Comment Form - Reliability Guideline: Generating Unit ...



Official Comment Form

Reliability Guideline: Generating Unit Operations During Complete Loss of Communications

Please use this form to submit comments on the proposed Reliability Guideline: Generating Unit Operations During Complete Loss of Communications.

Comments must be submitted by January 29, 2015. You may submit the completed Microsoft Word form by e-mail to (reliabilityguidelinecomments@) with the words “Reliability Guideline: Generator Loss of Communication” in the subject line. Only comments submitted in Microsoft Word format using this comment form will be accepted. Red-line document changes, PDF versions of this document, or email comments will NOT be accepted.

Comments may be submitted by individuals or groups.

If the comments are from an individual, please provide the contact information for the submitter in Information Table 1, and provide the requested affiliation information in Information Table 2.

If the comments are from a group, please provide the contact information for the leader of the group in Information Table 1, the requested affiliation information in Information Table 2, and a list of all group participants in Information Table 3.

Note: If you need to add a row to the table below please select Table from the above toolbar then Insert “Row Above” or “Row Below.”

If you have any questions on the subject information, please contact Larry Kezele at Larry.Kezele@.

|Information Table 1 |

|Individual Commenter or Group Leader Contact Information |

|Name: Robert Rhodes |

|Entity Name: Southwest Power Pool |

|Telephone: 501-614-3241 |

|E-mail: rrhodes@ |

|Information Table 2 |

|Select each NERC Region that you |Select each Industry Segment that you represent: |

|represent: | |

| ERCOT | |1 — Transmission Owners |

|FRCC | | |

|MRO | | |

|NPCC | | |

|RFC | | |

|SERC | | |

|SPP | | |

|WECC | | |

|NA – Not Applicable | | |

| | |2 — RTOs, ISOs |

| | |3 — Load-serving Entities |

| | |4 — Transmission-dependent Utilities |

| | |5 — Electric Generators |

| | |6 — Electricity Brokers, Aggregators, and Marketers |

| | |7 — Large Electricity End Users |

| | |8 — Small Electricity End Users |

| | |9 — Federal, State, and Provincial Regulatory or other Government Entities |

| | |10 — Regional Reliability Organizations and Regional Entities |

| | |NA – Not Applicable |

|Information Table 3 |

|Group Comments (Complete this page if comments are from a group.) |

|Group Name: SPP Standards Review Group |

|Additional Member Name |Additional Member Entity Name |Region(s) |Segment(s) |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

|      |      |      |      |

Enter All Comments in the tables below. Red-line Changes will not be accepted. Submit this form in Microsoft Word format only.

There are two forms provided for your use to submit comments on this guideline.

The first form is used to provide general comments on the guideline. These general comments should not reference a specific section or page in the guideline, but rather, should be overall comments on the guideline or concepts in the guideline, and may include repeating comments that are applicable to a number of sections.

The second form is used to provide comments to specific sections of the guideline, such as spelling, punctuation or word usage comments, as well as to provide specific comments to concepts on the indicated page and line of the guideline. When performing the review, please use the “clean version (not any “redline” versions) of the document in order to ensure consistently in provided comments from multiple commenters.

Please provide sufficient information in your comments to allow the working group to understand the issue being commented upon, and provide suggested changes to the guideline that the working group may use to update the guideline.

Instructions for general comments:

• Provide a description (or explanation) of your comments in the Comment column.

• Provide a proposed wording (or other) change in the proposed change column. The text in the proposed change column will be used by the working group to update the document.

The last column will be used by the working group during the comment resolution process, and should not be filled out on this comment form.

*Note: If you need to add a row to the table below please select Table from the above toolbar then Insert “Row Above” or “Row Below.”

|Comment |Proposed Change |Comment resolution adopted by the working/task group on each |

| | |comment submitted |

|From a plant perspective, we think the team has done a good job in | | |

|organizing and structuring this guideline such that it puts the needed | | |

|information in the hands of the plant operator who can in turn use it | | |

|as he sees fit. | | |

|The phrase ‘agreed upon actions’ in Line 34 of Page 3 is unclear. What |If we understood what the intent was, we could probably suggest | |

|actions do this reference and whose agreement is implied? The same |revised language. Lacking this understanding, we can offer the | |

|phrase appears in Line 27 on Page 6, Line 27 on Page 9 and in Line 30 |following lead-in for the newly inserted language at the end of the | |

|on Page 12. |sentence: ‘if the frequency trend continues to deteriorate, emergency | |

| |measures, as listed below, may be required in accordance with…’ | |

| | | |

| | | |

| | | |

| | | |

Instructions for specific comments on the text of the document:

• Provide a page number and line number reference for each comment (page and line numbers are provided in the review version of the document). When referencing page and line numbers, refer to the “clean” version of the posted document. Please DO NOT refer to page and line numbers in “redline” versions of documents.

• Identify each comment as either E (editorial), i.e., spelling, punctuation, formatting; or, T (technical) i.e., content changes.

• Provide a description (or explanation) of your comments in the Comment column.

• Provide a proposed wording (or other) change in the proposed change column. The text in the proposed change column will be used by the NERC Operating Committee to update the document.

The last column will be used by the working group during the comment resolution process, and should not be filled out on this comment form.

*Note: If you need to add a row to the table below please select Table from the above toolbar then Insert “Row Above” or “Row Below.”

|Page Number |Line Number |Type of Comment (Editorial|Comment |Proposed Change |Comment resolution adopted by the |

| | |/ Technical) | | |working/task group on each comment |

| | | | | |submitted |

|1 |40 |E |Insert ‘the’ between ‘for’ and ‘on-site’. | | |

|1 |42 |E |Delete the ‘d’ on ‘continued’. | | |

|2 |4 |E |Insert ‘the’ between ‘for’ and ‘on-site’. | | |

|2 |5-6 |E |Reword the end of the line to read: |‘…supervision from damage including, if necessary, taking| |

| | | | |a unit off line in a safe manner.’ | |

|3 |15 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|3 |19 |E |Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at the end of ‘operator’. | | |

| | | |This will provide agreement with ‘their’ as used near| | |

| | | |the end of the line. | | |

|3 |23 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|3 |29 |E |Replace the deleted ‘(s)’ at the end of the line. It | | |

| | | |provides agreement with ‘their’ as used later in the | | |

| | | |sentence. | | |

|3 |40 |E |Replace ‘transmission’ with ‘operations’. | | |

|3 |40 & 41 |E |‘offline’ is used here but ‘off line’ was used in | | |

| | | |Line 6 on Page 2. ‘Offline’ is used in Lines 33, 34 | | |

| | | |and 35 on Page 6. | | |

|3 |41 |E |‘online’ is used here and in Line 34 on Page 6, Line | | |

| | | |34 on Page 9 and Line 12 on Page 10. ‘on line’ is | | |

| | | |used in Line 5 on Page 5, Line 6 on Page 8 and Line | | |

| | | |14 on Page 11. Decide which it should be and be | | |

| | | |consistent. | | |

|4 |15 & 16 |E |Either insert a ‘the’ between ‘for’ and ‘on-site’ in | | |

| | | |Line 15 or replace the deleted ‘(s)’ in Line 16. | | |

|4 |28 |E |Capitalize ‘Transmission’. | | |

|4 |29 |E |Insert a comma after ‘basis’. | | |

|4 |30 |E |Use lower case ‘plant’. | | |

|4 |31 |E |Capitalize ‘Transmission’. | | |

|4 |35 |E |Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at the end of ‘operator’. | | |

| | | |This will provide agreement with ‘their’ as used near| | |

| | | |the end of the line. | | |

|6 |3 |E |Insert a ‘the’ between ‘as’ and ‘frequency’. | | |

|6 |6 |E |Replace ‘as required’ with ‘set’, ‘established’ or | | |

| | | |‘determined’. | | |

|6 |9 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|6 |12 |E |Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at the end of ‘operator’. | | |

| | | |This will provide agreement with ‘their’ as used in | | |

| | | |Line 13. | | |

|6 |16 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|6 |22 |E |Replace the deleted ‘(s)’ at the end of the line. It | | |

| | | |provides agreement with ‘their’ as used later in the | | |

| | | |sentence. | | |

|6 |33 |E |Replace ‘transmission’ with ‘operations’. | | |

|7 |5 & 6 |E |Make two (2) sentences from the 1st sentence in lines|For information, underfrequency load shed relays start to| |

| | | |5 & 6. |operate automatically when frequency declines to 59.30 | |

| | | | |Hz. Roughly five percent of system load is typically shed| |

| | | | |at this point. | |

|7 |7 |E |Reword for clarity. |‘load is shed if frequency continues to decline and | |

| | | | |reaches 58.90 Hz. The final step of load shedding is’ | |

|7 |11 |E |Either insert a ‘the’ between ‘for’ and ‘on-site’ in | | |

| | | |Line 11 or replace the deleted ‘(s)’ in Line 12. | | |

|7 |23 |E |Combine the two sentences on Lines 22 & 23. |‘minutes below 59.40 Hz, thirty seconds below 58.40 Hz, | |

| | | | |and two seconds below 58.00 Hz. Please note that’ | |

|7 |26 |E |Capitalize ‘Transmission’. | | |

|7 |27 |E |Insert a comma after ‘basis’. | | |

|7 |28 |E |Use lower case ‘plant’. | | |

|7 |29 |E |Capitalize ‘Transmission’. | | |

|7 |33 |E |Insert ‘The’ and use lower case ‘on-site’ at the | | |

| | | |beginning of the line. Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at | | |

| | | |the end of ‘operator’. This will provide agreement | | |

| | | |with ‘their’ as used in the next line. | | |

|9 |9 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|9 |12 |E |Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at the end of ‘operator’. | | |

| | | |This will provide agreement with ‘their’ as used in | | |

| | | |the next line. | | |

|9 |16 |E |Insert a comma after ‘limits’. | | |

|9 |22 |E |Add a parenthetical ‘(s)’ at the end of ‘operator’. | | |

| | | |This will provide agreement with ‘their’ as used in | | |

| | | |the next line. | | |

|9 |33 |E |Replace ‘transmission’ with ‘operations’. | | |

|10 |30 |E |Delete the ‘ ................
................

In order to avoid copyright disputes, this page is only a partial summary.

Google Online Preview   Download