ELEPHANTS AND CHEESE: AN EXPLORATORY PAPER



ELEPHANTS AND CHEESE: AN EXPLORATORY PAPER

by Teck Wann

It is widely known that elephants fear cheese, and will flee at the first whiff of it (see for example ). What is not yet well understood is why this phenomenon occurs. For more than a decade academics have been researching this perplexing topic. Their work constitutes part of the booming new discipline known as pachydermo-fromagology, which is defined as “the study of elephant-cheese interactions” ( ). This paper will evaluate existing research and theories, and argue that none of them satisfactorily explain the data which has been gathered so far.

That elephants fear cheese was an accidental discovery made by the noted elephantologist G. Coleman ( ). The story of the discovery is now famous, but worth repeating:

After a hard morning following the herd, I had just sat down under a tree for lunch and unwrapped a particularly delectable chunk of cheddar sent up from the base camp. Suddenly I heard an enormous trampling sound, and when I looked up, the entire herd was gone. ( )

His discovery, while dismissed at the time, was subsequently corroborated by other researchers. Several studies ( ) have confirmed the phenomenon, and that it occurs among both African and Asian elephants. A recent report by the Elephant Research Institute

( ) established that smell is the primary means elephants detect cheese, and that they will ignore large pieces of cheese if tightly wrapped. Meanwhile a French cheese expert asserts on his website that elephants do not flee from French cheese, only the lesser cheeses of other nations. “Zee creatures, zey have good taste, non?” he writes

( ).

Recently, a new theory has exploded on the scene and caused quite a stink. Based on several clever experiments, K. Maas

( ) has claimed that in fact elephants do not fear cheese at all, but instead fear the mice which are attracted to cheese. However, this theory, which she calls the Maas Mouse Hypothesis (MMH), has not yet been widely accepted. One researcher ( ) has published a series of articles roundly denouncing the MMH, and the debate has even spilled over into the popular press ( ).

What are we to make of this controversy? A good starting point

References

Achison, C.L. (2004, April). A ripe and weighty issue: an interview with Monica Sturgess. Cheese Lovers World, 6 (4), 12-13.

Coleman, G.J. (1984). An odd behaviour observed among the species Elephas maximus. Journal of Trunked Mammal Studies, 23, 421-429.

Coleman, G.J. (1988). Underfoot: ten years among the elephants. New York: Oxford University Press.

Concise Oxford dictionary, 11th ed. (2004). Oxford University Press. Retrieved October 20, 2004, from Oxford Reference Online database.

Elephant Research Institute, Simon Fraser University. (2001) Smell versus sight: detection of cheese by elephants. Retrieved November 1, 2004, from

Elephants stampede, 7 cheese-lovers trampled. (2003, November 22). Vancouver Sun, p. A1, A8.

Gibson, C.N. & Sturgess, M.N. (1987). Elephant fleeing behaviour confirmed. Journal of Elephantology, 16, 239-245. Retrieved October 27, 2004, from Academic Search Elite database.

Gibson, C.N. Sturgess, M.N., & Bates, A.T. (1989). Experiments with cheese effects on Elephas maximus and Elephas africanus. Journal of Elephantology, 18, 120-134. Retrieved October 27, 2004, from Academic Search Elite database.

Gouda, A.N. (n.d.) Commentary of a report about cheese and les elephants. Retrieved October 23, 2004, from

Maas, K.A. (2003). The missing link: elephants, mice, and cheese. International Journal of Rodentia Research, 56, 459-471. Retrieved October 31, 2004, from

Sturgess, M.N. (2004a). Of mice and cheese (Part 1). Journal of Trunked Mammal Studies, 43, 10-15.

Sturgess, M.N. (2004b). Of mice and cheese (Part 2). Journal of Trunked Mammal Studies, 43, 219-225.

TLN Advanced Essay Writing Workshop

In-text citations in APA style

APA style requires that you cite in the body of your essay the source of a fact, idea, quote, or datum you have borrowed. The way you do this is the parenthetical citation – which is a fancy way of saying a citation in parentheses ( ). The elements of the parenthetical citation are easy:

( author , year of publication , page ) Here’s a sample:

It has been argued that milk chocolate tastes better (Smith, 2001, p. 163).

Each parenthetical citation must correspond to a full citation in your reference list at the end of your essay. In this case, if we looked in the reference list we might see something like this:

Smith, J.T. (2001). A comparison of milk and dark chocolate. Journal of Chocolatology, 4, 134-167.

Easy? Okay, now here are some of the complications …

|If you are referring to the whole document or article, a page| |(Smith, 2001) |

|number is not necessary. | | |

|For two authors, use an ampersand. | |(Smith & Jones, 2004) |

|If there are 3-5 authors … | | |

|the first time cite them all | |(Smith, Jones, & Wilson, 1996, p. 345) |

|after that, use “et al.” | |(Smith et al., 1996, p. 345) |

|The author can be a group or institution. | |(Simon Fraser University Library, 2004, p. 2) |

|If there is no author, you sometimes use the title of the | |Newspaper article: (“Study finds”, 2003) |

|item/article/webpage as author. If it is very long, use the | |Book or report: (Annual Report, 2001) |

|first few words. | | |

|More than one item by the same author in the same year? | |(Smith, 2001a, p. 45) |

|Distinguish them with a, b, c. | | |

|For long web documents with no page numbers, give the section| |(Jones, 2002, Introduction section, para. 2) |

|and then paragraph. | | |

|Two citations in one set of parentheses: | | |

|different authors | |(Jones, 2002, p. 45; Smith, 1999, p. 67) |

|same author | |(Jones, 1999, 2002) |

Stylistically, it is common practice to use the author’s name in the text of the essay, in which case you can omit it from the parenthetical citation. Either of the following two versions is fine:

|It has been argued (Smith & Jones, 2004, p. 678) that … |Smith and Jones (2004, p. 678) argued that … |

by Teck Wann

It is widely known that elephants fear cheese, and will flee at the first whiff of it (see for example “Elephants stampede”, 2003). What is not yet well understood is why this phenomenon occurs. For more than a decade academics have been researching this perplexing topic. Their work constitutes part of the booming new discipline known as pachydermo-fromagology, which is defined as “the study of elephant-cheese interactions” (Concise Oxford dictionary, 2004). This paper will evaluate existing research and theories, and argue that none of them satisfactorily explain the data which has been gathered so far.

That elephants fear cheese was an accidental discovery made by the noted elephantologist G. Coleman (1984). The story of the discovery is now famous, but worth repeating:

After a hard morning following the herd, I had just sat down under a tree for lunch and unwrapped a particularly delectable chunk of cheddar sent up from the base camp. Suddenly I heard an enormous trampling sound, and when I looked up, the entire herd was gone. ( Coleman, 1988, p. 160)

His discovery, while dismissed at the time, was subsequently corroborated by other researchers. Several studies (Gibson & Sturgess, 1987; Gibson, Sturgess, & Bates, 1989) have confirmed the phenomenon, and that it occurs among both African and Asian elephants. A recent report by the Elephant Research Institute

( 2001) established that smell is the primary means elephants detect cheese, and that they will ignore large pieces of cheese if tightly wrapped. Meanwhile a French cheese expert asserts on his website that elephants do not flee from French cheese, only the lesser cheeses of other nations. “Zee creatures, zey have good taste, non?” he writes

( Gouda, n.d., Introduction section, para. 2).

Recently, a new theory has exploded on the scene and caused quite a stink. Based on several clever experiments, K. Maas

(2003) has claimed that in fact elephants do not fear cheese at all, but instead fear the mice which are attracted to cheese. However, this theory, which she calls the Maas Mouse Hypothesis (MMH), has not yet been widely accepted. One researcher (Sturgess, 2004a, 2004b) has published a series of articles roundly denouncing the MMH, and the debate has even spilled over into the popular press (Achison, 2004).

What are we to make of this controversy? A good starting point

-----------------------

Source F

Source D

Source B

Source C,

page 160

Sources

G, H

Source E

Source I,

Introduction, para. 2

Source J,

page 468

Sources

K, L

Source A

Source F

Source D

Source B

Source C,

page 160

Sources

G, H

Source E

Source I,

Introduction, para. 2

Source J,

page 468

Sources

K, L

Source A

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

K

L

................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download