Evaluating Web Tools and Apps to Support Didactic Teaching
[Pages:7]Evaluating Web Tools and Apps to Support Didactic Teaching
We have identified that there are different kinds of learning objectives that need to be addressed in didactic teaching practice. These learning objectives include:
Knowledgebased learning
Understandingbased learning
Applicationbased learning
?focusing on what students should know e.g. factual, moral, social and natural knowledge
?focusing on what students should understand e.g. how osmosis or the electoral system works
?focusing on what students should be able to do e.g. use a scientific calculator, conduct an experiment or a survey
Tools: Internet Windows 8 Apps
We need to consider what different resources/tools we would consider utilizing for different didactic teaching objectives?
But how do we know which resources e.g. websites, apps and tools, are going to support students to reach the outcomes we intend? How can we ensure that we are offering opportunities for successful learning? Also are we supporting different learning styles or approaches adopted by students?
ICT Skill Level Required: Beginner
Supporting Resources: Evaluating a Research Site Rubric
Evaluating a Web Tool Rubric
Evaluating a App Rubric
As with any textbook or classroom resource, evaluation is essential. Let's take some time to investigate and use a couple of rubrics that can help you do exactly this.
Page 1
Further Resources and Ideas
Evaluating a Research Site Rubric
0
1
Check the author's credentials and affiliation. Is the author an expert in the field?
The author is probably a student. Spelling and other errors indicate that the author is not an expert.
The author is unnamed and/or no credentials are given.
2
The author is named but credentials and contact information is incomplete.
3
The author's credentials are given and indicate that he/she is an expert in the field. The author provides an email address and/or contact information.
Does the resource have a reputable organization behind it? (If you can't tell right away, strip the URL from the right side until you get to a home page.)
The page is hosted by an individual.
Any of these: The home page is a K-12 site The home page is a student's folder on an .edu site. The home page is an unknown .com or .org
The home page is sponsored by a known business, professional association, organization, museum, or university
Are the site's sources of information stated? Are photos clearly labelled and sources cited?
No sources or works cited is given.
There is a general statement about the source of the information, but no specific works cited list.
There is a works cited list and/or a bibliography for further information.
A government department or agency is the home page.
There is a works cited list and/or a bibliography for further information. Photos are labelled and cited.
How current is the site?
There is no indication of when the site was created or revised.
The date given for the site's creation is over 3 years old and there is no date of revision or update.
The site has been created or updated within the last 3 years.
The site has been created or updated within the last 6 months. If there is a bibliography, the sources that are referenced are current.
Page 2
What is the domain in the URL?
The domain is .com or .edu but it is clearly the work of students or individuals without authority.
The domain is .com and there are a lot of popup menus and items for sale or the domain is .org and the organization behind the site is unrecognized.
The domain is .edu, .com, .info, .net, or .org and has been reviewed by a reputable subject directory such as The Internet Public Library, Dewey Browse, subject directory, etc.
Any of these: The domain is .gov The domain is .com, .info, .net, or .org and is posted by a wellknown, reputable organization or company.
The domain is .edu and t h e university or college faculty, not students, maintain the site
What is the purpose of the site? Is the information mostly fact or opinion?
The purpose is personal.
The purpose is to sell something, persuade, offer assistance, or give a point of view. There may be some factual information or useful pictures but the focus of the site is to promote something.
The purpose is to offer factual information. Some opinion may be included.
The purpose is to support scholarly research with factual information.
Check your total mark against the advice to the right, and decide on the applicability of use of this site.
0 to 6 pts
Highly questionable source.
7 to 10 pts
11 to 14 pts
Site is useful for ideas or casual projects. Do not cite as a reference for a research paper or academic project.
Good source for a research paper or academic project. Confirm with other sources
15 to 18 pts
Excellent source for research.
Rubric Adapted from: Diane C. Beaman -- Library Media Specialist, Moultonborough Academy, Moultonborough, NH
Page 3
Evaluating a Web Tool Rubric
Ineffective Use 1 pt
Instructional Goals met with Tool
Instructional goals might be met by implementation of Web 2.0 Tool.
Possible Use 2 pts
Instructional goals are mostly met by implementation of Web 2.0 Tool.
User-friendly design
Site is difficult to navigate, little or no help is provided, tools and resources are difficult to make use of.
Site can be navigated with minimal difficulty, help guides/tutorials are available, tools and resources can be implemented.
Reliability
Site is unpredictable, navigation between pages is inconsistent.
Site is rarely down for maintenance, navigation between pages is slow but predictable.
Free/Paid Resource
Limited free resources, paid subscription price is unreasonable for the benefit of the tools.
Most of the tools are free, desired tools require paid subscription although other comparable sites might be available.
Must Use 3 pts
Instructional goals are fully met by implementation of Web 2.0 Tool.
Site is easy to navigate, help guides/tutorials available and clear, tools and features are conveniently located.
Site is always available (especially at peak times of the day). Navigation between pages in quick.
Desired tools are available for free, or fee is reasonable and worth the advantage of the tools.
Tour/ Screenshot Available
Essential information is not provided, registration required to evaluate if site is worthwhile.
Feature list, screenshots available but lacking information.
Full feature list, screenshots, samples, and tour available before account registration is required.
External Links
Links do not seem to work or hold relevance to the topic.
All links are working but relevance is not apparent.
All links to pages are in working order and relevant to material.
Contact Information
No contact information is provided.
Contact information is available but not complete.
Complete information on how to contact owner/company is available and easy to find.
Maintained
Site is out-of-date, and many parts of site are not functional.
Site is in working order, although there may be a lapse in time since last update, update information is unavailable, or not current.
Site is well maintained, recently updated, and information is current and up-to-date.
Awards
Site apparently has little or no recognition outside of owner/company.
Site claims to have received awards although information is vague.
Site has received multiple awards (specifically educational awards). Information regarding awards is available on the site.
From: iRubric
Page 4
Evaluating an App Rubric
4
3
Relevance
The app's focus has a strong connection to the purpose for the app and appropriate for the student
The app's focus is related to the purpose for the app and mostly appropriate for the student
Customization
App offers complete flexibility to alter content and settings to meet student needs
App offers some flexibility to alter content and settings to meet student needs
2
1
Limited connection to the purpose for the app and may not be appropriate for the student
Does not connect to the purpose for the app and not appropriate for the student
App offers limited flexibility to adjust content and settings to meet student needs
App offers no flexibility to meet student needs
Feedback
Student is provided specific feedback
Student is provided feedback
Student is provided limited feedback
Student is not provided feedback
Thinking Skills
App encourages the use of higher order thinking skills including creating, evaluating, and analyzing
App facilitates the use of higher order thinking skills including evaluating, analyzing, and applying
App facilitates the use of mostly lower order thinking skills like understanding and remembering
App is limited to the use of lower order thinking skills like understanding and remembering
Usability Engagement
Student can launch and operate the app independently
Student is highly motivated to use the app
Student needs to have a teacher show or model how to operate the app
Student uses the app as directed by the teacher
Student needs to be cued each time the app is used
App is difficult to operate or crashes frequently
Student perceives app as "more schoolwork" and may be off-task when directed to use the app
Student avoids the use of the app and might complain when its use is required
Sharing
Specific performance summary or student product is saved in app and can be exported to the teacher or for an audience
Performance data or student product is available in app but exporting is limited and may require a screenshot
Limited performance data or student product is not accessible
No performance summary or student product is saved
From: Tony Vincent ? Learning in Hand
Page 5
Evaluating an App Checklist
Use of app is relevant to the purpose and student needs
Help or tutorial is available in the app
Content is appropriate for the student
Information is error-free, factual, and reliable
Content can be exported, copied, or printed
App's settings and/or content can be customized
Customized content can be transferred to other devices
History is kept of student use of the app
Design of app is functional and visually stimulating
Student can exit app at any time without losing progress
Works with accessibility options like VoiceOver and Speak Selection
App is free of charge
No in-app purchases are necessary for intended use of app
App loads quickly and does not crash
App contains no advertising
App has been updated in the last 6 months
App promotes creativity and imagination
App provides opportunities to use higher order thinking skills
App promotes collaboration and idea sharing
App provides useful feedback
Total s The more checks, the better the app is for education
From: Tony Vincent ? Learning in Hand
Page 6
Educator Scenario
Activity:
Step 1 Take some time to read through the rubrics Step 2 Working in pairs discuss the applicability to use in your classroom, consider the question:
Step 3
Will this site, app or tool help me to support the learning outcomes I am focusing on in this unit of work?
In pairs choose a new site, app or tool to evaluate
Step 4
Independently evaluate your chosen resource using the appropriate rubrics
Step 5
Compare and discuss your conclusions with your partner
Framework Alignment
Course: How do Technology and Pedagogy Mix? Unit of Study: TL.3.a Exploring Digital Technologies to Support Didactic Teaching Topic 2: Selecting the Right ICT Resources to Support Didactic Teaching Practices
Page 7
................
................
In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.
To fulfill the demand for quickly locating and searching documents.
It is intelligent file search solution for home and business.
Related download
- traffic accident reconstruction
- fun true or false questions
- evaluating web tools and apps to support didactic teaching
- v2021 3 0 september 2021 nsight compute release notes
- application for social security card
- retirement ready fact sheet for workers age 49 60
- zoomtext troubleshooting tips
- protocol guide original instructions
- bluebeam revu quick start guide
- release notes tobii dynavox snap core first
Related searches
- tracking devices for tools and equipment
- m e tools and methods
- microsoft word tools and functions
- program management tools and techniques
- knowledge management tools and techniques
- auto detailing tools and equipment
- tqm tools and techniques pdf
- how to add apps to desktop windows10
- soap making tools and equipment
- stock trading tools and software
- auto detailing tools and supplies
- auto body tools and supplies