I. Minutes of the July 01, 2020 meeting.

 New Orleans Historic District Landmarks Commission Meeting MinutesDate: August 05, 2020Location: Zoom teleconference Called to order: 1:30 p.m.Adjourned: 3:32 p.missioners present: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinCommissioners arriving after beginning of the meeting: Commissioners absent: Emilie Bahr, Annie Cambria I. Minutes of the July 01, 2020 meeting.Motion: Approve the Minutes. By: Jennifer Greene Second: Calvin Alexander Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:CommentsII. Consent Agenda Motion: Approve the Consent Agenda By: Anne Redd Second: Heather Szapary Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed: Comments: 1239 St Thomas St: Megan Bell, applicant; St Thomas Properties LLC, owner; New construction of a 3,975 SF, two- story, mixed use building on a vacant lot.812 General Pershing St: Jonathan Drennan, applicant; Cong St Henrycatholic Church, owner; New construction of a second floor addition to a nominated Landmark Building. 1519 Esplanade Ave: E.W. Tregre, applicant; St. Anna’s Episcopal Church, owner; Renovation to a Significant rated, one-story building including paving and HVAC.622 Forstall St: Renoir Pierre, applicant; NDH Properties LLC, owner; New construction of a 1,000 SF one-story, single-family residential building.408 Delery St: Bahareh Javadi, applicant; Bast Realty Partners LLC, owner; New construction of a 1,000 SF 1 1/2-story, single-family residential building.3700 Canal St: David Merlin, applicant; Bethany Church, owner; Addition of new steps and ramp to Landmark building.1216 Bienville St: Alexander Adamick, applicant; Abdel T Mousa, owner; Renovation of two-story commercial Landmark building including modification of openings, new doors and windows, new exterior ramp, new gallery railings, and new second-story addition at rear.339 Pelican Ave: Heather Mcvicar Ruoss, applicant; Dale A Firestone, owner; Construction of new two-story addition to two-story residential building.III. New Business Work Applications1525 State St.Application: Brandon Augustus Francois, applicant; William W Pinsky, owner; Install generator at rear yard of designated Landmark building.Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Greg Hackenberg Second: Jennie West Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:833 Alvar St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; Alvar Enterprises LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Jennie West Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:837 Alvar St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; Alvar Enterprises LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Jennie West Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:843 Alvar St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; Alvar Enterprises LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Jennie West Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:849 Alvar St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; Alvar Enterprises LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level.By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Jennie West Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:852 Bartholomew St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; First Choice Housing LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Jason King Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:3930 Burgundy St.Application: Marla Fontes, applicant; Alvar Enterprises LLC, owner: Request for conceptual re-approval of previously approved new construction of two-story, single-family residential building due to approval expiration policy. Motion: Grant conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the Staff level. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Anne Redd Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:446 Elmira Ave.Application: Steve Thompson, applicant; James W Adams, owner; Replacement of existing tile roof with new asphalt shingle roofingMotion: Allow the exploratory removal of the existing terracotta roof tiles to determine the extent of the undersized tiles. Staff will evaluate the percentage of tiles that require replacement to determine if replacement of the entire roof with asphalt shingle is warranted. By: Heather Szapary Second: Greg Hackenberg Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments: 934 Congress St.Application: Kevin Mccusker, applicant; James G Hannah, owner; Retention of work done to a contributing one-story single family residential building without permits.Motion: Deny the application for retention of work done without permits.By: Jennie West Second: Calvin Alexander Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments: J. 1405 Clouet St.Application: Imperial Builders South, applicant; Victory L. Strang, owner; Install painted Rib-panel roofing on a non-contributing one story residential building.Motion: Approve the application with the requirement that HDLC Staff approve the color of the paint prior to the purchase and application. By: Jennie West Second: Calvin Alexander Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments: K. 3800 Burgundy Application: Kevin Mccusker, applicant; James G Hannah, owner; Retention of work done to a contributing one-story single family residential building without permits.Motion: Deny the application. However, the Commission approved raising the sill height of the existing window to accommodate an interior counter top and stated that the details of this could be worked out at staff level. By: Jennifer West Second: Greg Hackenberg Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:L. 1527 Dumaine St. Application: Evelyn Ailshie, applicant; Angela Cadaro, owner; Installation of new, visually prominent solar collection system on the roof of a contributing one-story residential building.Motion: Approve the installation of solar collectors, provided they meet the installation requirements set in the HDLC Guidelines, but deny the installation of the rear set of solar panels on the front sloping roof.By: Renee Lapeyrolerie Second: Annie Cambria Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed: CommentsV. New Business Demolition Applications4645 Freret ments: This item was withdrawn. 3921 Chestnut St.Application: Alford Evan, applicant; Butler Brown Development LLC, owner; Demolition of more than 50% of the roof and more than 50% of the wall area of a contributing one-story, single-family residential building for a camelback addition.Motion: Approve the application for partial roof and wall demolition as illustrated with the proviso that the proposed left-side addition have a chamfered edge to maintain the appearance of a bay window at this location from the street, as shown in the rendering presented by the applicantBy: Anne Redd Second: Heather Szapary Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:3947 Magazine St.Application: Jennifer Zurik, applicant; SSH Investments LLC, owner; Demolition of more than 25% of the primary facade of a contributing one-story commercial building.Motion: Approve the application for demolition. By: Ed deMontluzin Second: Anne Redd Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:1205 Bartholomew.Application: Perez Lyz, applicant; 1205 Bartholomew LLC, owner; Demolition of a non-contributing single story residential building to grade and the New Construction of a single family, two story residential building.Motion: Approve the application for demolition, however the HDLC agreed that the demolition permit should be issued concurrently with the new construction permit.By: Jennie West Second: Greg Hackenberg Result: PassedtIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:VI. New Business Retention Applications729 Tricou St.Application: Larry Lebouf, applicant; You Had Me At Gumbeaux Inc, owner; Retention of installation of inappropriate windows, handrails, inappropriately sized side entry door, CMU piers without stucco coating, and installation of wood-grained Hardie siding without a Certificate of Appropriateness.Motion: Approve the retention of the inappropriately sized door and wood-grained Hardie board siding with the proviso that the following items will be corrected:Inappropriate windows replaced with appropriate windows (or) remove the half-screens, reset the windows deeper into the openings and install simple wood screens in the trim casings to minimize the overall visibility of the windows from the public right of way.Stucco parge coat all CMU piers visible from the public right of way.Install appropriately detailed wood handrails and newel posts at the front and side porches.By: Calvin Alexander Second: Heather Szapary Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:539 Deslonde St.Application: Lee Walker, applicant; Serota Nola LLC, owner; Retention of removal of slate roof and replacement with standing seam metal roof, removal of historic windows and installation of inappropriate windows with uneven header heights, removal of wood handrails, and construction of a camelback addition in deviation of a Certificate of Appropriateness.Motion: Approve the retention of the standing seam metal roof, installation of inappropriate windows and the rooftop addition with the proviso that a wood or metal handrail be installed at the front porch.By: Calvin Alexander Second: Jason King Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Emilie Bahr, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed:Comments:VII. Ratification of Architectural Committee and Staff Actions since the Wednesday July 01, 2020 Meeting Motion: Approve the Ratification of Architectural Committee and Staff Actions since the Wednesday March 04, 2020 MeetingBy: Calvin Alexander Second: Annie Cambria Result: PassedIn favor: Jesse Le Blanc, Jennifer Greene, Calvin Alexander, Heather Szapary, Greg Hackenberg, Anne Redd, Jennie West, Renee Lapeyrolerie, Emilie Bahr, Jason King, Ed deMontluzinOpposed: Comments:IX. HDLC Reports and Communications ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download