Youth Director of ICYM – INDIA
icymnationaloffice@; franklinphillip@; coolfranklyn@; frfranklin1973@;
From: Michael Prabhu To: icymnationaloffice@ Cc: Fr. Franklin Dsouza ; Philip Franklyn Dsouza ; franklinphillip@ Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 10:14 AM Subject: MY CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR ASSOCIATION WITH MR. DOMINIC DIXON'S MORELOVE/ETHOS MINISTRIES, BANGALORE with MORELOVE document
Dear Rev. Fr. Franklin,
The following is a recently included extract from one of Mr. Dominic Dixon's web sites:
"Due to their hectic clergy responsibilities, Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj could not be a part of our team as initially requested and desired.
MORAL ADVISORS
Rev. Fr. Franklin Dsouza - National Director - ICYM"
I have published a report on Mr. Dominic Dixon which I am of the opinion you must read in totality, especially the last page entry in view of his recent claim that you are a "Moral Advisor" to his activities.
The said report is available at
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE 31 JANUARY/UPDATED 12 MARCH 2013
but is also attached herewith for your convenient access.
The report will be further updated in a few days.
What you must be informed about concerning the disassociation of Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj with Mr. Dixon/MoreLove is that they took that decision after Fr. Faustine Lobo received and read a copy of this report as requested by him and then informed Fr. Arulraj.
The two priests' names were then removed from Mr. Dixon's web site.
A couple of days ago, Mr. Dixon came to learn about my report, made some changes on the web site*, and telephoned one of my web masters Mr. Francis Lobo yesterday, threatening him with legal action and informing him that he [Mr. Dixon] had tapped the telephone of Mr. Lobo apparently since a long time ago. While these last details are on page 28 of the said report, you can confirm the veracity of my statements by calling Mr. Francis Lobo on 0 98453 58358.
God bless you,
Yours obediently,
Michael Prabhu
*Details of the other changes on Mr. Dixon's web site will be included in an update to the report
From: "icym national office" To:
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 10:15 AM
Subject: Thank You Re: MY CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR ASSOCIATION WITH MR. DOMINIC DIXON'S MORELOVE/ETHOS MINISTRIES, BANGALORE
Thank You for Your Mail. We will get back to you as soon as possible.
,
Indian Catholic Youth Movement
CBCI Office for Youth
CBCI Centre
1 Ashok Place, Gol Dak Khana
New Delhi - 110001
Tel: 011-23340773/23344470
Fax: 011-23715146/23364615
2. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel SVD
DIRECTOR AND SPOKESPERSON, COMMUNICATION/INFORMATION BUREAU, DELHI ARCHDIOCESE
svddelhi@; cibdelhi@; frdominic@;
14.
From: Michael Prabhu To: svddelhi@ ; cibdelhi@ Cc: frdominic@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 10:22 AM Subject: MY CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR ASSOCIATION WITH MR. DOMINIC DIXON'S MORELOVE/ETHOS MINISTRIES, BANGALORE with MORELOVE document
Dear Rev. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel,
The following is a recently included extract from one of Mr. Dominic Dixon's web sites:
"Due to their hectic clergy responsibilities, Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj could not be a part of our team as initially requested and desired.
MORAL ADVISORS…
Rev. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel - Director - Delhi Catholic Archdiocese Communication Bureau"… [As above]
After a second threatening call to Mr. Francis Lobo at 10:30 am on March 13, this time from mobile telephone number 96860 99777, informing him that a local gangster Muthappa Rai had been hired to attack him, I dispatched the following letters:
1. From: Michael Prabhu To: icymnationaloffice@ Cc: franklinphillip@ ; Philip Franklyn Dsouza ; Fr. Franklin Dsouza Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 11:29 AM with MORELOVE document
Subject: LATEST INFORMATION: MY SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR ASSOCIATION WITH MR. DOMINIC DIXON
Secretary, CBCI Office for Youth
National Youth Director of ICYM – INDIA
Dear Rev. Fr. Franklin,
At 10:30 am today, Mr. Francis Lobo [0 98453 58358], Bangalore, received a call from mobile number 96860 99777.
The caller claimed that he belonged to some association and was speaking on behalf of Mr. Dominic Dixon and questioned him about his association with me and his involvement in this ministry's report on MoreLove/Ethos Institute. He spoke for around 15 minutes.
The anonymous caller informed Mr. Francis Lobo that a notorious local thug named Muthappa Rai was being hired by them to deal with Mr. Francis Lobo.
The entire issue is gravitating into a potential police case, what with the claim of phone-tapping and all.
You will note that in my report we had foreseen this eventuality because Mr. Dixon has orchestrated vicious Internet slander campaigns against Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas and the seminarians of the International Catholic Programme for Evangelization [ICPE] and has published cooked-up news reports against others, written by fictitious journalists.
It is good that you know the true nature of the person you are dealing with, a man who claims to be an evangelist, a Bible exponent, a psychologist, and who is certified by the Vatican according to his web site.
It would help us to know your views on the matter. With kind regards,
Michael Prabhu
2. From: Michael Prabhu To: cibdelhi@ ; svddelhi@ Cc: frdominic@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 11:37 AM Subject: LATEST INFORMATION: MY SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT YOUR ASSOCIATION WITH MR. DOMINIC DIXON with MORELOVE document
DIRECTOR AND SPOKESPERSON, COMMUNICATION/INFORMATION BUREAU, DELHI ARCHDIOCESE
Dear Rev. Fr. Dominic… [As above]
3. From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: ccbi@airtelmail.in ; cbcisec@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:34 PM and March 13, 2013 12:53 PM with MORELOVE document
Subject: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
MOST REV. BERNARD MORAS
ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE
Dear Archbishop Bernard Moras,
According to the web site of Mr. Dominic Dixon, his books and "ministry" activities are blessed and supported by you. Accordingly, you need to be informed of the following recent grave developments concerning this person.
From my Chennai-based ministry, which you are well aware of though you have not deigned to respond to a single one of a score of letters/reports from us from the day you assumed office, I have published a report on Mr. Dominic Dixon which I am of the opinion you must read in totality. The said report is available at MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE 31 JANUARY/UPDATED 12 MARCH 2013
but is also attached herewith for your convenient access.
However, we believe that Fr. Faustine Lobo, National Director, Pontifical Mission Societies-India, who is apprised of the situation since over four months, must have already communicated with you on this issue as was anticipated of him.
A couple of days ago, Mr. Dixon came to learn about my report, made some quick modifications on the web site*, and telephoned one of my two Bangalore-based web masters Mr. Francis Lobo yesterday, threatening him with legal action and informing him that he [Mr. Dixon] had tapped the telephone of Mr. Lobo apparently since a long time ago. He provided details of the calls that he had alleged tapped. Mr. Lobo had also received an SMS from the same number which is recorded as +91 9880536501.
At 10:30 am today, Mr. Francis Lobo, Bangalore, received a call from mobile number 96860 99777.
The caller claimed that he belonged to some association and was speaking on behalf of Mr. Dominic Dixon and questioned him about his association with me and his involvement in this ministry's report on MoreLove/Ethos Institute. He spoke for around 15 minutes.
The anonymous caller informed Mr. Francis Lobo that a notorious local thug named Muthappa Rai has been hired by them to conduct retribution on Mr. Francis Lobo.
The entire issue is gravitating into a potential police case, what with the claim of phone-surveillance and all.
You will note that in my report we had foreseen this eventuality because Mr. Dixon has orchestrated vicious Internet slander campaigns against Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas and the then seminarians of the International Catholic Programme for Evangelization [ICPE] and has published cooked-up news reports against others, written by fictitious journalists.
It is good that you know the true nature of the person you are promoting, a man who claims to be an evangelist, a Bible exponent, a psychologist, and who is certified by the Vatican according to his web site.
It would help us to know your views on the matter.
You may confirm the veracity of my statements by calling Mr. Francis Lobo on 98453 58358.
Yours obediently,
Michael Prabhu, Catholic apologist, michaelprabhu@; ephesians-
*Details of the modifications made on Mr. Dixon's web site will be included in an update to the existing report
CC: CCBI Secretary, Bangalore; CBCI Secretary, New Delhi
Sorry, the Dominic Dixon report was inadvertently not attached. Please find it herewith.
4. From: Michael Prabhu To: pmsindia66@ ; faustinelobo@yahoo.in
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:46 PM and March 13, 2013 12:54 PM with MORELOVE document
Subject: Fw: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Dear Fr. Faustine Lobo,
You declined to acknowledge my follow-up letters to you after responding to my first communication.
Not hearing from you, I could not be sure if appropriate follow-up was being done at the archdiocesan level and I was morally obliged to make public my report at my web site after a wait of about three months.
If you remember, I had warned you of the serious dangers of anyone's tangling with Mr. Dominic Dixon.
Now, I have the unpleasant task of updating you on the situation regarding this Bangalore archdiocese evangelist.
With regards,
Michael Prabhu
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: ccbi@airtelmail.in ; cbcisec@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:34 PM
Subject: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
MOST REV. BERNARD MORAS
ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE
Dear Archbishop Bernard Moras… [As above]
Sorry, the Dominic Dixon report was inadvertently not attached. Please find it herewith.
Fr. Faustine Lobo’s response may be viewed two pages below, on page 18.
My letter to the national leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from the archdiocese of Bombay whose letter instituted the initial inquiry, and the leader’s response at the bottom of this page:
From: Michael Prabhu To: Name withheld Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 1:23 PM Subject: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Here is information bringing you up-to-date on Dominic Dixon-MoreLove/Aneel Aranha-HIS.
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: ccbi@airtelmail.in ; cbcisec@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:34 PM with MORELOVE document
Subject: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
MOST REV. BERNARD MORAS
ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE
Dear Archbishop Bernard Moras… [As above]
From: Michael Prabhu To: pmsindia66@ ; faustinelobo@yahoo.in Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:46 PM
Subject: Fw: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Dear Fr. Faustine Lobo… [As above]
From: Name withheld To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 6:45 PM Subject: Re: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Thank you for keeping me updated. This is truly shocking news. At a time when the whole Church is praying for a new Holy Father, when we need to come before God in repentance and sorrow, such behaviour is deplorable. Please pray for your protection as well. Assuring you of my prayers, Mumbai
16.
My letter to Fr. Adolf Washington, Bangalore, President of the Indian Catholic Press Association [ICPA],
Managing Director and Editor-in-Chief of South Asian Religious [SAR] News Agency run by the ICPA, Public Relations Officer of Bangalore Archdiocese and Director of Communications in the Archdiocese.
From: Michael Prabhu To: washingtonadolf@ ; Fr. Adolf Washington Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 1:48 PM
Subject: Fw: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE with MORELOVE document
Dear Rev. Fr. Adolf Washington,
I am bringing you up-to-date on Dominic Dixon-MoreLove/Aneel Aranha-HSI. If you recall, he is the one who addressed you in an email as "Hitler" on 24 May 2007, and copied that email to others*.
With regards,
Michael Prabhu
Catholic apologist, Chennai FR. ADOLF WASHINGTON TELEPHONED ME ON MARCH 16, 2013
*From: Dominic Dixon To: Michael Prabhu ; Dr. Siga Arles ; Fr. Adolf Washington Sent: Thursday, May 24, 2007 8:40 PM Subject: PHONE CALL
Dear Fr. Adolf Hitler, [emphasis mine]
In regards to your phone call this evening, I'm responding. You had called and told me that something is either 'spiritually' or 'mentally' wrong with me. Well, I'm a member of the IAD under the Vatican [emphasis mine] and approved as a deliverance minister. I'm a Psychologist and administer that way. So, sir, please discern before you speak out words of destruction. If I had a problem in the past with anyone, it's between that person(s) and I [sic]. If you can contribute, pls do so in reconciliation and not destruction/ you also told me to hold my guns and to also tell Dr. Arles and Prabhu to hold their guns. You were threatening on the phone. Why don't you tell them yourself? You may have the name of a dictator, but you cannot dictate things to me, it won't work! You said that some people on the mailing list said some things about me, well you wrote about them in your newsprint and we heard what they had to say about that/ Pls stop all these unpleasant things, you should know that better – being [sic] a Priest
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: ccbi@airtelmail.in ; cbcisec@
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:34 PM
Subject: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
MOST REV. BERNARD MORAS
ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE
Dear Archbishop Bernard Moras… [As above]
From: Michael Prabhu To: pmsindia66@ ; faustinelobo@yahoo.in
Sent: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 12:46 PM
Subject: Fw: CRIMINAL ACTS OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE, BANGALORE ARCHDIOCESE
Dear Fr. Faustine Lobo… [As above]
Having read Mr. Dixon’s rude letter to Fr. Adolf Washington, an eminent priest, I reproduce for the reader the related correspondence between me and Fr. Adolf Washington -- and a letter that Dixon did not answer:
From: prabhu To: Dominic Dixon ; Dr. Siga Arles ; Fr. Adolf Washington Sent: Sunday, May 27, 2007 10:38 AM
Subject: Re: PHONE CALL
Dear all, I am back online only today, so I do not know if there has been any further correspondence on this issue.
So, let me apologize on behalf of Dom for the language and words chosen by him to write to Fr. Adolf.
We may not agree with one another on everything, but we are primarily Christians, followers of Jesus, called to serve and to witness. Hostility and confrontation are regressive and counter-productive.
We may want to express our views strongly and firmly, but please let us do so in a spirit of love.
There is so much of attack on our Faith and on the Church. United we stand, divided we fall. It is not from Scripture, but very true.
Dom, may I humbly request you to go over, meet Fr. Adolf, reconcile with him, and let us move together forward unitedly from there. [Emphases mine]
Love, Michael
From: Dr. Siga Arles To: prabhu ; Dominic Dixon ; Fr. Adolf Washington Sent: Sunday, May 27, 2007 12:31 PM
Subject: Re: PHONE CALL
Wonderful. I agree with the content of this mail 100%.Thanks for the spirit and wisdom of this mail. I pray that Dom will have the grace of God to walk in the light. Dear Dom, I wish you well as you walk humbly with God and take leadership on sensitive issues. To tackle such, you should not allow your mind to get disturbed much. Keep cool. Take it easy. Laugh in His Spirit. Love - yes that is the cement. Let us march together for God's glory and people's welfare. Fr. Adolf Washington, I am sure you will reach out to Dom! Keen to get to meet you dear children of God.
From: prabhu To: adolf washington Sent: Monday, May 28, 2007 9:46 AM Subject: FROM MICHAEL
Dear Fr. Adolf, I pray that you get your problem sorted out quickly. Victor Satish [ICPE] and Nalini used to tell me a lot about you, and Victor had suggested several times that I meet with you and make you aware about my ministry. I wonder if he spoke to you about me. I had also been invited by Fr. CM Paul SDB to attend the ICPA meeting in Bangalore on May 5, but I could not make it because of insufficient lead time, having already scheduled visits to Mangalore and Kochi from the 12th. I co-edit a Tamil/English fortnightly called The Catholic Times. Love and Prayers, Michael. 17.
From: adolf washington To: prabhu Sent: Monday, May 28, 2007 10:01 AM Subject: Re: FROM MICHAEL
Thank you for your mail. We will meet and see how we can do great things for our great God.
I understand that you are well acquainted with Dominic Dickson but I’m sorry I had to say things that I felt, about him.
I have told Dominic several times that I see a serious contradiction with his disposition and his ministry.
I have gone through a tough (very tough time) and much embarrassment for telling him what was wrong about the way he talks to people and about himself and his ministry. [Emphasis mine] Regards, Fr. Adolf
From: prabhu To: adolf washington Sent: Monday, May 28, 2007 5:45 PM Subject: Re: FROM MICHAEL
Dear Fr. Adolf,
I cannot say that I know Dom that well. I met him for about 10 minutes over three years ago at the KAIROS program in Chennai, and we started corresponding by email in October 2005.
Yes, I agree completely with your observations, and I have painfully watched him slowly destroying himself and his good ministry. On a couple of occasions, when he revealed his particular plans to me, I have given him some advice which he took and so avoided even more trouble for himself. But on other occasions where he has not shared with me, I was helpless.
So far he has not responded to my letter to you both on his calling you "Hitler". I admire you for the restraint that you exercised in your response. I cannot say that I might have remained so cool!! [Emphasis mine]
I know some very good and sincere people associated with Dom, like Sunil Jose for instance. Again, Dom has, unlike the mainstream charismatic renewal that doesn't do much for society in general, undertaken pro-action on several issues over the last few years. Since there are hardly any Catholics that venture out of their safe, insulated ministries, I have morally supported Dom in what he does, as long as he is faithful to Church teaching and authority.
I am terribly and sincerely sorry for the way he wrote to you, and about you; and I pray that as a priest, you will be able to take him under your guidance. Even more I pray that he will humble himself and work WITH you. Love & Prayers, Michael
From: adolf washington To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, May 29, 2007 8:56 AM Subject: Re: FROM MICHAEL
Thank you for your mail. I hope we meet someday. Regards, Fr Adolf
ON MARCH 14 AT 6:00 PM, I RECEIVED A CALL FROM AN 'INSPECTOR OF POLICE'. SPEAKING IN KANNADA, HE INFORMED ME THAT AN ARREST WARRANT HAS BEEN ISSUED AGAINST ME FOR "HARASSMENT". THE CALLER DEMANDED PERSONAL INFORMATION FROM ME WHICH I PROVIDED. MEANWHILE MR. FRANCIS LOBO RECEIVED A SERIES OF THREATENING ANONYMOUS CALLS, OBVIOUSLY ORCHESTRATED BY DOMINIC DIXON, ACCUSING HIM OF UNSPECIFIED CRIMINAL ACTS.
Here is the response of Fr. Faustine Lobo, National Director-Pontifical Mission Societies, and my reply to him.
Actually, his "response" to me was a forward of his response to Mr. Dominic Dixon who made an appeal to Fr. Faustine Lobo that was rejected by the priest. Mr. Dominic Dixon’s letter to Fr. Lobo is also copied here.
a) From: Faustine Lobo To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Friday, March 15, 2013 9:30 AM
Subject: Fw: FYI: False investigation
b) From: faustinelobo@yahoo.in To: domdix@ Sent: Friday, 15 March 2013 9:29 AM
Subject: Re: FYI: False investigation
Dear Mr. Dominic Dixon,
I feel that I can not serve your organization in any capacity as it is impossible for me to make time as I am too much involved in the activities of the Pontifical Mission Organization. Hence, I request you to leave out my name either from the list of consultors/Board members or from the faculty of the Ethos.
Hence, don't quote my name anywhere as the 'above mentioned' hereafter.
Fr. Faustine L. Lobo
c) From: Dominic Dixon domdix@ To: faustinelobo@yahoo.in Cc: simon_rodrigues@
Sent: Tuesday, 12 March 2013 2:10 PM Subject: FYI: False investigation
Dear Fr. Faustine,
Peace & Greetings.
Fr. Its [sic] has been brought to our intention [sic] that some elememts [sic] claiming to be Catholic investigators and supposidly [sic] guardians of the Catholic Church have been causing havoc and misunderstanding amongst the faithful for many years.
During our prayerful enquiry, we intercepted emails and phone conversation transcrips [sic] between these elements, yourself and others. [Emphasis mine] Namely Michael Prabhu from Chennai and Sunil Lobo from Bangalore.
Michael is not an approved ministry and neither does any diocese have an 'investigation commission.' This man has written against the Holy Father, against our Bishops and Priests. Michael in [sic] banned from attending Catholic conferences as he was last banned from the CCR Goa conference for earning a name as a mischief maker. 18.
In November, out of the blue, Sunil had asked me for our documents of approval and we had no idea who this man is. He only sent us mails but never wanted to meet us when we had invited him. We refused to give him any documents as we need to protect the integrity of the Church.
We had invited a Pastor as a speaker who is an expert in his area of teaching which is in line with the Eccumenism [sic] commission of the Archdiocese.
As a Ministry, we are an Association of Faith under the Vicariate of Arabia under the name Holy Spirit Interactive (Canon 312, 2/314/317) and approved by the Archdiocese of Bangalore.
As you know, we are in good standing and harmony with our Diocese. We are a registered Trust snd [sic] submit our audited reports to the Archbishop and Chairman of the BCCRS.
Please feel free to speak to Simon Rodrigues about this matter and the integrity of our standing. His number is +919342161851. Simon is copied in this mail.
Fr. Thank you for standing with us.
Love, Dom
Sent from Yahoo! Mail on Android
d) From: Michael Prabhu To: Faustine Lobo ; pmsindia66@ Cc: Francis Lobo
Sent: Friday, March 15, 2013 11:03 AM Subject: Re: FYI: False investigation
Dear Reverend Father Faustine Lobo,
I thank you for this forwarded response of yours to Mr. Dominic Dixon.
If you had done the same earlier, on the basis of my initial private report to you and three subsequent unanswered reminders, and taken up the matter with the Archbishop about Mr. Dixon's misrepresentations of approval from certain authorities, I would not have had to put my report in the public domain and he would not have had to threaten me and Mr. Francis Lobo with phone-tapping, physical assault by Bangalore thugs, and arrest warrants.
In addition to what I had informed you in my letter of "March 13, 2013 12:46 PM", he has arranged yesterday to have me rudely called and informed [in Kannada] that a police warrant has been issued for my arrest.
By the way, all of what he has charged me and my ministry with in his letter to you of March 12 is absolute lies and total fabrication -- which is not surprising considering they come from a man of his character -- and which you yourself might have already understood as false. After all, he has now shamelessly informed you that "During our prayerful enquiry, we intercepted emails and phone conversation transcrips [sic] between these elements, yourself and others", meaning that he has tapped your phones! But you do not appear to have minded.
I would suggest that you bring this matter to the immediate and urgent attention of the Archbishop of Bangalore, with the request that he institute an inquiry into both of our ministries, Mr. Dominic Dixon's and mine, and you have my assurance that I will present myself in Bangalore and depose before any such commission of inquiry. I would welcome such an inquiry because it would bring wide media attention to the many New Age and other errors in the Archdiocese of Bangalore which I have repeatedly pointed out to the Archbishop in a series of letters before I eventually gave up because they elicited no response. See ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE-LETTERS FROM THIS MINISTRY 06 AUGUST 2007/UPDATED DECEMBER 2009
You may access my latest updated report on Mr. Dominic Dixon/MoreLove tonight when it will be uploaded on my site, so I will not burden you here with my refutation of his false charges.
May I also inform you that the "recognition" of Mr. Dixon's activities by the International Association of Deliverance, a private association and NOT A VATICAN BODY AS DIXON FALSELY CLAIMS, has been withdrawn as communicated to me.
With regards, Michael
A SEPARATE COPY OF MY EMAIL TO FR. FAUSTINE LOBO WAS FORWARDED TO FR. A. SAGAYANATHAN, PARISH PRIEST OF ST. PATRICK’S CHURCH, BANGALORE. WHERE MORELOVE CONDUCTS ITS PROGRAMMES
From: Michael Prabhu To: sagaya1959@ Sent: Friday, March 15, 2013 11:20 AM
Subject: Fw: FYI: False investigation
Dear Rev. Fr. A. Sagayanathan,
For your kind information please.
Michael Prabhu
Catholic apologist [As above]
Apart from the letters reproduced above, I possess many more letters from Mr. Dominic Dixon that may require exposure if necessity demands. Those letters include attacks on those who he perceives to be his personal enemies, and letters from me requesting him -- time and again -- to remove my name from any association with his ministry. I was obliged to do that because he would plan programmes including me in them without my consent or give me high-sounding titles and exaggerated attributes as he is accustomed to giving himself. I have declined all of his invitations to participate in MoreLove programmes not because I thought that they were bad, but because of his acquired reputation for character assassination. 19.
Having said that, I will now refute, one by one, the false statements, lies and fabrications that he has leveled against me and my ministry in his letter of March 12, 2013 to Fr. Faustine Lobo, and which he copied to Mr. Simon Rodrigues, the Chairman of the Bangalore Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal who endorses his activities.
I. Fr. Its [sic] has been brought to our intention [sic] that some elememts [sic] claiming to be Catholic investigators and supposidly [sic] guardians of the Catholic Church have been causing havoc and misunderstanding amongst the faithful for many years.
Mr. Dominic Dixon lies. He only wrote the letter on March 12 when he became aware of my report to Fr. Faustine Lobo, MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
was on which is on my web site since January 31. It was from that very same day, March 12, that Mr. Francis Lobo and I began receiving anonymous telephone calls and threats.
We have never claimed to be "Catholic investigators".
II. During our prayerful enquiry, we intercepted emails and phone conversation transcrips [sic] between these elements, yourself and others. [Emphasis mine] Namely Michael Prabhu from Chennai and Sunil Lobo from Bangalore.
I have made just one call to Fr. Faustine Lobo, and that was on November 5, to confirm the appointment for me that Mr. Lobo had taken on his name. Mr. Lobo’s calls were made in October 2012. Mr. Dominic Dixon therefore has had, by his own admission, the telephones of Fr. Faustine Lobo under surveillance since at least October 2012, and he has the audacity to inform that to the priest! Amazingly, either that fact has not registered with Fr. Lobo or he is not perturbed by that revelation which constitutes a criminal act. It also verifies our already published disclosure that he informed Mr. Lobo that his phone was being monitored!
And for what purpose may we ask, since he only reacted to my report on MoreLove on March 12, 2013?
III. Michael is not an approved ministry and neither does any diocese have an 'investigation commission.'
I have never claimed that mine is an "approved" ministry. However, I have received over a thousand letters from bishops, archbishops, Cardinals, the Papal Nuncios and Vatican dicasteries, many of them available in different reports on my web site, and not a single one of them has questioned the Roman Catholicity of this ministry, its complete fidelity to Magisterial teaching (… or my psychological stability!).
Again, we have never claimed to be an "'investigation commission'".
IV. This man has written against the Holy Father, against our Bishops and Priests.
All information published by this ministry is sourced from material that is already in the public domain; it is analysed and commented upon by me. In reporting doctrinal and liturgical abuse and exposing error, I make every attempt to be objective, but that may not always be possible. One may read Mr. Dixon’s coarse posts on a blog which describes itself as "Catholic" but is in reality anti-Catholic.
All the information published by me in the MoreLove exposé is documented as always [sources are given].
Mr. Dixon should explain what he means when he insists that I have "written against the Holy Father". While he would be laughed at for making such a ridiculous claim by anyone who is familiar with my work, it is possible that he intentionally refers to a hypothetical scenario that I painted about the present impossibility of having an Indian Pope. If I have "written against … our Bishops and Priests", my work is in the public domain and it is up to the individual Bishops or Bishops’ Conferences or their Executive Commissions to evaluate whether I am undermining the Catholic Faith or defending it. That eventuality would be improbable considering that a large number of them have been and continue to be in touch with this ministry.
I might add that the document on the Holy Father that Mr. Dixon refers to has received endorsements from theologians, priests, seminarians, overseas Catholic ministries and even a Cardinal who was an elector at the recent conclave that elected Pope Francis!!! Their letters are included in the referred document.
V. Michael in [sic] banned from attending Catholic conferences as he was last banned from the CCR Goa conference for earning a name as a mischief maker.
I repeat: all information published by this ministry is sourced from material that is already in the public domain; that is to say, it is documented. The onus is on Mr. Dixon to proffer [even one word of] evidence from ANY source outside of my own writings that I have been "banned from attending Catholic conferences" or any single "Catholic conference", even the "the CCR Goa conference". It would be a blessing to me, because I have tried desperately to obtain any printed evidence of that, but failed miserably.
In fact, I have attended the said conference on the personal invitation of senior national leaders who can vouch for that. My integrity has never been called into question. Mr. Dixon’s has, always, and even now is.
VI. In November, out of the blue, Sunil had asked me for our documents of approval and we had no idea who this man is. He only sent us mails but never wanted to meet us when we had invited him. We refused to give him any documents as we need to protect the integrity of the Church.
All correspondence between Sunil [Mr. Francis Lobo] and Mr. Dixon was reproduced in the initial portion of the MoreLove report. No "documentation" was ever sought by him from Mr. Dixon. Straightforward questions from Sunil were answered with lies and devious explanations.
Dixon never invited Sunil over as claimed by him. This has been recorded already in this report, pages 5 & 6.
VII. We had invited a Pastor as a speaker who is an expert in his area of teaching which is in line with the Eccumenism [sic] commission of the Archdiocese.
That does not alter the fact that he is a Protestant Methodist pastor TEACHING a subject described as "Soul Ties" to Catholics of a claimed Catholic group on the premises of a Catholic church WITHOUT THE KNOWLEDGE OF THE PARISH PRIEST FR. A. SAGAYANATHAN, as informed to me on November 7, 2012.
And the issue had nothing to do with 'Eccumenism'; maybe if Dr. Dixon could spell the word correctly, we could take it from there.
VIII. Please feel free to speak to Simon Rodrigues about this matter and the integrity of our standing.
Now this is one of those rare instances when I am not being objective or relying on documentation. At the same time I am not making unsubstantiatible allegations.
Mr. Simon Rodrigues might be the leader of the Bangalore Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal [CCR] but I insist that he is more Protestant than he is Catholic. I have communicated my opinion in writing to the national leadership of the CCR and have noted it in a few of my reports, so it is not a new issue. If anyone requires me to write a separate report on that, it would be my pleasure to do so, since the Bangalore CCR has a history of nurturing closet Pentecostals. Mr. Simon Rodrigues spoke a false prophecy about my ministry in the present of a reputable Catholic witness in his Bangalore office in an effort to get me to abandon my ministry a few years ago. Interestingly, he was harbouring a Pentecostal pastor named Anthony Samuel in his residence. Anthony Samuel was present in the office of Simon Rodrigues at the same time that I had been taken along by a friend to meet him. The meeting ended with the false prophecy that caused my Catholic friend great consternation. Anthony Samuel has influenced many Catholics in Bangalore, Chennai and his home-town Secunderabad to reject Church teachings on sacraments, life [contraception], sacramentals, Marian devotion, etc. A number of these "Catholics" including Simon Rodrigues still look upon Anthony Samuel as a brother, host him at their homes and functions and defend him against criticism.
The point that must be noted is that many of these Catholics joined Samuel’s 'church' when his cover was blown after this ministry exposed him!! Till that time, no one outside a closed circle knew the truth!
A number of Bangalore charismatics are "under the influence". One cannot expect yours truly to be popular with this bunch of pseudo-Catholics, certainly not the Simon Rodrigues who Mr. Dixon appeals to!!!!!
See ANTHONY SAMUEL-ADONAI'S BRIDE-CATHOLIC CHARISMATIC PREACHER TURNS PENTECOSTAL JUNE 21, 2007/FEBRUARY 2009 .
I REST MY CASE.
IN RETALIATION AGAINST ME, MR. DOMINIC DIXON HAS COMMITTED SOME OTHER CRIMES AGAINST MY FRIENDS THAT I HAVE NOT RECORDED HERE. IT IS IMPERATIVE FOR ALL THOSE ASSOCIATED IN ANY WAY WITH MORELOVE AND DOMINIC DIXON TO TAKE SERIOUS NOTE OF HOW DANGEROUS THIS MAN IS. HE WILL DESTROY -- USING ANY MEANS -- ANYONE WHO HE PERCEIVES TO BE A THREAT TO HIS “MINISTRY”
MY SECOND LETTER TO THE ARCHBISHOP OF BANGALORE
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Most Rev. Bernard Moras,
Further to my communications of yesterday and earlier, please find attached the latest updated report on Mr. Dominic Dixon so that you may know the dangerous criminal mind that we are dealing with: his claims of surveillance/phone-tapping of Fr. Faustine Lobo and others, claims of hiring of contract thugs to assault people, actual calls received from Karnataka police claiming to be armed with arrest warrants, his frequent contacting by telephone and email the workplaces and superiors of his perceived enemies, a series of anonymous telephone calls made to this ministry and several of its friends, etc.
21.
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE 31 JANUARY/12/15 MARCH 2013
I learn, from evidence already available with me, that he is exploring the most effective way to launch a media attack on this ministry; the claim of his report will be that the writings of this ministry are fostering communal violence between Christians and Hindus!
We are unable to share the details of our latest findings because of the fear of repercussions from Mr. Dominic Dixon on innocent people and their family members.
If anybody is to be attacked by him, it should be me alone and no one else. While I haven’t the slightest qualms about being a martyr for Jesus, I would like to assure you, and am here placing on record, that I will not capitulate on the convictions of my writings whatever the price I have to pay. My family are preparing for the worst. We have informed certain influential people in the police and in the media (crime reporters of a national daily) both in Bangalore and in Chennai in anticipation of the "communal violence" claim that Mr. Dixon is making, but have made no effort to protect ourselves or take pre-emptive action against it.
Mr. Dixon never relents once he has commenced his revengeful pursuit of someone. A few years ago, he has slandered the good name of Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas, his daughters, and that of three ICPE seminarians, two of who are now ordained priests. He accomplished that through bogus emails using temporary email ids, posts on a "Catholic" blog, using the names of reputed or non-existent journalists to publish “investigations” which were actually his own venting against Bro. Fritz and ICPE, etc. This time, his going in the public domain could have wider and very serious ramifications for the local Church.
The sole reason for my informing you and addressing this email to you is to place the issue on record so that you cannot say that you were not warned by me well in advance.
I have copied this BCC to four priests and three ministries closely associated with the issue from the time of the commencement of our inquiry into MoreLove ministries in October 2012, and to a select number of those who are named as resource persons on the MoreLove web site.
Copies will be sent separately to the influential contacts in Bangalore and Chennai who we are keeping in the loop, to a group of Catholic lawyers, and to a few others who are as yet unaware of the crisis but need to be in the know.
In the event of Mr. Dixon’s continuing on the course on which he has embarked, which I will re-assess in a few days, I will be obliged to ensure that this letter reaches many others.
In all his communications he states that he is recognised and approved by your good self.
I am not asking you to intervene on my behalf. My request is that you rein in Mr. Dixon’s criminal pursuits because he would rather see anti-Catholic communal riots occur in Bangalore than have his “ministry” exposed for what it really is.
I would like to remind you that in the event of any unfortunate situation transpiring, the responsibility for not having restrained Mr. Dixon will rest solely with you.
Yours obediently,
Michael Prabhu
Catholic apologist michaelprabhu@
Cc: Fr. Faustine Lobo for information. I trust that you communicated to the Archbishop what I shared with you in my email of yesterday.
My above letter to the Archbishop of Bangalore was emailed BCC to a few priests associated in the past or presently with MoreLove and to selected priests and lay persons connected with the issue.
From: Michael Prabhu To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 11:03 AM
Subject: Fw: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM
Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE… [As above]
From: Name Withheld To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Sunday, March 17, 2013 4:08 PM Subject: Re: Fw: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Thanks for sharing the letter to the Archbishop… It is little difficult to digest the incident. I believe this guy will not be able to do anything, other than threatening and rumoring. Bangalore
22.
THE MANGALOREAN CATHOLICS JUNE 2009 INCIDENT; SEE PAGES 11, 12
Ancy D’Souza is the owner-moderator while Derrick D’Costa was the then co-moderator.
Here is the post from me, in response to a comment from Fr. Joseph Vas SVD, which "offended" Mr. Dominic Dixon and prompted his threatening Mangalorean Catholics that he would take the matter to the secular media and also respond with legal action against them:
Dear Father Joseph,
Your letter seems to verify the article that I posted.
Thousands of Mangaloreans, Goans, East Indians, Malayalis and Anglo-Indians have migrated to or studied in Australia and faced no problem. If one will note, all attacks have been carried out on North Indians.
By nature [from my experience of having worked and travelled across the whole of North India] they tend as a majority to be arrogant, brash, flashy, loud- and even foul-mouthed in public. They do not blend into the society around them.
On TV, I noticed that not even one of them could speak even a single sentence in clear English.
But it still beats me as to why Muslims, Lebanese or otherwise, should attack Indians in Australia.
Love, Michael
From: "Dr. Dominic Dixon" domdix@ Cc: dom@morelove.in, Dom domdix@
Date: Mon Jun 15, 2009 11:21 am Subject: Warning to Mangalorean Catholics' Forum
This is a response to Michael Prabhu's mail about the India [sic] students being beaten up in Australia.
Mr. Micaheal [sic] Prabhu,
It is disturbing to see you bullying so many people on this forum like you do with your emails and with your site. Let me deal with this subject in context.
You are more than just ignorant about the Australian issues by saying "If one will note, all attacks have been carried out on North Indians." This is an exclusive and an absolute statement when you use the words "ALL ATTACKS". For the benefit of those who don't know me, I'm the Executive Director of an international youth and social justice organisation and our team have just come back to India from Australia and we have evidence that not only were South Indians and other Indians from all over India were attacked, but also Sri Lankans because the Australians could not distinguish them from Indians. Just yesterday, students from Kerala were beaten up, what do you say about that?
You have described "North Indians" as "arrogant, brash, flashy, loud- and even foul-mouthed in public. They do not blend into the society around them." That is discriminatory and is an insensitive statement. Before you call them "foul mouth" look at what you do in your ministry. Your statement brings to mind an Anglo Indian statement "Kettle calling the chatty black" Theses [sic] North Indians have their democratic rights and freedom of expressions, don't deprive them of it.
Furthermore, you made this statement "On TV, I noticed that not even one of them could speak even a single sentence in clear English." You obviously are quite subjective in your facts and not just in this issue, but with many more on your site. There were at least three of the Indian students who even spoke with an Australian accent. You obovioulsy [sic] know very little about studying abroad. I studied in the West and know the issues faced there by Indians.
I demand an apology form the moderator of this group or I will take this to the secular media as I'm the Editor-in-Chief of a Radio and TV network. We just cannot encourage blood being shed by such people as these.
I will also file a case against this forum as a "hate group". I demand a set of rules from this forum.
I am expecting a reply from the moderator.
Regards
Dr. Dominic Dixon (Criminal Psychologist)
Executive Director - MoreLove, Dept, Social Justice
Editor-in-Chief - MoreLove Radio
Editor-in-Chief - Veritas TV
98805-36501/ dom@morelove.in
PA: Denzil Gomes - denzil@morelove.in 080-2571-0152 Bangalore [All emphases in bold black are Mr. Dixon’s]
Mr. Dixon describes himself as a "criminal psychologist”. Well, he certainly fits his description of himself.
From: josephvas7@ To: domdix@ Date: Monday, June 15, 2009, 11:57 AM
Subject: i saw your letter to the moderator
Dear Mr. Dominic Dixon,
I have taken note of the letter written to the moderator of the Mangalorean Catholics.
I know how some times we may make mistakes in assessing the situation that is volatile.
The case of Indian Students being targeted in Australia is surely a serious matter we all are concerned. But as you say since you have been a witness to the situation your view may be an authentic one.
Someone from Australia wrote to me a letter when I had expressed my concern, where she told me that the situation was compounded by the fact that the attacks were by many other ethnic groups which have migrated to Australia they targeted the Indian students and thus the situation looks to be serious. We feel sad about the whole situation.
If some of our members have used one section of people being the cause of the issue we are sorry.
Let us be more sensitive to the whole issue. I am praying. In union with the divine word,
Fr. Juze Vaz svd
23.
Dear Fr. Juze,
Thank you for writing and addressing your views and concerns.
Michal Prabhu has been a foul mouth and has defamed several servants of God.
This forum has been used as a gossip forum.
I need to know if you are the moderator.
Regards, Dom.
From: josephvas7@ To: derrickdcosta@ Cc: Ancy D’Souza ancyds@
Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 8:37 PM Subject: second letter to Dixon
Dear Dr. Dominic Dixon,
I have communicated with you earlier on other issue.
I am not the moderator of the group. But I interact with many people in becoming more sensitive to issues that concern each one of us.
Usually any site is a forum where individuals function independently though moderators try to keep controversial issues away from being personal.
The issue of the attacks on our students in Australia was such an issue.
Anyway I have expressed my view on this issue. I know it is very sensitive, as you say you were there and have personally seen the situation and have evaluated it objectively. I am glad there are views expressed sincerely.
Let us keep personal feelings away.
I know in taking the names of people on the site some times we can easily fall into the same trap as subjective as you have rightly expressed it is always better to be objective
Can I request you let us close this matter and be more objective in the future postings?
In the hope of reaching a consensus
In the divine word, Fr. Juze Vaz svd
From: Ancy D'Souza ancyds@ To: Derrick D'Costa derrickdcosta@
Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 10:11 AM Subject: Re: For your urgent attention
Dear Derrick,
There is nothing to worry about this message. We have done nothing wrong. Freedom of speech is the motto of our group and also it is the constitutional right of any Indian citizen. Anyone can express his personal feelings even if they may not be true. There is no hate content in the message of Michael Prabhu or no personal attack on anyone by Michael Prabhu. But the message by Dominic Dixon contains hate content and personal attack.
Remember that we need not reply to such emails.
Also let me know whether I remove hate content and publish it or should I just delete the message.
I have received several such messages in the past and this person can not do anything to us or to our group.
With regards, Ancy
Ancy S. D'Souza, Paladka, E2-139 Diwan Apt III, Vasai Road East, Thane Dist - 401 210, Tel: 0250-2390225, Cell: 9320733213
Having decided to ignore Mr. Dominic Dixon’s threatening letter to Mangalorean Catholics, Mr. Ancy D’Souza forwarded Mr. Dominic Dixon’s letter to me, as well as to the other moderator, Mr. Derrick D’Costa, and Fr. Joseph Vas:
From: Ancy D'Souza To: prabhu ; FrJuze Vas Indore Cc: Derrick D'Costa Sent: Monday, June 15, 2009 12:35 PM
Subject: Fwd: For your urgent attention
From: "Dr. Dominic Dixon" domdix@ Cc: dom@morelove.in, Dom domdix@
Date: Mon Jun 15, 2009 11:21 am Subject: Warning to Mangalorean Catholics' Forum
This is a response to Michael Prabhu's mail about the India [sic] students being beaten up in Australia.
Mr. Micaheal [sic] Prabhu [As above]
This was my response to Mr. Ancy D’Souza, Mr. Derrick D’Costa and Fr. Joseph Vas:
From: michaelprabhu@ To: ancyds@; derrickdcosta@; josephvas7@;
Sent: Tuesday, June 16, 2009 7:32 AM Subject: DOMINIC DIXON AND HIS THREAT
Dear Fr. Juze, I thank you for the letter that you wrote to Mr. Dixon.
Dear Derrick, I thank you for your solidarity, too.
Dear Ancy, I thank you for sending me a copy of Mr. Dixon's letter, and for not posting it in MC.
First of all, I do not see what is wrong in what I wrote in my response to Fr. Juze. I clearly said that it was my personal experience. And also what I saw and heard on TV. I was not attacking any minority group, either.
Last night, on Times Now, they gave the details of the 14th victim, another North Indian, Sunny Bajaj. Again, the two sentences of English were atrocious. What I was saying is that North Indians do not integrate themselves into Western society, first by learning to speak presentable English as early as possible. Of all the 14 attack victims named yesterday on TN, none was a South Indian. [So Dixon lies, as is his habit, that they were students from Kerala, see page 23]
I cannot imagine, for the life of me, what upset Dixon so badly that he wrote that letter! 24.
Unless it was my words to Hrishikesh Shenoy [a Hindu member of Mangalorean Catholics -Michael] about sticking to his doctorate and not theologizing on Catholic issues. I can only wonder if Dixon took that personally.
Dixon is a very, very, very dangerous man. I know him personally and have always steered very clear of him. He has a habit of attacking high profile Catholics in ministry to draw attention to himself. He slandered the personal reputation of Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas and his eldest daughter Divya and was finally forced by popular anger to issue a public apology. I know Fritz well but I had never seen him weep till Dixon spoilt the name of his family.
The people who called him to the Gulf had a very serious problem with him and then he slandered them. He uses his fora to institute personal attacks on people he considers as enemies.
In Bangalore it is well-known that Dixon is psychologically imbalanced. If you look at his letter, he will always be promoting himself, and the word "international" will always be used more than once.
When Dixon published his two books, he posted me the autographed copies even though I did not request for them.
One of his books received a terrible review in The New Leader. The reviewing priest said it was unadulterated rubbish.
Till a few days ago, I have received his latest postings. Frankly, I am very afraid to even ask him to unsubscribe me from his postings, much of which I think is self-glorification, because he will then consider me as an enemy.
You must also know that on two or three occasions he has included me as part of his ministries, but I have always written immediately on coming to know of it and asked him to remove my name from there.
A few times he has asked me if he could promote my campaigns, like against the NCB, and I have firmly said 'No thanks'.
Dixon has made a number of overtures to my ministry but I have always politely declined. He is such a man that it is even dangerous to say no to him. I was always wondering when he would turn his guns on me, but this has surprised me because, while reading his letter, I still cannot figure out what it is that I have done that has incensed him so much! Especially when he has been trying all along, both with and without my permission to associate with my ministry.
How did I become so bad all of a sudden? I wonder if anyone has a hand in this and has instigated Dixon by saying something.
There is no indication of any problem till our last correspondence [SEE FURTHER BELOW]*
Lastly, about his comments on my website and ministry.
"bullying so many people on this forum like you do with ...your site"
"look at what you do in your ministry"
"You obviously are quite subjective in your facts and not just in this issue, but with many more on your site"
It is true that I do write strongly, but against public religious error and always faithful to the teachings of the Magisterium. Over all these years and the scores of reports and thousands upon thousands of pages sent by email and print to every Indian Bishop and Bishops Commission and even to the Vatican, NOT ONE SINGLE LINE OF ANY OF MY REPORTS HAS BEEN FAULTED BY ANY AUTHORITY IN THE CHURCH. This week 9 new articles are being uploaded on my website and 5 more hard-hitting ones later this month. Many bishops and powerful erring priests are NAMED. I do not expect even one single refutal or criticism from the Bishops as a whole or individually.
I have no unresolved controversy with Mr. Dixon. In fact, as you can read from his correspondence below, he has always pursued me. You can read also how he tried to misuse my name to get mileage with the Bishops, and he finally apologized. [I have not hidden any controversial correspondence from you, here, but this is only SOME of a large bunch that I could have copied for you*.] Love, Michael
*The correspondence between Mr. Dominic Dixon and me which I reproduced in my above letter to Mr. Ancy D’Souza, Mr. Derrick D’Costa and Fr. Joseph Vas:
1. The attack on ICPE and its director, Fritz Mascarenhas:
From: Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Cc: dom@morelove.in Sent: Tuesday, June 26, 2007 9:53 AM
Subject: Re: BRO. JOHNSON SEQUEIRA OF MUMBAI CONDUCTING MINISTRY IN BANGALORE
Dear Mike,
Thanks for addressing the issue about Johnson Sequeira. However, I am very disappointed that you did not mention ICPE even after I have given you my investigation. It is because as you had said before that "ICPE is powerful in Bangalore" that you're not coming our publicly about them? Love –Dom
Here, Mr. Dixon admits that the slander attack on ICPE/Fritz Mascarenhas was orchestrated by him. -Michael
From: prabhu To: Dominic Dixon Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2007 8:18 AM
Subject: Re: BRO. JOHNSON SEQUEIRA OF MUMBAI CONDUCTING MINISTRY IN BANGALORE
Dear Dom,
I do not recall writing to you at any time that "ICPE is powerful in Bangalore". The only possibility is that I might have said, to caution you in your campaign against ICPE, that ICPE have popular support in Bangalore, so you better be careful what you do or write... but I did not say that in the context of my ministry.
As far as this ministry is concerned, surely you must be aware by now that I do not hesitate to write about any person or organization [Catholic] -- whoever they may be -- if they go against Catholic teaching, but one thing that I avoid is to name names - unless for exceptional reason as in the case of Simon Rodrigues [in the Anthony Samuel report]. As a matter of fact I have written to ICPE and to Fr. Jose Vettiyankal directly in my original alert, but have not so far received a response. [Fr. Jose is a supporter of my ministry]. 25.
I did that in the case of the Bangalore Service Team etc. in the matter of the Anthony Samuel alert too, and only when no response came I included the whole story in my final report.
My best enquiries reveal that Johnson did not give a program to the actual ICPE. The youth group which he ministered to had already earlier changed their name from ICPE YOUTH, which you also informed me is now Yeshua Adonai. This is precisely to disassociate from the ICPE name. That being the case, how could you expect me to NAME the ICPE?
Moreover, no one gave me the dates and places of Bro. Johnson's Bangalore programmes with ICPE. Love, Michael
From: Dominic Dixon To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2007 11:18 PM Subject: Johnson
Hi Mike,
I know that you're a man who does not compromise and that why i feel so closely knitted with you in Spirit.
I believe that Fr. Jose is also supporting Johnson. Fritz is the Shepherd and ICPE is shepherding the Yeshua Adonai youth group and therefore there is a link. Today Fritz tried calling me several times from different numbers but I ignored him.
I go live on the Internet Radio everday at 12 noon (12:00 to 12:30) go to and click on the Radio Icon on the left. love n blessings. Dom
2. The attack on ICPE and its director, Fritz Mascarenhas, continued:
From: Dominic Dixon To: cyriljohn@ Cc: Michael Prabhu Sent: Thursday, July 12, 2007 4:34 PM Subject: Frtiz
Dear Brother Cyril,
Bro. Fritz had attempted to contact me several times via my cell. Since I've been incessantly occupied with our International Radio, I could not answer his calls as I could not answer several other calls too. So Fritz had contacted Sunil Jose, Program Director of MORELOVE.IN and conveyed a message that I had sent you a mail regarding his Ministry and his tone suggested that there is an issue of seriousness and he SURPRISINGLY wanted to meet me and clarify things.... this is a miracle as Fritz had failed miserably in the past in resolving issues which led to an international controversy in the past few months.
Issues with his Ministry keep prevailing while certain brutes in his fold cause verbal vandalism within the Body of Christ. Some are Schizophrenics in their values.
My point is, if you perhaps need clarification on my previous mail about Johnson Sequeira which was copied to you, please do so. Let’s be candid. Dom
From: prabhu To: Dominic Dixon Cc: cyriljohn@ ; Archdiocese of Bangalore ; bgarchdi ; valdsouz@ ; punedioc@ ; nco Sent: Friday, July 13, 2007 11:09 PM Subject: Re: Frtiz
Dear Dom,
I was really quite taken aback to open my mail and read this letter from you this morning. After that I had gone out, and I found time to reply to all my mails only just now.
I am surprised because you have marked a copy to me of your letter to Mr. Cyril John regarding Fritz.
I cannot see how the contents of your letter are concerned with my ministry which is to create awareness against error in respect of Catholic faith, Christian orthodoxy and orthopraxis, etc.
There are some disputes and differences among some leaders in the Renewal, but these will always be there because of the human element, and they are best settled by personal meetings, mediation, and of course, prayer.
This ministry has always been impartial in publishing its reports and alerts, and they have never been personal in the sense of moral failings and the like. I am aware of my own many weaknesses here, and am not the one to judge another.
Except in one recent case where I was constrained to use a name, it was because the leaders concerned had declined to have any correspondence with me despite several years of my writing to them [which had followed unproductive personal meetings with most of them]. In all other cases, I have always endeavoured to meet the persons concerned [wherever error is perceived by me] if they were accessible, or write to them asking for their explanation against my perceptions or documentations, and I have published my alerts or reports only if my perceptions are validated and only after they continued to adhere to wrong [from the Catholic perspective] philosophies or practices.
Even if there is validity in your statements, I cannot either approve of the language that you choose to use, or be part of it.
On May 27th, I had already written to you, copy to others who were included by you in your email, QUOTE:
"So, let me apologize on behalf of Dom for the language and words chosen by him to write to Fr. Adolf [Washington].
We may not agree with one another on everything, but we are primarily Christians, followers of Jesus, called to serve and to witness. Hostility and confrontation are regressive and counter-productive.
We may want to express our views strongly and firmly, but please let us do so in a spirit of love.
There is so much of attack on our Faith and on the Church. United we stand, divided we fall. It is not from Scripture, but very true.
Dom, May I humbly request you to go over, meet Fr. Adolf, reconcile with him, and let us move together forward unitedly from there." UNQUOTE. I feel the same way now.
By writing to Mr. Cyril John under copy to me, you continue to involve me in an issue that has never concerned me or my ministry.
I am as much a friend of Fritz's as I am of you, and if Fritz or anyone else were to write to you in this fashion [under copy to me], I would be equally perturbed, and would have responded in exactly the same way.
You are aware that whenever you have publicly taken up issues that you have defended from a Catholic or Christian perspective, I have given you every co-operation through my letters, even against a lot of advice not to associate with you.
[Let me clarify here that not a single person from Fritz's community has ever asked me to disassociate with you. Not even Fritz.]
I make my own decisions, and cannot be pressurised or influenced by anyone.
The reason why I used the phrase "you continue to involve me" [above] is this:
When you rang me up sometime last month to inform me about your being interviewed on TV, you shared with me that Bro. Fritz had rung you up several times but you had not responded; and you will recall that I had told you that you were not right to do so.
Recently I have been provided with your letter of June 22, emailed to the Archbishop of Bangalore, the Bishop of Pune, and to Mr. Cyril John.
There appears to be no Cc marked to anyone, and certainly no Bcc to me, because I did not receive from you the copy of the letter. Amazingly, the letter starts, "Dear Mike".
Now, if I were in the Bcc, the letter surely would not have been addressed to "Dear Mike".
And since it is addressed to "Dear Mike", why was the letter sent to two Bishops and the Chairman of the NCCRS instead of to me? I can only presume that you are aware of how the letter was presented.
You have noted that I attend to mail within 24 hours unless my computer breaks down or I am out of Chennai on mission. If you had written to me and I did not respond for two or three days, you would immediately ask me why I had not responded as you have done on a couple of occasions.
Hence I must assume that you had NOT marked a copy of the June 22 letter to me, though it bears my name.
A copy of the referred letter of yours dated June 22 was reached to me because it bears my name.
On reading it, I asked Fritz if indeed [as informed by you to me] he had rung you up several times and you had not responded to him. He confirmed to me that it was so.
But then he told me that the reason he had called you up so many times was because he had just received a copy of your letter of June 22 which Mr. Cyril John had forwarded to him [Fritz] through a third person, after a delay of four days during which time he had tried unsuccessfully to reach it directly to Fritz's email id.
Now I wondered why, when you told me about Fritz's many calls to you and your non-response, you withheld from me the information about the June 22 letter to Cyril from you - that bore my name?
I was in Bangalore for several days recently and I was quite perturbed over what I heard everywhere I went.
Dear Dom, I am not looking for a response from you that will prolong the matter. I am sure that you have as much to do as I, and may I suggest that if we all really must do something, let it be done objectively. A letter like the one that you sent to Mr. Cyril John about Fritz Mascarenhas certainly does not help.
Assuring you of my moral support as usual on any of the Christian issues that you usually take up, Love, Michael
From: Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Cc: cyriljohn@ ; Archdiocese of Bangalore ; bgarchdi ; valdsouz@ ; punedioc@ ; nco Sent: Saturday, July 14, 2007 12:29 AM Subject: Re: Frtiz
Dear Mike,
Thanks for the email. In this email that has been copied to people, it's not right for you to mention past issues though they were genuine and were eventually sorted out. To me it's a cheap thing to do. Therefore my tone in this mail may surprise you. Now to address the points that you have mentioned.
When I had called you about a TV interview (NDTV), it was at least a month (May end) before Fritz had called me. At that time, there was no issue about Fritz that I had spoken to you in regards to him calling me. Fritz had been calling me in past two weeks only and I did not take up his calls for several reasons. He had called me because I had sent an email about him entertaining Johnson. I'm not sitting and doing nothing here. I'm in the recording studio for about 10 hours a day. You HAVE NOT told me that I was wrong in ignoring the calls of Fritz. Can you prove that? The last time I had called you was when I was on my way for the interview and it was very brief since I had to inform my other friends including my Bishop. The issue with Frtiz and Johnson is not even a month. So please get your facts straight before trying to look like a Saint.
You and I had issues about Fritz, as you had mentioned to me that "Fritz is a man of compromise and his daughter is a scandal" you also mentioned to me that "Matthew Mohan of ICPE is a schizophrenic" I did not mention you in quote as you have done in the email about past issues with regards to Fritz and Fr. Washington. I had gone to Fritz's place and sorted out the issues that I had with him. I had also gone to Fr. Washington's office last month and met with him. So why do you bring it up when there's no context and CC it to people who are not involved with the past issues? What point are you trying to prove?
Fr. Washington's happy with the work that I'm doing and he also gave me some advise [sic]. In humility I sorted out our issues. As you mentioned in this mail "the human element" in regards to our weaknesses. My Bishop is also happy with the work that I've been doing. I've represented the views of the Church in India and other countries.
27.
I will not hesitate to pull up anyone in the Church who operate in folly whether Ministry or Minister. I do this in the midst of my great weaknesses. That's a part of my Call.
In regards to the June 22nd mail, I just searched my "Sent Items" It was a silly mistake, In the process of adding mail id's, I forgot to add yours. Here is the mail. [The email in question may be read immediately following]
I did not withhold this information from you as you have mentioned in your email. I'm neither scared nor guilty to stand up for what I speak. If I'm right, you cannot shake me, if I'm wrong, I will go down on my knees and ask pardon and make amends. Dom
From: Dominic Dixon To: Bishop ; bgarchdi ; punedioc@ ; valdsouz@ ; cyriljohn@ ; nco@
Sent: Friday, June 22, 2007 2:39 PM Subject: Johnson Sequeira
Dear Mike,
Pastor Johnson Sequeira from Mumbai has done a retreat for ICPE's youth group 'Yeshua Adonai'.
Pastor Johnson has major issues in Mumbai and Goa. I personally had to rebuke him in the context of adultery as others have also done. He has also broken bread several times with Catholics in Mumbai.
Fritz of ICPE has invited Protestant Pastors to his premises to conduct session for his disciples. He has invited Pastor Aldrin Bogi from YWAM and Pastor Rudi Lack from the USA for sessions in the recent past.
Some of his members (Ester and husband with team) have even done Ministry at FGAG (Full Gospel Assembly of God Church) in Indira Nagar. Pastor Paul Thangiah is the senior Pastor there.
The Bangalore Bishop seems to have a very good impression of ICPE but he needs to be informed of ICPE's pretence and hypocrisy. While ICPE condemns and contradicts other Catholic missions, they are a ruination of many Catholics. I speak this through my bitter experience and others' too.
Since studying issues concerning the Catholic Church for its welfare, is part of you CALL, I request you kindly look into this issue as there is a roaring concern here in Bangalore. Leslie Quadros whose [sic] a disciple of Pastor Johnson told me that the Priests of LOGOS in Bangalore said that Pastor Johnson is operating in a counterfeit spirit.
I'm sure that Bro. Cyril John is well aware of Pastor Johnson. END OF COPIED LETTER
Several people have even advised me not to associate with you but I chose not to listen to them. You may have heard things and you were perturbed? Well, it seems that you have already made a judgement about me, so where's your objectiveness?
As you address issues based on Ministry names, I go a step further and mention the names of the individuals.
I speak in a tone that may not be accepted by some people. I'm sure even you have made statements in a strong manner. There are times that I use strong words. If you read the Old Testament properly you will notice that God and His Prophets used strong words. If you read the New Testament properly, John the Baptist, the Apostles and Jesus used strong words. Why persecute me when I get my message across in a Biblical manner?
Please understand that I have absolutely no time to waste and to indulge in issues that have no ground or foundation. I run an international Ministry, a Socio-religious portal, a 24hrs Christian Internet Radio, editing my second book and writing my third. All this among the other things that I do.
If you wish to keep in touch with me, it's upto [sic] you. Dom
From: prabhu To: cyriljohn@ ; nco Cc: Archdiocese of Bangalore ; bgarchdi ; valdsouz@ ; punedioc@ Sent: Saturday, July 14, 2007 7:59 PM Subject: DOMINIC DIXON, BANGALORE
Dear Bro. Cyril John, and dear Bishops,
I trust that you must have read Mr. Dominic Dixon's response to my letter.
My letter to him was marked B. C. copy to Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas whom Dominic had threatened.
I wrote it in the light of my recent meeting with Fritz at his home in Bangalore.
I myself did the first ICPE School and was the first member of Fritz's community, ICPE.
Dominic had also issued threats against Mr. Anthony Sagayaraj, acting Chairman of the Bangalore Service Team, CCR.
I had been warned by many people that if I tried to correct Dominic, he would turn on me too. Expectedly he has done just that. This is to inform you all that I am not responding to Dominic and not taking this matter any further.
Yours sincerely, Michael
From: prabhu To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Monday, July 23, 2007 3:08 PM Subject: DOMINIC DIXON / MORELOVE
Dear friends,
I met Dominic Dixon just once when I was introduced to him at Kairos in Chennai over three years ago.
Since he contacted me after that, whenever he has publicly taken up certain issues and presented a Christian or Catholic perspective, I have given him my moral support as I would do with anybody else.
Recently it was brought to my attention that, without my knowledge, he was [mis]using my name in some correspondence with the Bishops regarding other ministries.
This note is to keep you informed that due to the above reason and also his persistently harassing certain ministries and Renewal leaders in Bangalore, I am obliged to have to take the painful decision not to respond to his letters in the future and to avoid any association with him or his ministries.
Love and Prayers, Michael. 28.
TEN DAYS FROM HIS LAST LETTER, DIXON "REPENTS" OF HIS ATTACKS ON FRITZ MASCARENHAS/ICPE, BUT REPEATS IT AGAIN, AND AGAIN, AND AGAIN; SEE PAGES 31-35 OF THIS REPORT:
From: Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Cc: cyriljohn@ ; Archdiocese of Bangalore ; bgarchdi ; valdsouz@ ; punedioc@ ; nco Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2007 2:25 PM Subject: Grace
Dear Mike and those mentioned in the CC
I have been praying about our last email correspondence.
What has happened has been displeasing to God and I need to ask forgiveness for my contribution of the unpleasantness. As I kneel in prayer and go for confession, I'm convicted that I'm not in the right standing with you and with God. It was perhaps pride or plain negative fruit that has caused my reaction.
Therefore dearly beloveds, I'm seeking your grace of forgiveness. I'm 31 years old and have been in Ministry for just three years. My past as a gangster and rebel still has traits deep within me which Jesus is still healing and working on. In the meantime, I ask for you grace to bare [sic] with me and to encourage me in the Lord.
In such a short time, Jesus has given me an International Ministry and an International Internet Radio, authored a book on Deliverance, etc. All this perhaps got to my head.
If you have forgiven me, kindly acknowledge it by responding to this email. Please pray for me and impart your blessings.
Love –dom
However, he cannot refrain from vainful boasting about his "International Ministry and an International Internet Radio", etc., etc. This can be seen repeated in the great majority of his communications with others.
3. A year later, Mr. Dixon makes an overture which I reject:
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, August 02, 2008 12:47 PM
Subject: Re: UPDATE and ALERT: A "NEW AGE" BIBLE. CALL FOR WITHDRAWAL OF THE NEW COMMUNITY BIBLE
Dear Mike,
In continuation with your efforts, we could make an announcement on our Radio () about the New Age Bible. We beam into 40 Nations with over a million collective listners [sic]. If you would like us to do that, please send us a two para write that could be spoken over our Radio. We can do this for one week. In His Service dom.
From: prabhu To: domdix@ Sent: Saturday, August 02, 2008 4:57 PM
Subject: Re: UPDATE and ALERT: A "NEW AGE" BIBLE. CALL FOR WITHDRAWAL OF THE NEW COMMUNITY BIBLE
Dear Dom,
Many thanks for your gracious offer. I declined similar suggestions from The Federation of Catholic Faithful and The Catholic Times, Chennai. What I suggested and they did was to download and use my article from the net as per details given in my covering letter and inside the article. Love, Mike
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Sent: Saturday, August 02, 2008 11:38 PM
Subject: Re: UPDATE and ALERT: A "NEW AGE" BIBLE. CALL FOR WITHDRAWAL OF THE NEW COMMUNITY BIBLE
Ok, Mike,
I think your suggestion sounds better. But since I have not read the NAB, as I just don't have the time, it may be a little difficult. However, I will review your article and see what can be done. Will keep you posted. Love, dom
4. Here, he tried to get me to comment on Johnson Sequeira whose ministry, I have shown, is not Catholic:
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Friday, October 24, 2008 11:24 AM
Subject: Fw: Making Holy Garments from Flawed Material
Hi Mike, This mail was forwarded to me by my Kuwait ministry about Johnson's programs. There's an attachment. Love, dom.
5. Another overture from Mr. Dixon. He sends me his third book; I find problems with it:
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Friday, November 07, 2008 3:06 PM Subject: Book
Hi Mike, Please send me your mailing address. I would like to send you a copy of my third book. Love, dom
From: prabhu To: Dominic Dixon Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2008 6:44 AM Subject: OBAMA {PJM}
[...] I received your book "Living for the Audience of One", yesterday. Many thanks. The cover graphics, paper, etc are of very high quality. I went through a few chapters. I am sure that people will find the book useful.
I note that there is no record of the publisher. Also there are many quotes from Protestant sources compared to CCC, the Early Church Fathers and the Lives of Saints. There are punctuation and grammatical errors, etc. I suggest that you get someone who is thorough in English to do your editing. Love, Mike
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2008 10:01 AM Subject: Re: OBAMA
Hi Mike, As usual, thank for the valuable feedaback [sic]. At MoreLove, we're floated a publishing unit. 29.
It went through an editor and a proof reader, but I guess it needs to be improved.
I quoted different people because the book is for every Christian. This pleased some of our Bishops considering that it's coming for a Catholic that seeks unity within the Body. Love, dom
6. Yet another overture from Mr. Dixon:
From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, February 10, 2009 10:40 PM
Subject: Re: XXI CCBI Plenary Assembly at Mysore - Feb 12-18, 2009 / THE ST. PAULS' NEW COMMUNITY BIBLE
Hi Mike, Do keep up the tireless and thankless task that Christ has entrusted unto you. You sure are in my prayers. In the last three months I've been on constant travel to several countries on missions and could not communicate with you promptly.
Whatever you have in audio could be broadcasted with promos done from our side. The Lord has made our Radio as one of the leading Christian online radio's [sic]. Much love and appreciation, -dom.
From: prabhu To: Dominic Dixon Sent: Wednesday, February 11, 2009 12:22 PM
Subject: Re: XXI CCBI Plenary Assembly etc.
My dear Dom, Your blessing and prompt response is enough. I don't do audio, Dom. God bless your ministry too. Love, Mike
7. From: Dr. Dominic Dixon To: prabhu Sent: Thursday, March 26, 2009 10:25 AM
Subject: Re: FOUR COPIES OF THE NCB REACHING THE HOLY SEE
Rest assured of my prayers, dear Brother. Love, dom
The end of the correspondence between Mr. Dominic Dixon and me which I had reproduced in my letter of June 16, 2009 to Mr. Ancy D’Souza, Mr. Derrick D’Costa and Fr. Joseph Vas
UPDATE: More incoming letters:
From: Derrick D'Costa To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Sunday, March 17, 2013 3:55 PM
Subject: DOMINIC DIXON AND HIS THREAT
I was not surprised that you are threatened once again, though I do doubt that there is much for him to gain at this stage. I once sent you a letter from Fr Juze trying to pacify him. I did not get very involved as Ancy D’Souza was more experienced in dealing with his threats. Besides I am not very connected with Indian ministries.
Something is wrong with the way he is acting, I am not sure we know enough to determine what are his motives, whether it is a problem with his ministry, psychological issues or even a case of lead poisoning.
Unfortunately, and I am truly sorry to say this, you need to be a bit careful and deal with this seriously.
Derrick
From: Fr Dominic Emmanuel To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Monday, March 18, 2013 9:43 AM Subject: Re: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Mr. Prabhu,
I have been extremely busy so have not had time to look into what you have written and to follow the story through. I maybe able to pursue it after Easter. Thanks all the same for your mails. With regards and prayers, Fr. Dominic
Dominic Emmanuel SVD, Director and Spokesperson, Delhi Catholic Archdiocese, Communication/Information Bureau, 9-10 Bhai Veer Singh Marg, New Delhi 110 001 +91 11 23363214; 23369582 cibdelhi@
ON PAGE 14 OF THIS REPORT, I HAD WRITTEN: QUOTE
As I had forecast, Mr. Dixon quickly made some modifications to one of his web sites on finding my report:
EXTRACT
Due to their hectic clergy responsibilities, Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj could not be a part of our team as initially requested and desired.*
MORAL ADVISORS
Rev. Fr. Franklin D’Souza - National Director - ICYM
Rev. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel - Director - Delhi Catholic Archdiocese Communication Bureau
Alex Anthony- Mentor, Jesus Youth India
We may recall that Fr. Faustine Lobo and Fr. Arul Raj disassociated with MoreLove after reading this report.
UNQUOTE [*Their names as "Moral Advisors" were removed by Mr. Dixon and two new ones were added on]
Today, March 18, we find the names of THREE of the four original "Moral Advisors" missing. Fr. Franklin Lobo is added to the list of those who "could not be a part of our team as initially requested and desired". MoreLove has the highest attrition rate of any "ministry I’ve encountered!!! Things get curiouser and curiouser!! It is most remarkable that these priests’ names surfaced on the MoreLove faculty only on the basis of nothing more than a "request" and "desire" from Mr. Dixon to have them on board.
It is highly regrettable that the name of preacher Colin Calmiano, Director, Spread Your Wings, Bangalore, still appears on the page even after my letters to him of December 15 and 19, 2012, see page 10.
At the bottom of all ëthos pages, HolySpiritInteractive [HSI] is described as a lay "Apostalate". 30.
Mr. Dixon’s weekly meetings, at St. Patrick’s Church, 4:00 pm Sundays, are part of the "HSI International Communities" network. HolySpiritInteractive [HSI] is the ministry of Dubai-based Aneel Aranha, now banned in the Archdiocese of Bombay; see pages 2 and 3.
The revised [after Mr. Dixon read this report] ëthos team is given at as:
Executive Team
Aneel Aranha - Chairman
Dr. Dominic Dixon - Executive Director/ Provost
Clergy Participation Team
Rev. Fr. Roys - Rector - Infant Jesus Church
Rev. Fr. Pascal Ravi - Rector -St. Anthony’s Friary
Rev. Sis. Marjore - Administrator - Mount Carmel College
Rev. Fr. Cyril Victor- Pastoral Communications - Rome
Elders
Simon Rodrigues - Chairman, Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal Service
Alex Anthony- Mentor, Jesus Youth India
ACADEMIC ADVISORS
Dr. Fr. Edayadiyil George CMI, M.Sc., M.A. (M.G.), L. Th., Th. D. (Angelicum, Rome) (World Religion)
Dr. Fr. Kochuthara Shaji George CMI, L. Th., Th. D. (Alphonsianum, Rome) (Moral Theology)
Tom Cummings, M. Div (Director, STEP, Notre Dame University)
MORAL ADVISORS
Rev. Fr. Dominic Emmanuel - Director - Delhi Catholic Archdiocese Communication Bureau
There are some minor modifications in the wording on the page. For example, "The campus has a parking capacity for over 100 cars", see page 11 of this report, now reads "The campus has adequate parking".
The says, "ETHOS Institute aims at complimenting [sic] the Church". What compliments does the Church need from a private lay institute?
The "Vatican" word is nowhere to be found in the web pages of the ëthos Institute.
On pages 2 through 7 of this report, we have cited references from three links: , , and . The references concerned the claims of HSI/MoreLove/Dixon to be 'Vatican-approved', 'official ambassador of the Vatican', etc. They remain as earlier.
The HSI MoreLove Radio page offers evangelical Protestant programmes such as those of Nancy Leigh DeMoss, Billy and Franklin Graham, Dennis Rainey and Bob Lepine of Campus Crusade for Christ and Dr. Ravi Zacharias, and one which is Catholic, that of Boni and Yvette Dias of Goa. Are HSI MoreLove ministries engaged in the Catholic Church’s New Evangelization or in a "new" evangelization?
Mr. Dixon describes "Catholic" lay minister Johnson Sequeira as a pastor, see page 28, but isn’t he one too?
UPDATE: ATTACKS ON FRITZ MASCARENHAS AND THE INTERNATIONAL CATHOLIC PROGRAMME FOR EVANGELIZATION [SEE PAGES 11 AND 12 AND 25 TO 29]
EXPOSURE: Freedom from Fascism and Fritzism!
I. February 19, 2007
Posted By: domdix Mon Feb 19, 2007 1:52 pm
I received this mail. It all seems to be accurate as per the investigation and its [sic] the right of every Catholic to know whats [sic] happening in the Catholic Church.
EXPOSURE: Freedom from Fascism and Fritzism! SPECIAL REPORT
This is a report from religious investigating officers and journalists. More of this will be produced on the internet and in
the secular press.
2 Corinthians 3:17 - Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is freedom.
The Church has been liberated from the bondages of sin and satan and God has called His people to live free from captivity. The Church has a history of being tormented and scandalised by members of its body. The Church has suffered great distress in recent times due to scandals and malicious acts of ministers of the Gospel.
Bangalore is seeing great revivals of the Holy Spirit. More and more young people are being touched and anointed and are called to serve the Lord.
1 Peter 2:16 - Live as free men, yet without using your freedom as a pretext for evil; but live as servants of God.
This is the time we need to encourage one and other [sic] to freedom in Christ and not dominate one another in Fascism or Fritzism. To be a fascist is to take undue authority like Adolf Hitler of Nazism. To be a Fritzist is to pull down people servants of God and organisations in [sic] the pretext of spirituality.
31.
I really thank God for the organisations that are in Bangalore reaching out to people. On Valentines Day, a group of young
Christians gathered on Brigade road and proclaimed the true love of Jesus Christ with candles in their hands, plaque cards and tracts. It is amazing and we need more people like this. As a matter of fact we do have young evangelistic people ready to [sic] this but are suppressed by religious fascist organisations such as ICPE in Bangalore. These young people were opposed and their leader was almost beaten up but they responded with 'God loves you' and 'God bless you'
2 Peter 2:19 - They promise them freedom, but they themselves are slaves of corruption; for whatever overcomes a man, to that he is enslaved.
There is a danger of some corrupt evangelical missions' organisations becoming cult groups with the way they gather as a community in the name of communal living in the Church. Some of them have free sex in their youth groups and match making within the community. The concept of greeting each other with a brotherly kiss has reached the bed rooms for some at a youth group that meets on Saturdays in central Bangalore. Parents beware.
Galatians 5:13 - For you were called to freedom, brethren; only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh….
We need to be aware of such movements that creep into the Church as it has within other groups such as 'the Family' or 'children of god'. There are evangelists that just don't have control on their own kids and are busy preaching to other youth. One of Bangalore's most prominent youth leaders made this statement 'let that preacher who preaches Gods' will, first go and preach it to his scandalous daughter' this surprised a lot of people. One would really think that if these senior evangelists were proper shepherds instead of victimisers, many young evangelists would not have made the mistakes
that caused themselves and others pain. Many of us would have walked steadily with the Lord. Surely many don't stand alone with this view.
Galatians 2:4 - But because of false brethren secretly brought in, who slipped in to spy out our freedom which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might bring us into bondage.
Don't let such people or organisations pull you down, but instead be vigilant and prudent wise as a serpent. A report and exposure was produced on an organisation called ICPE which calls itself an evangelical organisation in Bangalore. The director of that organisation Fritz, had taken the article and went to a senior priest seeking mercy but there was still no repentance. The priest had communicated this to a reporter. Fritz had told several people that this particular priest was his spiritual director, but the priest denied the same. This was communicated to three religious leaders and reporters.
To cover up his faults, Fritz had taken the article and read it out to his community and pleaded with them to keep this secret. But some of his disciples, who do not endorse his view, reported his hypocrisy and double standards to religious leaders and a media reporter.
As an international evangelist said 'Fritz is a compromise and his daughter is a scandal' It takes us no pleasure to expose anybody, but we are simply being obedient to the word of God. Ephesians 5:11 'have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose them.'
A prominent and senior religious leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal expressed why he did not join the ICPE community. He mentioned that Fritz has failed in his calling for he has failed to control his daughter who dresses and behaves provocatively. He further stated that when he was in college, Fritz used to come to his college and tell the boys and girls how to dress and to keep distance from each other but has failed to convict his daughter with the same message. He further stated that after he had done his discipleship at ICPE in another country, he was refrained from joining the ICPE Community in Bangalore for he did not trust Fritz although he was forced. He endorses that he had made the best
decision of his life.
Another prominent leader who was to join the community stated that ICPE is an elitist community.
The Managing Director of a Catholic News Agency expressed that Fritz was behind him seeking press coverage to promote his philosophy. As soon as the previous article exposing Fritz was published, a much respected International Catholic Evangelist who knows Fritz made this comment when he knew that Fritz' missionaries had not gone to visit a dying patient when requested to do so. "Maybe some people would have rushed over faster if the Fijians had money or connections to invite over to Fiji, etc." I agree with that statement.
Some members of the Mangalorean community were scandalised to hear of the double standards of ICPE after they had found evidences of its scandal.
If we cannot help someone, we should not suppress those who are reaching out. These organisations tend to release the Barab'bas and arrest the Barnabas of the Church. Many of our young Evangelists have made several mistakes simply because those like Fritz who were supposed to be shepherds have been predators.
Are we simply preaching as a profession or are we really doing the will of God?
Let us be labourers of the vineyard and propagate God's love and mercy and compassion. Let us not give the devil a foothold into our lives. For we are all Gods' workmanship.
That the above alleged "report from religious investigating officers and journalists" was ghost-written by Dominic Dixon is so obvious that it does not need saying. The promised "More of this will be produced on the internet and in the secular press" did not materialise. There are so many spelling, grammatical and other errors in the above story that I stopped sic-cing. The errors and some of the words are typical of Dixon’s poor writings.
I -- and many Bangalore Catholics -- can easily identify the persons who the report claims condemned Fritz and ICPE. The "Ephesians 5:11" reference points to this ministry [mine]. Well, no one 'interviewed' me about Fritz/ICPE. Except Dominic Dixon! If he insists -- as he HAS -- that the comment about Fritz and his daughter was made by me to him, then he must concede to being the real author of this fabricated slanderous 'report'!
32.
Dominic Dixon’s bluff is called by his former associate Joel Fernandes:
II. February 21, 2007
Posted By: joelferns Wed Feb 21, 2007 6:48 am
The above is all made up. I know Fritz very well and also the ICPE. I had a personal investigator work on this based in Bangalore and he was quoted as saying "there is a sort of campaign against Dom within ICPE (because of all
the stupid things he keeps doing)* to which Dom is actually reacting, which he should not be doing…
You remember that interview with Glen & teresa?
The reason I gave you (before I knew anything about Dom) was that it was a very uncomfortable interview with strong sexual overtones and narrowing down to teresa's personal life. that has always cast a cloud over dom's character to me... and it is proving true… he did get into the call centre campaign and get into the papers and even on TV! he went to a girls college here and made them sign "Chastity Pledges" and the girls were like: "Who does he think he is! He made us feel so cheap like we are all selling ourselves!" some even remarked saying, "Who is this Holy Spirit who talks about and who seems to be revealing to him only the sexual sins of girls" u get the hint don't u? that's all i have to say for now".
Thanks my friend for the inputs. I know Dom personally and that is the reason I can say, that his exposure of ICPE is totally a personal assault on the Fritz and the ICPE. *Text added by me [Joel Fernandes]
LOOK OUT FOR THE COMPLETE CONVERSATION BETWEEN JOEL AND MR. DIXON IN A FUTURE UPDFATE.
III. February 22, 2007
Posted By: domdix Thu Feb 22, 2007 11:49 am
Jeol, You need to get your facts right. Why would there be a campaign against me at the ICPE? I thought that they were a religious group. Be careful of what you say.
Note that Dominic Dixon is always threatening people, for example "Be careful of what you say", and that the people whom he threatens are ALWAYS those whom he has associated closely with earlier.
One may also note that all of the people whom I have cited in this report from emails and blog posts believe that Dixon is a VERY disturbed person, some of them saying that he is psychotic and needs therapy. There are many more, including priests, who have spoken this to me in person or on the telephone but are afraid to put their words in writing to me for fear of retribution from Dixon.
When I made the first installment of this report public, I mentioned that I expected to be threatened, and I did expect abuse and slander in the public domain, but the ferocity and devilish ingenuity of his personal attacks on people associated with this ministry took even me by surprise. The details of those instances cannot be revealed by me at this point in time. We may do so in the future, if discerned to be necessary.
From: MORELOVE To: MORELOVE FRIENDS Sent: Tuesday, July 08, 2008 12:04 AM
Subject: Semper Reformanda - always reforming
Recently in Bangalore, there was a case reported of a youth leader who was repeatedly sexually molested by his mentor who belonged to a prominent Catholic missions’ organisation. This boy had done his discipleship at this missions’ organization. His greatest pain was that the mentor said that he saw nothing wrong in his actions and gave the youth leader a philosophical explanation. The danger is that this mentor will be ordained a Catholic priest in the next few months. How did this happen? This happened because of the negligent lifestyle and leadership as there is a delinquent pattern with this ministry. This ministry had started off very well and have done great things, but now, the testimony is lost. Dom
NOTE THE USE OF THE PHRASE "missions’ organisation" [to describe ICPE] IN BOTH, the above MoreLove circular signed by Dixon as well as in the alleged "report from religious investigating officers and journalists" on page 32. The SAME phrase is used by Dixon in his Mangalorean Catholics post of April 20, 2010, see page 35,
And yet again, for a FOURTH TIME, in his Mangalorean Catholics post of May 17, 2010, also on page 35
NOTE ALSO THE REFERENCE by Dixon to "Adolf Hitler of Nazism", page 31, is uncannily similar to his calling Fr. Adolf Washington "Hitler", see page 17. Must I continue to furnish evidence that the ghost-writer is Dixon?
Despite his vicious slanderous attacks on Fritz Mascarenhas/ICPE in February 2007 [EXPOSURE: Freedom from Fascism and Fritzism! pages 11, 12 and 31-33], June 2007 [pages 25-29], [with the intervention of a pretended repentance on July 24, 2007, see page 29] and July 2008 [on this page] he interviews and felicitates the very same Fritz Mascarenhas on HSI MoreLove Radio just a few months down the road:
From: HSI MORELOVE RADIO To: MORELOVE FRIENDS Sent: Tuesday, November 25, 2008 11:21 PM
Subject: Authentic Ministry : Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas & Dr. Dominic Dixon
A conversation with Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas, Director – ICPE, International Catholic Program for Evangelisation
&
Dr. Dominic Dixon, Director - HSI MoreLove Radio
with personal testimony, pearls of wisdom & revival!
Wednesday Nov. 26 TO Friday Nov. 28 @ 1pm & 5pm IST.
We @ HSI MoreLove Radio honour Bro. Fritz for his service to God by dedicating our new song to him:
Thanks brother, for calling home, all the lost!
Log on to to listen to the conversation with the song "Coming Home"
33.
But fewer than 18 months later, in April 2010, he is at Fritz Mascarenhas' throat yet again, once more utilising the Mangalorean Catholics [MC] forum for continuing his vendetta against Fritz and ICPE:
I. The following article, posted in Mangalorean Catholics on April 19, 2010, may be accessed at
The sex scandals in catholic churches, April 10, 2010
Posted by J. S. Rodricks, April 19, 2010
:
The sex scandals in catholic churches by Israel Jayakaran
What’s wrong with the Catholic churches and their priests? Day in and day out, we read in the papers that a particular priest molested some young girls, one Fr sexually abused some 200 deaf boys. Recently there was a news in Chennai, India that a Fr had misbehaved with an young girl somewhere in the USA. And he happily escaped quietly back to Chennai evading the investigation. The Archbishop of Chennai had told the concerned priest to go back to the States, face the inquiry and clear himself or receive the appropriate punishment. The Pope has also been accused of taking a lean view on such cases and nearly closing his eyes to the happenings in various churches.
One needs to go into the root cause of such sexual misdemeanor rather than focusing on particular incidents.
I think the basic trouble lies in the condition that all Catholic priests should be single men. Which Pope had laid down this proviso? The Catholic church claims that Apostle Peter was their first Pope, who was a married man. Somewhere down the line of Popes, some Pope had brought the ‘single person’ criterion. Where in the Bible has it been stated that those who do God’s work must be bachelors? According to the old Testament, God appointed Prophets to carry His messages through to the people. God never insisted that they be bachelors. Moses, God’s most favorite prophet had 4 wives. Coming to the New Testament era, Apostle Paul refused to marry and raise a family all because he felt that he cannot divide his time between the Gospel and the family. He wanted all his time for preaching Jesus Christ’s good news. Simultaneously, he had also said that he did not recommend celibacy to all evangelists; if they cannot stick to bachelorship, they must get married. So, by what Biblical authority, did that Pope whoever it was, demand bachelorhood as a pre- requisite to join the priest community in the Catholic system? He is answerable to God for this stringent rule, which is against all norms of life, at the time of judgment. The Protestant church permits its pastors, deacons, bishops and moderators to marry. They also do God’s work, don’t they?
It is my information that the catholic priests in many African countries have defied this edict from the Vatican and had gone ahead with the marital status. The Pope hadn’t been able to prohibit them or punish them for this step.
Will some Pope be bold enough and remove this obligation? That will put a stop to all sexual malpractices.
I had the privilege of teaching the English language in a catholic seminary for some ten years. All my students were school pass outs around the age of 17. They were the future priests around the age of 25 after all kinds of training.. Can young men of this age group, suppress their sexual urge? Isn’t it unfair to expect them to do so also? They cannot. It is natural. So, they resort to all kinds of moral depravity. And their immoral behaviour among their congregation makes world news casting aspersions on the character of the Christian community as a whole.
In such a scenario, the Catholic church has two options. One, to permit the priest clan to marry if they wish to. Next, to recruit only persons above the age of sixty, either single or widowers, to become clergymen. Would the current Pope please take a decision and clean up the mess of sexual corruption in the church? Whatever step he takes in this regard would certainly have God’s approval and the world would hear no complaints of sexual crimes any more.
The above article I found in the net and feel this is a suitable subject for discussion with an open mind. Since there are many learned priests and Catholics in this blog, I thought we may share our thoughts with others through this blog
Joseph and Stella Rodricks, Bangalore.
The article, purportedly written by Israel Jayakaran, a retired Colonel of the Indian armed forces who expired on February 1, 2013, is so replete with grammatical and other errors [for example, "one Fr", "a news in Chennai" and "The Archbishop of Chennai"] that I suspected that it was authored by Dominic Dixon, which I mentioned in the earlier edition of this report, especially since Israel Jayakaran’s profile states that he "turned into an English teacher during my retired life. Have evolved a new method of teaching English for learners from non-English speaking countries". Moreover, there is no traceable record of any other writing by him on religious issues, Catholic or otherwise. This is a puzzle that will probably never be solved.
II. Church-baiter Allwyn Fernandes wrote, , Congratulations to you both for saying what you did, boldly and out loud, when many are finding it convenient to say what their priests and bishops want them to say. Fr Henri Boulad, the Jesuit from Egypt has made the same point in a long
open letter he wrote three years ago. Sadly, the Pope chose not to respond to him. Celibacy should be optional, with the right to opt out should you come across someone you choose to love. That is why many people who want to devote their
lives to the service of society choose to stay away from convents or seminaries - and they live good lives. Because the free choice is applicable every day of their lives. They dont feel imprisoned.
Many members of MC find it a good place to post anti-Catholic, heretical, New Age and other such stuff that shows the Church in a bad light with the open support of the liberal owner-moderator Ancy D’Souza which finally resulted in the exit of a few members including the other moderator Derrick D’Costa and me.
34.
III. Mangalorean Catholics digest no. 1973 dated April 20, 2010
Posted by: "Dr Dominic Dixon" MangaloreanCatholics@ domdix Apr 20, 2010 1:53 am (PDT)
Hello everyone,
I agree with the views that somewhere, the Church have [sic] taken God's authority into its own hands!
In Bangalore, a lay missions organization that just had it's first Priest ordained, has two in the making.
Sometime ago, one of the Priest [sic] in the making was caught molesting a boy several times from that youth group. When the boy questioned the perpetrator, the perpetrator phiosphised [sic] it and explained the different types of love and said that his actions were love as another Priest had expressed the same to him, sexually & verbally.
The perpetrator is now in Rome doing his final studies. He was a student of St. Peter's Pontifical Seminary in Bangalore.
What was the action taken by the Director of that missions organization, NOTHING, as usual, put everything under the carpet. The victim was my counsellee [sic] and now rehabilated [sic] and has forgiven [sic] the perpetrator.
I belive [sic] that if the perpetrator has repetented [sic], then God has forgiven him. My only concern is - has the perpetrator been helped or are we going to see more scandals.
We all have our weaknesses as I am aware of mine. We need to acknowledge that we have our struggles and not deny it. Having said that, there is no condemnation in the above mentioned, but I am going to do my part in praying for us, the Body of Christ. Love, Dr. Dominic Dixon
The above was communicated by me to the ICPE director and to three ICPE seminarians, two of who are now ordained:
From: prabhu To: fritz mascarenhas; Name Withheld 1; Name Withheld 2; Name Withheld 3
Sent: Tuesday, April 20, 2010 9:01 PM Subject: CONFIDENTIAL. SLANDEROUS ACCUSATION AGAINST ONE OF YOU, APPARENTLY. PLEASE PROTECT MY IDENTITY
Dear Fritz, Bro. Nn, Bro. Nn [with a copy to Fr. Nn],
I thought that you should know this. Dominic Dixon has been writing on this forum, MangaloreanCatholics, and elsewhere against ICPE for a long time. It is read by 5,000 Mangaloreans in India and all over the world.
It is not difficult for most people to identify the organization and it’s Director.
If you feel that you should respond to this, the moderators' email addresses are as follows:
1. Mr Ancy D'Souza: ancyds@; salusoz@yahoo.co.in;
2. Mr. Derrick D'Costa: derrickdcosta@;
PLEASE ENSURE NOT TO REVEAL MY IDENTITY. I AM FIGHTING ERROR AND ANTI-CATHOLICISM IN THIS FORUM ON AN ALMOST DAILY BASIS.
In solidarity with you, Michael
I did not receive an acknowledgement. Today, I have taken the decision to publish this and all other related correspondence –Michael
Below, Mr. Dixon uses a completely unrelated thread to bombard the hapless Fritz Mascarenhas and ICPE:
Mangalorean Catholics digest no. 2004 dated May 17, 2010
Re: Our Mangalore bishop is too busy with inaugurations and blessing
Posted by: "Dominic Dixon, Bangalore" MangaloreanCatholics@ Mon May 17, 2010 1:03 am (PDT)
Dear Joseph/ Stella [Rodricks],
It is the right for one to stay anonymous in a public forum. As the head of a media organization & the head of a social justice organization, I advise you not to try to rob them of that choice. In the Christians spirit, we have a choice to address the issue. If it is true, have the guts to dialogue with the Bishop. If not, continue to clarify the issue.
The Bishop may be a living Saint, I do not dispute that. His human element could urge him out of his first calling and that needs to be addressed.
There is one funda-mental-ist, so called Catholic missionary organization in Bangalore that have ripped people apart when they brought up issues while they encourage adulterers & homosexulaus [sic] as missionaries in their minsitry [sic] till this day. Let us dialogue and not suppreess [sic]. Regards, dom.
This was informed by me to the ICPE director and to three ICPE seminarians, two of who are now ordained:
From: prabhu To: fritz mascarenhas; Name Withheld 1 ; Name Withheld 2 ; Name Withheld 3 ;
Sent: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 6:25 PM Subject: DOM DIXON IS STILL AT IT! [As above]
Only one of the seminarians, now a priest, acknowledged receipt of this letter.
THE "SUNDER DASS" EPISODE – CHECK OUT MY INTRODUCTION ON PAGE 12
In June 2009, I received an email from a person calling himself "SUNDER DASS". The email, reproduced here, is an attack on the moral character of Anthony Sagayaraj, a former chairman of the Bangalore Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal [CCR]. Once again, the Mangalorean Catholics forum is used.
From: Sunder Dass dasssunder51@yahoo.in To: dasssunder51@yahoo.in Date: Wednesday, 17 June, 2009, 6:30 PM
Subject: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Sunder Dass Sub Editor of a secular publication (Chennai) 35.
Another major humiliation in Bangalore. The Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal is yet again in another high profile scandal with its service team member, Anthony Sagayaraj.
Anthony Sagayaraj, working at an NGO and a long time member of the Bangalore Service Team, was found guilty during an investigation in Bangalore, moderated by Simon Rodrigues, chairman of the Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Anthony was found guilty last week of "defamation of character" of a young girl and several other youth over the years. A youth from a youth group in Bangalore said that "Anthony is a sly and corny man" while another youth said that "he is a man who is a stronghold in the renewal". One of the leaders of a large ministry with over twenty years of being an evangelist in Bangalore said that "Anthony is the cause of disunity in the renewal" while another said that "he is hungry for power and he abuses it".
This issue was brought to our notice here in Chennai through the victim’s family members who were fed with immoral information [sic] about their own child. The mother of the victim and other parents now refuse to attend the “Bread of Life” prayer meeting because Anthony is a leader there. The mother spoke to a legal counsellor today and in her statement in Bangalore has expressed that her family was tormented with Anthony’s actions which almost broke her marriage as the father accused the mother too and refused to speak to the daughter who is innocent and now depressed, undergoing serious psychological counselling. She says that Anthony took her aside after the prayer meeting and told her derogative things about her daughter which made her feel "dirty and humiliating" [sic]. She says that leaders like Anthony should never be given a chance to preach again and should be shown the door. She and her family members threaten to sue the Charismatic Renewal if this persists and will boycott any meeting that Anthony preaches at.
Just today the wedding anniversary of the victim’s parents was celebrated and over 80% of their relatives did not attend the much anticipated celebrations due to the vicious act of Anthony Sagayaraj that has left deep scars on the family’s image and has caused separation. The victim says that Anthony needs to know that even he has daughters. The mother of the victim had cried bitterly today because at their Mass, the husband stood on the opposite side of the Church and did not even wish "sign of peace" to his wife. Such are the ramifications [sic] of Antony’s well planned wicked deeds.
The investigation uncovered Anthony’s brainwashing and indoctrination of parents about their children’s companions. Anthony is also a leader of the oldest prayer group in Bangalore , the "Bread of Life" which according to three women, is known to be a warehouse of gossip mongers with luke-warm [sic] Catholics and is also the prayer meeting where Anthony indoctrinated the victim’s mother.
Anthony had been an undercover spy in demoralizing the youth of Bangalore and because of his strong hold in the charismatic renewal, has been getting away. This time he had spoken against the character of a young girl who had just come to the renewal. The girl had drafted a letter to the State Human Rights Commission and two others had an FIR [sic]. Anthony was asked by several people to resign from his position, but he shamefully has not done so even after causing a great deal of hurt to the already tainted image of the renewal.
It was also found that Anthony has also had riffs with his female colleague. His file at office indicates that his integrity was questioned in the areas of money laundering but it was overlooked. We were informed that he is quite unfaithful in spending the appropriate required time at work and arrives late, leaves early and takes leave, unaccounted for.
All legal action was apparently dropped due to the request of Simon Rodrigues, who according to the victim was calm.
The above slanderous letter has "Dominic Dixon" written all over it. It purports to be from a sub editor based in Chennai, but my enquiries with the media, with which I have fairly good contacts, reveal that there is no one in the media named "Sunder Dass".
A few days later, "Sunder Dass" wrote directly to me, copying to me the above email of June 17. In his letter to me, below, he refers to a discussion thread "Affluence, power cause rot in the Church" in Mangalorean Catholics, claiming that someone forwarded it to him. However, since Mr. Dixon was a member of MC, he would have received it in his mailbox:
From: Sunder Dass To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Sunday, June 28, 2009 10:07 AM
Subject: Fw: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Dear Michael,
Your article to Harold "Affluence, power cause rot in the Church" was forwarded to me. Below is what I had run in within the regilious [sic] news forums and was requested not to get this out into the press.
As I read the issue of you lacking "humility" it is however the supression [sic] of reilgious [sic] people in power who abuse the God given authority. I have spoken to other voices such as yours in Bangalore, Chennai and Mumbai and people with over 25 years of serving God have complained about the strong hold in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal.
Will connect back with you when I'm back in the Country.
I appreciate your prophetic voice as I'm a convert to the Catholic Church. Best Regards Dass.
The referred "article" was not written by me as claimed by "Sunder Dass"/Mr. Dixon, but posted by Church-baiter and MC moderator, Ancy D’Souza on June 20. It concerned "Sr. Jesme, the author of the controversial book, 'Amen'" and was responded to on June 26 by one Harold Lobo who shared his thoughts, adding "Will some learned person who has studied church history (Mr. Michael Prabhu for example) enlighten readers about this?" to which I responded on June 27, see .
I wrote AGAINST the anti-Church slant set by Ancy D’Souza, also reproducing a June 16, 2009 article, "Bishop Tells Oxford Students to Challenge Dissent, Even in Priests or Bishops" by Patrick Craine from . 36.
"Sunder Dass" grabbed the opportunity to try and publicise his anti-Anthony Sagayaraj "news story". He let me believe that he was presently out of the country so that I could not use the telephone to speak to him. I decided to play along with "Sunder Dass" who I believed [and still do believe] to be Dominic Dixon:
From: prabhu To: dasssunder51@yahoo.in Sent: Monday, June 29, 2009 3:01 PM
Subject: Re: Fw: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Dear Sunder, I am happy to hear from a Catholic lay man like you.
Because my ministry is independent and impartial, I do get a lot of information and feedback from all over India, even from Chairpersons of some service teams of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal who tell me how other leaders including former Chairpersons try to undermine their positions and activities.
But this news about Bangalore takes me completely by surprise. Normally I would be the first to know, but in this case I must admit that I am totally ignorant. I am quite taken aback about the developments concerning Anthony Sagayaraj.
I have no personal problems with him, and in fact I like him and he has been good to me.
But I had always suspected that he was too good to be true, because there were some things about his actions that did not match his words. However I always gave him the benefit of the doubt, having no evidence, except that I noted that he rejects the position that the Catholic Church has accorded to Mother Mary, something that I could never reconcile with his being a Service Team chairperson.
I have stayed at his home in December 2007 when he invited me to give a two-day Seminar on Catholic apologetics to the leaders of the Bangalore Service Team. The Lord had already warned me about something concerning this invitation, it was again confirmed before I left Chennai, and once again after my arrival in Bangalore, but I did not share the details with Anthony Sagayaraj till now.
Today I can understand why. After the Seminar, public assurances were made by Anthony, unsolicited by me, but he did not honour them. It was only then that I really started to wonder about his credibility and integrity.
Then in July 2008 I started my crusade to have the New Community Bible withdrawn by the CBCI. Please see the homepage of my web site ephesians- to understand my ministry [and me] better. Anthony declined to give me a letter of support despite my several requests. After that I removed his name from my regular mailing list as I did with all those, even my best of friends who would not join me and fight for the faith of their children and grandchildren.
The report that you have written shocks me. But it should not. I have seen similar cases before concerning other Chairmen of Service teams and I have not been popular because of my open condemnation of what has been happening.
I look forward to meeting you at your convenience. God bless, Michael
In his response to me, "Sunder Dass" cunningly tries to use me to get his "news story" posted in MC. He also tries to draw me out on his own friend, Simon Rodrigues, the Chairman of the Bangalore Service Team who succeeded Anthony Sagayaraj, and I continued to play along:
From: Sunder Dass To: prabhu Sent: Monday, June 29, 2009 10:25 PM
Subject: Re: Fw: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Dear Michael, Thanks for responding so promptly. I am amazed and shocked to hear about Anthony. But like you said, it does not surprise.
Please feel free run the article at the Mangalore forum. I cannot post as I'm not a member.
Many people whom I've spoken to said that Anthony is a [sic] very "sly" and "two-faced". I also heard that the present leader of the renewal is a Pastor of some sort. How is that possible?
I was told that one of Anthony's friend became a Pastor and even took some Nuns with him. I was so shocked. Some one in the Catholic Church wrote against the issue and they sneared [sic] at him while Anthony told people that this writer was out of his head.
All this is so confusing. I beleive there is a Catholic social justice organisation in Bangalore that has taken up the case.
I have to leave right now. Will catch up with you in a while. Regards, Dass.
Not getting a response, "Sunder Dass" follows up on the above with a flattering email to me:
From: Sunder Dass To: prabhu Sent: Monday, June 29, 2009 10:15 PM Subject: Re: Fw: NEW COMMUNITY BIBLE: VATICAN HELD RESPONSIBLE, BRAHMIN LEADERS DEMAND ITS WITHDRAWAL
Dear Michael,
I just wonder how you get the courage to write such truths without compromise. I'm surprised as to how the leaders did not take action against you.
Me being a sub-editor, have restrictions from the publications I write at. Truly God must be with you.
Will get back to you at a later date. Thanks for the encouragement to speak the truth. Regards, Dass.
My reply to "Sunder Dass", from which he realises that he is not going to be able to use me to do his dirty work in MC, and finding me becoming inquisitive, he vanishes, not even responding to a reminder from me:
From: prabhu To: dasssunder51@yahoo.in Sent: Tuesday, June 30, 2009 9:56 AM Subject: BANGALORE, etc
Dear Dass,
I thank you for your two emails. To answer some of your questions, I must explain further.
37.
I regret that I am unable to post your report on MangaloreanCatholics for some reasons. My involvement there is 1) mainly to respond to questions put to me; 2) to correct erroneous postings made by others; 3) very rarely to post some news item on a topic related to Catholic faith, from a recognized Catholic source, to counter mis-information.
I am unable to even post my own alerts because they are labeled as personal attacks on individuals. My last successful attempt was a warning about maverick Jesuit priest Fr. Ronnie Prabhu, but there was a small storm after it got posted. So I have adopted a different strategy: I look for an opportunity against someone's posting to include references to my website and my articles.
Another thing is that, because of the very nature of my ministry, I am extremely careful not to print something unless I have personally verified all details from printed and published evidence if possible and from one or two other sources which verify it in writing. My research is meticulous and intensive. I cannot afford to make one small mistake because there are powers that naturally wish to see the end of my ministry. A couple of times I have made very small mis-statements and even those were taken very seriously and I had to apologize for them. One mistake will harm my credibility and nullify all the good work that I have done, as a lot of other questions may then arise.
In the case of your first letter to me, I at once noted that I could not know to which bishops and leaders exactly you had written. If you check the reports on my website, you will find that all identities are revealed. The only thing that I may conceal is the email address of the person who writes to me so that the person does not get spam. Otherwise his/her name is always revealed. My argument is this, that if a person wants to be anonymous, then he/she is not really and truly standing up for truth, justice and righteousness.
Only in one out of a few hundred cases have I withheld even the name of the person who might be a priest or a very senior leader in the CCR who might have requested anonymity so that they can continue to help me. I take the stand that if someone objects to my using their name, I would rather have nothing to do with that person because then I cannot trust him or her and if there is an enquiry on me or to me, I would be left stranded and without defense.
Of course, I am taking only about my ministry, and I completely respect you or anyone else that chooses to act differently and in their own style in their work or ministry.
A few times I have initiated some action on a letter received from someone or the other, and every time I had run into problems because I did not know enough to defend myself or my position when the party challenged me. I learned through experience. In most cases, the person who fed me with the information wanted to remain safe while I took the risk and it was often because the other person had some personal problem with the other party.
I hope you will understand my limitations and my principles and bear with me, in the overall interests of our ministries.
You asked how the "leaders" [Church or CCR] have not been able to restrict or stop me. The above is partly why. I ensure that my homework is done thoroughly. And I make my report on the basis of the teaching of the Church. If someone challenges me, they will effectively be saying that the Church is wrong! If you would kindly spend some time running through some of many reports, alerts and articles, ephesians- you would understand how I work. That is why I sent you that forward of my letter to Cardinal Tauran as an example. You will see that I gave Derrick D'Costa's name and even his email address as a guarantee of its legitimacy.
Again, you are 100% on the dot when you express your doubt about Simon Rodrigues being some sort of a pastor. I have always being saying that he is a closet Pentecostal. In fact the person referred to is me, and the report is mine! If you read on my web site the report ANTHONY SAMUEL-ADONAI'S BRIDE-CATHOLIC CHARISMATIC PREACHER TURNS PENTECOSTAL about a Catholic charismatic leader who left the Church, Simon's name figures in it twice on page 4. He made false prophesies to me. This is one of the very rare cases where I have disclosed personal information on my site, but I was obliged to do it, because I cannot stand Pentecostals pretending to be Catholics and subverting the Church from within. Anthony Sagayaraj and Simon Rodrigues are Pastor Samuel's closest friends in Bangalore and he’s been staying with them even till recently. People like Sandeep Rodrigues and Martin Ribeiro are also part of that group.
The powerful forces in Bangalore have never forgiven me for it, and I lost a number of friends and even a couple of benefactors. If we can work together and document more facts, I am more than willing to put together a new report. I am ready to visit Bangalore along with you to that end if you have people who will talk. It will be proper if I can make a pucca report for the National Service Team and the CBCI.
About the problem with the girl in Chennai, I know nothing. But there is something else very personal in connection with Simon, Anthony and Pastor Anthony Samuel that I will share with you when we meet.
Presently, I am slowly building a report on people close to the Goa Service Team who are involved in New Age centering prayer and other questionable stuff.
My telephone number is 2461 1606 and I live next to Foreshore Estate. Where do you live in Chennai? I am rather eager to meet with you. I don't know what you are the sub-editor of, but I respect whatever privacy you might want to keep. Love & Prayers, Michael
From: prabhu To: dasssunder51@yahoo.in Sent: Sunday, July 26, 2009 9:10 PM
Subject: WHY SILENT SINCE A MONTH?
NOW THINGS BEGIN TO GET EVEN MORE INTERESTING AS I DIG DEEPER INTO THE "SUNDER DASS" SAGA.
When Mr. Derrick D’Costa, the second MC moderator called me from Bahrain, we found that, having failed to instigate me to get his "story" published in MC, "Sunder Dass" had made an unsuccessful direct attempt.
38.
Here is my correspondence with Derrick D’Costa -- sent to him when I found that "Sunder Dass" had gone silent -- with my explanatory notes:
From: prabhu To: Derrick D'Costa Sent: Sunday, July 26, 2009 9:10 PM
Subject: CONFIDENTIAL: MY CORRESPONDENCE WITH SUNDER DASS
Dear Derrick, Thanks for your telephone call. This is what I told you about. Love, Michael
My entire correspondence was reproduced to Derrick D’Costa. Derrick informed me that "Sunder Dass" had, directly or through a third party [he did not say which], attempted to get his "news story" posted in the MC forum, the very day after he had received my above recorded evasive and inquisitory letter of June 30, and that his [Sunder Dass'] attempt had been thwarted by Mr. Ancy D’Souza, the owner-moderator:
From: Derrick D'Costa To: prabhu Sent: Monday, July 27, 2009 3:52 PM
Subject: CONFIDENTIAL- MY CORRESPONDENCE WITH SUNDER DASS
Yes we discussed this one- he must have posted it through someone else- He made a lot of personal points which have potential to hurt people and their loved ones.
From: Ancy D'Souza To: Derrick D'Costa
Sent: Wednesday, July 1, 2009 3:37:23 AM Subject: Fwd: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Dear Derrick, I do not think this may be published in our group. What do you feel? With regards Ancy
From: Derrick D'Costa To: Ancy D'Souza
Sent: Wednesday, July 1, 2009 5:46 AM Subject: Fwd: Attn: Bishops & Leaders [Humiliation in Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal]
Dear Ancy, This one is good for deletion. God bless, Derrick
From: prabhu To: Derrick D'Costa Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2009 4:45 AM Subject: URGENT: SUNDER DASS
Dear Derrick, Can you let me know clearly who exactly tried to get the Anthony Sagayaraj story posted in MC? What name or alias or id did he use? Did he write to MC or to Ancy personally? What was the date of the attempt? Please be clear in your reply, because I think that I know who did it. You know the guy. Shall confirm on hearing from you. Love, Michael
From: Derrick D'Costa To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2009 11:38 AM Subject: Re: URGENT: SUNDER DASS
Dear Michael It is quite difficult to find out. I did go through the logs and some deletions were made both by me and Ancy. But one Dass Sunder membership was accepted around that time. Even though Ancy allows me I do not approve memberships due to a huge number of spammers and right-wing fellows. It was deleted as the mail suggests on 1 July. God bless Derrick
From: prabhu To: Derrick D'Costa Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2009 12:30 PM Subject: Re: URGENT: SUNDER DASS
Dear Derrick, It was Dominic Dixon. I got an inspiration and studied careful the style of the writer.
Moreover, no one else has such agendas and personal grudges. He was careful to say that he was not in India so that he need not give me his telephone number. It is he. I am certain. What a crook and schemer! Love, Michael
From: Derrick D'Costa To: prabhu Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2009 2:05 PM Subject: Re: URGENT: SUNDER DASS
Dear Michael, If so, then we have let a very nasty person in. Dominic is anyway a member, I cannot understand why he would want a fake ID. I am sure unless it is very late at night and Ancy is distracted such mails of his will not get through. God bless, Derrick
So, quod erat demonstratum, "Sunder Dass" IS Dominic Dixon.
Now, if one will once again look at my long letter of June 30 to Mr. Dixon, upon receipt of which he realised that he was not going to get anywhere with me, and then look at the correspondence with me below -- which commenced a few hours later on the VERY SAME day, one will see that the new alias -- which Derrick could not recall because a month had elapsed before my inquiry was made with him and the post was deleted from MC -- donned by Dominic Dixon was CYRIL SUNIL DANTHI!
THE "CYRIL SUNIL DANTHI" EPISODE, ANOTHER OF DOMINIC DIXON’S ALIASES?
The post "Affluence, power cause rot in the Church" referred to in the subject line was from the owner-moderator, Ancy D’Souza, and other MC members had also commented, but he chose to write to me:
From: Cyril Danthi cyrilsunil@ To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Monday, June 29, 2009 5:41 PM
Subject: Re: Affluence, power cause rot in the Church
I do agree with your views, Cyril Danthi
From: prabhu To: cyrilsunil@ Sent: Tuesday, June 30, 2009 8:47 AM Subject: THANKS, CYRIL
Dear Cyril, Thank you. You must be referring to my posting in Mangalorean Catholics though I do not recall seeing your name before. My website is ephesians-. Kindly visit it. Love & Prayers, Michael
39.
From: cyrilsunil@
To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Tuesday, June 30, 2009 12:00 PM Subject: Re: THANKS, CYRIL
Dear Sir I just went through your website, really its good, I could not go through it thoroughly ... since I am at work now, however I think I have found a really good group where i can interact and contribute. Prayers and Grace of blessing 2 you,
regards, Cyril
Cyril Sunil Danthi made exactly one post in Mangalorean Catholics -- on July 24, 2009, . Cyril Danthi is a real person -- his profile may be accessed on the Internet -- but Cyril Sunil Danthi isn’t. If I am wrong -- and I doubt that I am -- I invite the real Danthi to contact me by email and give me his telephone number.
THE "ROHAN F. BRITTO" EPISODE
Almost concurrent with all of the above correspondence, a new front emerged, this time from Dubai:
From: rohan@ Sent: Sunday, July 26, 2009 8:47 PM
To: 'Bro. Michael Prabhu' Subject: IDOL WORSHIP IN CHURCHES - An Open Letter Importance: High
The Peace & Love of Christ Jesus and the Holy Spirit Be With You Always,
Dear Bro. Michael,
Let me briefly introduce myself as a very deeply rooted Catholic whose very life and existence revolves around the Eucharistic Lord with the intercession of MOM (Mother Our Mother). I have been following your zeal for the Catholic Church and Thank and Praise Abba from the bottom of my heart and depth of my soul for filling you with his Spirit of Truth and Wisdom to challenge erroneous catholic doctrine. Bro, I am not sure if you have ever read this letter below but it is of deep concern for what is written so blatantly and spread across using different media.
Below please find an Open Letter to the Church titled “IDOL WORSHIP IN CHURCHES” written and circulated by Dominic Dixon (Founder of HSI More Love Radio) who is supposedly conducting Charismatic Seminars with other prominent preachers in Bangalore. He is also a partner of the widely spreading Holy Spirit Interactive Movement (which has many unanswered questions of its own)
These are certainly very provocative, deeply concerning statements and will raise unwanted questions among the Catholic laity and lead them to search for answers in the wrong places which this is what I firmly believe that these people in the Jesus business intend to do (using the cover of unveiling truth) but ultimately gathering numbers which translate into $$$. What has got my nerves ticking is not the fact of him questioning the Idol Worship in Our Catholic Church but what I have quoted from his letter below where he is now questioning the BLESSED SACRAMENT: “I had done a survey of Catholic retreats. In carrying out the survey, my findings indicated that around 87% of Catholics cannot stay focused on praise and worship or a walk through during retreats, if the Blessed Sacrament is not exposed. Furthermore, Catholics demonstrated more reverence for God, only when the Blessed Sacrament was exposed. When I had dialogued with some international Catholic retreat leaders, their response was that “Catholics need something tangible” in order to worship.”
Bro. Michael, I hope you understand my grave concern especially when someone who is preaching from the pulpit and a structured platform but is now questioning the presence of The Eucharistic Lord in The Blessed Sacrament which is the centre and focus of Our Church – Our Life!
I have being lead very deeply to share my heart with you on this with the hope that such leaders are corrected and not permitted to PREY on people with their own personal agendas.
Humbly in Christ, Bro. Rohan (Dubai)
From: Rohan F Britto To: 'Bro. Michael Prabhu' Sent: Wednesday, August 19, 2009 1:06 AM
Subject: FW: IDOL WORSHIP IN CHURCHES - An Open Letter
Dear Bro Michael, I pray all is well with you, further to my last mail below I did not receive any acknowledgement from you and so am unsure if you received the same and so I am resending it to you for your valuable perusal, comments and actions.
I continue to pray and thank Jesus each day for giving you the Spirit of Truth and helping you in all your endeavours. Humbly in Christ Jesus, Bro. Rohan .
Rohan F. Britto is a real person with a Dubai-based ministry. I reproduce here the article purported to be written by Dominic Dixon that was sent to me by Rohan Britto:
IDOL WORSHIP IN CHURCHES An open letter to the Church!
By Dr. Dominic F. Dixon, March 16, 2009
Please Note: In writing to the Church in this tone, it is with the purest of intentions only for the purpose of building the Church and to bring people to the authentic knowledge of Christ. Sometimes it is difficult to write such letters not for the fear of being ostracized, but of being misunderstood. Having said that, I rather obey God and present the authentic Gospel!
“Priest admits to idol worship in Church”* These were the headlines in the newspaper in Bangalore on Thursday, March 12, 2009 [DH]. I spoke to the Priest who was accused of making that statement and he said that those were not his statements and that it was fabricated. I really wished that the Priest had actually made that statement.
40.
* March 12, 2009 [from Express News Service, March 11] and March 13, 2009.
According to indiantake.blogspot, "no other English newspaper has carried this story. Even the 'New Indian Express' has not carried this story on its website. That is why I have reproduced the entire article here".
Indeed, we have adulterated worship in our Church. We idolize our rituals, we paganize our shrines, we even legalize our prayer life and in doing so, we have lost the purpose of our very being, which is to have a relationship with God.
When a protestant calls a Catholic an idol worshipper, he should first remove the Cross that hangs in his Church, remove the name board of the Church and remove the Pastor, because at many Churches, the Pastor is idolized (hero worship). The concept of biblical idolatry is not so much that of kissing statues of saints per se. It is more of substituting your intimate relationship with God for something tangible i.e. Romans 1:25 “They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served created things rather than the Creator—who is forever praised. Amen.”
No matter how you define sin, sin is sin. You can call sex out of marriage as love making; it is still adultery and is still an abomination to the Lord.
I had done a survey of Catholic retreats. In carrying out the survey, my findings indicated that around 87% of Catholics cannot stay focused on praise and worship or a walk through during retreats, if the Blessed Sacrament is not exposed. Furthermore, Catholics demonstrated more reverence for God, only when the Blessed Sacrament was exposed. When I had dialogued with some international Catholic retreat leaders, their response was that “Catholics need something tangible” in order to worship.
Around 82% of Protestants on the other hand, especially the Pentecostals, cannot worship nor have their services without vibrant worship, even if that worship is a mere sounding gong. This is also partly the case with some Catholic Charismatic groups.
It is the desire of ardent Catholics, for our people to have an intimacy with Christ rather than the symbolic clinging on of a saintly image. The Catholic Church has failed, I say it again, failed to bring its flock to an intimacy with Christ. You can call a separation of marriage as “annulment“, it is still separation and a violation of Mark 10:9 and it is propagation of divorce. You can call kissing and garlanding of a statue as veneration [CCC Paragraphs #’s 127, 2132, 2141], it is still a violation of God’s law and of the commandments. The Church in its wisdom has foolishly presented Christ.
The Protestant Church has idolized its number of flock, or its worship band, they even idolized the image of the Cross.
When Aaron had built and worshiped the golden calf, he could have called it as the lamb to be slaughtered! Justification can happen on every event, but is our justification authentic? How do we define authenticity? It is through the word of God. Just as Catholicism accuses Protestantism of removing seven books of the Bible and called it the Apocrypha, the Catholic Church is also accused of adding to the Word of God through the “documents” and “encyclicals” which is equated with the views of Mormonism who [sic] adds to the Bible.
If you take a man, enroll him in a discipleship program for one to three months; put him to sit for two years and call it formation, after those two years he will preach from the CCC [Catechism of the Catholic Church] rather than from the Holy Bible. This we have seen happen at our prayer groups. What has happened to the Priest is who has studied doctrines, theology & philosophy for fourteen years? How many of them do you find with an evangelical fervor?
Why is the Catholic Church not taking a stand and telling its people that kissing of a statute is not authentic worship and neither is the statue a mediator?
The main reason why a non-Catholic heathenizes a Catholic, it‘s secondly because of our zealous devotion to Mary the mother of Jesus. Devotion is perhaps accepted, but the way people pray to her, Jesus seems to have second or no place. How much of a Catholic you are, is defined by the love to God only with the Holy Trinity and your love to people, not your devotions or rituals.
Living in a pluralistic society and a pantheistic culture, a pantheist doesn’t mind accepting Christ as one more of its gods, et al Acts 17:23 “For as I walked around and looked carefully at your objects of worship.” That’s what happens at our shrines, an addition to other gods. When a non Christian loses an article, he goes to St. Anthony’s shrine since he’s the patron saint of lost article. Who instituted that?
In trying to bring Christ into a cultural society, inculturation has caused more damage than presenting the Gospel. What is the use of inculturation if the true meaning and a true Christ is not being presented? When we have these practices, heresies and infidelity of the Gospel are unavoidable, as St. Thomas defines heresy: "a species of infidelity in men who, having professed the faith of Christ, corrupt its dogmas".
41.
There are priests who promote and incorporate pluralistic theism in disguise of ecumenism and inculturation. The Vatican is well informed about these wolves in sheep clothing but have found it difficult to act in accordance with the word of God. There are Bishops who attend seminars and large presentations of transcendental meditation, yoga and new age movements yet condemn other Christian denominations when there are evangelistic gatherings.
It is true that there have been instances that during Holy Mass, priests have read from the other non Christian religious books and used those texts during sermons to promote heresies. I have personally admonished one of India’s prominent Bishops for doing so.
Titus 2:1 You must teach what is in accord with sound doctrine.
When a Catholic priest is leading his flock into destruction and heresy, and when a protestant protests against this heresy and leads the flock back into the truth, he is doing exactly what is right and we Catholics just cannot blame a protestant denomination and call them sheep stealers for they are leading people into the Truth. (I mean this statement with the highest level of integrity as I am a Catholic)
James 5:20 Remember this: Whoever turns a sinner from the error of his way will save him from death and cover over a multitude of sins.
It is like this, if the parents abuse children, the government will intervene and protect the children from abuse and will put them in homes and appoint foster parents.
Titus 1: 9 He must hold firmly to the trustworthy message as it has been taught, so that he can encourage others by sound doctrine and refute those who oppose it.
Though we have these ecclesiastical adulterers and perverts of the Gospel, we should not abandon our faith and go to another denomination. Just because our parents are not right, we cannot abandon them nor can we pretend that we are not a member of the family. That’s the reason why I’m still a devoted Catholic.
I called up my friend who is a God fearing, powerful politician right after his meal with President Barak [sic] Obama and in my conversation I asked him about the President. His response was “he’s liberal in his thinking”
On another occasion, due to my international missions and not being able to be in India for the Prime Ministers’ meeting, my friend called me from the PM’s office and told me that the PM is looking into the morality of the nation. Who is a better human being, Obama, a confessing Christian, professing that abortion is a freedom of choice, or Dr. Manmohan Singh, a non confessing Christian, with Christian values?
Brennan Manning reflected upon this thinking when he said, "The greatest single cause of atheism in the world today is Christians, who acknowledge Jesus with their lips and walk out the door, and deny Him by their lifestyle. That is what an unbelieving world simply finds unbelievable."
The most powerful humans who hold superior positions in governments and businesses have embraced this belief system. India is one such country of secularism and fanaticism and extremism and radicalism. Quite sadly, the Church has become a victim to these systems and counterfeit beliefs. During sermons; there are so many preachers and priests who seem to propagate humanism and relativism if not the prosperity gospel.
The Church does not know anything about true success. We have built orphanages, synagogues and mansions, but we have forgotten to build the kingdom of God. We boast of having over a billion Catholics, then why are the Churches in Europe empty, shut down and converted in [sic] mosques and bars? The Protestant revolution broke out of Germany, then why have the Protestants failed in sustaining the Gospel amongst those it has evangelized to [sic]? We have become too complacent and have forgotten to set our hearts and minds upon the Lord. For the Catholic Church it has been how many rituals we profess. For the Protestant Church it has been how many souls we have brought into the Church, even if those souls were from another denomination.
“The first step in reformation is repentance. We evangelicals need to confess individually and collectively that we have betrayed the Great Commandment to love God with our minds. We need to confess that we have given ourselves up to countless forms of unutterable folly.” Os Guinness
The danger of the Church lies in its legalism of methods of worship.
What we need to understand is that in the West, secular humanism is the religion. A religion where there is no deity but self. In the East, the religion is pantheistic.. The danger for the Judeo-Christian belief is that we will be ostracized if we do not believe in a relativistic system. The Church needs to know to draw the line of polarities, stand united and support lay missionary organizations who strive to proclaim the Gospel in such heinous times as these.
The Church has to deal with the philosophical issues of outside the Church because the world is full of philosophies and notions. The Church needs to learn to think. We have become dumbfounded and cloistered in shells of the four walls of our Church and prayer groups.
I’ve come across many teaching groups who profoundly teach the word, but when a question is asked, they have no sense of rationality or logic to present the argument of the context.
We have come across Christian spiritual leaders who do not believe in Christ anymore, yet preach about Him or celebrate Mass. A Bishop of England went of [sic] national television and said that he does not believe in the virgin birth nor does he believe in the resurrection. That night a storm hit one spot of that city and the altar at York Minster was scorched. Nobody knew what happened. The headline in London the next day said this: “If that weren’t of God, it ought to have been“. Even the skeptic began to criticize the Church clergy of double standards and the atheist moved from being an atheist to now being an agnostic because now he simply does not know!
Romans 1 says 29They have become filled with every kind of wickedness, evil, greed and depravity. They are full of envy, murder, strife, deceit and malice. They are gossips, 30slanderers, God-haters, insolent, arrogant and boastful; they invent ways of doing evil; they disobey their parents; 31they are senseless, faithless, heartless, ruthless. 32Although they know God's righteous decree that those who do such things deserve death, they not only continue to do these very things but also approve of those who practice them.
Dearly beloveds, indeed, the time of the coming of our Lord seems nearer now than ever before. Signs of His coming are more prominent with the atrocities and disasters happening around us that the Holy Scriptures speaks about. It’s as if we who are in tune with the Lord can hear His footsteps and the roaring of His voice. Let us come to the Lord in fervent worship, living lives of purity. May garments of the bride be spotless at the coming of the Groom!
Much love and prayers, Love, dom.
Sometimes, it is difficult to understand exactly which side Dominic Dixon is on. For example:
-Just as Catholicism accuses Protestantism of removing seven books of the Bible and called it the Apocrypha, the Catholic Church is also accused of adding to the Word of God through the “documents” and “encyclicals” which is equated with the views of Mormonism who [sic] adds to the Bible.
-You can call kissing and garlanding of a statue as veneration [CCC Paragraphs #’s 127, 2132, 2141], it is still a violation of God’s law and of the commandments… Why is the Catholic Church not taking a stand and telling its people that kissing of a statute is not authentic worship…
Dixon appears to reject Church teaching on annulment of marriage when he writes:
-You can call a separation of marriage as “annulment“, it is still separation and a violation of Mark 10:9 and it is propagation of divorce.
He apparently sees no problem with Protestants' sheep-stealing from Catholics and indoctrinating them with their erroneous teachings of Sola Scriptura, Sola Fides and Sola Gratia. Being "born again", "saved" and "justified" are entirely different events for most Protestant denominations vis-à-vis what Catholics believe:
-We Catholics just cannot blame a protestant denomination and call them sheep stealers for they are leading people into the Truth
If protestant denominations are "into the Truth" [with an upper case T], what then are we Catholics into?
Rohan Britto, see page 40, took issue with Dixon’s revelations of the results of his claimed survey on Catholics and the Blessed Sacrament. I am unable to comment on them because, due to Dixon’s unique writing skills, I am unable to understand what exactly Dixon was attempting to say.
I wrote the following letter to Rohan Britto, but for all the zeal he had displayed in writing to me, he avoided replying. Maybe, as with "Sunder Dass", I should not have asked him for his telephone number or suggested that we should meet:
From: prabhu To: rohan@ Sent: Wednesday, August 19, 2009 4:12 PM
Subject: Re: FW: IDOL WORSHIP IN CHURCHES - An Open Letter
Dear Rohan, No, I did not receive your earlier letter of July 26 and that is why you did not hear from me.
Thank you very much for writing again.
I read and re-read several times the portion of Dominic Dixon's article that you quoted. To me, it did not seem that he was saying that Catholics idolized the Blessed Sacrament or that he questioned the Presence of the Eucharist Lord therein.
Could you try to explain it again to me, or anything else that you have to share?
Your is not opening*.
May I have your Dubai telephone number please? I am coming there shortly on mission and would be delighted to meet with you. Michael
*I only opened it today, March 22, 2013 -Michael
From: prabhu To: rohan@ Sent: Sunday, January 03, 2010 9:10 PM
Subject: CHRISTMAS & NEW YEAR GREETINGS [NO RESPONSE]
43.
MORE LETTERS
From: Name Withheld To: 'Michael Prabhu' Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2013 11:24 AM Subject: RE: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE [EDITED]
Thank you for sending me this information. It makes me sad. Please do not pursue this line, even if you are totally correct. One informative letter to his bishop, yes, but your ministry should not be sidetracked by all sorts of, maybe psychotic people. The world is full of them and inside and outside in our Catholic society there are plenty of people one could fault. We have little time to give solid Catholic teaching and information before a widespread persecution, not just of all Christians, but predominately of Catholics, which will break out. Your business is to help to save souls from getting lost in the quagmire of false New Age teachings and fashions and especially in India from syncretism.
When I saw the photo of Dixon, I thought that something was not ok with him psychologically, but I felt this might be due to the "evangelical" influence or some sort of wrong Christian teaching. His expression is fanatic and hence I conclude that he would fall into the category of "traitor" if and when it comes to widespread persecution.
From: Michael Prabhu To: Name Withheld Sent: Tuesday, March 19, 2013 5:21 PM Subject: Re: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE [EDITED]
I thank you for your letter. Regretfully, despite your kind suggestion, I must pursue this matter to a conclusion.
The initial inquiry was made of me separately by [a very senior charismatic leader] and a Goa lay ministry to check him out. Next, Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, Pontifical Missions Society, India called for a detailed report, which I submitted to him. As he declined to reply despite three reminders, I was constrained to publish the report on my site.
Mr. Dixon could have ignored it but he chose to blackmail and intimidate my two web masters and me. Things got serious when he threatened to use my reports to incite communal violence, so I had to send the report along with covering letters to different people associated with him. Exposing pseudo-Catholic preachers is one aspect of my ministry.
The other is exposing New Age. […] Many of the people on my mailing list, especially all the leaders, do not even say a thank you, to acknowledge receipt of my reports into which so much of time, energy and money goes in. But I continue, because I do not depend on that, as you know well. Mine is today I think the leading Catholic apologetics web site in Asia, consulted by ministries from all over the world regarding Hinduisation of the liturgy and New Age. So, I continue to do what you want me to do apart from which I expose the false prophets -- like Dixon -- in our fold.
From: Name Withheld To: 'Michael Prabhu' Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2013 4:35 AM
Subject: RE: FYI: False investigation URGENT [EDITED]
I am sad that Dixon is such a difficult type... Please try to set aside all investigation, accusations (even if you are totally right), this is a tool of the enemy to steal your time and to run down eventually your most important ministry.
I do not think that any clergy, Bishop or even Archbishop, will have any interest to see the truth of that matter. It will only confirm them in their view that the laity should not really be involved in "ministry-ing", but should just live a "sacramental Catholic life". You have to understand that most clergy are at heart "bureaucrats" to keep the structure of the Church alive. There is nothing wrong with that, as we have the greatest organisation in the world, functioning for 2000 years. It has always been up to the one exceptional character that followed the Lord’s calling to evangelise, to leave the safe haven and go out in the deep…
Just make sure, maybe with a letter of a solicitor, not the Bishop or clergy to warn Dixon about his threats to you and your family or colleagues. It should be officially recorded, but you have to chose a Catholic solicitor or lawyer and you should only write one letter and let the Archbishop have a copy, but do not ask the Archbishop to do more about. I believe that after a letter of warning you will be left in peace. From now on, even if you prayed protection regularly you will have to pray over your PC, books, correspondence, telephone, for protection under the precious blood of Christ.
Ask St Michael to protect your work and correspondence and the people you communicate with. Pray for the clergy involved to forget these incidents, do not seek justice, only protection of your person and work and of course the family.
If Dixon is not well, the more we have to be cautious to proceed. I think he goes down the path of many … leaders, who in the end lose common sense and fall…
If you carry on, all what will be remembered, whenever you bring attention to a wrong practice in our Church, will be ”the man who caused us trouble”, forgetting about which issue it was and never remembering that actually not you but Dixon was the trouble maker. The whole thing is an attack on your work Ephesians 5:11…
Your … work is in forefront of the battle against deceptive invasions of esoteric or occult practices into our Church.
Even here we have to be careful not to "throw the baby out with the bath water".
St Paul teaches about the freedom of a Christian in I Corinthians 6:12: A Christian is allowed to do anything he/she likes, BUT NOT ALL IS HELPFUL (for salvation), and "I will not be dominated by anything". Here is the key and recognition and the limitation how far we should condemn anything…
I will pray that a speedy conclusion of this matter will take place… When I saw Dixon’s picture I was not feeling ok [about him]. I thought either he was mentally afflicted or too much influenced by evangelical Christianity … I thought, that like yourself he was not recognised properly and that was why he embraced the wrong teaching then gave up. But I do think, after hearing your report, that he has a mental problem, on the lines of a psychopath.
What I wrote was in view of the ever increasing persecution of Catholics, your ministry is in the forefront for it.
Fear of persecution I feel is the reason for the increased syncretism in India’s Church.
You are in the frontline against the enemy. You disturb his deceitful actions among our Catholics.
A lay person with an international preaching and writing ministry
44.
The MoreLove/HSI report was sent to MoreLove/HSI associate and ëthos Institute team member Methodist Pastor K. Vasudevan along with the copy of my letter to the Archbishop of Bangalore, as below:
From: Michael Prabhu To: revkvasudevan@. Sent: [Log not maintained]
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE… {On masthead}
Pastor Vasudevan had not replied as on April 6, 2013.
Similar emails under different covering letters, along with the copy of our letter to the Archbishop of Bangalore, were sent to one Mr. Jacob Jose, to Mr. Simon Rodrigues, Chairman of the Bangalore Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, to Mr. Anthony Sagayaraj, the former Chairman, and to Bro. Fritz Mascarenhas, the Director of the International Catholic Programme for Evangelization [ICPE] and to two ICPE priests and a seminarian.
From: Michael Prabhu To: jekob@ ; jekobdesignery@
Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:30 PM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Jacob Jose,
Your name does not appear on the attached report, as of now at least.
Still, I am sending it to you for your kind information please.
The report, updated as at 2:45 pm on March 26, 2013, is attached.
Whether I include you in the next update to the report will depend on whether you reply or not and on what you have to say to me in your response, in case you decide to acknowledge this letter.
Your role, as understood by me, has been to make casual enquiries from my contacts in Bangalore, and feed that information to Mr. Dominic Dixon who used it to criminally threaten some of my associates.
I had spoken about your said role to senior Jesus Youth leaders earlier today, and their opinion of you was that you are a nice person and may not be aware of what Mr. Dixon has done with the information that you supplied him.
With their opinion in mind, I am now writing to you to help me to make my decision which will be based on your response.
From: jekobDesignery To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 8:33 PM Subject: Re: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Prabhu, May Jesus guide you. Do what you descern is right.
Since your intention is to help people realize their mistakes, amend their ways and return to Jesus, the Christ-like act would be meet them personally, clarify things with them and help them in charity to become useful members in the body of Christ, where you and I belong.
Your ministry will surely help many if "love" becomes the centre of all your activities.
Easter wishes in advance to you and your family.
Please note, I would not like any further communication on this matter. Exempt me from your mailing list.
Lovingly, Jacob
One comment by "Kiran" at our blog :
/ agape@ / 115.109.178.213 / Submitted on 2013/03/26 at 10:52 am
I seriously think that there is a confusion in all this. I took a look at their website and spoke to a few people who are Bangalore leaders. They all say that HSI is doing a good job. The Archbishop of Bangalore seems to be very please with their efforts. May be we have the wrong notion of things because of past experiences. If I was the writer of this blog, I would try and speak to these people in love and sort out the issues. From what I hear, HSI has done a lot for Catholics who were persecuted. Speak to them or just pray and drop the matter. Non Christians are watching what we are doing and they may use this against us.
The comment, which was posted the same day as our letter to Mr. Jacob Jose and his reply to me, was deleted by our moderator. On examining its style, it is quite evident that the comment is written by Mr. Dominic Dixon under the name "Kiran". It is strange to see Jacob Jose and Dominic Dixon appeal to "love" and be concerned about the anti-witness of this report to non-Christians. Where were those same sentiments when they blackmailed and threatened this ministry and its associates and their employers in Bangalore?
From: Michael Prabhu To: simonrodrigues.associates@ ; Simon Rodrigues
Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:38 PM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Simon,
For your information kind please, since Mr. Dominic Dixon uses your name and your position as Chairman of the Bangalore Catholic Charismatic Renewal Services team for us to contact as you can see for yourself in his letters in this attached report; and since your name continues to appear on the Ethos Institute web page.
Report updated as at 2:45 pm on March 26, 2013 attached.
45.
From: Michael Prabhu To: anthony.sagayaraj@ Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:44 PM
Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Anthony,
For your information kind please, since Mr. Dominic Dixon used your name in his slander campaigns.
Report updated as at 2:45 pm on March 26, 2013 attached.
From: Michael Prabhu To: icpe; Diana Mascarenhas; Diana Mascarenhas; Diana Mascarenhas; Fritz Mascarenhas Cc: Fr. Alliston Fernandes; Fr. Tony Alex; Fr. Tony Alex; Francis D’Souza Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:52 PM
Dear Fritz, Diana, Fr. Alliston, Fr. Tony and Bro. Francis,
For your information kind please, since Mr. Dominic Dixon used your name and that of ICPE and its seminarians and priests in his slander campaigns.
Report updated as at 2:45 pm on March 26, 2013 attached.
From: Fritz Mascarenhas To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 6:53 PM
Subject: Re: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Michael,
The peace and love of Jesus be with you.
It was great connecting with you after a long lapse. Thank you for dropping in to see me and for sharing your concerns. I have had a meeting with Dominic and advised him to go the Way of the Lord and the path of Forgiveness. He was very receptive to all that I shared with him.
May the Lord bless you abundantly for your strenuous labour of love for the church.
Love and God Bless, Fritz
From: Fr. Tony Alex To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2013 12:44 AM Subject: Re: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Br. Michael
Thanks for your mail and letting us know about the developments with Dominic.
God Bless You and your ministry. In Jesus, Fr. Tony
Mr. Simon Rodrigues, Chairman of the Bangalore Service Team of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, and Mr. Anthony Sagayaraj, the former Chairman did not acknowledge receipt of my letters to them.
I telephoned and also wrote to Mr. Alex Anthony who is listed on the ëthos Institute’s web page as "Alex Anthony, Mentor, Jesus Youth India"
From: Michael Prabhu To: Alex Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 2:56 PM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Alex,
As discussed on the telephone, for your information please.
With regards, Michael Prabhu, Catholic apologist, Chennai
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE… {On masthead}
I wrote a third time [see page 10] to People of Praise [affiliated to Sword of the Spirit, an international community] Bangalore leader who is listed on the ëthos Institute’s web page under Leadership Development, "Colin Calmiano, Dir. Spread your wings"
From: Michael Prabhu To: Colin Calmiano Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:05 PM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
Dear Colin,
Since your name continues to appear on the Ethos Institute web page, for your kind information please. Report updated as at 2:45 pm on March 26, 2013 attached.
With regards, Michael Prabhu, Catholic apologist, Chennai
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE… {On masthead}
This letter from me is to Dr. Siga Arles, Bangalore, an eminent Protestant who has corresponded with me several years ago, He is on the Ecumenical Panel for Peace & Unity, (Missiology) at the ëthos Institute
From: Michael Prabhu To: Dr. Siga Arles Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2013 8:56 AM
Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE
46.
Dear Dr. Siga Arles,
For your kind information please, since you are a resource person at the Ethos Institute.
With regards, Michael Prabhu, Catholic apologist, Chennai
From: Michael Prabhu To: Arch bishop moras Cc: pmsindia66@ ; Faustine Lobo
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2013 10:55 AM
Subject: UPDATED DOMINIC DIXON REPORT WITH LATEST CRIMINAL THREATS: AN IMMINENT DANGER LOOMS: COMMUNAL VIOLENCE… {On masthead}
LETTERS TO THE CARDINAL AND A BISHOP WHO ANEEL ARANHA OF HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE MET RECENTLY, BOMBAY ARCHDIOCESE
From: Michael Prabhu To: Archbishop Bombay ; Archbishop's House ; abpossie@
Sent: Saturday, March 23, 2013 9:29 AM
Subject: ANEEL ARANHA AND HOLY SPIRIT INTERACTVE MINISTRIES [HSI]
Dear Oswald Cardinal Gracias,
I understand that Aneel Aranha and his HolySpiritInteractive are not allowed to conduct their programmes in the Archdiocese of Bombay.
I would like to know from you whether that is correct information or not, especially because criminal threats [phone-tapping, goonda-giri, abusive telephone calls and arrest warrant allegations] have recently been made against eminent priests and lay ministries by HSI associate Mr. Dominic Dixon of MoreLove ministries, which information I have already documented in a recent report and brought to the attention of the Archbishop of Bangalore and the priests concerned. Several priests have already withdrawn from the resource team of Mr. Dominic Dixon's Ethos Bible Institute on receipt of my report on MoreLove/HSI.
There are also concerns about Mr. Dixon's fidelity to Catholic teaching as seen in his own statements cited by me in my referred report.
Mr. Aneel Aranha is probably unaware as yet of these developments.
I await your clarification.
Yours obediently, Michael Prabhu, Chennai
From: Michael Prabhu To: St.Pius College ; agnelorg@ Sent: Saturday, March 23, 2013 9:32 AM
Subject: ANEEL ARANHA AND HOLY SPIRIT INTERACTVE MINISTRIES [HSI]
Dear Bishop Agnelo Gracias [As above]
The bishop had not replied as on April 6, 2013.
The letter from the Cardinal:
From: Archbishop Bombay To: prabhu Sent: Friday, April 05, 2013 11:28 PM Subject: Reply
April 1, 2013
Dear Mr. Prabhu,
I have received your email of March 23, 2013. I have not given permission to Aneel Aranha to conduct programmes in the Archdiocese. I had asked one of my auxiliaries to study the matter.
I am not aware of HSI Associate, Mr. Dominic Dixon of MoreLove Ministries. We will keep it in mind.
With kind regards and best wishes,
Yours sincerely in Christ,
+ Oswald Cardinal Gracias
Archbishop of Bombay
[pic] [pic]
Left: Mr. Dominic Dixon; Right: Mr. Aneel Aranha
THE MORELOVE/HSI REPORT WAS SENT TO ANEEL ARANHA OF HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE
From: Michael Prabhu To: aneel@ ; aneelrnr@ ; Prayer Team Sent: Sunday, March 24, 2013 11:12 PM Subject: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
Dear Mr. Aneel Aranha, Please find herewith the link to my report on the HolySpiritInteractive/MoreLove ministries combine.
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
Michael Prabhu
Mr. Aneel Aranha of HolySpiritInteractive did not reply, but one of his ministries did, and I responded:
From: prayerfamily@ To: Michael Prabhu
Cc: aneel@ ; Aneel Aranha ; Aneel Aranha ; aneelrnr@
Sent: Friday, April 05, 2013 11:26 AM Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
From: prayerfamily@ To: Michael Prabhu
Cc: aneel@ ; Aneel Aranha ; Aneel Aranha ; aneelrnr@
Sent: Friday, April 05, 2013 12:56 PM Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
From: prayerfamily@ To: prayerfamily@ ; Michael Prabhu
Cc: aneel@ ; Aneel Aranha ; Aneel Aranha ; aneelrnr@ ; roshan.j.mathias@
Sent: Friday, April 05, 2013 12:57 PM Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
Dear Brother Michael
My humble request please DO NOT copy this REPORT to the Prayer Team. God bless you for all that you do.
With Love in Christ, Roshan Mathias roshan.j.mathias@
From: Michael Prabhu To: roshan.j.mathias@ Cc: aneelrnr@ ; Aneel Aranha ; Aneel Aranha ; aneel@ ; prayerfamily@
Sent: Friday, April 05, 2013 6:44 PM Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
Dear brother Roshan,
I thank you for your reply.
It is two weeks since I wrote to Aneel Aranha and to your intercession group email id.
He has not deigned to reply to me regarding my report on the criminal behaviour of his associate in ministry, Mr. Dominic Dixon of HSI-MoreLove, Bangalore.
I am unable to understand what you mean when you request me not to send my report "to the Prayer Team".
With regret, I must inform you that this ministry and I cannot accede to your request.
Catholics everywhere must be made aware of the situation as long as the three pillars of HSI-MoreLove ministries -- the archbishop of Bangalore, Mr. Simon Rodrigues, the Chairman of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal in Bangalore, and Mr. Aneel Aranha of HSI-MoreLove -- elect to ignore our letters thus condoning the deceit and intimidations of Mr. Dixon.
With regards, Michael
Finally, a terse response came from Mr. Aneel Aranha. The letter is emailed to me, but its content does not clearly reveal who exactly has not to be replied to or communicated with, Roshan Mathias or me. I have considered the possibility that the letter was meant for Roshan but instead sent to me inadvertently.
From: Aneel Aranha To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 1:49 AM
Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
You should not have replied to him. Do not communicate with him anymore. Just ignore his mails. We got better things to do.
From: Michael Prabhu To: Aneel Aranha ; roshan.j.mathias@ Cc: prayerfamily@
Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 8:41 AM Subject: Re: Report on HSI/MORELOVE from Michael Prabhu
Dear Aneel,
I am not clear as to who exactly your letter is meant for, Roshan Mathias or me.
I have just updated the HSI MoreLove report with a letter from the Cardinal, Bombay, and with your association with Sri Lankan enneagram-promoter Lalith Perera.
With regards, Michael
Mr. Aneel Aranha has teamed up with Sri Lankan businessman and enneagram-practitioner Lalith Perera whose other profession is leading one of the island nation’s largest Catholic charismatic groups. Lalith Perera is in great demand for giving enneagram workshops to corporates and large numbers of Catholic charismatics have been exposed to the occult through these programmes. Lalith Perera is also popular with other international Catholic ministries because he carries a lot of Sri Lankan support with him [ministries in India simply love to report on how many Catholics from this or that country attend their Asian- or international-level programmes] and is a potential source of preaching invitations to Sri Lanka. See
ENNEAGRAMS-SUMMARY , and
DIVINE RETREAT CENTRE ERRORS-01 .
ANEEL ARANHA MISSIONARY JOURNAL
Lalith Pereira [sic] and the 4 step retreat
Posted by Aneel Aranha, December 5, 2009
Over the past five years we have been blessed to have some very anointed people ministering to our communities and joining their number this week was internationally acclaimed preacher Lalith Pereira [sic] who came down to the UAE to conduct his popular—and powerful—4 Step Retreat.
48.
As I listened to him, I found myself fascinated, not for the first time, at how God uses different people to deliver his messages in different ways and in different styles. There were over 250 people in attendance in St. Francis of Assisi Church to listen to him and be blessed by what he had to share.
Notes on the "4 Steps" will be found in my blog Christianity and the Art of Mountain Climbing shortly.
A recap: the whole inquiry started with the confusion over a "HSI School of Theology of the Body", see pages 1 through 4, which was advertised/promoted by Mr. Dominic Dixon.
To underline the close association between HSI and MoreLove, check out the following email that I received a few months ago. If one places the cursor on "Holy Spirit Interactive", the email address displays as info@morelove.in.
The revised [after Mr. Dixon read this report] ëthos team is given at as:
Executive Team
Aneel Aranha - Chairman
Dr. Dominic Dixon - Executive Director/ Provost
HSI and MoreLove are therefore fully integrated with each other and HSI must share the responsibility for the intimidatory threats and errors of Mr. Dominic Dixon, and vice versa.
From: Holy Spirit Interactive To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Tuesday, August 14, 2012 12:14 PM
Subject: Theology of the Body […]
Dr. Dominic Dixon shares many experiences and insights in this book*, which is a wonderful combination of personal testimony, Scriptural reference and human psychology. It will be a useful guide, not only for those eager to grow spiritually, but also for those who want to pursue the Call in public ministry. *Living for the Audience of One
Aneel Aranha - Founder, Holy Spirit Interactive, Dubai [From MoreLove, 21 October, 2008]
Holy Spirit Interactive (HSI) is a lay apostolate recognized as an Association of Faith and Outreach by Bishop Paul Hinder of the Vicariate Apostolic of Southern Arabia. Founded in January 2004 by Aneel Aranha, it is dedicated to strengthening the faith of Christians and spreading the Word of God around the world. Through its various ministries and activities HSI reaches several million people each month. [From the new-look HSI web site, October 2012]
From :
H.E. Bishop Paul Hinder, OFM Cap., officially recognized Holy Spirit Interactive (HSI) as an Association of Faith and Outreach of the Vicariate Apostolic of Arabia in a simple ceremony held at St. Mary's Church, Dubai on March 23, 2010.
Bishop Hinder handed over a copy of the approved Statutes of Holy Spirit Interactive with his signature and seal to HSI Founder Aneel Aranha. He appointed Fr. Varghese Chempoly, OFM Cap., Vice-Provincial, Vicariate Apostolic of Arabia, as the ecclesiastical assistant of the lay apostolate.
This recognition formally opens the doors of churches in Bahrain, Qatar, Oman, Yemen, and the United Arab Emirates to HSI and its Schools of Discipleship. HSI already has three hugely successful schools functioning in parishes within the UAE and India: St. Francis of Assisi Church, Jebel Ali, UAE; Our Lady of Perpetual Help, Fujairah, UAE; and Don Bosco Church, Borivili, Bombay. More such schools are to open shortly in other countries.
Holy Spirit Interactive has been actively engaged in strengthening the faith of Christians and spreading the Word of God around the world since January 1, 2004. Through its various ministries and activities, which include schools of discipleship, retreats and seminars, radio and publishing, and an extremely popular and respected web site, HSI reaches several million people each month.
The HSI/MoreLove report was sent on April 6, 2013 to Bishops Paul Hinder and Camillo Ballin as well as to a number of priests and prayer group leaders in both the Apostolic Vicariate of Southern Arabia as well as the Apostolic Vicariate of Northern Arabia.
From: Michael Prabhu To: phinder@ ; paul.hinder.ch@ ; bishop@
Cc: vicariate_clergy@ ; vicapar@.ae ; vicariate_news@ ; vg@ ; chancellor@ ; info@ ; office@
Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 1:32 PM
Subject: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES {On Masthead}
Kind Attention:
Most Rev. Paul Hinder, OFM Cap.,
Vicar Apostolic of Southern Arabia
Dear Bishop Paul Hinder,
My name is Michael Prabhu and I am a Catholic apologist who operates an Internet ministry from Chennai, India.
At the request of a very senior leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from Mumbai, and later from the Director of the Pontifical Mission Societies [PMS], Bangalore, India, I initiated an inquiry into the HolySpiritInteractive/MoreLove ministry combine which developed into a report that I submitted to Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, PMS.
When its contents became public, this ministry and its associates were deluged with intimidatory threats at our homes and our workplaces. These intimidations came from Mr. Dominic Dixon of Bangalore, whose MoreLove ministry is integrated with that of Mr. Aneel Aranha of HolySpiritInteractive.
Accordingly, I sent a copy of the report to the Archbishop of Bangalore.
Since you have "officially recognized Holy Spirit Interactive (HSI) as an Association of Faith and Outreach of the Vicariate Apostolic of Arabia", as per the HSI web site, I am now writing to you.
The updated [as of today] report is attached herewith for your perusal. You might want to read the letter that I received yesterday from Cardinal Gracias, Archbishop of Bombay, concerning Mr. Aneel Aranha.
A terse response to this report received earlier today from Mr. Aneel Aranha may be also found towards the end of the report.
The title and link to the report at this ministry's web site are
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
Yours obediently, Michael Prabhu
Copy to:
Rev. Fr. Lennie J. A. Connully, Vicar General
Rev. Fr. Valerian Fernandes, Chancellor
Rev. Fr. Gandolf Wild, OFM Cap., Secretary
From: Michael Prabhu To: bcamillo@ ; askbishop@ ; mail@
Cc: lopezantony1@
Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 1:45 PM
Subject: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES {On Masthead}
Kind Attention:
Most Rev. Camillo Ballin, MCCJ,
Vicar Apostolic of Kuwait
Dear Bishop Camillo Ballin,
My name is Michael Prabhu and I am a Catholic apologist who operates an Internet ministry from Chennai, India.
At the request of a very senior leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from Mumbai, and later from the Director of the Pontifical Mission Societies [PMS], Bangalore, India, I initiated an inquiry into the HolySpiritInteractive/MoreLove ministry combine which developed into a report that I submitted to Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, PMS.
When its contents became public, this ministry and its associates were deluged with intimidatory threats at our homes and our workplaces. These intimidations came from Mr. Dominic Dixon of Bangalore, whose MoreLove ministry is integrated with that of Mr. Aneel Aranha of HolySpiritInteractive.
Accordingly, I sent a copy of the report to the Archbishop of Bangalore.
Since the Vicar Apostolic of Southern Arabia has "officially recognized Holy Spirit Interactive (HSI) as an Association of Faith and Outreach of the Vicariate Apostolic of Arabia", as per the HSI web site, I am now writing to you.
The updated [as of today] report is attached herewith for your perusal. You might want to read the letter that I received yesterday from Cardinal Gracias, Archbishop of Bombay, concerning Mr. Aneel Aranha.
A terse response to this report received earlier today from Mr. Aneel Aranha may be also found towards the end of the report.
The title and link to the report at this ministry's web site are
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
Yours obediently, Michael Prabhu
Copy to:
Fr. Antony Lopez, OFM Cap., Chancellor
From: Michael Prabhu To: nuntiuskuwait@ Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 1:52 PM
Subject: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES {On Masthead}
Kind Attention:
Most Rev. Petar Rajic,
The Apostolic Nunciature, Vicariate of Arabia, KUWAIT
Dear Msgr. Petar Rajic,
My name is Michael Prabhu and I am a Catholic apologist who operates an Internet ministry from Chennai, India.
At the request of a very senior leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from Mumbai, and later from the Director of the Pontifical Mission Societies [PMS], Bangalore, India, I initiated an inquiry into the HolySpiritInteractive/MoreLove ministry combine which developed into a report that I submitted to Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, PMS.
50.
When its contents became public, this ministry and its associates were deluged with intimidatory threats at homes and our workplaces. These intimidations came from Mr. Dominic Dixon of Bangalore, whose MoreLove ministry is integrated with that of Mr. Aneel Aranha of HolySpiritInteractive.
Accordingly, I sent a copy of the report to the Archbishop of Bangalore.
Since the Vicariate has "officially recognized Holy Spirit Interactive (HSI) as an Association of Faith and Outreach of the Vicariate Apostolic of Arabia", as per the HSI web site, I am now writing to you.
The updated [as of today] report is attached herewith for your perusal. You might want to read the letter that I received yesterday from Cardinal Gracias, Archbishop of Bombay, concerning Mr. Aneel Aranha.
A terse response to this report received earlier today from Mr. Aneel Aranha may be also found towards the end of the report.
The title and link to the report at this ministry's web site are
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
Yours obediently, Michael Prabhu
Similar letters were emailed without the attachment [the link to this report was provided] on April 7, 2013, in groups to various parish churches, the respective parish priests, and in some cases to the different parish associations and prayer groups in the Vicariates of Southern and Northern Arabia.
RESPONSES
From: Info Vicariate To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 3:38 PM
Subject: Re: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES
Dear Mr. Michael Prabhu,
I acknowledge receipt of your report and pity our bishop who during his busy visitation schedule is expected to take time to go through 49 pages, which is more a collation than a report and only indirectly touching HSI, the lay association recognised in the Apostolic Vicariate of Southern Arabia, where it exercises a fruitful ministry.
For any activities outside the Apostolic Vicariate of Southern Arabia the permission of the competent bishop is required.
'Metamorphose' is unknown to me and I have no idea which ecclesiastical authority has allowed it to carry the title 'Catholic Ministry'.
Pope Francis asks us all to reach out rather than to pick quarrels and engage in infighting, at the base of it we often find prejudice, envy and commercial interests, not exactly Christian virtues.
May the Lord of Mercy touch you and transform you from a watchdog of orthodoxy to a beacon of light that shines in the dark and illumines the world.
Fr. Gandolf, Secretary of Bishop Paul Hinder
From: Michael Prabhu To: Info Vicariate Cc: phinder@ ; paul.hinder.ch@ ; bishop@ ; vicariate_clergy@ ; vicapar@.ae ; vicariate_news@ ; vg@ ; chancellor@ ; office@ Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 6:10 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES
Dear Reverend Father Gandolf,
I thank you for your prompt response.
You were not obliged to do anything about my report; you could have avoided your many subjective comments or simply not replied.
The attachment to my letter was a report and not a collation of information as you describe it to be.
Canon Law 212.3 enjoins the laity to take up with the ecclesiastical authorities issues related to the Faith and I am only fulfilling one of my duties and rights as a Catholic. I think that you might appreciate that, as well as the fact that there are some Catholics who are engaged in ministry without, to quote you, "prejudice, envy and commercial interests".
This ministry has received over a thousand letters from bishops and Cardinals from all over the world including Rome till and including yesterday, and I do not see how I need ecclesiastical approbation to write to a Bishop on a matter that might concern the interests of the faithful in his diocese.
Your views need not necessarily be that of your Bishop, granted that you are his Secretary. I believe that one of your functions is to ensure that my letter reaches him in case I have got his address[es] wrong.
Father, maybe you could consider giving a little credit to lay Catholic initiatives that exhibit concern for the Church.
There are dozens of lay Catholics from the Vicariate of Arabia who are in close rapport with this ministry and a few of them are our benefactors. They would not be happy to read this letter that you have sent me, especially considering that the one thing that Pope Francis -- who you cited -- emphasised over and over again is that Bishops and priests are meant to SERVE the faithful, not rebuke them for undertaking an active role, especially that of "watchdog of orthodoxy" which is a synonym for a prophetic role.
I welcome your closing prayer for me which is consonant with my ministry letterhead's Scripture passage, Ephesians 5:11, "exposing the fruitless works of darkness to the light".
God bless you Father Gandolf, Michael Prabhu
51.
CANON LAW 212.3 - "RIGHTS OF THE FAITHFUL"
They have the right, indeed at times the duty, in keeping with their knowledge, competence and position, to manifest to the sacred pastors their view on matters which concern the good of the Church.
They have the right also to make their views known to others of Christ’s faithful, but in doing so they must always respect the integrity of faith and morals, show due reverence to the pastors, and take into account both the common good and the dignity of the individuals.
From: Info Vicariate To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 6:47 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES
Dear Michael Prabhu,
I admit I am only the secretary and my message was purely personal, the opinion of an old man who is sad about the misdirected waste of good energy (without any prior consultation with my bishop who is out of station but must surely have seen your message).
I am very much in favour of lay participation in the Church but not the kind exposed in your submission to the bishop.
I know Canon 212.3. I did not question the legitimacy of lay faithful expressing their concern to the bishop but I questioned your use of 'Catholic Ministry' in the mast head "METAMORPHOSE - A Catholic Ministry for Exposing the Truth..." Any ministry in the Church needs ecclesial recognition as recently demonstrated in the case of Catholic Caritas organisations.
You do not have to answer me. Just calm down and direct your energy in this Year of Faith in a positive direction that builds a stronger faith community.
On the pilgrimage from darkness to light greets you, Fr. Gandolf
From: Michael Prabhu To: Info Vicariate Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2013 9:48 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON MR. ANEEL ARANHA/HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE AND MR. DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE MINISTRIES
But I DO have to answer you, dear Father Gandolf.
I thank you for your apology, but my ministry is not supposed to please you or anyone else. It is an answer to a calling.
You would have done well to visit my web site to understand what I do and why I do it.
As yours is a vocation, so is mine. We serve God, and His Church.
My wife and I have "sacrificed" a "normal" lay life for three decades in that service.
I would find little to say if you had
a) found any errors in our presentation of facts and in the conclusions that my team and I drew from them;
b) decided from those facts whether HolySpiritInteractive and MoreLove are credible Catholic ministries or not.
Whether you find those ministries Catholic or not,
a) several priests have already pulled out of the MoreLove/HSI resource team on examination of my pilot report;
b) both Mr. Dixon and Mr. Aranha do not have permission to minister in at least one leading Indian archdiocese.
The report that I sent was not about me. If you wish to critique me, kindly do it after examining my web site.
As for my describing my ministry as "Catholic", it is not for obtaining either mileage or patronage. It is not Protestant; it is not Traditionalist; it is not "ecumenical" as are many so-called Catholic ministries.
The only suitable adjective for my ministry is "Catholic", Roman Catholic.
Would you deny me that?
If you would, you must be able to find, among the tens of thousands of pages of my writings, one place where I am doctrinally or liturgically in deviance/dissenting from the teachings of Rome.
On the other hand, there are media agencies that call themselves Catholic but they only harm the souls of Catholics.
One such is the National Catholic Reporter. Another is UCAN, the Union of Catholic Asian News. A third is Church Resources, CathNews. I could go on. No one in authority questions them while they destroy the Catholic Church from within.
To that list, you might also include MoreLove ministries, the associate of HSI.
God bless you, Father, Michael
P.S. I trust that you are aware that all correspondence with me is eventually posted on our web site.
Letters to two ACADEMIC ADVISORS of ëthos Institute:
From: Michael Prabhu To: george_edayadiyil@ Sent: Sunday, April 07, 2013 8:49 PM Subject: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
From: Michael Prabhu To: dpinformation@ Sent: Sunday, April 07, 2013 8:57 PM Subject: Fw: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Father George Edayadiyil CMI,
My name is Michael Prabhu and I am a Catholic apologist who operates an Internet ministry from Chennai.
At the request of a very senior leader of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal from Mumbai, and later from the Director of the Pontifical Mission Societies [PMS], Bangalore, India, I initiated an inquiry into the MoreLove/HSI ministry combine which developed into a report that I submitted to Fr. Faustine Lobo, Director, PMS.
When its contents became public, this ministry and its associates were deluged with intimidatory threats at our homes and our workplaces. These intimidations came from Mr. Dominic Dixon of Bangalore, whose MoreLove ministry is integrated with that of Mr. Aneel Aranha of HolySpiritInteractive.
52.
Accordingly, I sent a copy of the updated report to the Archbishop of Bangalore with copies to some priests associated with MoreLove/HSI, on receipt of which all of the original priests withdrew from associating with MoreLove/HSI.
However, the once-again revised ëthos Institute team of Mr. Dixon -- as given at -- includes your name:
ACADEMIC ADVISORS
Dr. Fr. Edayadiyil George CMI, M. Sc., M.A. (M.G.), L. Th., Th. D. (Angelicum, Rome) (World Religion)
As some priests had informed me that they were either unaware of the inclusion of their names on the ëthos Institute team or disassociated with that enterprise on reading my report, I thought that you also might want to be made aware of this.
The title and link to the report at this ministry's web site are
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
Yours obediently,
Michael Prabhu
From: Michael Prabhu To: shajikoc@ ; kochuthshaji@ Sent: Sunday, April 07, 2013 8:54 PM
Subject: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Father Kochuthara Shaji George CMI…
However, the once-again revised ëthos Institute team of Mr. Dixon -- as given at -- includes your name:
ACADEMIC ADVISORS
Dr. Fr. Kochuthara Shaji George CMI, L. Th., Th. D. (Alphonsianum, Rome) (Moral Theology)…
RESPONSES
From: Shaji George Kochuthara To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Sunday, April 07, 2013 9:15 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Michael Prabhu
Thank you for the mail, for the information. I was told by Dominic Dixon that his institute had the approval of the Archbishop. I shall ask for more details. I thought of collaborating with this initiative, since it is basically a lay initiative, but under the impression that it had the approval of the legitimate authorities, though so far I did not have any particular role in its work. I shall ask for more details.
Regards, Shaji
From: Michael Prabhu To: Shaji George Kochuthara Sent: Sunday, April 07, 2013 9:41 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Rev. Fr. Shaji,
I thank you for your prompt response to my communication.
What Mr. Dominic Dixon told you is true. His Institute does have the approval and blessing of the Archbishop; and therein lies the crux of the problem. The Archbishop gives ear to Mr. Simon Rodrigues, the Chairman of the local charismatic service team who is also the archdiocesan auditor, I am given to understand, and who supports Mr. Dixon and also one Johnson Sequeira, a questionable lay ministry which is not permitted to function in some other archdioceses.
It is because of the support that Mr. Dixon receives from the Archbishop and Mr. Simon Rodrigues that he slanders and criminally threatens others [as I have shown in my report]. Unfortunately that report is tiresomely long, but if you just scroll down you will get the gist of the situation and why all the priests that I contacted till last week, excepting one who wrote that he would read the report "after Easter", informed me by letter or on the telephone that they were distancing themselves from the Ethos Institute.
Wishing you a most blessed Feast of the Divine Mercy, Michael
From: George Edayadiyil To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Friday, April 12, 2013 5:49 PM Subject: RE: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Peter,
You once mentioned in an email something about this movement. But we never had any personal talk on this. It is good that we discuss the whole project and programme of this and then decide how to proceed with it. Till that time, you delete my name from the same. This is because I have no idea about the whole programme and the issues that you and your organisation are undertaking.
Yours sincerely, George
From: Michael Prabhu To: George Edayadiyil Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2013 6:54 PM Subject: Re: REPORT ON THE CRIMINAL INTIMIDATORY BEHAVIOUR ETC. OF MR. DOMINIC DIXON OF MORELOVE/HSI MINISTRIES
Dear Fr. George,
You addressed your response to one Peter and I am unable to figure out who that is and what you meant in your message.
God bless you, Michael
53.
From: George Edayadiyil To: michaelprabhu@ Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2013 12:41 PM Subject: Please ignore
Dear Michael,
I have received an email from ID: michaelprabhu@ on April 7, 2013. I have given the reply on April 12 as it was addressed to me. I addressed it wrongly to Peter. Sorry for the same.
You can just ignore the whole correspondence, if you haven't anything to do with it.
God bless you, George
The latest from the ëthos Institute, April 26, 2013:
ETHOS Institute, (a mission of Holy Spirit Interactive) under the Archdiocese of Bangalore is calling young men & women to honor God and lead their lives in Holiness & lead others to Holiness.
For men to honor women and for women to honor men
Call us @7204012777/ 7204013777
Also see .
April 29, 2013:
Jesus Youth member Rajesh Raphail promotes ëthos Institute on social media
1.
Rajesh Raphail
ON APRIL 4, 2013
FREE course on Theology of the Body (Into The Heart) by Ethos Institute - Ministry under the Archdiocese of Bangalore on 8 Sundays between May 12th & Jun 30th from 4pm to 6pm. A minimal amount will be charged for the course material:
[pic]
2.
Rajesh Raphail
ON APRIL 19, 2013
As above
3.
[pic]
Rajesh Raphail
ON APRIL 19, 2013
FREE Course on Pastoral Counseling & Psychology by Ethos Institute, the ministry under the Archdiocese of Bangalore. A minimal amount will be charged for the course material for those who can afford. It will be conducted on 12 Saturdays between May 11th & July 27th from 4pm to 6pm.
54.
In case one imagines that he is promoting Mr. Dominic Dixon in his personal capacity, note the Jesus Youth logo in the lower left-hand corner image in the following Facebook post made by Rajesh Raphail in November9, 2012.
Rajesh Raphail on Facebook 13 November 2012.
Theology Of The Body Seminar — with Jenni Thomas and 58 others at Snehadaan, Sarjapur Road, Bangalore.
[pic]
[pic]
From: Michael Prabhu To: rajeshraphail@yahoo.co.in Cc: Manoj Sunny
Sent: Monday, April 29, 2013 9:38 AM Subject: DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE
Dear Mr. Rajesh Raphail,
I introduce myself as a Catholic apologist based in Chennai.
I have noted that you are promoting the ëthos Institute and related programmes of Mr. Dominic Dixon among the members of the Jesus Youth [JY] and other Catholics in Bangalore and elsewhere through social media like Facebook.
Since I have already published an adverse report on the referred activity at my web site at
MORELOVE-HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-SOUL TIES AND ETHOS INSTITUTE
31 JANUARY, 12/15/17/18/22/23 MARCH, 6/8/16/26 APRIL 2013
and it is possible that you may not be aware of it, I am giving you here the title and link to the said report so that you can peruse it and make your future decisions in the matter.
I am also marking copies to Mr. Manoj Sunny, and blind copies to a few other JY leaders with whom I have already communicated with in this connection, before my next update, in the hope of being reassured that there is no official JY endorsement of your promotion.
With regards,
Michael Prabhu
From: Manoj Sunny To: Michael Prabhu Sent: Monday, April 29, 2013 9:52 PM
Subject: Re: DOMINIC DIXON/MORELOVE/ETHOS INSTITUTE
Dear Michael,
Thank you very much. I will also follow up with our leaders in Bangalore.
God bless, Manoj
See HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE ANEEL ARANHA AND NEW AGE
WATCH THIS SPACE FOR MORE IN MY NEXT UPDATE OF THIS REPORT
[pic]
Soul ties
EXTRACT
October 3, 2012
I engaged in pre-marital sex and I believe I developed a soul-tie with this individual. To the point where I knew things I shouldn't know, like: One time I heard, in my head, in his voice, what he was going to say before he said it. I felt when he was angry with me even when he wasn't around. I had a dream he hit his head and low and behold, he hit his head. I also felt that he was cheating and later was given a reason to confirm my feelings.
After we broke up, I had horrible things happening internally. I was filled with doubts about God and despair, which I had never had, I felt abandoned by God, I felt self hatred, I felt like I was insane, my heart literally felt like it was breaking, one time I felt as though I had an out of body experience, I would have terrible darkness, I couldn't get out of bed, and sometimes it felt like a porthole opened in my body letting in what felt like the pain of the whole world. I felt as though I was damned and there was no hope.
I knew something was seriously wrong. I did my best to offer up all the pain as redemptive suffering in union with Jesus. I received the sacrament of the sick, I had been to confession, and I was receiving Eucharist daily (It was often the only thing I could muster to do but I didn't dare not go, afraid I would not have the strength to go on.) I desired to die. I begged and pleaded with God.
One night it felt as though my soul was being wrestled for. I cried for 9 plus months continuously. Tears of a kind of sorrow I had never experienced, a gloomy sorrow. I always felt that what I was experiencing DID NOT BELONG TO ME. I did receive deliverance through "Unbound" and my priest. It helped but I still felt connected to this man. I went through all of the breaking soul tie prayers but I remember the officiator of Unbound saying, "If for some reason a soul tie is not broken it is because God wills it."
So, I was wondering if through this soul tie God was calling me to offering suffering and Masses for the salvation of his soul. I was very courageous through the whole thing remaining firm that "I belong to God." I did gain insight into the agony in the garden.
I do not seem to suffer from this soul tie anymore, except once in a great while. -Teresa
The term "soul ties" is controversial. Its first use is not known, but it probably began, or at least took root in Pentecostal Charismatic circles. Like most everything from the Pentecostal Charismatic movement the theology and the interpretation of both the Bible and the spiritual phenomena is deeply flawed. Unfortunately and sadly, much of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is grossly contaminated by Pentecostal ideas.
For example, some people speak of "fragmented" souls or "dividing" of the soul. This is false. There is no such thing as a fragmented or divided soul. One can have a fragmented personality (e.g., Dissociative Personality Disorder) or a divided mind (e.g., cognitive dissonance, inability to make a decision, strongly pulled emotionally in two different directions, and other psychological behaviors), but the soul can never be these things.
Those who use the term "soul ties" refer to Biblical passages such as Judges 20:11; 1st Samuel 18:1; 1st Chronicles 12:17; Colossians 2:2, 19 and similar verses that could be called the "knit together" passages. These verses, however, are about deep emotional ties in friendship or in marriage. One can have deep emotional connections with good people or bad people. This is why the Bible teaches to stay away from bad influences as we may be drawn into sin and harmful emotional attachments.
If we are talking about "soul ties" as bondage, then we are closer to a true definition. We can have an emotional bondage to people or things (an attachment that becomes an addiction or so strong that it places the person in a bondage that is difficult or impossible to break without help). What is probably most referred to is calling "soul ties" demonic bondage. The "tie" in a demonic bondage is with the demons, not with a person, though a person may be a conduit for the demon to hold a person in bondage.
I think the term "bondage" is a far better term than "soul ties". Bondage is also more accurate and less likely to be misinterpreted. Like many phrases and concepts from the Charismatic movement, the language tends to be sloppy and imprecise. –Bro. Ignatius Mary OMSM
MORE ministry
February 21, 2009
I was just wondering what your thoughts are on the MORE Ministry and if you are familiar with Dr Dominic Dixon and his ministry in India. Apparently this is a Catholic Ministry and they are under the Magisterium of Rome. –Marion
I do not know anything about the man and his ministry other than a quick look on his website. It looks okay, but in the section about "Accept Christ" he gives a "sinner's prayer" with an appeal to seek out a local Church with no mention of Baptism. Without Baptism one is not a Christian. This is odd for someone claiming to be an evangelist. He is billed as a "Christian evangelist". I can see no reference to him being Catholic. Much of the site is very Protestant in presentation.
As for being under Rome there is no indication of that on his site, nor is there any indication that I can find that he or his ministry is Catholic. –Bro. Ignatius Mary OMSM
MY COMMENTS as reproduced from my report DOMINIC DIXON AND MORELOVE-MORE UNHOLINESS:
The Q&A is from February 2009, and that is over four years ago.
My own recent conclusions [see the first two documents listed with links on the previous page] were that Dominic Dixon is Protestant-influenced and his ministries are Protestant-oriented or "ecumenical" despite his bandying the Vatican word with suspicious frequency.
Dominic Dixon has modified his web site many times over during the past years, more especially with this ministry’s recent exposés of his false claims, especially those of his having some special recognition from the "International Association for Deliverance [IAD] under the Vatican council" -- to cite just one of those misleading claims -- and a similar statement in 2004 on the MORELOVE web site must have been the reason for Marion to seek Bro. Ignatius Mary’s confirmation that MORELOVE is "under the Magisterium of Rome".
"Under the Magisterium of Rome", while devoid of any sense, is typical Dominic Dixon-speak, and there are several examples of this in my earlier reports. Such phrases are cunningly inserted to impress and deceive gullible visitors to his site. It is not simply interesting but crucial to note that Bro. Ignatius Mary was hard put to conclude that Dominic Dixon’s web site had any approval from Rome or that his ministry was Catholic!
Despite only a cursory glance at the MORELOVE site, he was able to inform Marion, "I can see no reference to him being Catholic. Much of the site is very Protestant in presentation." Note also his analysis of the Dominic Dixon’s "sinner’s prayer" and his related appeal. What Bro. Ignatius Mary did not either notice or come across was that Dominic Dixon emphasises on the "ecumenical" spirit of his ministry.
This was one of the several factors that contributed to publishing the 2012 alert on the dubious Catholicity of the Dominic Dixon-Aneel Aranha MORELOVE-HolySpiritInteractive combine.
If Bro. Ignatius Mary had only dug deeper, he would have uncovered more dirt.
UPDATE NOVEMBER 2015
Soul Ties
By Susan Brinkmann, October 6, 2010
MW writes: “The Priest was talking about ‘Soul Ties’ and offered ’healing Prayers’ he said for everything is connected in the universe, people, places, things, etc. I don’t buy it! What do you think?”
Without knowing the context of why the priest said everything in the universe is connected, it’s impossible for me to comment on what he might have meant.
As for soul ties, however, I turned to Fr. Edmund Sylvia C.S.C., our theological advisor, and he explained that soul ties have to do with what St. Paul speaks of in 1 Corinthians 6:15 where illicit sexual unions established ties that should be renounced and broken spiritually.
"Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ? Shall I then take Christ’s members and make them the members of a prostitute? Of course not! Or do you not know that anyone who joins himself to a prostitute becomes one body with her? For 'the two'", it says, 'will become one flesh'. But whoever is joined to the Lord becomes one spirit with him. . ."
In some of the material he forwarded to me, soul ties are explained as being formed through intense relationships or inordinate affections with spouses, close friends, sexual partners, business partners, cults, religious denominations and lodges. Soul ties resemble a kind of spiritual umbilical cord that connects one person to another in the spiritual realm. When these relationships are ungodly, such as those forged in sexual sin (adultery/premarital sex), or for purposes of control, manipulation or domination (controlling parents, friends, bosses, etc.) they can have a toxic effect on our life in Christ. For this reasons, soul ties should be properly severed in order for a person to free themselves from any spiritual bondage.
"I have used explicit prayers for the breaking of these ties, usually in confession, and I ask the person to explicitly renounce the ties and forgive the person they were involved with, thereby setting them free," Father said.
The following is the prayer he uses:
“I bind in the Blood of Jesus all your hooks, lines and tentacles, your roots, attachments and attenuations, and I command you in the Name of Jesus to remove them now completely and entirely: in the Name of Jesus remove them now (x3).
“I cut, sever, disconnect and separate any and all soul ties, their attachments, hooks, lines, tentacles, roots and attenuations with the Sword of the Holy Spirit and the Blood of Jesus Christ.
“In the name of Jesus and the authority of my Priesthood, I cut and sever and separate anything attached to this child of God, through any acts of perversity, fornication, sexual promiscuity or engagement of illicit pleasures.
“All you spirits just named and all you companion spirits, in the Name of Jesus Christ, by His Precious Blood and the authority of my Priesthood, I bind you separately and individually and break all seals: you are bound and the seals are broken in the Name of the Father + and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit (x3).
“I come against your hooks, lines and tentacles, your roots, attachments and attenuations, and I command in the Name of Jesus that you are cursed. In the Name of Jesus be cursed (x3). You are cursed because you do not bear good fruit in this child of the Lord, and you are like the fig tree that did not bear good fruit.
“In the Name of Jesus you must wither and die (x3). You must come forth from this child of the Lord: you may not rend or tear, do harm or hurt of any kind as you come forth. In the Name of Jesus come forth (x3). In the power and authority of Jesus, I command that you go directly to the foot of the Cross, remain there and never return. In the Name of Jesus never return (x3). In the Name of Jesus be done (x3). Amen (x3).
“All you spirits just named and all your companion spirits: in the Name of Jesus Christ, by His Precious Blood and the authority of my Priesthood, with the authority granted to me by Jesus Christ and His Church, I bind you separately and individually and break all seals: you are bound and the seals are broken in the Name of the Father + and the Son and of the Holy Spirit (x3).
“I send you separately and individually to the foot of the Cross of Jesus Christ to be held there and to be obedient to His Holy Name until He tells you to go elsewhere. In the Name of Jesus be gone (x3). You no longer have a rightful place in this child of God and in the Name of Jesus I command that you are never to return. In the Name of Jesus never return (x3). In the Name of Jesus be done (x3). Amen (x3).”
He recommends the following site as an excellent source for Catholic information on this and a variety of other subjects pertaining to spiritual warfare: warfare/library/swprayers
See also
DOMINIC DIXON AND MORELOVE-MORE UNHOLINESS
THE PRAKASH LASRADOS, THE JOHNSON SEQUEIRAS AND THE DOMINIC DIXONS
HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE-WARNING ALERT ISSUED BY
HOLYSPIRITINTERACTIVE ANEEL ARANHA AND NEW AGE
DOMINIC DIXON CONTINUES TO DECEIVE CATHOLICS
AGAINST DOMINIC DIXON’S “VATICAN-APPROVED” REFRAIN, AN UNSOLICITED CLARIFICATION FROM THE FORMER SECRETARY OF THE AIE
Comments for submitted on 2013/12/06 at 1:52 am
Neither AIE, the International Association of Exorcists, nor IAD, the International Association for Deliverance are as yet Vatican approved. After the death of the President and Vice president, the new President and new Vice President (2012) of AIE have decided to apply for this association to come under the umbrella of the Liturgical Commission of the Vatican. No such plans are possible or desired for IAD. The fact the main office of AIE in based in Rome and its members recognised Exorcists or retired Exorcists does not confirm any canonical approval by the Vatican. Membership of both associations is not automatically ongoing, but has to be annually renewed by payment of the membership fee, and the ongoing recognition of the members by their Bishops or clerical superiors in case of monks.
Mrs Erika Gibello (retired AIE secretary for English speaking members and active secretary for IAD) 6th Dec.2013
erika gibello
erikagibello36@
2.29.155.126
................
................
In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.
To fulfill the demand for quickly locating and searching documents.
It is intelligent file search solution for home and business.
Related download
- bjp yoga is bad news for schools upa yoga is mandatory
- 23 oct 2006 dear lawrence
- introduction to the enneagram thinking partners inc
- metamorphose catholic ministry michael prabhu
- caso a 1992 d d e evans
- exploring the enneagram from ken wilber s integral perspective
- amazon web services
- from prabhu to cyriljohn vsnl
- why christianity must change or die a bishop speaks to
- resource manual ettc
Related searches
- oct 2019 free printable calendar
- lawrence kansas art galleries
- oct to decimal converter
- lawrence cohen routine activities theory
- what occurs in lawrence kohlberg s conventional level
- dr lawrence chang in delaware
- lawrence kohlberg theory pdf
- national day oct 2020
- lawrence kohlberg family
- lawrence kohlberg books
- oct 2019 calendar template
- harvest moon oct 1 2020